Loading...
City Council - 04/28/1988 - Board of Review { APPROVED MINUTES CITY OF EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW THURSDAY, APRIL 28, 1988 7: 30 PM, CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS 7600 EXECUTIVE DRIVE BOARD OF REVIEW MEMBERS: Gary Peterson, Richard Anderson, George Bentley, Jean Harris, and Patricia Pidcock BOARD OF REVIEW STAFF: City Manager Carl Jullie, Assistant to the City Manager Craig Dawson, City Assessor Steve Sinell, City Staff Appraisers Lorna Lisell , John Sams , Barb Cook, Rick Petersburg and Earl Zent, Hennepin County Representative Don Monk , and Recording Secretary Jan Nelson PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE i ROLL. CALL: Board Member Jean Harris was absent. g Z. CALL MEETING TO ORDER Board of Review President Peterson called the meeting to order. City Manager Jullie stated notice of this meeting had been properly published in the Eden Prairie News; notice of the meeting was also included with each valuation notice which was sent to homeowners. Jullie said the purpose of this meeting was to allow any tax payer to come before the Board of Review to request the Board act to amend the classification or property valuation which the City Assessor and his Staff determined to be appropriate to that property. Jullie said that the Board of Review will reconvene at a later date to hear any appeals continued from tonight's meeting. He reviewed the definition of Estimated Market Value. I1 . ORDER OF BUSINESS A. Personal Appeals 1. STAN VOLP - 13252 Cardinal Creek Road 03-116-22 42 0005 P Mr. Volp said his house was built in late 1986 and was assessed at $228,000. He said the new valuation is $260, 800 and he questioned the sharp increase in one year. He said Staff had told him the first valuation was a partial assessment. City Assessor Si;nell said J Board of Review Minutes 2 April 28, 1988 there were several incomplete items that were reflec- ted in the first assessment. Sinell said the entire Cardinal Creek area was reassessed this year .and the new assessment also reflects the value of the completed property. Volp said a house three doors away which is very similar to his property sold at $210,000. Sinell said he would recommend that the Board refer this back for further review and analysis. MOTION: Pidcock moved, seconded by Anderson, to refer the Volp property, PID 03-116-22 42 0006, to Staff for further review and research on comparable sales. Motion carried unanimously. 2. KAY AND ARLEN WESTLING - 9332/9334 Overlook Trail - 24-116-22 34 0043 Mrs. Westling said they have sold their duplex twin home for $172,200 and she thought that should be the valua- tion amount rather than the $188, 100 on the valuation notice_ Sinell said a review of the property has been started. MOTION: Pidcock moved, seconded by Bentleyr to refer the Westling property, PID 24-116-22 34 0043, to Staff fr to complete the review of the property. Motion carried unanimously. 3. Mary Jane Swanson - 9440 Eden Prairie Road - 29-116-22 11 0001 (Primary) and 29-116-22 12 9007 (Secondary) Ms. Swanson said she takes issue with the valuations of her two parcels , one nine-acre parcel and an adjoining eight-acre parcel. She said there is no City sewer and water out there and there is a building restriction on land less than 10 acres so none of it can be sub- divided. She said it has been increased every year and the property has been physically inspected every year except one. Sinell said that his department reviews construction or new improvements over $1,000 at the time of assessment. If those improvements are not complete at that time, they will return the following year to see if the im- provements have been completed. Swanson said she failed to see where the property could increase in value that much considering of the lack of amenities in the area. Bentley asked if she felt that the assessed valuation is greater than the value of the property. She replied that she did. Sinell noted that the property was purchased at $156,000 y Board of Review Minutes 3 April 28, 1988 and there have been some improvements done since the purchase. Swanson said she didn ' t think it had gone up 30% because there are many items that have not been im- proved since the purchase. Bentley said he saw nothing that says the valua- tion itself is wrong but he heard an objection to the rate of increase. He said he was concerned why it is suddenly going up 30% when it has been reviewed annually. Pidcock said she would like to see some comparables on this property. MOTION: Pidcock moved, seconded by Anderson, to refer • the Swanson properties, PID 29-116-22 11 0001 (Primary) and PID 29-116-22 12 0007 (Secondary), to Staff for further review and research on comparable sales. Motion carried unanimously. 4 . RICHARD & KAREN FYOCK - 13188 Cardinal Creek Road - 03-116-22 41 0005 Mrs. Fyock said she had researched several homes in the Cardinal Creek area and there are a lot of discrepancies in the value of the properties. She said her statistics show that property values have not gone up in Cardinal Creek. Sinell said he thought this would be a good one to refer back for review and comparison. MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Pidcock, to refer the Fyock property, PID 03-116-22 41 0005, to Staff for further review and research on comparables. Motion carried unanimously. 5. Chiwon Sohn - 8735 Darnel Road - 23-116-22 21 0020 i Mr. Sohn said the valuation will make his house one of the most expensive in the neighborhood and he couldn' t understand why. Sinell said the Lake Eden area was one of the revalua- tion areas. He said with this appraisal the property now has 70% of the basement finished . He also said there had been a market comparison to three others in the neighborhood. Mr. Sohn said one of the three has a lake view and there have been no sales on his side of the street. Peterson asked if $109,600 is more than Mr. Sohn could sell the house for . Sohn said $103,900 is the maximum estimate he would make. Bentley said he would be willing to have Staff review this in order to have another appraiser take another Board of Review Minutes 4 April 28, 1988 look at the comparables. MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Anderson, to refer the Sohn property, PID 23-116-22 21 0020 , to Staff for further review and research on comparable properties. Motion carried unanimously. 6. THOMAS SWIRTZ - 6584 Mistral Lane - 05-116-22 14 0042 Mr . Swirtz did not respond when his name was called. The Board proceeded on to the next appellant. 7. MERRILL 6 ELIZABETH WATSON - 8047 Curtis Lane - 17-116-22 13 0179 Mr. Watson said they purchased their townhouse in July of 1987 and now have an estimated market value that is more than their purchase price. Sinell said the appraiser found comparable units that had sold for more than $80, 000. Pidcock asked if there was any duress on the seller to sell the property. Watson said it was a new house. Peterson asked if any improvements had been made. Watson replied they had put in air-conditioning. MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Anderson, to amend the Assessor 's estimated market value on the Watson property, PID 17-116-22 13 0179, to $78, 500. Pidcock said she wanted to reiterate that when you buy ' property from a builder you may not be able to turn around and resell it at the same or at a higher price. Anderson noted that he thought the criteria was the selling price plus the improvements to the property. VOTE ON THE MOTION: Motion carried with Pidcock opposed. 8. Cancelled 9. PAUL WELIN - 6630 Kara Drive - 04-116-22 42 0045 Mr . Welin said he was contesting his estimated market value because of structural problems with his home. He said he would like to have a review by one of the ap- praisers and the inspector involved with the property construction. Sinell asked if he had an independent engineering report f' on the property. Welin said he did and that it reported many defects in the structure that would require exten- sive corrective measures. g' Board of Review Minutes 5 April 28, 1988 ••► MOTION: Anderson moved, seconded by Pidcock , to refer the Welin property, PID 04-116-22 42 0045, to Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. 10 . RONALD MOELLER - 9511 Bennett Place - 25-116-22 22 0009 Mr. Moeller said he was concerned about parity in valua- tion. He reviewed some properties he considered com- parable to his property and said he thought his valuation should be somewhere between the other two properties. Sinell said the appraiser used the most current sales in determining the value. He said he would like to see a market comparison done on this property. MOTION: Pidcock moved, seconded by Bentley, to refer the Moeller property, PID 25-116722 22 0009, to Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. 11. THOMAS & KRYSTYNA PLOSZAY - 7564 Eileen Street - 07-116-22 41 0012 Mr. Ploszay said he had purchased his house in March of 1997 for $161#000. He said his assessment is 105% of the sale price while the other houses on Eileen Street were assessed at 96% of sale price. Sinell said a review appraisal has been completed on the property. Mr. Ploszay said he thought the first year appraisal should be very close to the purchase price. Bentley said he could see no indication of distressed sale in this case and unless there is such a distressed sale he could not see that high an amount of appreciation since the purchase of the property. MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Anderson, to amend the Assessor ' s estimated market value on the Ploszay property, PID 07-116-22 41 0012, at $162,590. Motion carried with Pidcock opposed. } E 12. TIMOTHY DUNPHY - 17300 Peterborg Road - 05-116-22 33 0031 Mr. Dunphy said he was also interested in equalization. He said he experienced a 17% increase this year. He checked on comparables in his neighborhood and found them to be far less than the value placed on his house . k Sinell said he would like to have a chance to review this property. MOTION: Anderson moved, seconded by Pidcock, to refer the Dunphy property, PID 15-116-22 33 0031, to Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. Board of Review Minutes 6 April 28, 1988 13. MATTHEW & DAWN HERKENHOFF - 16000 Baywood Lane- 05-116-22 41 0053 Mrs. Herkenhoff said she felt the condition of their neighborhood reduces the value of their property. She said the comparables used for their property were in Olympic Hills and Hidden Oaks and their neighborhood is not comparable to those two areas. She said they paid $285, 000 for the property in May, 1987 and re- ceived a mortgage company valuation of $301, 000. Sinell said they do look for a change in value because of negative influences; however, they haven ' t been able to find such influences on this property. He said he would recommend a decrease to $296, 000. Pidcock said she thought location does have a bearing and should be taken into account. Bentley said he agreed with that; however , he assumed that the mortgage J 11 company also took that into account in their valuation. a MOTION: Pidcock moved to amend the Assessor 's estimated market valuation on the Herkenhoff property, PID 05-116 22 41 0053, to $285,000. MOTION DIED FOR LACK OF A SECOND. k MOTION: Anderson moved, seconded by Bentley, to amend the Assessor 's estimated market valuation on the Herkenhoff property, PID 05-116-22 41 0053, to $296, 000. Pidcock said she didn ' t see that there would be that much appreciation in ten months. She said she thought we were f trying to arrive at a market value. p Peterson said he would like to see another year. of his- tory and comparables closer to the area and also to see if the neighborhood improves. VOTE ON THE MOTION: Motion failed on a split vote with Anderson and Bentley voting "aye" and Pidcock and Peterson voting "nay". Bentley asked what things had been done to the property since they moved in. Mrs. Herkenhoff said they have put in grass and landscaping . MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Peterson, to amend the Assessor 's estimated market value of the Herkenhoff property, PID 05-116-22 41 0053, to $290# 000. Motion carried with Pidcock opposed. i 14. RAYMOND RICE - SOLO Island Road - 17-116-22 24 0015 Board of Review Minutes 7 April 28 , 1988 Mr . Rice said he had paid more for his lot than others in the area. He said in December 1986, the assessor concluded that it was 621 completed. He said he paid a total of $316, 000 for his house and lot. He said he asked the assessor about comparables and was told that the highest sale in Weston Bay was $220,000 and there were no sales over $200, 000 in Timber Lakes. Rice said he thought his valuation was more proper for homes in Cardinal Creek, Olympic Hills or on Bryant Lake. Sinell said he would like to see a market comparison on this prcperty. MOTION: Pidcock moved, seconded by Bentley, to refer the Rice property, PID 17-116-22 24 0015, to Staff for further review and research on comparable sales. Motion carried unanimously. k 15. LARRY OLSON - 7351 Walnut Court - 08-116-22 14 0050 Mr . Olson said he wanted to raise the issue of in- x equity of valuation of houses on Walnut Court based on a comparison he did of three homes there, including his own. He said his tax per square foot is much higher than the other two. Sinell said Staff has not had a chance to do a com- plete review and would like to do one. MOTION: Pidcock moved, seconded by Anderson , to refer the Olson property, PID 08-116-22 14 0959, to Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. 16. CLARK KUSE & JOANNE KUBE-HARDERWIJK - 15909 Cedar Ridge Road - 21-116-22 23 0013 This appeal was cancelled as it was settled before the meeting. 17. RONALD NEHER - 14860 Ironwood Court - 04-116-22 43 0081 Mr . Neher said he wanted to ask for a look at the com- parables. Sinell said that had not been completed as yet. MOTION: Pidcock moved, seconded by Anderson, to refer the Neher property, PID 04-116-22 43 0081, to Staff for further review and research on comparable sales. Motion carried unanimously. l8. DOUGLAS OLSEN - 9030 W. Staring Lane - 21-116-22 42 0008 . Mr. Olsen said he disagreed with the amount of the assessment and would like to have it reviewed. Board of Review Minutes 8 April 28, 1988 MOTION: Pidcock moved, seconded by Bentley, to refer the Olsen property, PID 21-116-22 42 0008 to .Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. 19. BRUCE MAR20LF - 7680 Atherton Way - 08-116-22 33 0018 Mr . Marzolf said he had anticipated selling his home and had asked one of the realtors to do a market analysis. He said that analysis was $88,700. He also noted that he did not receive a notice of this meeting. Sinell said he would like to be able to review this and would like a copy of the realtor 's market analysis. Mr . Marzolf said he knows of only one time when an assessor came in their house. Sinell said the last complete review of the property was in 1984. MOTION: Pidcock moved, seconded by Bentley, to refer the Marzolf property, PID 08-116-22 33 0018, to Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. i i 20. RUSSELL a SANDRA STEPHENS - 16029 Baywood Lane - 05-116-22 41 0052 Mrs. Stephens said they suffered extreme damage from the big storm last summer. She said they believe the value of the lot is no longer at the current value, particularly in view of the extensive damage to the railroad property behind them. She said they don' t know if they could sell their property now with the existing damage . She said they were concerned about the lack of services in their area and the fact that their children have to attend Prairie View school which will be forced to use t portable classrooms next year . She said those !concerns affect the value of their property. Sinell said Staff has not completed a market review and would like to complete that. MOTION: Anderson moved, seconded by Bentley, to refer the Stephens property, PID 05-116-22 41 0052, to Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. 21. RALPH & JOANN TESCHNER - 6463 Mere Drive - 05-116-22 14 0051 Mr. and Mrs. Teschner did not respond when their name was called. 22. LEE LOBSTEIN - 6900 Roseman Road - 03-116-22 34 y 0815 Mr. Lobstein did not respond when his name was called. u s fi a Board of Review Minutes 9 April 28, 1988 23. BYRON & KRISTINE ANDERSON - 16881 South Manor Road - 05-116-22 24 0034 Mr . and Mrs. Anderson did not respond when their name was called. 24 . ALVIN & MILDRED BREN - 7202 Topview Road - 10-116-22 14 0111 Mr. and Mrs. Bren did not respond when their name was called. 25. JAMES MILLER - 8583 Darnel Road - 23-116-22 23 9020 Mr. Miller said his new assessment was an increase of 15. 6%. He said he was not satisfied that he had a fair appraisal nor that the comparables were not similar enough to his property. a MOTION: Pidcock moved, seconded by Bentley, to refer the Miller property, PID 23-116-22 23 0020, to Staff for further review and research on comparable sales. Motion carried unanimously. 26. WILLIAM HARGENS - 9060 W. Staring Lane - 21-116-22 42 0010 Mrs. Hargens said W. Staring Lane is a very old neigh- borhood and they were surprised at a $10, 000 increase on their property when no improvements have been done since the early 1980s. She said there has not been a house for sale in their neighborhood since 1982 so she wanted to know what the basis for their valuation was. Mrs. Hargens said she was also concerned about the prob- lem of people being taxed out of their birthright, not only in Eden Prairie but in the entire country.. She said you are taxed on the basis of what the current market is even though you don't intend to sell your property. MOTION: Anderson moved, seconded by Bentley, to refer the Hargens property, PID 21-116-22 42 0010, to Staff for further review. !notion carried unanimously. 27. ANDREW & SUSAN WOLF - 8833 Jasmine Lane - 23-116-22 24 0078 Mrs. Wolf said she believed the property has devalued because of the large number of vacancies in the eight building complex. Sinell said they have not had a chance to look at this property. MOTION: Bentley moved , seconded by Pidcock, to refer 7 P Board of Review Minutes 10 April 28, 1988 the Wolf property, PID 23-116-22 24 0078, to Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. 28. MIKE FLYNN - 16980 Duck Lake Trail - 05-116-22 31 0016 Mr . Flynn said his property had not been on the tax roles prior to their purchase because it had been a parsonage. When they purchased the home, an assessor reviewed the house for the first time and placed a value of $78,000. He said it then went up the following year to $80,400. This year they received a 28% increase to $103, 200, and he couldn ' t understand such a large increase. He said he thought it would be hard to sell because of the lack of some amenities in the house and its location on Duck Lake Trail. MOTION: Pideock moved, seconded by Anderson, to refer the Flynn property, PID 05-116-22 31 0016, to Staff for further review and research on comparable sales. Motion carried unanimously. 29. DEAN & KATHY JOHNSON - 9170 Flyway Circle - 24-116-22 32 0009 Mrs. Johnson said the estimated market value is greater than they could sell the house for. She said the im- provementp they made have not added that much to the y value of the home. She said the comparables used were not fair since they used two homes in Olympic Hills and their neighborhood is not similar to that area. MOTION: Anderson moved, seconded by Pidcock, to refer the Johnson property, PID 24-116-22 32 0009, to Staff for further review and research on comparable sales. Motion carried unanimously. 4 30. MICHAEL SUTTON - 9754 Purgatory Road - 26-116-22 14 0018 10-116-22 21 0001 10-116-22 21 0002 Mr. Sutton said he put together a small development with 13 lots. He said he built a new home on one lot and lived in an older home which has since been demolished. He said the assessment covers a house that no longer exists. Sinell said the valuation was done as of January 1 when the house was still there and Mr . Sutton had applied for homestead on that property. Bentley said he was concerned that if it couldn't be marketed because of restrictions placed by the City and we are trying to determine market value, then there► is 5 ri Board of Review Minutes 11 April 28 , 1988 / a problem. He said he' would like to have a review of the Developer 's Agreement for this property to deter- mine whether the property was :marketable. MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Anderson , to refer the Sutton property, PID 26-116-22 14 0018, to Staff for further review to determine whether the property was marketable at the time of the valuation. Motion carried unanimously. Mr. Sutton said the house on Baker Road is being rented, however the property is not in very good condition. He said he hopes to put the properties there together at some time for development. MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Pidcock, to refer the Sutton property, PID 10--116-22 21 0002, to Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. Mr . Sutton said the other property is a vacant lot next to the Baker Road property with the house. He said the valuation increased from $13,000 to $28,000 this year . Bentley asked if there was sewer and water near the property. Sutton said there was in a neighboring cul- de-sac. ., MOTION: Pidcock moved, seconded by Bentley., to refer the Sutton property, PID 10-116-22 21 0001 to Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. 31. JOHN SWANSON - 6626 Boyd Ave . - 06-116-22. 41 0024 Mr. Swanson said his valuation is much higher than other l property in his neighborhood. MOTION: Pidcock moved, seconded by Anderson, to refer ! the Swanson property, PID 06-116-22 41 0024, to. Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. 32. WILLIAM a WANDA CARPENTER - 15517 S. Eden Dr. - 04-116-22 21 0014 Mr. and Mrs. Carpenter did not respond when their name was called. 33. LEE GARBER - 15085 Ironwood Court - 04-116-22 43 0050 Mr. Garbe r said a house u the street from him has been on the market for over a year and is still not sold. He said he was concerned about the disparity of valua- tions in his neighborhood. He said he bought his house in 1981 and paid more than it was worth in order to get an assumable mortgage. Sinell said the assessors have been unable to get into T Board of Review Minutes 12 April 28, 1988 the house to perform an appraisal. MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Pidcock , to refer the Garber property, PID 04--116-22 43 0050, to Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. 34. FRED PURCELL - 8610 Red Oak Drive - 21-116-22 22 0035 21-116-22 22 0034 Mr . Purcell said he is objecting to the valuations on two of his lots on Meadowvale. He said there is a 70% increase on one lot and an 80% increase on the other . He said one of the lots acts as the neighborhood play- ground , and he had received two offers for it last year for $9,000 to $10, 000. He said the other lot backs up to his house. He read a letter that offered him $10,750 for the second lot. ' Bentley asked what last year ' s valuations were. Purcell replied that they were $10,000 and $11# 000. Sinell said these properties were part of the revaluation done this year. He said there were some sales of lots in the area which were used for comparables. Peterson asked if utilities were available. Jullie said they are not yet available. Pidcock asked if there was a park in the neighborhood. ' Jullie said he was not sure. MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Anderson, to amend the Assessor ' s estimated market value on the Purcell 3 property, PID 21-116-22 22 0035, to $12#000 and on the Purcell Property, PID 21--116-22 22 0034, to $13, 900. Motion carried unanimously. . 35 . HIHARI DESAI - 16587 Terrypine Drive - 17-116-22 12 0058 Mr. Desai said he paid $65, 000 for a half-duplex for investment purposes. He said the property was then assessed at $72, 900, which is $7, 900 more than he paid for it. Sinell said the value at January 1987 was $70, 000. Mr . Desai said he was not aware of the procedure used to protest the valuations,. MOTION: Pidcock moved, seconded by Bentley, to refer ( ' the Desai property, PID 17-116--22 12 0058, to Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. 36. EUGENE DIX - 18341 Ginavale Lane - 06-116-22 43 17 b j x ti Board of Review Minutes 13 April 28, 1988 Mr. Dix had to leave the meeting and his appeal will be considered with the written appeals. . 37. GARY T. REYNOLDS - 16630 Baywood Terrace - 05-116-22 43 0016 Mr . Reynolds said he was also looking for equalization. He said his home is assessed higher than one next door to his that is bigger than his home. He said he had gone through the court process in order to obtain a reduction before. Peterson noted that Mr. Reynolds ' estimated valuation • of $118, 100 is less than the $122, 000 value placed by the court. Reynolds said he thought the court valua- tion was higher than it should have been. Sinell said a neighborhood review had been performed. He said he - would like to have another review with conparables. MOTION: Pidcock moved , seconded by Bentley, to refer the Reynolds property, PIA 05-116-22 43 0016, to Staff for further review and research on comparable sales. Motion carried unanimously. 38 . OTTO HALSTENSEN - 8965 and 8967 Preserve Blvd. - 23-116-22 14 0931 23-116-22 14 0032 s Mr. Halstensen said his property was severely damaged by the flood in July, 1987. To date only patch-up b repair has been done on the building; therefore he felt that the value of the building has decreased rather than increased. Bentley said he had witnessed the water damage in that area and had encouraged Mr . Halstensen to present his appeal . Sinell said their review had not yet been completed. MOTION: Pidcock moved, seconded by Bentley, to refer the Halstensen properties, PID 23-1.16-22 14 003L and PID 23-116-22 14 0032 to Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. The Board then considered appeals of those who did not respond when their name was called during the meeting . 6. THOMAS L. SWIRTZ - 6584 Mistral Ln - 05-116-22 14 0042 MOTION: Pidcock moved, seconded by Bentley, to refer the Swirtz property, PID 05-116-22 14 0042, to Staff for A 3 t Board of Review Minutes 14 April 28, 1988 further review. Motion carried unanimously. 21. RALPH & JOANN TESCHNER - 6463 Mere Drive - 05-116-22 14 0051 MOTION: Pidcock moved , seconded by Bentley, to amend the Assessor ' s estimated market value on the Teschner property, PID 05-116-22 14 0051, to $159, 600. Motion carried unanimously. 22. LEE LOBSTEIN - 6900 Rosemary Rd - 03-116-22 34 0015 MOTION: Pidcock moved, seconded by Bentley, to refer the Lobstein property, PID 03-116-22 34 0015, to Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. 23. BYRON & KRISTINE ANDERSON - 16881 South Manor Road - 05-116-22 24 0034 MOTION: Pidcock, moved, seconded by Bentley, to refer the Anderson property, PID 05-116-22 24 0034, to Staff for furl-her review. Motion carried unanimously. 24. ALVIN & MILDRED BREN - 7202 Topview Road - 10-116-22 14 0111 fr MOTION: Pidcock moved, seconded by Bentley, to refer the Bren property, PID 10-116-22 14 0111, to Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. t 32. WILLIAM & WANDA CARPENTER - 15517 S. Eden Dr. - 04-116-22 21 0014 MOTION: Anderson moved, seconded by Pidcock, to refer the Carpenter property, PID 04-116-22 21 0014, to Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. 36. EUGENE DIX - 18341 Ginavale Lane - 06-116-22 43. 0017 MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Pidcock, to refer the Dix property, PID 06-116-22 43 0017, to Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. B. Written Communications Written communications were received from the following and are attached to these Minutes. 1001. DONALD N. PATON - 102 South Third Street, St. Joseph, MO 64501 - 17-116-22 13 0026 1002. MARK J. PETERKA - 9064 Preserve Blvd . - 23-116-22 42 0063 1003 . BRUCE H. ELLIASEN - 9635 Bennett Place - 25-116-22 23 0922 24-116-22 22 0219 ti Board of Review Minutes 15 April 28, 1988 1004. LINDA & DAN MACDONALD - 17031 Honeysuckle Lane - 05-116-22 31 0064 1005. DAVID W. LEE - 9330 Overlook Trail - 24-116-22 34 0019 1006. DANIEL J. HELTNESS - 9328 Overlook Trail - 24-116-22 34 0020 1007. DONALD P. SABINSKE - 7740 Heritage Road - 08-116-22 33 0010 MOTION: Anderson moved, seconded by Pidcock, to refer the seven properties listed above (Items 1001 - 1007) to Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. 1008 . PROPERTY TAX RESEARCH COMPANY - 14-116-22 22 0004 14-116-22 22 0005 16-116-22 24 0011 15-116-22 13 0001 15-116-22 21 9004 15-116-22 22 0010 15--116-22 23 0004 12-116-22 11 0002 1009. CRANE AND NORCROSS - 10-116-22 34 0004 1010. CRANE AND NORCROSS - 12-116-22 41 0002 MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Pidcock, to sustain the valuation on the above listed proper- ties (Items 1008 - .1010) . Motion carried f unanimously. 1011. TRAMMELL CROW RESIDENTIAL 14-116-22 43 0014 MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Anderson, to sustain the valuation of PID 14-116-22 43 0014 at $7, 800,000. Motion carried unanimously. 1012. BRUCE & RUTH ANN HIRMER - 19247 and 10257 Tarn Circle - 24-116-22 43 0057 and 24-116-22 43 0056 1013. ELFERING CONSTRUCTION, INC. - 06-116-22 33 0014 Board of Review Minutes 16 April 28, 1988 06-116-22 33 0077' 06-116-22 33 0078 1014 . THOMAS & DEBRA WILSON - 10270 Mooer La. - 35-116-22 21 0096 1015 . RONALD & LESLIE EZERSKI - 13192 Cardinal Creek Road - 03-116-22 41 0004 1016 . JOHN & DIANNE HOCKERT - 16180 Westgate Lane - 08-116-22 41 0013 1017 . MICHAEL W. DUNN - 9044 Preserve Blvd . - 23-I16-22 42 0062 1018 . WILLIAM J. DIERS - 9157 Preserve Blvd. - 23-116-22 31 0003 1019 . DAVID N. & JEANNE H. MOOTY - 6871 Sand Ridge Road - 03-116-22 43 0011 1020 . NANCY & JEFF LUKENS - 6824 Jeremy Ct. - 04-116--22 44 0007 d 1021 . EDTED PROPERTIES - 6466 City West Parkway - 01-116-22 24 0029 1022. NORTHWOOD GAS INC. 03-116-22 22 0019 03-116-22 22 6021 03-116-22 22 0022 1023 . MICHAEL J. MCNAMARA - 10260 & 10270 Tarn Circle 24-116-22 43 0038 1024 . CAROL BURNETT - 9940 Bennett Place - 26-116-22 41 0033 . MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Anderson, to refer the above listed properties (Items 1012 - 1024) to Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. 1025 . LAURA & JOHN GILSON - 8923 Hidden Oaks Drive - 24-116-22 24 0085 t MOTION: Anderson moved, seconded by Bentley, to sustain the Assessor 's estimated market value on the Gilson property, PID 24-116-22 24 0085. Motion carried unanimously. 1026 . GARY ROBERT ERNST - 15851 Summit Dr . - 21-116-22 22 0013 1027 . ELTON M. NELSON - 16231 Westgate Dr . - — — --- - 'J x Board of Review Minutes 17 April 28, 1988 08-116-22 41 0033 l 1028 . JEFF MILLER - 15195 Ironwood Court - 04-116-22 43 0047 1029. ROBERT T. CALLAN - 9051 High Point Circle - 24-116-22 31 001.7 e MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Anderson, to refer the above listed properties (Items 1026 - 1029) to Staff for further review. Motion carried unanimously. 111 . CLOSE MEETING MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Anderson, to reconvene the Board of Review at 6: 39 PM, Monday, May 16. Motion carried unanimously. Peterson thanked the Appraisal Staff for the fine job in putting together the overall assessed valuation for the year and Don Monk for his help in tonight 's meeting . MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Anderson, to adjourn the meeting at 11: 15 PM. Motion carried unanimously. f} f i