HomeMy WebLinkAboutCity Council - 05/22/1984 - Board of Review APPROVED MINUTES
CITY OF EDEN PRAIRIE
BOARD OF REVIEW
TUESDAY, MAY 22 . 1984 7 :00 PM, SCHOOL ADMINISTRATION BOARDROOM
BOARD OF REVIEW MEMBERS- President of the Board Wolfgang H. Penzel ,
Richard Anderson, George Bentley, Paul Redpath
and George Ta nnen
BOARD OF REVIEW STAFF: City Manager Carl J. Jul l ie, City Assessor S'.eve
Sinell , Hennepin County Representative Kerman
Benson and Recording Secretary Karen Michael
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
ROLL CALL : all members were present.
I . RECONVENE BOARD OF REVIEW MEETING
The meeting was called to order by President of the Board of Review Wolfgang
H. Penzel .
II . APPROVAL OF BOARD OF REVIEW MINUTES OF MEETING HELD TUESDAY, MAY 8, 1984
MOTION: Redpath moved, seconded by Bentley, to approve the Minutes of the
Board of Review Meeting held Tuesday, May 8, 1984, as published. Motion
carried unanimously.
III . REVIEW OF ITEMS CONTINUED FROM MAY 8, 1984
City Assessor Sinell called attention to the materials which had been sent
to Board members reviewing the items which were continued from the May 8th
meeting.
PENTTI T. LEHT0'1FN - 9688 Buckingham Drive - 25-116-22-41-0007
Lehtonen stated he had a third party appraisal made of the property
(Wiley Appraisals ) and the appraiser stated the property had a market
value of $12.2,000. Sinell noted that Wiley had not used any comparables
in the immediate neighborhood and the figures used were from the Fall of
1982; he said he would have to disagree with the appraisal . Lehtonen
indicated a home across the street from his is for sale for $114,000
and has been on the market for six months.
MOTION: Redpath moved. seconded by Bentley, to accept the recorrrrendation
of the Assessor and to sustain the valuation on the Lehtonen property.
Notion carried unanimously.
M i nutes of the ?t:,ard of Review -2- '�ay 22, 1984
i
BERNIE FINK & IONY LESINSKI - 6331 Industrial Drive - 03-116-22-22-0016
MOTION: Anderson moved , seconded by Tangen , to accept the recommendation
of the Assessor and to sustain the valuation on the Fink & Lesinski prop-
erty . (lotion carried unanimously.
MR. AND MRS DONALD JOHNSON - 7261 Willow Creek Road — 12-116-22-22-0005
MOTION: Redpath moved, seconded by Bentley, to accept the recommendation
of the Assessor and reduce the value of the Johnson property to $121 ,000.
Motion carried unanimously.
14ILLIAM QUIRK - 14308 Charing Cross 03-116-22-32-0051
MOTION: Redpath moved, seconded by Bentley, to accept the recommendation
of the Assessor and reduce the value of the Quirk property to $102,000.
Motion carried unanimously.
MICHAEL DAVIS - 17261 Park Circle - 08-116-22-33-0042
MOTION: Bentley moved. seconded by Anderson, to accept the recommendation
of the Assessor and reduce the value of the Davis property to $81 ,000.
Motion carried unanimously.
MR. AND MRS, JERRY McKINNEY - 9826 Brighton Lane - 25-116-22-11-0129 and
MR. AND MRS. DICK LAIRD - 9840 Brighton Lane - 25-116-22-11-0128
MOTION: Tangen moved, seconded by Bentley, to accept the recommendation
of the Assessor and to sustain the valuation on the McKinney and Laird
properties . Motion. carried unanimously.
FLOYD AND JANE_ DAY SIEFFERMAN - 6997 Edgebrook Place - 03-116-22-44-0029
MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Redpath, to accept the recommendation
of the Assessor and to sustain the valuation on the Siefferman property.
Motion carried unanimously.
UPPER MIDWEST MANAGEMENT CORP. 8140 Flying Cloud Drive - 14-116-22-42-0002
�-' and - 14-116-22-13-0005
MOTION: Redpath moved. seconded by Anderson, to accept the recommendation
of the Assessor and to reduce 42-002 to ;10,000 and to reduce 13. 0003 to
$372,000, Motion carried unanimously.
FACTORY OUTLET CENTER - 11-16-22-32-0008
MOTION: Redpath moved, seconded by Anderson, to accept the recommendation
of the Assessor and to reduce the value of the Factory Outlet Center to
$4,700,000. Motion carried unanimously.
1-1irutes of the . .-%&rd of Review -3- May 22, 1p°4 b
THE BUSSE COMPANY - 6300 Carlson Drive - 03-116-22-21-0007
MOTION: Anderson moved seconded by Bentley, to accept the recommendation
of the Assessor and to sustain the valuation on the Busse Company property.
Motion carried unanimously.
01-116- 22-14-0006
01-116�-22-43-00_08
12-116-_22.14-0015
12-116-22-14-0017
1_2_-116-22-14�-0018
13-116--22-32-0003
01-116-22-34-0011
City Assessor Sinell referred to a letter dated Play 15, 1984 , from
the City Attorney regarding whether or not a written communication
constitutes an appearance before the local Board of Review; the City
Attorney's opinion was that the letter was sufficient for the property
owner to preserve his right to appear before the County Board of
Equalization, Hennepin County representative Benson said the County
Attorney's opinion was that it did not constitute an appeal . Tangen
said the City should go along with the ruling of the City Attorney.
MOTION: Tangen moved, seconded by Redpath, to accept the recommendation
of the Assessor and to sustain the valuations of the properties with the
following PIN numbers: 01-116-22-14-0006 , O1-:16-22-43-0008, 12-116-22-14,0015,'
12-116-22-14 -0017, 12-116-22-14-0018, 13-116-22-32-0003, and 01-116-22-34-0011 .'
Potion carried unanimously.
CECIL MARTIN - 6585 Eden Prairie Road - 04-116.22-23-0050
Martin indicated his valuation had been raised approximately 10% this past
year while his neighbors had been raised about 2%. City Assessor Sinell
noted the valuation in 1983 was $61,100; for 1984 it was $66,500. Sinell
said the appraisal of this property had been done on a cost approach less
depreciation.
MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Redpath , to reduce the value of the
Martin property to $62.800. Motion carried unanimously.
Michael Davis and Mr. and Mrs Floyd Siefferman arrived after action had been
on their properties. Both indicated they will consider their rights to appeal
to the County.
IV. ADOPTION OF RESOLUTION NO 84-122_,_ACCEPTING THE 1984 ASSESSMENT
MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Tangen, to adopt Resolution No. 84-122,
accepting the 1984 assessment . Motion carried unanimously.
V. ADJOURNMENT
MOTION: Bentley moved, seconded by Tangen, to adjourn the reconvened meeting
of the Board of Review at 7:43 p.m. Motion carried unanimously.
.u . 4