City Council - 06/03/1986 - Board of Review APPROVED MINUTES
CITY OF EDEN PRAIRIE
BOARD OF REVIEW LL
TUESDAY, JUNE 3, 1986 6:00 PM, SCHOOL ADMINISTRATION BOARDROOtl
BOARD OF REVIEW MEMBERS: President of the Board Gary D. Peterson,
Richard Anderson, George Bentley, Patricia
Pidcock, and Paul Redpath
BOARD OF REVIEW STAFF: City Manager Carl J. Jullie, City Assessor
Steve Sinell, and Recording Secretary Karen
Michael
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
ROLL CALL: All members were present.
i
I . RECONVENE BOARD OF REVIEW MEETING
The meeting was called to order by President of the Board Peterson.
II . APPROVAL OF BOARD OF REVIEW 14INUTES OF 14EETING HELD THURSDAY, 14AY 15, 1986
MOTION: Redpath moved, seconded by Bentley, to approve the Minutes of the
Board of Review fleeting held Thursday, May 15, 1986, as published. Motion
carried unanimously.
III . REVIEV OF ITEM CONTINUED MAY 15, 1986
City Assessor Sinell stated those items referred by the Board at its May
15th meeting had been reviewed by the Board of Advisors (Regan Massee)
and/or City Staff.
1. RUTH OHNSON - 4437 Upton Avenue S. - Vacant Land - Non Homestead
1986 E14V Ad. Bd. Rec. Assessor 's Rec.
30-116-22 22 0015 13,000 16,500 16,500
30-116-22 2? 0020 10,000 18,500 18,500
30-116-22 22 0029 10,000 23,000 23,000
30-116-22 22 0030 10,000 22,000 22,000 a
30-116-22 22 0032 4,000 4,000 4.000
30-116-22 23 0002 15,000 25,000 25,000
30-116-22 23 0003 15,000 22,000 22,000
Mrs . Johnson said she did not understand how the values could be
raised. City Assessor Sinell explained the process used. Pidcock
i
Board of Review Minutes -2- June 3, 1986
1
said she was disconcerted there was no modification of the values.
She said she did not agree with the advisor 's recommendation or the
assessor's recommendation. Pidcock said there has been no appre-
ciation in property in the metropolitan area since 1981 so she could
see no reason why these properties should have increased.
MOTION: Redpath moved, secondea by Anderson, to reduce proposed
increases by one third on all properties except 0015 and 0032 to
sustain recommended values: 30-116-22 22 0020 to $15.600; 30-116-22
22 0029 to $18,600; 30-116-22 22 0030 to $18,000; 30-116-22 23 0002 to
$21,600; and 30-116-22 23 0003 to $19.600; 30-116-22 22 0015 - $16,500
and 30-116-22 22 D032 - $4,000.
Bentley said he could not go along with an increase over the original
estimated market values.
VOTE ON MOTION: !-lotion carried with Bentley voting "no".
2. GEONEY TUTTLE - 7030 Willow Creek Road
1986 EMV Ad. Bd. Rec. Assessor 's Rec.
11-116-22 11 0007 $200,000 no change no change
It was noted that Tuttle intends to further appeal his valuation.
MOTION:ON.• Re
dpath moved, seconded by Anderson, to sustain the 1986
Estimated Property Value on the Tuttle property, PID 11- 116-22 11
0007, at $200,000. Motion carried with Pidcock voting "no".
3. VIOLA GAVIN ESTATE - 427, 429 b G5 - Castle Ridge
1986 EMV Ad. Bd. Rec. Assessor 's Rec.
14-116-22 32 0295 $104.000 no rec. no change
14-116-22 32 0249 $ 2.400 no rec. no change
MOTION: Redpath moved, seconded by Bentley, to sustain the 1986
Estimated Property Value on the Viola Gavin property, PIDs 14-116-22 -
32 0295 and 14-116-22 32 0249, at $104,000 and $2,400 respectively.
Notion carried with Pidcock voting "no".
4. GARY WAGNER - 7269 Gerard Drive
1986 E14V Ad. Bd. Rec. Assessor 's Rec.
11-11.6-22 23 0044 $128,000 $115,000 $115,000
Board of Review Minutes -3- June 3, 1986
MQTION: Redpath Waved, seconded by Bentley, to reduce the 1986 value
on the Wagner property, PID 11-116-22 23 0044, to $115,000. Motion
carried unanimously.
5. GERARD WERSAL - 12645 Sunnybrook Road
1986 ENV Ad. Bd. Rec. Assessor 's Rec.
23-116-22 33 0014 $88,000 $83,000 $83,000 e
Wersal addressed the results of the review.
NOTION:: Bentley P'0 ent ey moved, seconded by Adcock, to reduce the 1986 value
on the Wersal property, PID 23-116-22 33 0014, to $80,000. notion
carried unanimously.
6. BRUCE BRILL - 6574 Flying Cloud Drive
1986 EMV Rvw. Appraisal Assessor's Rec.
01-116-22 13 0005 $171.300 $183,000 no change
Brill addressed the appraisal.
140TION: Bentley moved, seconded by Redpath, to reduce the 1986 value
on the Brill property, PID 01-116-22 13 0005, to $158,500. Motion
carried unanimously.
7. DR. JOHN WRIGHT - 6608 Flying Cloud Drive
1986 E14V Rvw. Appraisal Assessor 's Rec.
01-116-22 31 0001 $148,400 $152,000 no change
Dr. Wright gave historical background on the property. He noted his
1985 estimated market value was $127,000.
MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Anderson, to reduce the 1986 value
on the Wright property, PID 01-116-22 31 0001, to $137,700. Motion
carried unanimously.
8. S & D PROPERTIES - 7565 Corporate Way
1986 EMV Rvw. Appraisal Assessor 's Rec.
09-116-22 42 0006 $472,200 $490,000 $449,000
i
Board of Review Minutes 4- June 3, 1986 i
City Assessor Sinell said he had reviewed this property and based on
additional information provided by Ralph Duesch le he would recoamend a
reduction in value to $449,000.
MOTION: Bentley roved, seconded by Redpath, to reduce the 1986 value
on the property owned by S & 0 Properties, PID 09-116-22 42 0006, to
$449,000. Motion carried unanimously.
9. EDENVALE GOLF COURSE
Taxable - 1986 Deferred - 1986
04-116-22 44 0001 $130,800 $349,000
09-116-22 11 0003 $244,600 $540,000
09-116-22 41 0002 $189,200 $505,000
10-116-22 32 0049 $ 98,300 $263,000
F
u
4
George May, attorney for Edenvale, introduced Bob Martin, former
Hennepin County Assessor, who spoke to the increase in assessments
placed upon golf courses in Hennepin Ccunty and the process used to
determine those assessments,
MOTION: Red path moved seconded b Bentley, to reduce the 1986 value
p y y.
on the Edenvale Groff Course properties to their 1985 taxable values:
04-116-22 44 0001 to $70,000; 09-116-22 11 0003 to $161,400; 09-116-22
41 0002 to $101 ,000; and 10-116-22 32 0049 to $52,500. Motion carried
unanimously.
THE BOARD OF REVIEW RECESSED UNTIL 9:30 P.M. AT WHICH TIME IT RECONVENED.
MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Pidcock, to reduce the 1986 values
on the Olympic Hills and Cedar Hills Golf Courses to their 1985
taxable values:
Olympic Hills -
23-116-22 44 0025 from $30,500 to $23,000
23-116-22 44 0026 from $35,500 to $26,500
24-116r22 33 0007 from $57,400 to $20,200
24-116-22 33 0008 from $57,900 to $42.200 '
24-116-22 34 0045 from $180,100 to $131,700
25-116-22 21 0045 from $92,600 to $69,300
25-116-22 21 0046 from $7,900 to $5,800
25-116-22 22 0016 from $8,200 to $1,000
25-116-22 22 0037 from $860,200 to $785,800
25-116-22 23 0027 from $2,100 to $1,000
s
Board of Review ttinutes -5- June 3, 1986
Cedar Hills -
29-116-22 13 G001 from $6,400 to $5,400
29-116-22 14 0001 from $88,700 to $62,500
29-116-22 14 0002 from $66,100 to $59,000
Motion carried unanimously.
10. DARYL V. COOK - 15516 Village Woods Drive - land only
1986 EMV Rvw. Appraisal Assessor's Rec.
3
{
16-116-22 34 0031 $28,000 $32,000 no change p
140TION: Redpath moved, seconded by Pidcock, to sustain the 1986 n
estimated market value on the Cook property, PID 16-116-22 34 0031, at
$28,000. Motion carried unanimously.
11. KAREN 0. OLSEN - 9104 Neill Lake Road
1986 EMV Rvw. Appraisal Assessor 's Rec.
24-116-22 31 0046 $85,000 $86,400 no change
tIOTION: Redpath moved, seconded by Pidcock, to sustain the 1986
estimated market value on the Olsen property, PID 24-116-22 31 0046,
at $35,000. Motion carried unanimously.
12. BRUCE H. LIEBERI4AN GENERAL RESOURCES
1986 EAV Rvw. Appraisal Assessor 's Rec.
03-116-22 22 0013 $ 96,900 $121,000 $121,000
03-116-22 22 0014 $292,700 $390,000 $390,000
03-116-22 22 0029 $185,600 $187,000 no change
City Assessor Sinell noted a letter from Lieberman (see attached).
140TIOU: Redpath moved, seconded by Bentley, to sustain the
recommendation of the City Assessor on the General Resources Corp.
properties: 03-116-22 22 0013 at $121,000; 03-116-22 22 0014 at
$390,000; and 03-116-22 22 0029 at $185,600. Motion carried
unanimous ly.
13. LLOYD CHERNE - Green Acres - non homestead
1986 EI-W Rvw. Appraisal Assessor's Rec.
15-116-22 44 0001 $400,000 $400,000 no change
14-116-22 33 0009 $ 48,800 $ 48,000 no change
14-116-22 33 0010 $203,000 $203,000 no change
l
r ,.
Board of Review Minutes -6- June 3, 1986
MOTION: Redpath moved, seconded by Pidcock, to sustain the
recommendation of the City Assessor on the Cherne properties: 15-116-
22 44 0001 at $ ,000; 14-116-22 33 0009 at $48,800; and 14-116-22 33
0010 at $203,000. Motion carried unanimously.
P
14. UPPER MIDWEST MANAGEMENT CORP.
1986 EMV Rvw. Appraisal Assessor's Rec.
14-116-22 42 0002 $ 10,000 $ 10,000 no change
14-116-22 13 0005 $418,200 $374,000 reduce
MOTION: Redpath moved, seconded by Pidcock, to affirm the
recommendation of the City Assessor on the Upper Midwest Management
Corp. properties: 14-116-22 42 0002 at $10,000 and 14-116-22 13 0005
at $374,000. Motion carried unanimously.
15. MARVIN F. POIR & CO.
1986 EMV Rvw. Appraisal Assessor 's Rec.
12-116-22 14 0013 $2,634,600 $2,470,000 $2,470,000
C MOTIO14: Redpath moved, seconded by Pidcock, to reduce the value on
the Poer & Co. property, PIO 12-116-22 14 0013, to $2,470,000 as
recommended by the City Assessor. Motion carrier! unanimously.
16. GILBERT C. WILLIAMS
1986 EMV Rvw. Appraisal Assessor's Rec.
01-116-22 14 0003 $258,000 $230,000 $230,000
MOTION: Redpath moved, seconded by Pidcock, to reduce the value on
the Williams property, 01-116-22 14 0003, to $230,000 based on the
M.A. I. appraisal and the recommendation of the City Assessor. notion
carried unanimously.
17. SAM SCHNE IDER
1986 EMV Rvw. Appraisal Assessor 's Rec.
24-116-22 21 0065 $ 99,800 $100,400 no change
24-116-22 21 0068 $127,000 $141,000 no change
24-116-22 21 0069 $133,000 $147,000 no change
24-116-22 21 0074 $130,000 $134,000 no change
24-116-22 21 0081 $ 93,000 $ 89,000 reduce
Board of Review Minutes -7- June 3, 1986
24-116-22 21 0083 $ 93,000 $ 89,000 reduce
24-116-22 21 0087 t 10,000 i 10,000 no change
24-116-22 21 0089 $ 10,000 t 10,000 no change
24- 116-22 21 0098 $ 10,000 E 10,000 no change
24-116-22 21 0102 $ 10,000 3 10,000 no change
24-1.16-22 21 0103 $ 10,000 $ 10,000 no change
24-116-22 21 0109 $ 5,000 $ 5,000 no change
24-116-22 21 0110 $1,365,000 $1,365,000 no change
MOTION: Redpath moved, seconded by Pidcock, to accept the
recommendation of the City Assessor regarding the valuations on the
Schneider properties: 24-116-22 21 00617- at $99,800; 24-116-22 21 0068
at $127,000; 24-116-22 21 0069 at $133,000; 24-116-22 21 0074 at
$130,000; 24-116-22 21 0081 at $89,000; 24-116-22 21 0083 at $89,000;
24- 116-22 21 0087 at $10,000; 24-116-22 21 0089 at $10,000; 24-116-22
21 0098 at $10,000; 24-116-22 21 0102 at $10,000; 24-116-22 21 0103 at
$10,000; 24-116-22 21 0109 at $5,000; and 24-116-22 21 0110 at
$1 ,365,OG0. Motion carried unanimously.
i
18. JOHN TE141N - 1010 Eden Road
1986 EMV Rvw. Appraisal Assessor's Rec.
14-116-22 24 0011 $993,900 $993,900 no change
(deferred) (deferred)
ock sustain MOTION: Redpath moved, seconded by Pi do to sta the
recommendation of the City Assessor on the Teman property, PIO 14-116-
22 24 0011, at $993,900 (deferred). Motion carried unanimously.
IV. OT11ER BUSINESS
The Council commended City Assessor Sinell and his Staff for a job well
done.
V. ADOPTIO#1 OF RESOLUTION N0. 86-119, ACCEPTING THE 1986 ASSESSMENT
140TI ON: Bentley nrved, seconded y Redpath, to adopt eso u xon No. 86-
119, accepting the 1986 assessment. Motion carried unanimously.
VI. ADJOURN14ENT
MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Anderson, to adjourn the meeting at
9:45 p.m. Motion carried unanimously.
9
4