Loading...
Planning Commission - 09/12/1977 A G E N D A Eden Prairie Planning Commission Monday, September 12, 1977 7:30 PN, City Hall Invocation --- Pledge of Allegiance --- Roll Call COMMISSION MEMBERS, Chairman Sundstrom, Redpath, Schee, Dearman, Lynch, McCulloch, Retterath STAFF MEMBERS: Dick Putnam, Jim Jensen, Jean Johnson I. APPROVAL OF AGENDA .11. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: A. of the August 22, 1977 Meeting - B. Minutes of the Special Meeting August 29, 1977 III. MEMBERS REPORTS A. MErman B. Others IV. REPORTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS A. Edenrte,by Gerald A. Pautrz and Pautz-Franklin Realty Co.. . request for UD Development plan and preliminary plat approval and rezoning from Rural to RM 6.S for 198 townhouses. The size is located north of Duck Train Trail, 1/4 mile east of TH 101. A continued public hearing. B. TEyM Homes Inc. , request to preliminary plat ;4 single family lots on 14 acres. Tht site is zoned. RI-13.S and is located in the northeast corner of Duck Lake Trail and 168th Avenue. A coat inward pub 1 i c hearing. "C. Edenvale Convenience Center, request for revised site plan.+, approval . e site Is local east of Shadow Green Apartments. D. Garrison Forst 2nd and Amsden Hills 2nd Addi t ions, by The P eserve. - - - Reconsideration of zoning request from Rural to RI-13.S . V. ' PETITIONS AND REZR II'S A. Amoco Oil Stution Rezoning,, request by Amoco ail Company to rezone from Mural to Highway Comercial for a service station. The site is located acr033 US 169 from the Eden Prairie Shopping Center. S. Crosstown Park, by Richard Anderson, request to resone from Rail to -c ra c ana pretaainary plat �B acres into 6 lots . The site is located south of the US 169/212/ Co AA. it interdumge. A public hearing. C. O1 is Hills 3rd & 4th Additions by Olympic Hills Corporation.Request to rezone mat plat 32 lots From Cal to R1-13.IF . Tht sites' are locat_-d north of the NN corner of Frmlo Road mad Piower Trail, A eontitwed public hearing. _ VI. OLD BUSINESS VII. NEW BUSINESS VI I I.��R'REPORT Ix. K051, 3'Yw'�!� •:.&Y` 3"±-i: _.;A V7=- ''�`,b ..y .,sM1,...W • ' S'Y '1]i) aa.'AKL .a ";'c_ L l@. .•::�.V�'. ' -; :t: .... ­W Dint W ru. W=a 0 r W.0,$7 lh Wig J W W J1 r Jii .. ,, i"h I. �,jl6iWYf a W;1U �ALa 0:01 JC,i-t i.. 9,IYW 11 Ahi u A AhmiY . V MINUTES EDEN PRAIRIE PLANKING COMMISSION ' approved Monday, September 12, 1977 7:30 PM City Hall COM►9ISSION POESENT: Chairman Sundstrom,Schee, Retterath, McCulloch, Lynch COMMISSION ABSENT- gedpath, Bearman ' STAFF PRESENT: Dick Putnam, Jean Johnson I. APPROVAL OF AGENDA Schee reminded the staff to designate times on the agenda and to attempt to place items such as the Guide Plan Discussion at the beginning. Schee moved, Retterath seconded, to approve the agenda as submitted. Motion carried unanimously. II. MINUTES A.' Minutes of the August 22, 1977 Meeting Lynch moved, Schee seconded, to approve the -minutes as written. Motion • carried unanimously. B. Minutes of the August 29, 1977 Meeting P. 2, 8►, 1ast sentence should read-Sundstrom felt that the important historical context of the PUD process is not as well. outlined in the existing update draft as it might be. Greater recognition should be given to the defini- tion of the update plan as the final PUD concept/development stages for all Of Eden Prairie. Lynch moved, Schee seconded, to approve the minutes as written and corrected. Motion carried unanimously. III. MEMBERS REPORTS A. Chairman Sundstrom-none B. O'chers-none - I V. REPORTS AND RECONWNDATI ONS A. Edengate, by Gerald B. Pautz and Pautz-Franklin Realty Co. , request for PUD Development plan and preliminary plat approval and rezoning from Rural to RM 6.5 for 198 townhouses. The site is located north of Duck Lake Trail mile east of TH 101. A continued public hearing. -. Mr. Howard Dahlgren, Howard Dahlgren $ Associates, project planners , stated he a felt the staff report was well done and he concurs with the recommendations. He reviewed the project of ownership :nits, varied roof lines and colors(earth- tones) , double garages, floor plans for 2-3 bedroom units, etc. He stated in response to the neighbors' concerns they ►+i 1 i not use U8' sheets of plywood for the exterior. Mr. Dahlgren felt the traffic increases would be phased over 3-4 years as tLe construction of the units are completed. He then distributed and outlined the contents of a draft covenant/bylaws governinge maintenance. The planner reviewed the site's history and past plans as outlined in the staff report dated September 8, 1977. He stated the staff is not recoaiending another crossing of the creek for additional access to the site, but that 2 accesses could be off of the proposed K/S Parkway. He also stated the staff does not feel an additional environmental review is necessary for the project. He believed _.. u _ u+ ul Aliia del +■ d.,.JWY iii Y, u r Y1.►.i. Lu � �a •Y x W thtl111Wl 4w JIAN u , . i.Jii Ni ii.C�l WI . rW.. ul Yi +NY 4..17 approved Planning Commission Minutes -2- Set 12 1977 P , the dedication of approximately 80 acres is reasonable and although ch: project does not strictly conform to the Purgatory Creek Study, it may not be feasible to purchase the property involved. He suggested ,modifications to the site plan in order to eliminate the totlots from the auto courts . provide more guest par' ? ng and the addition of a walkway system. Lynch inquired as to the emergency access plaAned for the project . The planner replied residents along Tartan Curve oppose the access through their street , and the site plan depicts two access points off of the proposed N/S Parkway. Lynch suggested the staff have the Fire and Public Safety Departments review the Emergency access plan for the project. „ Mr. Harley, 6741 Tartan Curve, disagreed with the multiple proposed next to single family and suggested the parkway be constructed prior to any units . Mr. Booth, 6781 Tartan Curve- , concurred with Mr. Harley. Mr. Miller, 6840 Parkview Lane, felt townhouses. should be constructed where traffic is not a problem instead of proposing them in' an area that has an existing traffic pr,-,blem. 1l Glen Keller, 6721 Lochanburn goad, asked if the project would be reviewed .by the Park & Recreation Commission. Mr. Dahlgren replied it has been presented to the Park $ Recreation Commission but a recommendation has not yet been made. • Mr. Miller objected to the precedent that might be set if townhouses are allowed on hilltops in the NW area of Eden Prairie. W. Askland, 18219 Ginavale Lane, opposed any development prior to an adequate road system. '� 4 Mr. Catt, 18600 Duck Lake Trail , did not believe the project is consistent with the Purgatory-Creek Steady, that an environmental reivew should be undertaken, ane objected to the need of a N/S Parkway with TH 101 only 1/2 mile away. He suggested the City purchase the property with fiords according '�.o the Creek Study. The planner stated the revised Edengate plan has been supplied to the EQC and DNR and todate no further information has been requested . : Schee expressed her opinion that alot of growing is taking place in Eden Prairie and zero growth would be untrealistic. She stated her neighborhood has under- EiE gone many changes in housing styles, roads, etc. , in the past 10 years, but i she stall enjoys Eden Prairie although it is not what -he enjoyed 1C years ago. She believed residents should realize that changes in a neighborhood do not have : to mean a lower quality of living. Mr. Catt urged the commission to listen to the neighbors, not to the petitioner, as was voiced at the Guide Plan Seminar Meetings and again during the Edengate hearings. Motion 1: Lynch moved, Schee seconded, to close the public hearing on the Edengate • preliminary plat. Motion carried unanimously. Notion 2: Lynch moved, Schee seconded, to recommend to the City Council approval of the revised Planned Unit Development Concept Stage Plan for Edengate. Motion carried 3:2 with McCulloch and Retterath voting nay. . approved Planning Commission Minutes -3- Sept. 129 1^77 Motion 3: Lynch moved, Schee seconded, to recommend to the City Council approval of the development stage and rezoning request from Rural to RM 6.5 for the Edengate Townhouse project. Motion carried 3:2 with McCulloch and Retterath voting nay. Motion 4: Lynch moved, Schee seconded, to recommend to the City Council approval of the rreliminary plat for Edengate based upon the revised plan and other subr.dtted docua-nts and the staff report of September 8, 1977 . And request an opinion from the Public Safety Department relative to the emergency access . Motion carried 3:2 with McCulloch and Retterath voting nay. t Motion 5 : Schee moved, Lynch seconded, to recommend to the City Council that the Environ- mental Review. Board - further review the revised Edengate Townhouse project . Motion carried 4: 1 with McCulloch voting nay. B. Trumps Homes, Inc. , request to preliminary-plat 34 single family lots on • 14 acres. The site is zoned R1-13.5 and is located in the NE corner of Duck Lake Trail and 168th Avenue. A continuedpublic hearing. Tim Pierce, Pierce and Associates, introduced hi.- -lf and informed the commission he is representing Ray Stod-la the landowner and Mr. Truempi the developer. He stated the property was zoned to Rla--13.S and preliminary platted in 1973, but since the final plat was not submitted within six months a preliminary plat must again be submitted. He stated the changes from the original plat are the the islands in the cul-de-sac have been eliminated and there is less cut and fill. Mr. Pierce then distributed photos depicting the types of homes that would be built for $ S5,000-60,000. The project is to be called Country Vista. The planner referred the commission to the staff report stating the staff is recommending approval but questions the need for the totlot. Sundstrom inquired if covenants would be needed to maintain the totlot. Mr. Pierce felt a homeowners association for this small developsneist would be undesirable; other options would be deeding an undivided ynterest to all lot owners, dedi- cating the .lot to the City or eliminating the outlot. Lynch felt the solution of eliminating the outlot may be best. McCulloch expressed concern about lots fronting onto Duck Lake Trai.L. The Planner replied no lots in this plat would front on Duck Lake Trail. Sundstrom asked if any members in the audience had questions or comments. None were raised. Motion 1 : Schee moved, Lynch seconded, to close the public hearing on the Country Vista preliminary plat by Trumpy Homes. Motion carried unanimously. Motion 2: Schee moved, Lynch seconded, to recommend to the City Council approval of the Country Vista preliminary plat by Trawpy Homes for 34 lots located in the NE corner of Duck Lake Trail and 168th Avenue based on the 5-8-77 staff report -and: 1. trails be constructed along Duck Lake Trail and 168th Avenue* by the developer in the road right-of-ways. &7%e Duck lake approved Eden Prairie Planning Commission -4- Sept. 12, 1977 Trail section shall be 8 feet wide, 4" thick and constructed of deep strength asphalt. The trail along 168th Avenue shall ' be '6 feet wide, 4" deep and also constructed of deep strength r= asphalt. These trails will help prcvide public access to adjacent sites anti community facilities. 2. provisions of Gruinance i55 are foi lowed with a variance granted only for density. 3. cash park fee be paid in an amount as per ordinance. 4. that proposed outlot A either be eliminated or maintained by a homeowners association. Motion carried unanimously. f a C. Edenvale Convenience Center, request for revised site plain approval . The site is located east of Shadow Green Apartments. The planner referred- the commission to the revised site plan stating the staff is recommending approval based upon the staff report. Mr. Ed Kodet, architect, stated they feel they can properly screen the project as was intended in the original approval . He stated they are requestir•g a median cut on Mitchell Road . Mr. Lynch inquired who would Sad the service pumps . Mr. Kodet replied the attendants of the PDQ store. Damn Peterson , Eden .Land Corporation, informed the commission only gasoline would • be sold, not oil , antifreeze, etc. Sundstrom inquired where the underground tanks would be located and if there is sufficient room for fuel trucks to deliver. Kodet stated the tank locations are undecided and that they would investigate the -room needed for delivery trucks . Peterson felt the 2 accesses provided would allow for flow of traffic if a truck temporarily had to obstruct an area. Motion : Scnee moved, Lynch seconded, to recommend to the City- Council approval of the Edenvale Convenience Center at Valley View Road and Mitchell Road as per the report of 8-11-77 with specific _landscaping details to be worked-out with the city staff and that the underground tank locations be consistent with the original approval. Motion carried unanimously. e D. Garrison Forest 2nd and. Amsden Hills 2nd Additions, by The Preserve. Reconsideration of zoning requests from Rural to R1-13.5. Mr. Bale, Attorney representing The Preserve, . informed the Commission The Preserve requested continuation of the public hearing before the Council to allow then time to investigate the possibility of changing the road location and State/Federal requirements on road and fund transfers. Mr. Bale presented a revised plan for Garrison Forest 2nd which contained two outlots( one at the SW corner of Amsden Road and Co. Rd 18 and the other south of Ansden Road to the west of the entrance street) , and fewer single family lots. He asked the Commission for approval of the rezoning request based upon the revised plan. Lynch inquired how many lots would be less than 13,S00 square feet. Mr. Hess estimated 50%. f approve 3 Planning Commission Minutes -5- Sept. 129 1977 McCulloch expressed his opinion that parkland should not be used for road purposes. w Bale agreed stating road construction prior to project approval is their responsibility, but they would like to provide the money for parkland transfer if agreeable to the City and State/Federal Agencies involved. Sundstrom inquired how large outlot D is. Mr. Bale estimated 9 acres. Lynch expressed his opposition in being aske6 for a recommendation on a plan that is just presented on a board that evening. He believed the Council should proceed with negotiations. McCulloch also felt the Commission is being asked to make a recommendation without sufficient time or material. Notion 1 - Schee, moved, Sundstrom seconded, to reconsider the Planning Commission's pre- vious action on Garrison Forest 2nd Addition in The Preserve. Motion carried 4: 1 with Lynch voting nay. Motion 2 : - Schee moved, Retterath seconded for discussion purposes, to recommend to the City Council approval of the revised Garrison Forest 2rd Addition rezoning request contingent upon the plan presented this evening containing Outlot C 6 D, and that the original Commission recommendation for the southerly road alignment be reaffirmed. Motion carried 4: 1 with Lynch voting nay. Lynch voted nay because he believes the previous Planning Commission action should stand and this type o: aegotiation should be accomplished by the Council if the petitioner dues not want to submit a revised plat in the rout:ne :manner. r V. PETITIONS AND REQOLSTS A. Amoco Oil Station RezoninX request by Amoco Oil Company to rezone from Rural to Highway Commercial for a service station. The site is located across US 169 from the Eden Prairie Shopping Center. W. McGregor, Amoco Oil Co. , presented the plan for a 3 bay service station, a drive-through wash and building of brick exterior and a mansard roof. The piamer referred the commission to the staff report stating the staff is recommending spproval of the request and variances (lfsted on page 2 ) for the AMC* Oi 1 Service Station to be located in the Major Center Area. Lynch felt attempts should be mode to wreet the requiremes is of the ordinance. McCulloch felt the variance request,, were reasonable in this case. MrGrefar stated he concurs with the staff report and recom mendat ions . k nee moved, Nettersth seconded, to recommend to the City Council approv.s'. of the Awco Ai 1 Company rezoning request frow Rural to Highway Comwaercial as per the staff -report dated Septe►Ab&r 2, 1977. Motion carried 4 , 4: 1 with Lynch abstaining. approved Planning Commission Minutes -6- Sept. 12, 1977 8. Crosstown Park, by Richard Anderson, request to rezone from Rural to I-2 Park and preliminary plat 28 acres into 6 lots. The site is located south of the US 169/212/Co.Rd. 18 interchange. The planner informed the Commission the grading plan wsI brought in late that afternoon and the staff has not yet prepdred. a report Mr. Dick Anderson, presented the site plan of office/warehouse uses on approximately 26 acres. He stated they intend to- retain the pond and woods and only change the grades slightly. He informed the Commission he has a letter from the DN% stating no EAW will be necessary. Sur_dstrom asked if any members in the audience had questions or comments. None were raised. Not i on: Retterath moved, Lynch seconded, to continue the Crosstown Park public hearing to the September 26th meeting for a staff report . . Motior. carried unanimously. C. Olympic Hills 3rd F 4th Additions , by Olympic Hills Corporation . Request to rezone and plat 32 lots from Rural to R1-13.5. The sites are located north of the NW corner of Franlo Road and Pioneer Trail . A continued public hearing. As no further material had been submitted to the staff, Lynch moved , McCulloch seconded, to continue the public 'gearing to the September 26th meeting. Motion carried unanimously. The planner informed the Commission the staff had been notified by phone that the applicants on the Olympic Hills South Addition had withdrawn their applica- Wotion: Olympic Hills South AEM-illoch moved, Retterath—seconded, to close the public hearing on Olympic Hills South Addition with no recommendation as the proponent has withdrawn the applica- tion. Motion carried unanimously. VI. OLD BUSINESS none VII. NEW BUSINESS none VI I I. PLANNER'S REPORT none IX. ADJOURNMEN"r McCulloch smed, Lynch seconded, to adjourn the meeting at 11 :23 PM Motion carried. Respectfully submitted Jean Johnson _