Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
City Council - 04/19/1990
CITY,OF EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW AGENDA THURSDAY, APRIL 19, 1990 7:30 PM, COUNCIL CHAMBERS • 7600 EXECUTIVE -DRIVE BOARD OF REVIEW MEMBERS: Chairman Gary Peterson, Richard Anderson, Jean Harris, Patricia Pidcock, Douglas Tenpas BOARD OF REVIEW STAFF: City Manager Carl J. Jullie, Assistant to the City Manager Craig Dawson, City Assessor Steve Sinell, Hennepin County Representative Larry Miller, and Recording Secretary Jan Nelson PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE ROLL CALL I. CALL MEETING TO ORDER II. ORDER OF BUSINESS A. Personal Appeals B. Written Communications . i C. Schedule Reconvene • III. CLOSE MEETING 1990 Board of Review Appeals Active/Cancelled as of 4:30 P.M. April 12, 1990 Appeal * PID/Name Date Recd. Appraiser 1 22-24-0119 John Jenkins Cancelled 2 15-33-0021 Richard Hendrickson 3/15/90 Lorna 3 04-23-0039 Leonard Kodet 3/15/90 Barb 4 04-24-0050 C. 0. Thompson 3/16/90 Barb 5 10-12-0038 Carl & Gloria Moser Cancelled 6 26-42-0023 David Howard Cancelled 7 09-31-0036 Richard Bianski Cancelled 8 25-42-0021 Cheryl & Mark Harelstad Cancelled 9 24-31-0104 Robert Duncan 3/21/90 John 10 24-43-0038 Michael McNamara Cancelled 11 24-31-0107 Robert Morgel 3/22/90 John 12 07-32-0052 Martin Wheeler Cancelled 13 17-24-0030 Earl Ingram 3/26/90 Lorna 14 24-43-0010 Janice Patterson 3/27/90 Earl 15 26-12-0031 Stephen Birke Cancelled 16 26-11-0033 Douglas Swanson Cancelled 17 24-44-0005 George Sicheneder 3/28/90 Dean 18 05-41-0038 Rick Norell Cancelled 19 25-33-0038 John Bergh, Jr. 3/28/90 John 20 09-31-0011 Daniel Johnson Cancelled 21 25-33-0074 Patrick Sahli 3/29/90 John 22 05-13-0085 Robert Blunt Cancelled 23 05-14-0012 Robert Raschke 3/29/90 Barb 24 24-21-0029 Ravi Kacker 3/29/90 Earl 25 25-33-0030 Carolyn Reichow Cancelled 26 23-44-0023 Barb & Bill Cadogan 3/29/90 John 27 02-32-0007 Fred Saxe 3/29/90 John 28 07-23-0081 Faye Ulrich Cancelled 29 22-24-0013 Kevin Tomka 3/30/90 Barb 30 08-34-0031 Frank Reker Cancelled 31 05-12-0039 Stephen Clark Cancelled 32 24-21-0005 Carol Hoeft 3/30/90 Earl 33 20-44-0037 Van Andersen Cancelled 34 26-31-0008 Gerald McGraw 3/30/90 Dean 35 25-41-0027 Ray Stiles 3/30/90 Dean 36 26-12-0026 Kevin & Joni Strathy 3/30/90 John 37 25-22-0032 Robb Gilman 3/30/90 John 38 26-11-0008 David Stewart 3/30/90 John 39 14-32-0154 Lloyd Wartman Cancelled 40 17-14-0087 American Legion 4/02/90 Steven 41 01-41-0003 18 Park Business Ctr. 4/02/90 Steven 42 24-21-0007 Fred & Marcia LeVoir 4/02/90 Earl 43 10-23-0080 Craig Gontarek Cancelled 44 23-44-0006 Greg Wilkes 4/02/90 John 45 01-32-0012 Clarence Schafer 4/02/90 Lorna 46 27-14-0023 Bruce Haverly 4/02/90 Steven 47 04-42-0058 Terry Jorgenson 4/02/90 Dean 48 05-14-0018 Raymond Murray 4/02/90 Earl 49 05-42-0023 Kent Carlson 4/02/90 Dean 50 09-31-0091 Dixon Jones Cancelled 51 09-31-0092 Dixon Jones Cancelled 52 09-31-0093 Dixon Jones Cancelled Appeal 4 PID/Name Date Recd. Appraiser 53 09-31-0094 Dixon Jones Cancelled 54 26-24-0066 Steven Jenkins 4/02/90 Dean 55 08-14-0061 Johnson,Johnson,Johnson Cancelled 56 04-22-0052 Thomas Carey Cancelled 57 25-33-0016 Hark Drew 4/02/90 Lorna 58 25-41-0024 Jerry Reinhardt 4/02/90 Dean 59 24-21-0057 Douglas Reuter Cancelled 60 23-44-0003 Frank Dixon 4/02/90 John 61 24-32-0009 Dean & Kathy Johnson 4/02/90 John 62 35-22-0009 Donald 0. Smith 4/02/90 Dean 63 24-33-0005 Marvin Segal 4/02/90 John 64 09-23-0036 James Kaufman 4/02/90 Earl 65 03-11-0002 Donald Poupard 4/02/90 John 66 03-22-0002 Northwood Gas, Co. 4/02/90 Steven 67 03-22-0019 Northwood Gas, Co. 4/02/90 Steven 68 03-22-0021 Northwood Gas, Co. 4/02/90 Steven 69 26-44-0047 Lecy Const., Inc. Cancelled 70 26-12-0025 Lecy Const., Inc. Cancelled 71 25-33-0044 Lecy Const., Inc. Cancelled 72 23-43-0017 Roy & Ruth Lecy 4/02/90 John 73 26-44-0044 Lecy Const., Inc. 4/02/90 John 74 25-33-0028 Lecy Const., Inc. Cancelled 75 26-44-0053 Lecy Const., Inc. Cancelled 76 26-44-0046 Lecy Const., Inc. Cancelled 77 25-21-0019 Boyd Jones/T. Schwartz 4/02/90 John 78 25-21-0018 Boyd Jones/T. Schwartz 4/02/90 John 79 02-34-0003 R.Bjelland/T. Schwartz 4/02/90 John 80 14-31-0032 Orlo Johnson 4/03/90 Steven 81 14-31-0033 Orlo Johnson 4/03/90 Steven 82 14-31-0041 Orlo Johnson 4/03/90 Steven 83 25-22-0020 John & Carol Nelson 4/03/90 John 84 05-12-0015 Hark Hatasovsky Cancelled 85 26-24-0068 Emily Cheng Cancelled 86 04-24-0003 Jack Steinmetz 4/03/90 Barb 87 02-32-0004 Richard Waterbury 4/03/90 John 88 23-11-0058 Stanley Nesbitt 4/03/90 Earl 89 23-42-0011 Marta Lewis Cancelled 90 26-42-0030 Steven Hall Cancelled 91 17-12-0058 Bihari Desai 4/04/90 Lorna 92 25-41-0039 Andrzej Peczalski Cancelled 93 26-42-0028 Jerry Nelson Cancelled 94 14-22-0004 Datasery Cancelled 95 11-11-0020 Donald Sorenson 4/04/90 John 96 25-22-0028 William & Karen Goon 4/04/90 John 97 05-12-0007 John & Mary Lou Smythe Cancelled 98 04-24-0018 James & Nancy Stokes Cancelled 99 26-11-0024 Stephen Jacobs Cancelled 100 02-21-0029 Herb & Kathy Cantrill 4/05/90 John 101 23-13-0018 Lonny Gulden 4/05/90 John 102 10-24-0012 Paul Schee 4/05/90 Lorna 103 36-43-0003 Helen Fowler 4/06/90 Lorna 104 05-12-0040 James & Lori Olson 4/06/90 Earl 105 13-14-0017 Lexington Cabriole LTD. 4/06/90 Steven 106 07-32-0037 Kenneth Shannon 4/06/90 Barb 107 25-33-0076 Jonathan Moren 4/06/90 John 108 24-24-0104 Douglas Mac Lean 4/06/90 Earl 109 26-22-0051 Shirley Moyer Knutson 4/06/90 Lorna 110 27-11-0023 Gary Radtke 4/09/90 Barb 111 24-21-0006 Ann & Gerald Kalin 4/09/90 Earl 112 23-44-0007 Donald & Diana Lucker 4/09/90 John 113 03-34-0047 Lou & Noreen DeSotel Cancelled 114 25-22-0023 Lawrence Kitts 4/10/90 John 115 23-44-0012 John & Terri Cain 4/10/90 John 116 17-12-0073 Cynthia Chadwick 4/11/90 Earl 117 05-13-0023 Dennis Scheppmann 4/11/90 John 118 25-33-0066 Gregory Brown Cancelled 119 23-14-0039 Sexton & Heim Rlty. Cancelled 119 23-14-0040 Sexton & Heim Rlty. Cancelled 120 10-14-0111 Alvin & Mildred Bren 4/12/90 Earl 121 24-21-0036 Mary Boulay Cancelled Nppeai No. N • • PID # 15-116-22 33,0021 Date Received _/15/1990 • ,. - i*CQ MAR 1 5 1J Appraiser Lorna Lisell • . - APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be com ted by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 1/7 -/S73 / Work: }1'/ ,3 67- Name: /c ar er-ic ri c,eSert matiol ad re SS /7f/ , cynthla 7)r0✓- P-ITKA m.4ss3ys- Address of Property: yi7/3� Mo4:64n) ,CAAg- r11D -is-#6-AA-33-Oa.J January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ -yam o00 Date property was acquired: S/fly Purchase Price: S 6'S.as- Terms of Purchase: �y,4 Aka r6A6a-CA<ex) "4/.6A6E- Additions and alterations since purchase: - Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? /V'O If yes, at what price S — (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: S to ' 6 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated $value? (Please attach supporting information): ppiO,,,,,tLy 7-64s ,D 14f4S Nsrry 8 HuO Q.7'/,s1,o�Xosc�Ta I-TS el AssrgSe20 ✓AI-Winrio4 9'7. o ).T/e-re.v4at .040 Aior sal. $S rr Li-1)r0 NOT'S'eu.Zoe- To Sr5 £410,Tio.,r A o✓eat 4€,c,9cS- ChM. ocFap�,. V.IA-5 AGeE'P re'D ay Ff kA -zed .TL'l re? E✓e-N THog6N 141A-S N.'-mRLJ #/o,oOO ,Lo�Ni')2 TNA#J TAL-rit 4SK,AJ6 Pd€rc E, VIE 46' met e e oFFr� o-*6H 6�S /r/oRE GLEARLy kEFtrC7S -rNE {49L41477dAJole•77(6 me CQuA0 AS _ -y VIAZ 6FFe7 By MO. 241 Ae.7- Owe OR'r , 07(.1,64(oaS WAS 7wfi /461/ Sr of-2.pN r/frs 621414b qN'r E"kQem WHrcH vJE'Co,JctdDe 7-#47` 4 yq�1{AT/an) el Tier{ 62S AA E Too f//6//_ pli , _ r • Sig re o ner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is J helpful. ." %4. (To be completed by the Assessing Oepartment) Prior year values: Landppgq • Building55g Total Property h ClasS. • ; 1e 1/2/8988 160O0 56000 72000 TowTnwnhouse 1/2/B7 16000 56000 72000 Townhouse Last Inspection: 1 /t'q Appraiser: LerA.A. L,_ t1 Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: a H' c-4 c-tt- I-1 .� A.o /.�c.a+�c-,-r ,u�d�K t , apt �LE.,t_ ..t�•-� ut.c G,e7.g, ,tief•.0(td .c ,..,, 4 i1u•c c .,wa . Safe History v a Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments �a i / rav- i 76925 wn 3 /7/86 CRV S 79000 WD 13% 7 7 89 CRV `4: 64625 WD 9% HUD Sale Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: • vr JAN. 2, 1990 REAL PROPERTY ASSEESMENT VALUATION NOTICE , • ' CITY OF `EhEN PRAIRIE 1 • EDEN PRAIRIE ASSESSING OFFICE �( ,__i 7600 EXECUTIVE DRIVE PROPERTY I.D."'+ EDEN PRAIRIE MN 55344 r 15-116-ae-33-0021 TELEPHONE: 612 `937-2262 • �15-116-22-33-0021 11990 MARKET VALUE 72,000 i CLASSIFICATION 484 / �� RICHARD ' 'HENDRICKSON 17815 CYNTHIA DRIVE i• I MTKA., MN. 55345 .!; 1 PROPERTY TYPE ' RESIDENTIAL NON-HOMESTEAD The Eden Prairie-Board of Review will meet Thursday, April 19,1990 at 7:30 A.M. in the Council Chambers, 7600 Executive Drivel, Eden Prairie to review the 1990 market values and Classifications. jI, you intend to appeal, please call the Eden Prairie P ing Dept. et:937-7415 for an appointment and application form•t be returned by April P. For an appointment to the Hennepin County 8oe�rd of Equalization, which meets i June 18, 1990, call 348-5076 before Lunt 11, 1990. ' li R • - . 01101.1110,111112/0101.1..S.0......It 1.89 ,.—. • • ill, , 21A:Hal' 0.0 M I IN 1•1': 1.t s.,..•1,....,,-!,.,I,•i....,),,,i,, ,,,i4,,1 'I...T..,..,.,,,:----.,'.,'F L14`,•C"',..4.w„,,e,l,lk, u, V.I II1.,.'il'IVlt• r'r 1 s.l r•f'-.s°....n•;'". _ - --.-......--. AR.• -- -s--.....*_•:. f-... n iiEREirs A HUD HOME FOR EVERY BUYER. 10 DAY LISTINGS IR FHA FINANCING . . ::.....=. '47: ,‘,. ‘....... ........... Z.'.....Z..." ".r.: .... ,........ .,.......- .T...".... "...:..".= ... . Caw/WWI V. B.43,1, 1 Claww ra.lon a c Wt 7.1 MI 010...W. 2 .. :::000 • In int..NW Pmenoni Awl. 2 I 30.00/ • Pr...V re.B.Bion.W•0 WV. Paw WON A . 09•900 0B .21.3,1 t120t Ow.St. 2 61.030 WI NMI.2223 Orml BINE 277 w• 04.4 10.090 1 . w 330 2 , Con. 113,000 1 rt M...2.11-tOGIB Lane. 2 73.0100 .311.11 WO 3323 0...1. 3 tot 0000 • . Fri MOO. 2739 lame.W.SIM 11 00100 0007927.. 5.110,23 2 2 C.. 00.0110 0 C ,,,,...„.„,,„.„,... , 23.000 1,111970203 10.0.r.f.a07 7 1 /e.ro SIMI/ , , ..., ..... „...„..„„,....A... „ ,.... ..... 110..112. „, 3 „..... 3,...., ass. al Phol . .. „ .,.... ...... . 7 t t22131003:21....0*.9.....0 1 03 olmak MIN /11-1111.3.00 V-Ow.wwww0 3 r 7. 110.0011 .221.203 4.12...........C•I III 31.1 WOO 01.300-1111 3.0..111 6 1 1 .. 00.000 A •Sr Xi 2 , ..... &Moo .110.i VI 1.1.Cww..... 2. NOT ELIGIBLE FOR IFHA FINANCING Cwt. SIAM a.c . 1 0. 61.000 .9 Lams, r.st Mow . MOOG a "'..."''..tr.:=7:4.4.....2.....• .." "..." , .„ 2 1/121.31,203 3.1.1.ese.3111„.. • , „... . ••.• r Ow.. B0.000 • sroomana t.sor c....e.o. r • Spam MOM In/sm.'s.lama res...C.e...in 2 1 Co. H.M. G . lot1ww. ... yr I r 2,, i• r...e. so•000 a c ,,,r.....,...T.,"..".. ' ' '.... ...... . srt r 211 MO...Bee 2 o 09,003 3 C 1.1, 00.0. ...00 1., 13090... 3 7 1.11. 19.000 1,C . 1 ......„. .11 „..... A .newolla sr,NW/la 22,2 W... 1 t I BOB NAGS alaft St.•32t .1 * 49009 110,000•C W,410 31:1112152*0499: 3 i 70019* /3.11110 20,Walt 193 WI UM.Pi , 00.0e0 A 19.000 Tr,M..Wwit...row•or, , c.a. CIA., a ''.....3.......... Ls...« to t wW21-02 211.114www•11 1 01 0, 20.000 W B. .". '' ' '"'" ...". 2ri 09')9.)309 2900,11 St 9 I. ' 17.000 A OW 70.1291.303240,00909 II 01 1211,000 • at Pi 1 ri Cw. 40.000 B •• .`• NAM A . ESULTS HOTLINE: 333-SOLD ON(76531 AFTER 4 P.M. . , BID OPENING DAY INSTRUCTIONS .4°.",=...tr;.::v,•41,7°,.1."„..." - On Tuosday,HUD will held seminars at 9,00 AM in Room 112 to answer questions soles agents ot the general public may CODES&INCENTIVES to OhOUt HUD Hornet Bet BanOwwWw•...144.4w.1..12 Bow.111............ , W www 10 W.w..•.4.0•WW0 ..—.A wobewd.oW41.1.mow -,,, . ..••,T11*"*.ttrt"..%•.••.1•11,11.20 WI,1.41 Wiwnia• ' ,w.w.ww3 www r.w..........tn.... II ...........=............;:...............r..... •awe maw ere...am...I,a Pm....a...a.....• ..„.............--- •---...,..,.......... ............ sunutns„........ '..".:•^".'1,',..17.•ar'.7ra's'a 7.Lr,:,...*.,P: C .."t..7:::.'"......."%."'r....•.'"%"s.*.*%r,=t•r""'.. ::.=='"?........=:::=7:41...,r:::tr. an.s.....•••.:a.as a.t.toms mons.a......r... i••ina swootlion p.m..er roe...on t102....1 EXTENDED BID LIST ... ........ .... ,.. ....... -..,.. ...... .... 9:'.7.3.79,..,, 1,0 We,..• 2 zr r yoa.roar 6,1••a.In...am.. ICCea. • * 2,lusapr,o, N."•21 Pao.,•.I •S•f.0 no 2.i t. rt wws.33 tr.....nr,--....1.- „...• ,...,. , ,„....,.. :4...-1.7-....=4. —. ........,... ........,- • ..,.',a 1 MI :•••••,.01.6.0.6 ...,. 3 I. 1/1.4930.1 1:0977.3.7.1 MOW• 1 i • 11,•••••Ww to :11.2. I t twas I wi wwwwwww woo W Me ow cow t ..........., ...,,,,, ../„.....„0 ... . t „,,.....,„ .....„„.„A,•. „.... 1 Vers:Br". .3.. „t'arS,.. w.owe...1 ..".. ' ' W Wr..). ........1www..ot •••••••nu c..... • .1.71.......... ,.....,., • ”'........ i....SOLO'. ..,.......... ....• •••• ' n,...na ...................,....so.....3.32 •......... sr am.... , ...so• c.o.."•,.• „,,.„..., LILL.=...a. 1.33 ow wow 1 27z,zn,r::Liza-,.... , ,,,,...... ,=.„„-..... ,,...,• .,. ,,,,...... it...-....,........- .,.....,,.,,,.. ,.. -..... :......„........,.....,....:::T...... ,._ r t wt.Boa la.sa..s.......... sem.4.• , , 2ot...au so to...I...7...mar.. se..s-K. -.—.....1-7 " ' ,„......., ....',1%",:,,...... ,,....,. ,.. ,,,.,..,..,,. ..-...7.47,..,...., ...,..... . ,Tr°,..,.•..1:.-11`.,.,''.....:7.7..,",'..'.. ,,..,..-,... :,......--....... ,...,.,.,.........,., -,„„..„„ :,".:...'"?.:,,....... ....,- 111111111r Appeal No. 3 PID # 04-116-22 23 0039 Date Received Vj�/, a Appraiser Rarb Cook APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 9 3 4/—90 t 5 / ��r I Work: Name: erx�n 13. X.-4.-10✓✓n d e t) Address of Property: 6 6 C. Iwr 424dl_t+.et January 2, 1990 valuation as it appeaK on the not ce• 5,0, '-rD Date property was acquircd: l9 — Purchase Price: $ 02 D err-r? Terms of Purchase: �.K 6 S Additions and alterations since purchase: 741rirp Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? If yes, at what price $ 8p,.era-o (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 575; .' o What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): G O /71. ; . Sign ure of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 �GOGb `occ%p � ' �2 1/2/88 3coo0 bo`'oO 1/2/87 a5w0 cy000 F!q.poo +e� Last Inspection: j2/1/g7 Appraiser: sorb CcoK Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments / $ / / S ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. PID # 04-116-22 24 0050 Date Receivedkgl„ MA, . Appraiser Ijcirh Cnnk " APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW(To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home:"/,2 1 h3.i'-, j Work:y„,:� Name: 1 - /'eiii:r� C l? , 1/�(Al(se,A) Address of Property: £..g? /(f//QT'Z Li? j= /�/)L/rJ /'/?,y//c'16 January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ y.5 C,e•n Date property was acquired: /9e,/ Purchase Price: $ Ocu/U,-,p - ak,47*--pro,�E_? Terms of Purchase: CA' C 1.1 Additions and alterations since purchase: ( /_xerp j /,rf / IMM 7gEE5 /j iw.'p J y (1,ry le rvIc ii 0 � &oil/z lc' .4T l�/s 1 Y/ /V 5e Cost of additions and alterations: � u E 27- Is property listed for sale? /1/0 .If yes, at what price $ - (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $114, 7k10/p, T11/'/,,e,k,,GO, What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? • (Please attach supporting information): r'14 s..,,J!r a tr lca,ect�Leue wz .s MCP CuL, w l a,y%n ,�.T� ett c..,-t1 4,, ;re 7L., 1 '-z_, -6 ,.LL Y"C" .),..7, .:tf. -14 t ..✓pie. ,L p k, ci.,.t.FP, ,,,aIte -L.(zf 75-p-ta<I.c.c.),.2/.�.��,y4.. )4 ,,,,z .'- �k 2L.ye-e..�.. 4,aI11.e_k-,..e.;4. , iqC - fch.e 1 E i"iuir.-a+f C--4K c„)41 sew.,", e w �/ C./ / �Gn{/ 4�� i-.,, a ,' �' Signature of OwnQ� please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 i rfv� cqo^.-? - 1/2/88 �� — 1/2/878 =Gc�� ;c'a-� �.=_-o R ,.',-4 GCS cc--- Last Inspection: 2_/,22/j Appraiser: Garb CocL Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: 4421:c-,,c-0i ?..1 .tl.. ( C+ cS UF_ N'lUa� d c_C"n...4 _t�•f� .- �.' c,.i.�-F' .r-:!a.,- .•..-.. L.l n.cr.a. -1,-el af.l.:,. /gvci cv.:i...ay'..ti.c-1 t,C.a• . %. Sale`History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments / / $ —/_/— $ ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: �) ���ff a Date Received 3/16/1990 r + UCl? " _ Appraiser Barb Cook b t` Ai.. ► 1" • f,r "j PID ' 04-116-22 24 D050 • 1% r1 d - k' ? ♦.;^� 4i. r,• , �� C. 0. Thompson .:7'41-1:-. ..`t ' . �r ,1. ; V,_4 /_.- .r ;' ' C'-';' ' `" ° • F.. l '� • 1: C !' .: ,tt1� ,' r r �y yLv - ". - I • Appeal No. Date Receivel4Ii yaR 2 14vu PID # 24-116-22 31 0104 Appraiser John Sams • APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW • (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: PIN- r3 qy y � Work: 949_ z6q Name: lloBEtcr A4.50 430W Du.aw44%) Address of Property: 9/3y For January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ a0.000 Date property was acquired: 8/p(Q Purchase Price: $ 1E,r oov Terms of Purchase: Ju ,i,, PP Additions and alterations since purchase: /0E Cost of additions and alterations: •— o — Is property listed for sale? /.7p If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ a20,004) What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): This home has continually been over appraised; after construction was comlpete 1984 appraisal was 199,300 tkis was contested and lowered to 193,300 in 1985. We bought the home in 1986 and paid 185,000, we abated the appraisal and it was lowered to the true Market Value. 1987 up 4,000 to 189,000; 1988 up 7800 to 196,800; 1989 up 6600 to 203,400; now again up 8600 to 212,000. We have acknowledged to the appraiser that this is a very nice home; however it is very unique in its design and simply was way overbuilt. It never has nor will it ever sell for these over inflated appraisals. We are located in an area of single family homes, apartments, townhomes all of whi re of much lower appraised value. �V Signature" of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 140800 16afoc70 d0_�GYo 1/2/8B 39500 /57.3oO lge;oo (. • 1/2/87 38CCQ 15ioo0 igyow Last Inspection: _/L/gs, Appraiser: 5ohw Sav►n5 Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: ldsn.e na o-..*- -.e- ,{ ,yti 'L�.A anL.h GEC L, �kt.1.4 ,.e.rt.A-Gill. 4, a. jr • n v��aac� Y�Ease -tit&n, G `t'i- 1�I�,r'( �qQ . OS70 A.d.luAtii�Fi+ i 7.4 vL Sal History tt%k. Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments /3/g6 CkV $ i85000 c•&,75'Jo / / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. �Er• ro /I Date Receive - row, > ,. .: PID # 24-116-22 31 0107 Appraiser John Sams APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: tl'ft lit 1- ��/ Work: lutrG Name: I�G ( g. ivrU1F� :� Address of Property: —sit m F �rcr•�° `. t) ! I4'iP nf��, 3/4 January 2, 1990 valuation as it ap ears on he not ce: 40S7��o. Date property was acquired: i 7 Purcha a Price: $ /4,/'—ca cG� Terms of Purchase: (Isrrt.9oT F., \ �-(4Fl6 u,G.4`i jj,g/-ja ✓u. ilen-T'L 1 n n Additions and alterations since purchase: et--*►rt)nlc.Y eie , �i/e47Sr,Y ?Pee'e k1P �i A,L J mN, i �n Se - i/ Cost of addition and alterations: IfT es atwhatprice $ Is property listed for sale? /6 Y (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 1719, C. What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated iia ue? (Please attach supporting information): lQ 90 p C114g- he 641.E (1 ,4'4, Pi6 iiii-- //6-..Li - 3/ 0/O /7O/ C?ir�, QI so ,� olif- //6-11- ?/- 0/0. //70 kia, 9/ 7 ✓ r, &�-1 l b N$'-4-31 - c� '`/I/6 1lei d4-1/6 - 4,-)-.3/ •-,r2)//di /y-7 6 c.oc� gna ure o wn /90 Please note: This form'requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 4'137T7 I pq"1 DO T ii'OO moo. 1/2/88 4;900 1a5S07 l t,ENCO leeo• 1/2/87 yia0O ►aoS'O /4 07oo Rom. Last Inspection: 3h1/p Appraiser: "Sohn &aims Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments aJ_ rip; — ibs o00 _/_/_ $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. 13 PID # 17-116-22 24 0030 Date Receive MAR t. i.3z") Appraiser Lorna Lisell APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: ?3 '- 0 7,7 Work: rtv„,,,, Name: �4t-Ai- /�. �16—kif/I A.litam „id Address of Property: /7o 61- yYEs7' /3g 0January 2, 1990 valuation as it Appears on the notice: $ Oil?,74r0 Date property was acquired: 3- Purchase Price: $ l_g y s s o — 7 Terms of Purchase: 4toesoup,110 Additions and alterations since purchase: ",t.cnQ Cost of additions and alterations: -74-4,_ Is property listed for sale? .744 If yes, at what price $ ��-rr-C (attach copy of listing agreemdntj a o d Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $/34 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? , (Please attach supporting information): 7 j fI' . .4,4-., .f:Y - a Jsad -e.P l-ate``' -,..-- .....y..,.........-/A,J.0,--"..„7"--,-) i e.r..t..,..,--,_-y ' , i ,a-7e z Signa wner1.1 � Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/8• 164900 88888 164900 2449Uu Residento ial l 1/2/B8 l 1/2/87 9000 9000 Land Last Inspection: l/1/311 Appraiser: LovNA.. Lrsell Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Convents E.7.7:11B7 CRV $ 299679 W.D. 10.5% / / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: _ Appeal No. �];;: IiitiR c T,JU PID # 24-116-22 43 0010 Date Received"" Appraiser Earl Zent APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: ?vs- 5,324 Work: 370-Prsc, Name: J/NUe:E /./ 02/97 ERSON Address of Property: 92)(• MSAcw zw9y January 2, 1990 valuation as It appears on the notice: $ /1/7 yoo Date property was acquired: 2/,/ii Purchase Price: $ /YP,000 Terms of Purchase: fin �,.cs..n Additions and alterations since purchase: Wpu rhfez mire-mew. &wear Fa(g1M, aeon% Cost of additions and alterations: "Jove, Is property listed for sale? ryo If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 13.c o,o What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? • (Please attach supporting information): 1 CCQYeSTEQ /NFo&mRTi.n, ra A' 1ZE)94.7o4 f4/1111,,/+0 w17HOUR AREA ABour Qe tr,'r s4,L6L oc AP o/MPoPnl4 84c Li AMEN t en,iev£ 1-k/r7 eWOF OF 77.Etc 1io ' ;. aa411.T BY Tin£ 4mis Salo 12u out Orme, 0. . Mr"- IS Akro 4.4mrmlyyw6 cow coin, ,A&*r 411t4r LY,LL MA P)EN Tb ANv e,,. ,.AkeS PO 0.0414 /i[ �T ge. CA. "Ael FAR dYcv 1eASnac T2AFF+4, gnature of wner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 nfsooD 10 L/00 /47�fOO (� 1/2/88 g000p /0P700 14a700 1/2/87 SoOD (ia100 /'t'7/00 Last Inspection: ±/ o/1 Appraiser: g--Arl Ze�fi Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 75771 CeV ty87o0 wo -7.375% 7/_1_0 c-70- $ (:3-7oco _ w0 7.7 cktl iao1'53 wO ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: 4$3`947;132;i/06as•+Lvi•c 5159.950 li .• CAN/11)04• S 41/��1OQa `p6607S VM6ISA•11210 STY•SR! ►IWA L4145000 j v'l Imo•,,,y D i t.I Oaf... 01/16/11 72 DAYS P750 S051110LH114900 15142,000 { fv. NNUMTOFCl ITAx13301 10F IMP All .10 - �' MMN 10111 MAIMS 2R sumjT.4 winS2306 Ua • DIST sa SUS 1 Cow.,MENN Al 0 1EN0 N 2M TA1 sla7 N i MY y -tA LR/1x12fxf/x1A3 AC.2 MS FOR 1111'1 TWAT 102N AMMAN WAY 900 ANOEIISONLA01g/NW1 TO MASCO WAY TO LEAFTOF C10CL1 M1w 101N11AMM DP S1N7 MYMA1Ra7 LAU FANTASTIC MULTI LEV1L 11O14 AMMO MLS N-TIP F0ISMIVP - 06F 1112 SUB couNri111101 a 111D N 01010.0ON PANS PPIFICT FON[Irma mew F10MU TO ON 1.13711120 ACO FOR ISM TF Yips 1171 TO 11T0.000 FA11ILt 000M.1111 WPM 0 JUST MWIC!. 000T1 N 11 tO M011N111W1/AMWAS'W 1010.4 M00Ef00N4lt LAMOSCA110 F0T10 OM THE FAMILY 100M OUT171N0110 PUT oar MCONATEO TO/0N0C100 CLASSIC 9GAL AMOEN MILLS LOT 11 0.0C11 A WALL COVSI0M00 MO SWOOP TIMATIMIRS00tlCT F001 Or OWNER. NO25s troy 200N ILW CWCO NIL REFA66.004.031 . i1. W10 PAW 10 M 4OT140101N01LACl W010305 I.AMOK t AF110x'CS es-CO CM MC WONIO MAT!UPI TAIO.NOR MRMAAa1 F0MNC0101I U M 14U21 •1 Uit0111 Mt MC 1E3VIS CON MD III D1 M 10111 u U 11113 HOOT FA GAS MTO050000 NTt; MD 11S 1'1S C CO •NNJN0�0WF.Op 0 M 1111 30 U 11012 E17 W000 TM CONn 001177 API 1 A1101 •R SCLCO KY f111 IA L 10111 aMTF NO PS1N SMICON ASM1 U 120,az11 71. 13111 Y AMC 01 ISx11 a a111 AY FA ON 101121112 Wr+L/ FN L 11123 GM 2• GOY ENJOY TMSLOVOL1 0 31 12111 NT OTUCC• AMP 001117 APIA ' FS 1300 MOMS AND OPOLNO1 IT 10011 a 11111 PM NOT. 11112 2MR0'. All 'VT BA Y MS21 SA 1 1T7 1110 SO 272 1M s27.10N 101201 F0 0113 E0 11110 3• 001 •10A01 MP 013311010 .-.. 11AN ',#006220,00 F tat Ms1R 1 IF 2:. ... 3 FN/T•1': _6N71a'. I p16013 x111A f1A•1/110 STYa1V/ CONY 14141500 06101/61 11 DAYS PTS.0 104237 0t1•5141,100 14135,000 AT j . ._... . _ j , 1 r0N1AMPNNWAY `IM5243A tlF Wye •IA '. .. MOON FORM OP PPM TASW1L51221L LANE 001 PM SUSI COUNTY NUN Al0 MO LIS 1070120Ra11n At0 N110111N F 1111T MP 0111 cTY 11•AI0E120NLARI0.IW110 AMNIA WAY LOVELY OM10WNa CUNOM 00T•N110TMASONAIULTLUVII LOCATED N TNEFMINVI.Wa11AT4OITQNNROIFOOMM 01IM0 A0.VICIOUS NC011C1M1N FORM MEMO W00010 LOT.WOFES40NAL LAMOICANNO. • LEGAL LOT 111LOCA S 1/40114NILLS F10 24 11/•22.11-0a1 yCN C.00 ' MQ a1AN00wo.00F:MN L APN4P L AM11;CS 1L CS40 tC Lt oft113111 10 U112113I T A01 C TE014FMA.VA.ON. ON 12112 21 U 11112 JMATIA OAS I630 wr♦0.N 0 26 WAIT SIT W000.1• 1Ywo CONv COO ASM1 Al 10111 4 M10111 5SMTF VA SO 2WMN AIM' . F1 IMI1 S124 OAR C' G3 451360 s0M7344 VYF SA ,012000 SO VI 1N171.1110 111(20' Appeal No. /7 Date Received 3/28/1990 • PID # 24-116-22 44 0005 Appraiser Dean Jacobs APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: q 4y-a2C 3 /� Work: Name: `"iccbe G(rc L l cir, . ,C\edit er A Address of Property: g3l„j CQO�'l{ `tO- �,,\ January 2, 1990 valuation as appears on the not ce: $ 1 1Q‘�uV Date property was acquired: (Jfl•,- c b dI Purchase Price: $ Terms of Purchase: �oc\\-tt c$ € keedA Additions and alterations since purchase: c\op•P Cost of additions and alterations: +' Is property listed for sale?OP! If yes, at what price $ cefs (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ � � What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): cP 4rAS C Signature of wner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 33900 t i7oa g—(oC�O 1/2/88 3a3c0 474#O0 97 L. 1/2/87 loOO 4SSGO 76SO0 Last Inspection: g L/gy Appraiser: pear 30.c4=b . Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale Histor Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments / $ %a $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: • JAMES M. GROBE, INC. March 14, 1990 George and Linda Sicheneder 9360 County Road 18 Eden Prairie, MN 55344 RE: Property inquiries. Dear Linda: I have been marketing this property for over five years and have not had one serious inquiry from a prospect wanting to purchase the property as a home site. The location fronting on County Road 18 has discouraged any residential interest. Why would anyone want to live on a three acre property fronting on a road that will eventually a freeway. We have been unable to find anyone with the desire to buy this property as a homesite and value should reflect this. Sincerely,l James if. Grobe JMG/ma Commercial Real Estate Services 10249 Yellow Circle Drive,Minnetonka, MN 55343 (612)936-0760 „\ ;` r0 • • �� ` t v�G (V .� Q\\isAj, c\C‘C'1. \61',w\T .\k:;;ti, <\c-\(•:;_o . LA ki\Cr kii\Ct \C) c)C1 Clif\t/S-C) cccU,NN'R,N0,3,_,1-w Nr\ON c\cAO 91L-'\- c-1 -3\ek ck v\o 't.k.,OciS,tko ck5 1--PcYc, a \ \`: 53''‘‘ .-) k-)0i)')C. \_CC 1 Li\i‘NA\,-1\kk S<I2Nso,.ohl, 1 Appeal No. Iq PID # 25-116-22 33 0038 Date Received 3/28/1990 Appraiser APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: go-T.//S3-7 Name: Jan 'Bet it\ Work: Address of Property: //C),30 lane January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: % 2!Q g v"-o Date property was acquir d: /p R Purchase Price: $ Z.zS/uuo Terms of Purchase: o- vrc c, ( 1ve,tiL,-.a/ Additions and alterations since purchase: Cost of additions and alterati n Is property listed for sale? Q If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 2'/Soap What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above staged value? (Please attach supporting information): 'Fa:ec9 rn /4use Cos / I- rrc oc-e or,'ce v- t/cl/ue o� Nfai�G 4,,,e5 4r 5ck �hZ/ tinSo/& / i nature of Owner f Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 5/000 .2r-7O0D A,gocb 1/2/88 3400 1/2/87 3300 — 3$Do F Last Inspection: /a/11 Appra se -l0ti,ti Su.5 Building.Permits/Appraiser Comments: • ,,. ,.Lcrn.P Da0- °1. • Mtn, 1.� 0 44. .0 a¢ .o. Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments pro/ 6-kJ $ y34oO SA1¢ iS for I +o„Iy / / $ ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. ai PID # 25-116-22 33 0074 Date Received Joh3/29/1990 Appraiser APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 9yz-8334 ! ��� Work: 2 7 7- MV7 Name: 1�-'A l:,i..t .7F/PAi SA H/., Address of Property: //n/17 13lucS7'Errt LAI January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ .2t.V 040 Date property was acquired: 2-2G-88 Purchase Price: $ A/8,UDO Terms of Purchase: /4/All PLor ok 6 mild eesh. Additions and alterations since purchase: A/an/E Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? )/ES If yes, at what price $ 248,006 (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 199D is: $ 2 Y9 200 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? , (Please attach supporting information): 7' 7 e /24.6eAf' f44t6 p/GAi6R /m .-2 ..ge r-t A.,.. //i 7/tc A/C�LiI,.kae/. id AttmeAd (info. was not sent with appeal) TO Gt/i rA 7. dQ/z 7/ /4sr')4".0,M5 ASSessm /Y7 WE lro,..te L&c9AJ MRRAFf:i+y oft( A0.•,,6 Zr a/6R ONE .t.../dA 41 G ges a . 81 nature of owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Buildin 2 Total Propert Class. 1/2/89 53oa0 ar I00O .ZbV000 1/2/88 y,000 010.000 /73000 lf: ,patr+0.13 1/2/87 A000 .COO t-- Last Inspection: ,/(o/lqj APpra ser: 'TQhvk SavK� Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Convents i//C/S1 ai FCoo WO 5ellcr 1..5 (4.1a+$d- 1/ $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. PID # 05-116-22 14 0012 Date Received 3/29/1990 Appraiser APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: q 34-5 7 Q 3 Work: 914--10614a". Name: Rotoert 3. ' Marl c 1 M, �asc:.0(e. Address of Property: 10599 Mere, 1 1>r, eciept Prairie, January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ I3(0.9oo. Date property was acquired: 3/3o/g7 Purchase Price: $ !AS,5cO. Terms of Purchase: As 1s" Additions and alterations since purchase: SoLlecy-4e.. bQ. L 10 rc1. 0.,�(,�, —ayrs coo. Cost of additions and alterations: i.5oo. 1 Is property listed for sale? Ylo If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ /a 6,,COO What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? • (Please/attach supporting information): O,� ll GA.. dt.c-tie�!q �l w �-�'e-r lQ d x�z,.c..� ,�lt,e>,a. . /lam. 11 .,e fo 'lut/caece),a e- x�l.iruh,1i 4-e,�sa� e�(1 p�.ca.�r� �s+r./te-.ca-� , 1/ems+ )[ �+u�/l4 .teat% ,i,„cn / �It J IZ• G(`C G'ec l WL�Lorrc .lMQ4& i�-v t{Fu V {LC�2¢b aJt a ct�r�C 44,Ielk �ti AAA, A,tsy�i.�" Alit-la 1 µa U[ cy ,�ucc�i �tt..CGv 02Kit ca. yLRvL ll 4-elt 7 u Please note: This form 'requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Buildin Total Pro ert Class. 1/2/89 .3000 g o�p i3oS0o 1/2/88 3Npp oO 13Tx500 1/2/87 op o 45 i?S300 _ Last Inspection: off//0j Appraiser: lohh 5444.5 Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 17_/81 Le.Q $ 1�67Sa W� / /_ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. a(-1 Date Received 3/29/1990 PID # 24-116-22 21 0029 Appraiser Earl Zent APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW ��)) /' (To be c leted by owner - please print) Telephone Home: "l44 _A$ 446 A-VI K KAGIce(1.. Work: 33O 36T1 Name: �-�' " Address of Property: g7at RENT- .2?iOC •t /"t/} 2IRIb/ mN S53y4 January 2, 1990 valuation as .ppe.rs on the notice! $ I6 50 Date property was acqguired: 4;.,/I:a Purchase Price: $ 15.1/90U Terms of Purchase: CONVatJfON: MICE— Additions and alterations since purchase: t\i(DNE Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? NO If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $J(3 5 0 o What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stilted value? (Please attach supporting information): (.) Earl Zelk reU'eroeiC f 1 ,pit. Mack Iggq Aczi• �ea& 0„,41 un la. Point ' IdltgL C17-)W , a ed fo .j prey /cceocamn hita f&i,000 Ecid Zea Atirbuld 4 tri OYfah 27— 1993 tut yard 9 Signature of Owner ` ,1,0, 4 &acne' n .., �4 f�oF^°rtt aa2 9 02500 In uu g.Overti ant whic g10 Please note: T . form requests privateUor confidential data o applit is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 S,OOO 109000 /vl0oo 1/2/8B 5030O tisso0 /652C00 1/2/87 0300 /logo° i5,aoo Last Inspection: Sal Sallti Appraiser: :a rt Ze x-}- Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: i,.Avs .K2-itavAiLoacl AvA4 ps o,ir U At- .pie hR-a+, 11 UU Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments te/i6 (. J !$ 53oop WD ro% / /7ti ct $ 13e1750 w 75 cRO y�yci� WO Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. a(c 23-116-22-44-0023 Date Received 3/29/1990 T �' MAP e y ' 40 Appraiser 5. • APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: (hi h-1(4y Work: Name:3)CA! b o)c._ `4' 3h)l Cc ,403c,.) Address of Property: i`3 3 1 Ce L,Ai' (2,2o2 P January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: 5 9 7 7 c; Date property was acquired: q/B 1 Purchase Price: $ 4. '' n Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: .jcr(\ E o Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? N() If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: S 3 �. c,' r,,o What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? , (Please attach supporting information): C-e', atA 7 \t .\-?'ck -Yc,.) 500o -YC,' 4 '1, /y-(-,s) ST a.4-- c,--‘) 1‘49 O00 - IAoco SA-,)( cm-. +--Nc,.) ,-'-1 -car) 114 35,OoO ' � ev c .c d rrun) )e Q$ 'c�i&fa '. /� A 1 .p z)go .aY(t).b�.,D Cr-,80 - Signature of Owner Please note: This form'requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 115000 aSf;,?OO 39720 k 1/2/88 90ooO ZAwoq0C2 aszegC0 e 1/2/87 $50 — .S o0O 1.... Last Inspection: r0//99 Appraiser: Sam Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 5:41/2_7 1:70- H5. 160 w0 (0.5°70 / / S Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: 1 0 yn, CI '..- Q. 4 } Q 4) u t A°-- 'au_ ._ 8 ($y N 'O - , 0 V__— tl Q c. oQ -t7 co— r ci .9 t o -----.t .. a 8 a § c,cs 6 c 6 `n r -- 0— O — ra Appraiser ,lnhn calve PID 0 02-116-22 32 0007 APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD.OF REVIEW Received March 29, 1990 (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 941 693 Appeal # c%7 Work: 544.3501 Name: Frederick L Saxe Address of Property: 6761 Beach Rd • January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 2$o 6c0 Date property was acquired: 7/1/68 Purchase Price: S 43.900 • Terms of Purchase: Mortgage & cash • Additions and alterations since purchase: None • Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? No If yes, at what price S (attach copy of°listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 194.300 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): Market Value estimate: 1990 up 29% over prior year 1989 250,000 vs 194,300 1989 " 10% " " " 1988 194,300 vs 176,700 1988 " 4% " " " 1987 176.700 vs 169,700 1987 " 3}% " " 1986 169,700 vs 164,000 Market value 1970 -- 1990 up 605% 1970 414 1989 un 470% Taxes 1970--1989 up 306% My earnings up 22 years- 50% . g p p Owner ` fe Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land • Building Total Property Class. 1/2/8' A‘rgoo '7gscn 1q�13co ,� 1/2/88 g expo 40500 +7h7co Q_ 1/2/87 ESoo st1oo 1b97G0 Last Inspection: / / Appra sew- . Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments • Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2 Assessor's value adjusted to: • 3 Assessor's value sustained: • Appeal No. :=,'9 Date Received - 3/3n/igg0 PION 22-116-22 24 0013 Appraiser Rarh frank APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 7 '9-a2 8/,s ----- Work: Name: Ale✓/v 4, /0/j Address of Property: 4/4 A , ''00A O,e• January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ //.l, 000 Date property was acquired: Purchase Price: $ /O / 90e, Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: /i✓1r Cost of additions and alterations: D- • - Is property listed for sale? Ato If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ /&4 D oO What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? , (Please attach supporting information): 4/o EA?� Ro+in ,e/.„v 44///1 t✓o poss',2,!'�+/ 4r_ A 3R.a ?ewer*, o,oc>/ ' ,3-- 4,00 0 / 3) /'0 ,NAB(CO " 1_!.Qr,a 1.40rt—P--- � peinap-p 21.474;4r0 Imveb---; ,v1/7 er,zigi Aircl— dad N 4f,2E, 7744s /7�P9P TowneE` i—) aMst Signature r Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Pro ert Class. 772/89 a7coo i5770O iO�700 1/2/8B abC00 7ai500 1/2/87 a5&JO b5%00 — Last Inspection: IN /15 Appraiser: &avb (leoK Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 4 u/S$ v $ ;oygi0o WO cic10 a/.(v_/ $ C/454 ,iO Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: i3) Assessor's value susined: Appeal No. 3� PID # 24-116-22 21 0005 Date Received 3/30/1990 Appraiser Fart Zant APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW ,i! (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: /Z/g''7-/��/ Work: kart/rR/6a/y Name: 044)L /06/ Address of Property: f , 7 hoee Je,'vc January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ /,S oop Date property was acquired: aPurchase Price: $ 77,c Terms of Purchase: j' Additions and alterations since purchase: /10/0/1/dc- Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? ^/Q If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $/ 4 OO What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): D 7/i'i //1/v6P6WI�r AFC/31/LS f/n'c V/ afNc ur/1i//4/ L'157 y6 2e /+/D.t/E /9(. A.5 /•//4y A 7f1E el.7y Eve/cg,17—O '. g_,4 A( 4/C y /De f7 CAc ffew5c oN Ti/F $'r c Si:Ct (Buie i ley Ylin< (3dickr) /S iz'e' 10e Ar A.✓ ASC." A&35 7//slr///!f/ 4 .e/43Fp i;a 'e // cAedr� / z OF SA/PE Dei661.14uy AL°cofHSlA FdC /1r GBHi/2% gar jf//TA/low /5 ece,ee/'e z y AP/''""5 2) fiv.e 4-655 7/k9,i/ Ike" 16=7-ae OGm/NE, A11,),7"t/RG I "fled 4'finEA/TS /.V2Z/0? 1cExzYtt1C /JAUC• /3E-.✓ Awe 4y 7i / Fo2mcr� oc.0.✓6-s - g. hI Saed Geg tin/6 Auy (44,41 Signaturq UX se,.d Geri 4653 ,14(eeMt( ,obeC ' l /1/n our u r TGL[/.✓ Please note: This form'requests private or confider! is being collected for purposes of review by the Ci �A/T7L A��/L �� /��0 Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for herein. The submission of this data is not mandator an accurate assessment of the property prior to the! helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/B9 (40bO0 G-7g00 135SSCO 1/2/88 3473o0 `10 r 3'/000 1/2/87 -77t00 Iag700 I� Last Inspection: g/121M Appraiser: lAri ZIA+ Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: '+r vtc -WAG -paw per a .41.-- 01, A,Suo • Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments (ku $ i?7S w0 / / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: 26-116-22-31-0008 Appeal No. 314 Date Peceived 3/30/90 Appraiser Dean Jacobs APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW(To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: y/' /-,2 6 9 `'7 Work: Al- X2/r Name: Gorn/J F . al D raw - inaria,'.f iehc Address of Property: /a//s- Oxcbo LAJ Or January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ I a S, i''6D Date property was acquired: "Ii q Purchase Price: $ SCs, e-rm it) Terms of Purchase: /I �l n ee Additions and alterations since purchase: ).�0�j, /„ o�[c„C, ,u,a.oarn.,. Cost of additions and alterati ns:%1,€'b'D ern Is property listed for sale? ►I n If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? , • (Please attach supporting information): 0 11 �e � 0. ,1 ' }/ LI.:///(1 � �� s, ozr ��jp,�✓L. ^a///qeJi,/..4.,... Qo!P.�4,{u/ _ v-vvJ) f�Z./Gixh.2.l� A/ .1. Ir/� .Li../ /J �(rR.t.td� 1LQ�� k G ,�`-L` RAT' N} ia--j/ �i}-L ii'"ki4,' i M , /�A Al Jt!(tn.ro� !'uGctt Signatur of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Propert Class. 1/2/89 30000 93Rcx) td5F56 1/2/88 a3boo RgSoo it tom 1/2/87 30-700 r D i0 Crop Last Inspection: 1 /t3/19 Appraiser: in. Rs5 Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 7- /7 C kJ $ S Lib% cud ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. 3 S Date Received 3/30/1990 PID # 25-116-22 41 0027 Appraiser Haan Jambs APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Work: 941-0328 370-3009 Name: Ray M. Stiles Address of Property: 9920 Balmoral Lane January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $128,700 later adj. to 119,500 Date property was acquired: 11/79 Purchase Price: $ 77,490 base with additional items Terms of Purchase: FHA loan of $60,000 (35,035 Down Pmtl & appliances: $95,035 Additions and alterations since purchase: Central Air Conditioning. Sheetrock and partial bathroom inprovements in lower level. Cost of additions and alterations: $950 C/A. $500 sheetrock & tub/stool Is property listed for sale? No If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) 112,000 Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach sorting information): Attached items: I urrent appraisal of 3/30/90 showing 6 comparable sales with an indicated market value of $112,000 prepared by Ray Stiles (owner) an appraiser with (Multi-family) the U.S. Dept. of Housing & Urban Development (HUD) with 18 years experience in real estate appraising, investing, new construction and sales. Reviewed by Angie Johnson, Review Appraiser with HUD. �� Z,pSecond appraisal completed 10/4/89 ordered '.ii natur Hof de' by Metropolitan Mtg. Co. for refinance. 9 Indicated value of $115,000 (poor selection of 2 comps - value should be lower) Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 33-2,OO -73300 106 ,oO 1/2/87 3IOOO io 1/2/87 to h I OD `l34(00 Last Inspection: , 33/qD Appraiser: Avail ffa.cb4 s Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments -/_/.25 cl2J $ R4E:00 vJ0 / / $ ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: • HiP-r v.lv.tl.n Section UNIFORM RESIDENTIAL APPRAISAL REPORT FIN No. Q Pons,Al Alauaoal is In esAnmle MaIAet V.a,as aeleeaml Ilk•Cr,Al0.10n A Slal,vav,1 d I unWlnl Gavalwns ilelllVG SIiLI(llSlcyN GROSS LIVING AKA AURA 1150(IfI ESIIMAMTG N[r'NUUIIG(AN COSI-NEW OF NOR OVEMFNI6 ..vP•.�w...P..,.w,-.v... w,uo.u.,...u...n..i..n�.0 «w.,i..,v... Dwelh�q Sort'rn I -S _. ..- Sy fl vc$ -_- 1 Special I new illsacto lions _ Pa I s.Pallas is f:aaiJe/Calpd,l So ft va$ _ tole I amnion Cosl Now S PInseal rowel Wool! less 0earcmlml - -.-$ flvyoaaleal Vale Al Ylllllovelnenis '•S (ale.lost"as ls'III(doeveway.landscaping.eat) -$ ___._._..... TSUNAMI)SIZE VALUE -$ JQ,C051 Ill lease.m.snoe ally leasehold value} MINUTES PAINE IT COST APPROACH $ • (Not Nenama toy Fiedle Mal.alai Fal.r.Mael Calm0Kna1 Waaido LI vu [34 No Does pgeny cadanl In alyAcabW I(UO/VA visuals sladands' 1)4 Yes [..I No Name te Walaily P,a ram II!b.espial. - Whnanly Covelaye Fxpees r.APe. .Wi Ian µ V. *WM, w.nm 'I...INPn Nrr wr P.'v. ,,a a'syw.mu vmP.nuI.°snood won m nto N. ' u ns.1...............,l.wn lul'I .,sl Plv1..urys,mwa,oss+,1t.nr.Fnuvv.i the Jm.•ua+.•al,w: .... .aM IIwP.nr. wool, • aaxxu,v a1 1 ITEM SUBJECT COAIPAOADLE NO I COMPARABLE NO 2 COMPARABLE NO 3 992D Bal.mora 10349 Englewood Dr. 9805 Friar Dr. 10150 Buckingham • AIdte 1f p RRpp'f;I -_- ha dY_Io SRFm._IIIIIIIIBIIIIIIIIII111IIIIIIIIIiI_.. _.left 3 Miles —t ee Saks Pv:e - s INIIIIIIIING11I111111111 :105 900 " 11111111111111111111111 11$_I17,500l f11IVl�lll11111l11llllu 1 flyIGess UV Alra i -E (1INIIIIIIIIIIVIIIIIiill I _._.-_ 01111111111111111181IV ,ems_.__ Assam_._ _.. MIS Cony Data S c MIS Assam VALUE ADJUSIMENTS SG - DESCRIPTION RSCIPI01 t wo,om (ESCIUPCV I.,t nww -_.WSCIO-W10N 1...,Is5M mn. a1 s 1aFinsaaIq I1I lu Iu. i 11 Dale o1&Helele 11/89 MIT 10/89 LocAlan SEEP Equal Equal Fqud.l 91;vew 120x1J6LAyg. 78x 140/Avg01 _- 68x133/Avga 85x155/Avg, neogl and Appeal SF/Avg - Equal _-- _ Equal Ft SF/Avg __ 500 OusulyoIC ISEvcaa, Avg. _._ Avg_ -- Avg Aye_ -_ Mle _ 1979 1983 1977 1983 CalVes.. Avg/minus Good _ -1500 Good -1500 God _ -I500 A6olr GPaife a.xw a 9 es aax nmy, n•k s m: P.J Ha an m Cs 63 I 6 3 2 -1500 6 3 ;_ 1 5 2,1_,I____, Ov ine;vine Mot a 1 329 59 PT 1200 SII ft +1935 1200 So ft _+1935 l08 So ft +3675 Unynxll6 hoisted Partially FIR FR, 2 BR,RI FR, 2 BR, FR,28R, Bath Room Baow Glade w/o, " Bth w/o Part'1 Rath, 996 sf -4980 1.R 700 sf -3500 Functional Y al llidl Normal Normal Normal Normal __-Ikamg/Coaug GFkIA/CA GFWA/CA CFWArA GFWA/CA.. ..._ .._... , Gam/coma 2 2 -- -"- k 7x12 Deck 12x15 Dock 350 20x26 Deck -1350 2 2 Wotas.s.M elt Pooches. l Vault SDI: +1000 Vault +500 Parquet/Atr.tr *coal Enemy _. -_. 2x6 walls EO Ann Rents 2x4 -.. ... Highi LE F t -2000 verancelsl l _.. - - ----'_'--OlIselfe9AacIen Appliances - 500 Niel.tenookInual - N 1 Adi Qaall _- 1 ' K I ,.'..Pf +935 d.R S -4395 r 1 -5175 kd-atedVle �i 1�• ��. ' l'1111I1•111 106,835 1 lIl'f Ill t09.105 _•ill'I. 110,325 I SOAIat 9 111 , 1 l 11119 To- $ I IL 1,.....1 1 ni I,I I ,1 Comma,n Salesfailanlsal square ft. adj. for upper level, lower and deck are 115,/5,1 . CoiOo AI required fewest net adjustments.'(romps 0566 have add it tonal amenities, Al comps were_in superior cant/it ion (see below). Subj. site has steep real lilt(nusahle area) 4 dj :seeps:_ INDIUM PIMNE IT SAILS COMPARISON APPROACH Comp fly is similar but 2 BR's converted to 1 large MISR/112 000 II INOICAIEI VAIN IT INCOME I APPROACH Ill AParala•l(Omelet]MarArl Rnll S Ala.Gloss Rent IAA*. S INNS afyxanal IS made I M as IS-I -I salted In ile op.ailaalmns.mspMoats a consigns Listed below I { _I compellon Del ldalls and sWMdlcalian Gnnenls and C.axmnllsa Actaasal Rub)ort has several.deffic tone les that need correction& influenced _ via(let seal broken on 6 windows ($2000) and skyl I gh Ls leaking and cell ing damaged in Kit. 1xlaI 0ecunualmn Bathroom sheet rock S. Spray coiling $800) haft i shed lower level (sheet rocked • but not taped or painted, 6 stool,tub 4 lay in). Part of rear hill washed .away ($650) Sees cu.W*t-fr•' .1.4 -- OA,aunasal is Eased Skin Isle above lemons Ienb.lie rrnmi.Plmn radxxµml aro lnnamlo lmrminin alai il.okel woe*halal mat ao staled mn [..•r.''YJ, r ry.rndlA Ill*Am VA mislnrlxxn -1 I rrti5le Mac loin l 439(lie,71NRprmxx May rani 11RIR11 ill,71R61 Med well rka 1 ,a _.. 19 all.%led ▪ t IMEI ESTIMATE IRE MARKET VALVE.Al MINTS.If THE INJECT PRIMES AS Of 1'14y-4.1t-36____.1I CfQ ASIR S112,000 I Ito,mot,na1 To 9,fx'sl ul my Imv1 Alx,wlnke and Wei IIx Ives and d.Ila oval learn are one,1nnt nrial.11,1 I(wet Pemaul?loMeLled Ile sWlea ryigeliv. Ivan,mR1I4'oat ran.II.!lour nude an,.loin aa'a.slxm lit at u:myvIalle sales 1.11ed.,It,II.I.1 and ono I(wet(aveOu i.W dosed mined.grim ce Po:neaire Reim .1 at,1 1 aP,PASTA TJ."'—ri Rrv.n AlYvar.r•.nalnn x•IINUv. ?v..• `J[t. ns=—.l _IDd t^IDd 11M .. ,1 er.c Iu.P�r.IM1mnly • 119..Mr. . . Valuation Section UNIFORM RESIDENTIAL APPRAISAL REPORT ....., nPurpose ol Ainuarnal Is In eshirrar Millet Vile as dallied ur rhe larrairartro&$tareruent trl 1.1111111111j Condirrons .. NYLONS ra ICH 1501W GAUSS t IVING AMA NASAL GRAI/E) ESTIMATED ntrnowc HON COST-NEW-01 IMPROVEMENTS '.'"'".""'"'''''''''''''''''''''''"'''''''''''''''''''''"*. Owellmq So II rn$ -$ (.1., - •Sproul Energy i thuent hems a •Porches,Panos.etc • Gamile/Cnohri So ft nO S .' Total Eslanalrd Cost New . .. - -$ Physical EinVonal Edda* Lem •Deprecular -$ Derwortied Valor ol Inornyeannis. -9 Sale hoo-as is'Ot noway.landMalmol air I -$ - ESTIMATED SHE VALUE -$ . ill leasehold.show only leasehold role !INGRES 11111111 It COST ABPSIONGII -$ ISot Retorted by Freddie Mao and Faure Mae) Comiruclarn Whammy L.Sea 1_414o Ones truperly Lnoloon to applicalle IIUDR/A tootle standards, I)Yes Lithe Snot ol Wanarly hog= *No,mplan Warranly Coverage Eames rrn natal trans.K,4 faies al p4,11•16 41451•.t...1 40,xtsAbolki14.lu 5010001.0.s Lorna-no rhtte n on narrer ru0..lin riesuntran Fauna a dorm anninnn.11,ct..o..a.rel re....lo Ouse MOMS al,xpolicar.unp...1.4.(Al won ttal.SW,I in or late laroialie 11....1...pac...a nnan cal aarahnarn nano nary...ran on ainaho arnn a nowt d a 1.14.50 de".go...Ms*a b., co.6....Own Inn 515.1 f00051r.a...11.1.1.1.01i9..le NA IMMO.,the a0*0101.1114 al II,,nrwht ITEM SUBJECT COMPARABLE NO 4 CCIAPARABLE NO 5 COMPARABLE NO 6 • 10459 Huntington Dr. 9838 Balmoral Ln 9953 Balmoral Ln Addless P'ssirr°1'a 3.hso 1111111111111111111 En —Frriie .2 Miles , .2 Miles 000 II II II III I I Sabs Rice $ INIEMORMIRs.IIIT666—EIMMMMIIMMEls 122 IIII Is 123,000 Price/Gross In Area S 0$ 41111111111FIRMII S 01111111llIMEINI 3 1=1 IIIIIIIIII IIIII IIIII I . Bala Swat ICS- ssum MLS Assum MLS Costs VALUE ADJUS1MENTS DESCRIPTION DESCRIPTION r HI.4•310. OESCRIPTICN FS Won. CESCAP TION I.i-,s amemase ' r:117510115"'") OF . . _1- • Date M Sale/lane —270-. ITO— 8/89 location Equal Equal Equal , Saa/View 126x113/BV8. 1 25i7S7Avg/ 1 25x85/Avi/ Oespn and Appeal Equal Sonar—1.---r---- SF/Good r----1000 Onalst Conssuction Avg Avg Avg__ Ade 1980. 19-78 1979 Condrior Coed -1500 Cood ----. -1500 Cood -1500 Stowe Grade Val ...a.NM, 4. .80.111,1.15 lulal ,M.:.Mows'------ total .11.1...,Daft ... _...___. Room Corot 6_., 3 : 2 -1500 5T. 1 -r-:2 . 2 -1500 . .. Glom lawny Area So F I 1287 Sd fl 1 4'so rt +2775 1l080 So +3735 Basement A finished FR,28R,Bath FR, 2611. Bath FR,3BR,Bath Roans Below Grade 573 sf -2860 Ent. Cntr.67B -3890 729 sf -3645 foncloanal Uhlay Normal. ----TOlina 1 Normal HeasnolCoolam GFWAICA GRAFifa ' GR-IATCA .__, Gma9etrapot 2 2 2 Pooches,Palm 12x7 Oeck 25X1-4—POt io -509 sc.Por -1500 Poets,elc +1000 2 Bow Wind. .f... 4.4.x12Dekyi - 500 Speco1Enemv , 'Mood Senn reeplacOs1 1 2 -1500 filTi. Ins -2500 .._,. — Oils teo Aachen Security Sys -1000 nOP.mmWdmo FR Bit. Ins - 500 Appliances - 500 Ne1 Adt°plan 1114 590 ill .-"-i--`?'_IS —31f6ti — . lr_Ti -:6f13——+ 'X_:s -8410 cl Indlcaled Value .1 ,Subeci „1, , , ,I• _ s 111,140 ,. I s 115,885 I. Ili I COO no Sakx Consslinan _ : (Slat 7.2,40.4k.iwt_70,..ri INRCA1111 SALVE II SALES COMPARISON APPILIGN S II 151111051 NAIR II INGOIM MIAMI It ApolcablelEstsnaMil Waal Rah,S (Vu 1 Guns Anil Multiplier .5 This dissarsal IS made M-as is'I..11 ammo to the,epans.allot:ours.nepectrus ot conditions laud Orlon Licompleoon per plans and speoneaose • Convents and Sandman of APP.., Filial neconciialiOn _... . _......_. 1 ,,,,ann.nal n ta.n Won an.b..;cowmen's.de Ll111.1.1,110.1.[.....10.11 i1.01.11111.itg[01..1.1.011,a...1 M,....a1 V..k.,......nur po-yr-j,rd or ___1 IXR41.1.11111)Rio 0 insInichons 1 7]Finkle Man loom 439 4 new 7/86Nranne Mae lam innaB Olt,7/116)IWO will chont 19 0 aflachod. I I lilt ERINSIE Ill RABBET VMS,AS 1111111,Or MR SUOMI PIIPINIT AS Of }44.z.1,...A._jr II fo Is MI F/2 411.0 I V.t)eeitly mat IS Ow lest 0 my(0,01111.1@dg,and brhet me Lull and data used heron are Out and coned,loll Iwo)WS.*PNINIMMI Pile BOW 1.9.11-I both snide and aill.ale hare made an ace*,entry=UI di 1:111111.AMIC,IleS CAW*111113 loporl.and Mar I Woo lure lb ionksclosed inlerest Resale o,PeARONsf mmem o 11111111.. ArmannIst 11.41014 )51'). r....•7' I neoew N..oer hen ul to 1044 TiZipt.r.n,LaraM r .-s• • +4''r Description AAneraele UNIFORM RESIDENTIAL APPRAISAL REAUrn1 Er1e'Fn.2^1-4a5 :_-,_ I,, :::aPmr ArMlrls 9.920_Balmoral.raw-___----- C®aas' , LEW R e-.CM leVARY'19 • "I•?O'Y (1en_Tral.rin County Henn ln Mate EIN 2P Cfde 5)A! Sap Pre S Lepal Oesa,pen^ 1 19 Plack_2-1'A'alrie ha d Adlllln_o __ Bale _.._- oOwea(ocwc+nt Raymond ,he. Stiles tv 1 nrl�erce u[S 1.-�- Mono?Amalnl S W .__- Sal Pao$ Dal*bl SIN _ 11101'1IHY ROM AM'RMtiFU 1!dllpvle type _ • p taut Malges/c,arcessro!K to M;dd by'env S - _[xi'rr Frorre LAxauu P^,n..rna erhel L,.0 s,.,n, vt RE lazes S__.1.681_,47 -Tao Year 19E, IIUA S AM. - [1 L•asehM1 Paden See, S ..._.- --_ - Londrnnvnxn if.4.Lender/Dent Het rolxall Tan_Fl nano 1;11_14ot.tgnt,_Cori, 1 _I - . - _ ' -- - - t Dr%x,n PUU SNAL • p LOCA1a,N T I(ban 3 x Suburban L. nue! NiIGNUp+11UW/,NALYSIS rice Aq r, ' RUIN UP I x[Orer 75% [- 125 11% [[UMm 25% Employment Suc.My [ f I xJ Gn0'NTN RATE (x[Rood { 1 Smut [-_]M. Ca oannnxe to EoeAhnenl x 1 1 {'fRODERIY VALUES Ircreoarng Stable Declining Commerce le$homy .ac 'q OEMANO/SUPILY Snonope - In Balance Owl S,eny Convenience In S0h(AP L Lx.f[ . NAMING TIME may.thdr1 3 MMs. B 6 Mos �Ow!6 Mos Adendaty M P Sh,l,n•re,taTmn (r I(x 1 1- ,7 PRESENT LAND USE '. LAND USE CHANGE (NIEROMINANr SINGLE IAMf,Y 117US, ''In tentam Fables 4'pc 1 I o Sage Fan* _100 NA LIE'ry (y]GLCUPMICY i lam+ IAGE+ Mowacy e.umnu0 1 .1 %;( et 24Family Likely rj Owner [j] AnpntyLamm)IAly I [1I[ •UM11-Snuy _°m In process []Tenant [-]3B _Low 5 Poleobal bum DellmxdalC iii_ i d L o Cornmeal Ta vacant ID5'c) 10 1135 5r 2F F/Ace6 Foe&maw .i J[__ ill Matra! LSule(war FOCIPahnwwt &meal Aponte.of Pesb:ee [`[Ix]I _ x vacant 110 - 10 A eat to Madet x I ' j• ,Note Pane a Rle meal composaun l 1he noghbphood me not consd l*eted rena aaaa1Sal tides • i•COMMENTS _jplmedlate�el,ghborh9od_gopsls ter cgnpa&:able_Sind_eompatlble*triple fasilLlrsln!^,n:'- S;.121d—oun0, ---------- -.. _-------------------.. Omwnsicfs _53 x 128 x 188 xJ__-------_--- Ivsomoln S1op1ng- . Ste Area 1 a74.&_ _____ Corer Lot_ N9_._ Sae Average . 1mkp Uaseildden Single Family Zonal 2oneg ComMMrce YQs_- Share Irregular___ INGNEST 6 NEST USE Present Use Ye.c Onei Ilse N7A Upnage (DC UIUTIES Public (Ow SITE IMPROVEMENTS Type rubric Phan* Kew Rostdrntl_1k Cr,, Electricity [xl Stied _Aspha.S____-. x1 L_I uxSCaPing Avoraa . Gas [xl — --Cub/Gutie, Coe retc I-s1 L l D,amray .Asphaltl;__ -_ _ tiler [x Sidewalk None [,I 1 Apparent base nena ox(b Sanitary Sewer :, Sheet Lights Yes_ [x1 _1 FEMA Flood lane:* Ws' No _% Slain Sewer xl AUe5 Nm I 1 '1 FLAIR'Vro1?ane N.--- CAMMENTS(Arpa,ent enema easement.encnoachmenls,sow'assessments.Lde Great etc 1'j'be.r_o_gro 110♦4PP4rent adverse easement• or,tperorchmonts__EIssoclatM4 uth tlalc sjte,_.___--._-_----- ---_-_`-_ - GENERAL lH5G111'IYJN EYIt1IU.M SCIIPG01 fl%INOATIpI IUifTAENI NSULAIa71 T u'nn _ 1 F�x.analwn Ceygn3�AIOCIL Slob No A�ca So F+ 1161 Rorl • Slaws /F Enpn1 Wens Vert .Wool Crawl Space _'Ic _ea Faished 24 tx e1 _Aye . Type Met(Alt) Det.xclixVl Root Solace Tab_Sid dale_._Basement 11,71; _ Lenny Drywall Nana Ave t S Oesgn(Slyle1 spit Foy Cxmnam 6 bwn:Dls (21 Soria f., Yns Viaes Drywall Ilnn - >Ealslxp __Yee:. Maawlype -Tr1vgz5_o_ Dampness _Tie_____flan rtarget Nmm _ e¢q rammed IF, Sim Sash No _Salemrm No___ anvue follyYes Aucaucv 4", I, I 1 UMa Conslla ton TI,i Screens �Y9s- !Mestalen _ NO __.__._-__-_-- (loony E14'I^I I e^,•{s Age rim l __in_ Manulanl xb House_ig__NQevi donee of_�. d711!3r'i • Ellectrve An.YrsI 1-0 dam.10.no l.,1 nB0A15 loyal Lox OunN dthen (en Farrel,Rm Sec Inn, Bed,mns •Bath 1aulby DI lw Area Su I I in Basement _ _ Ayrtla _ 2 Part 1 Unf._ :90 Fri:..!. ii U+e 1 __.1-__. _.1 _.. 1 l._ .._..._. ...) _ 1.-__ - 1)22. • e level 0 S >.Imshed W.e*oae colt ebnnms () Roans. ) Ited,wverys), 1 I',:'OI 11.u Square TM xl mows I r... SURFACES MAIC,mISICQMbrmn NEAIIIIG KITCHEN(SUIP. Al la; Ins. iMPROUEMESI ANAlIsts Gee A.g {.x. r.- GamS CarpetjrAye (toe _AFA Neiroud a p1 eve 11 WIN u'Ca 111,11 a, i_..[I i I,' . Walls llry 11.1JAve_fuel sag__ Na,gal(10n 11 .ens [ l Coam«eol Anamenvnls 1".I[.1[_].- - Trim/finish Wood/Ave fnoMion Ave Acposn [IJ pa,timu (i Puny S.,slla:wl I 11 I:.1 Bath now CeramicT�a Adrgmxy Av: Uxl,w she 1 x1 Sadie Ix I Coraln and Storage I I IXI I ' Barr Ab I Cera 1Ln a CGNNG Ia/Dad Iri Fla, Li Lneup Ff,i.rc, -1 Ix!t ' Boas Nov VA'+^ Cfldml Yy. I wa*,aa l {!llra.d i.1 Iraleoy ArIC nny P.C,A.Im, 1_[loll_' ___.-__. Mee Yhdvinlvrf L. f•xamd 1.]EhrlrcalnH n cvs 7:n1 I 'I.I I - ! , ___L d I M_Av LiC'ewavr I„1 Not [_I AntMr,C M 1 A(Nrl�:.tty A frxxl[__I Iff.x I ' FI'aV'fISI Itrl. 1, •• I Aden eoa Pro H l:om t 1 C un I A I IkxA,y to I5 oMaNand I I[x I CAR STIAIAf E Gage I.,x( Att cted (.,J Ad rnwle .4 kkAn Ent, Ix I anneal A AWArldIAy I I[-%)I I No Cola _ Ca pal 1 J O laGl ed [ I I dnn le Buh te E 1, ( 1,1..01 U.Itx,ng L C'xx l I.5- 5 ^ ��la anomie A.e None I 1 alb, I. 1 Gnl,cnaxe a I:,I,nn Ey[ l r.uatrn nemino511,,,,r.,l.an -I >`_ Aad'I'onal mmmes,pcc}._�>2yllcht,_l'atlo,.Vaal Led-Cal ling,'.Piurahl(C it-,_eo14v:ra clrc t.rlca 1,o er•-',e - _l5!._4mr-•_.__.._____ _.... __.__-. ___ _.__ __ __._ __ (kpac4101lP+rascal luuumaH and eamu,al,nadeeuaces,*pans needed.mld�Nm*o�,.n�t ehl This due 171!if;hasLaen welt a:a In '1 tale and in in good condIt5on�a , �.. ejL.aoss.I-le.fa, p..l)-_-_.. --__—_. i Gelwal market condom and prevalence m nce Sal al saver/aarkei area iegalyq DAwa dawns.coned b,gdwns aro c amessrts A.eet a 1 sei l.•r_. I lOASSDDvxnts anLt':low marlcetlnterest rate.financl.n7..ran.aftecLUto Dx(ehe..Mica._nt cna1_nalal VI ,, //i L—J : r-1 i 7 rLou ... ...0:444:*:::5s2 7'- i ",b' i71, e /PAlft , f)plp ip ip. 0 r i f . f• z,) b % i \‘ ,..._._, , (A,,44$S-al.t •Og I I.4 0 .44 13600 4.. •••444: ---...,*- 'AI 8 •,,, 8 8 g IttliW 'g: 41) 1 - l i. ...... . %1 .,,y1.73 1:Plik •••.4. Oftl, ••• :I> NV 1•0010, ".... CON , 11 1 1' li , 1,...'. .MIR ail.** ilh .'• j''' 1 g , PI i 1 1 1 kw,„ 101 0 Iv. 3 eaonotrnPo..•i i * ti, ' ——— ;. tj:. . 0 OMEWAR0 He,RV.'" .. .•'.. •mo MIA ') I `8:c0.1 : e''•^. . 1`ir."•2111W ifti/ .:nial7.,'Z'l 1..,. j zvAs./.../* ° lisruir i j It i — ... 41'''1 e s. I % . ismo. "...4: ; i"'::07: •11., •• 1. ..,,,.., 1/4,4.4 ,04 , B Ill,, i 4 c.„..:i, si. ENP,41 onesore BEMNITT 0. I' , IA q A § .6) , o 1 , f. ENTEX• S : .., I, •••• 0 2,,, 'T ,z,,,t,.1 4 1' LP, :I ' x z •., 3 1 t -- _ • . • i ....s I ....t. ' ; .- ° Si. .,_ , i I u ,,,i41111.c.... . ..., % ...;p.... 11. lig A LOR12,... 0 SAN 71:47 4'.• 'V i"".. eV .:"''''e ,.,, ''''' °-T41':It: g 1 ;"4 i ,, • • .... /. dl -•,,.,_ t.• . to.,,,i °" t iiial• 1 .. ..".. .41 miommk, EDIII,. ; ,. . 1109.18.. 1 *au i '4,,.. ; ,-..,'.. • . , - ! • . K.31,IMO INDEM7WAhlong (1 OECOTY•• .. I 0 1,.. z.c,19,1i ft-atilize..1 1. c'':''''' it :gmfrGiCkf%:..-v'F:cil'L., i It""."'..... ; ..r. 0 .... 4 <,.I ,• . .. ..o.a,. ...*:: g 4.7: F) 1 "*“" • •; •g ''°' 4 •*s".'14•Ill\' '. •A C. i. o eke:°' U ; A., w r o..,AA 4#640, !iii: 8000 g-,.^.:';:•°,1\icric,:,....v,i'' ... i-::-.11xtzploallo ,.on moray,: 3:',. 10k..__'''`,111V..e • :: ? • :,:::'•* `..,64r; 6,571"1 % Trrt„,,N\"'1 ..,..'•"\‘` MN ': 0,. 4 ::P ..„,;,Millib, 4•• -r... —`,....1 --.. ...: •4-.. co ...... ••••...4EVID3E i gli...!!.1:,,rr tt.' . * t g .• , a W.: 3'•-i. ;',/ 1; . .t.,i:`... '., . ......-I .'"'. t x 1 ,wow .s.c,. ii 1 l J. P.M. . . ' . 7,.... .1:7..... 2 BUSH...•" ICE I,•. gi t.1 28 NAVE i ; • • •....."..> % . 'I. .I 4:1 I i'''''''''' [ . ... C'Allibl • . , . fl, , 1 gil zi. '504A AVE 5 I k I '' C:: 0 I •" ; 1 R 1 7, .0,, ..., . „ . . e^s SUBJECT PROPERTY 9920 Balmoral Lune Front 6 rear pictures 1.. ae�a 0. ',1,1,11(I 11,11Kle 1,111‘11::1 Tr. •41'.11- 8r • - V L. L 1' ..1 -L• •• ' i COMPARABLE/ 1 I 10349 Englewood Dr. ra —_ , . ',A i IMWY.I.I..„,I1„N,I1O. 111MIM WIPP 1Mtn l,11 SO 0O1 O1.I..W 1IMMO 1 l 0. .1't I , .fir N fit! 0▪i 14eeil1.,. .�.OY.l,,1Jl.INtY I ,..Vu.r 161111,ay a .•kn+..•.•yr•xr..t w1 ,nw.a•.itl..w.eaa.� . ¢sews .x1x.I./e..1Ar�tnw w.__ ,,,,..„.,.m... • � Au CI:::47,:::.-vil.,--,-;r,,=, y1 ..r. r.i ..tr.!t.r 7.S11w7.S .4 .1.111 14114.01.4104.44..Y,. M . COMPARABLE # 2 9805 Friar Dr. ri : yr • i t 1L•^y� i • r 'tom 1 • i .!. 4 1110% 1F 1 1111r1r1111 N,C011 11111118 01r11411 11Wi1111001 b1111W11111F 1.1113.111 11, i0,E21.IH-._.S'1—_ Y • ">! MC tl9l"1f --- — <,a<r wrwlrwrwl I1.11. , ^L�9!PE��',,rr"�,1 err r r e r ' " NII <a�.n:,r -:„. vi wn,s.alwr eor•roe nun ,ia^sue_ I`'�ae",ime ce. `�'1'-111 A . , COMPARABLE 4 3 10150 Buckingham Dr. • ,. . . . ..._ _ , • - ..,,,,,, 11 ill i -------;,-, ::,..F.....c. ... . : _ ... - t,L , , L., " .•i,Fi,, , ^ 111111111°1 —: . . ..- .. 'I. •riEr 11 11, --..„..........411k tell 1 ....„....._ .. . , • • MUM OM 1.64 it.MAI AVM 111111101 %MON 10411•111 101111100.111111031 141111.1/4 (.., . . • 4.1iiiimit Te.,01............... • wow roam. •1.4100.141,110[441.11000.1 .,,,014 t,e.e.0i7.4.0..,,,..„:1..,t,4?-4.1.: •aat..1021110.140 Mt...CI •144401.101.01•00Ms 44.16001.00•11110 lat.n1 44 r as .1 •Sallal004 YAM 40/40. .,..4.40. 440. 0.,4,. .0, •MOM I1140.1401011.1•14 . NI Ma 1,11 I .104 II 4011 •C110141.•• MIMIR •.,,,,........g....r../......., wsmassisesoles_tiirtears_____ _._ ••100.0000/1001.2 tA•21•00000..04,000.ww....finaloweatopo—ii — •0411.104441•1111.00011 14004000 410•1044.114.044 406044 1•01011 •01.4.4•114 1.1.•ftwil 1.410.10.044101 MI 00004.0040146.0 NO •,...........4.00 10.1,0•,.. ..i..11'..71%.A...,Te:17.—ilii ow vi;o2,— •.ecnar.1 ..4.010400.0.0.4 440414.1 •004.000 004.0140 14 14•4 1.1111 e 4L i 4!..;11-ililMl•---- 0 0 4s4 010.1.1• 0 40 0.1 ruf, SI Mt 4 40 IPS Ins aL. 1. A i ta .... .,...,... •41.UNA •44.000.44, 061400.11 WS Mt II•AL:. iftt• 7144010111 1.110.0114 MS 0•114 00 1.11/11r . .—s COMPARABLE 6 4 I0459 Huntington Dr. b I 6 • . i SSuv M-uTUl1 LPL SSW UrnW W.MMO Mua'�%PISS SO OM M.Is Si ISO SSWNO . . , _ Jr ,, ilb.. , . - _ , .gct . ,... .,..;..._.„,....,,,,,,.;....,:.,-,.. _,-.,..4 45[M4MSJ :tlIU� "li•�i.Y.1i1 R.M f nwdf0J1--- 11 a 1 V M I 31•111 vJg1JY_lk 4L U COMPARABLE A 5 9838 Balmoral Lane ---`''.----.7---.--". -. '' 1 I. - • ." it ,/ 41.8 14 nal tot*,• '-i EMI - - P 1'.1:::'t,,r9;I AI;k*P;Vitilifir/;•;''4!-' ,1_t4....,-_ ',., '. -7:-- . • - , . , • it , '814 88 . •tr....._. . .T ! 1 1 A. . 'I .7 60. SIR I 88k 1.14 SIT MO a. 11188•01 lattlit81 IV.Pak 10 118.01k 1.1.80 I,.111,101 BEAUTIFUL BUILT-IN ENTERTAINMENT CENTER IN FAM11.Y ROOM! k'.. I: ASSUMABLE 4,„, MORTGAGE! 23X10 MASTER BR. 't-t. .• '- - .'iii - -- .,...,..,...„:„..7...,-,...........--- ..,,,...k.. -1,.... ."-},,* . •46.h...81..0 mai.r. .•....... ".0 ,•-•0. [.. .„.,.„. ::7:411.,::, .:''''; le.''.1.,....... '..''. •NAdov•MA'•"Ye.0,01,401.•NM MIVIVOICY. Ilit:::::=1;714.111.11,0,1 UV •KI.411•111.11eV/00.6•••••••• •••1111..1 OW.VOIV A.M.(11•111.1a. lOon.0011 Mt•y•••1.61 SOY,li••V'let.. .0::::1:72;1===;Ir;::r.'"';• -4F,:re,t1 ', . - .. VU, ,....,D :•11,001 I . %It A.1,tl, •,,,,,,,, L,,,,, , ''' ''' .. 4....---- ...OM 0 0.141.611,*1.4•1101.1 vv%1 V ',.,".e' „,V.;• .m.,-- NM Valeill "4:'". .iriftL:P11.019.1- v.v.iv pv...'"'" .11,0•01,01.11 al VA MY 11111111r. COMPARABLE B 6 9953 Balmoral Lane • • • -- ®e — . ti tM♦4M•1l,11 SR 111t Cm I SWAM ti a.M 31101.1 FIS4 141mtl.,1!>AM 4,111011 ',rr ._ r11.. •11 • �o../▪,.at,„„ t• rb. J Ip ra�w• .r .�. uYm wIM+1T1.11 a <1 u,w a V ▪ wa 1140aV u •1rw.IVVnw�4VarV.r1 ra 3 ▪ qt9 V w�rP�W1•Nt.._• _.y,�lftur ntY.__- '.a4ri.r,l�Tn.i��♦ 4�L�iuiiw �w"t.�'.� Irni, H•loollon Section UNIFORM RESIDENIIAL APPRAISAL FIFiPUri r Tao no. .'7)/. — El Pup,!'I sic e,1om1.•Me,kel Va!Le as deltred ut Inc Eettficattott&SNIcrneot cl Ummna Gooddons T3U1LDING SKEIN[SHOW GROSS LIVING AREA MILNE lineal ESTIMATED REPRODLICIION COST-IfEW-OF 11.1FRovEmENIS •k•fr.ks,I.1.NOW..1,..•Mry nraiM.cosISItro.rte enenINC-nowif an 1.!own s„,,s„..„,, _ _.s„,.,0,s •$ __r' (v — 5. ____ si:.,..,...„Em4i(14..1 Huns - Pootes.Pahos.etc __ - • Garagegarron Si Ft ii0$ - 10' Isdat Estimated Cool New 1;7. [6-` • vapeel I f ordlirotat I 1..temai 1 BemeCiailon S . i 22' tkeveceated Value al unmoyameme. .. ..-S ...,„-al,(dmewar.InnscaPOO.sic) "S ESTIMATED SUE VALUE -$ 3 c.000 . . .27' (a leasehold.see.only*retold vein) ENEMAS'S VALVE II COST APPROACH -$ ..Noi FleoteM1 by ttedrite Mac and tannic Mae) Conallocoon Wartante U j Yes ',Al No Does pfoperly conlaro to applicable HUDNA popery Standatdat f— Yes LIN° Name of Wartante Ptoceam it No,exciaon yeartamy Coontoe Excites -- ' 71.•onArty..00ll..5 ret.,11..CP let.SA,a tflAwnirS TIV.Sin.And An,......ic soil,.,,m i-,,,,,,,..^..,"•.,'..`o,r,..A,%,,,111,st,reocr Lorittle,a o.so .,eo.neornt mAecigo maw meow io IttaMickla1 41.,pnilu.r u.I..Wren....fUtl.,1....,,,...r.C.".15,..,,,e,1.1 r e S.,,,,.IN tl..rti on Ile I^'‘:7 !17":7lie!'''''7 CI7:'I-I1: ',''"'."l;r;4I':'r:r'r.,''* '''''''''t.x'7''''lo''.0:"k,1 1',IS'no"' ; A.Z.•4:n. n 1 ALt 7ianc.,ao, 0:cate;,iOeoAnc • ITEM ll SUBJECT COMPARABLE MO I COMPARAIIII NO_2 tsoMPANARS ND 3 Alhess_2920 Balmoral Lane .805 Friar Drive 8041 Darnel Road 8522 Darnel Road 1 : P'DMIMIY 10 S,Ailtr liffll 11111101 011 .,z5 miles 1.75 Mi.les 2 IS len ales Pole SIlill IMETE1119E57,,E0,162 111111ELIIIMIlllgn,qeili., ,,RbTaS1111_Ths ing .6 ,r.encevOress le Am $ N/A GO$ 94.58 unm 1..Him . 0_92.77 0 trajaaW 8,..97 0 eluilma ilvela ..Data Source 111arrectLan_1_1.9 (41.5 MIS — 12 VALUE ADJUSTMENTS DESORPTION DESCRIPTION I.1-IC141Atts4 DESCRIPTD)N •IA MM.. DESCRIPTION I,ill Avowal i;Sales or Finarcioo 1, 1,— 11,11r , , ---i comessicas 1 uu , 0r, a cony. . Anure. i F.'C.., 'flgri Dale Ot saletTme 10-4-09 Rmi9____ .5-80 all'^c_._"^____.E0111._ErAlriv_141n_PAaLr/c*; ..A/rt.Er.'Al.1.71g; Eden Prairie l_ )„,S401+ _122x158LAyp 68x113/ave i __:_ar20_506_130kairr,..4 _ 140)(126/Ave : 1 L''''`'''''''APP•2"_.....Spi,l_FoybLy.e___S_B /Byin_ 4_1a2...3.212/11Y0 4 ktl Soltikto doable oi Conalocto Ay,-tr..sce Av0_178.R.. I_— Average, Averaae 10_ bOtitlitbrk (1004. . G.29.1_ e...0_0_ ;drove Glade tea. .ea..too btS k Wont,bits kW •Ottss•Italts t ,..,;•51.-.1••.-7.,:.—-----— 4 Room Cool 6..L.3 L 1_ 6 L3_i_.1-_.: 6 1 3.2L..-1_._; • ty2,1.11/11102Ta 1:NliFj,•0 100Is El. !_al±2t 61LTrreAlq,T"T,IatT,5,_11s0.sc3i4 .. rrr2,17S1a Ltitio__ • A q -19u° r ato,,d j._ath +600 ' A Fttoctonal Natty A2z±zrage kkattal__ _;_. ikLual - l51.01 "eomrcon GFALCentral 0Fkilientral_i GF/t/illen i.s. .i._ CPA ELL:c .ESTa.2 ,, . liatdottCarpott _2 At taC'..11*A .:.'..A.-t-tAC.110-Ct ,'' 2.._A t tached. .2 6 tiatted ..,,t Porches.Palo. Deck Patio Deck,V 1 td Nola tic Sky Li ght,V1 LI Cl • I.:01 +700 Multi Lv 1 Dolt +900 Duck,Vlt,1 Cell +700 - ,..%mum tome I , F,I..cril ernts 3 t..,niard Standu1 .;tandard Stanlari .l.I Ice-SS:Vt,/ i Fi lib 1,1.400 I Firbit..,1,1C0 i 1,3 xrplae, t El z-on La cc...:, ___ • )4,t le g 401,1,1 ..i.,lb,P.t.r.d.tstP Spl,r,blartt SE:sato/arca F.,"tantiar.c1 . I II I T -,i : • Net Adi Itotalt l'rt!--11,171111111$[,i,itc t ,. 1,200 li. ix_-1- 1,coo r x). 7•S____1,1,0.0 tretscated VW: TTiP.1 I I,•I T,il t'll, Efil.I i 11111,„Ifi, 1,!,I.1 1.,jir„ll ifr 1.1-- „„.. ;,1,,,„ :,,,„„,,„,„:,,,,„,,,, A,,,„,1 110o ,,,„,,,,,,,, III )..., .:., n7,0. ,,, „„ .:ts 110,100 t Comment,on Cates Compaidon Como u.:•,d aro th,.. one.,t recent'.,1 bodrouut Is p I 1 t des l 01..I.rt•1 licil:-; avat L.Vole •. A in.cjvc.. .pr_exi.mtLt_y_N sut,IT,,:t 11_154ton Prat e...i , INDICATES IALIM Ill SALES COSPAMSON SPANDAU S 115,_2122__ al trauctito VALUE II MINE SPRUCES(II Applicable)Estotalcd Mattel Iltatt S IM7.X Gu.s Root Atettolier I1'Ills app121.1/5 elude[Al"a,is-LI sullacl 1u the repos.alrattotv.,Impactions ea condemns Itstalboloo L'I carplcoto pta Sans and 55e5141a1t019 Ootnotatts ana CooJaAto III Sri...!,0outtlly..cati10-1L00 a._ __aro_Arcs urand e-i_d 5 iteat and Utillties..$131. _Raialmnaneemil_11____ ! r,..,R.1501.1.0 !'kuket,..apEroa6hLite.Qurate_tie le./allia.te.of value-.K.'t I- Ns Ipplart.11 It t.ttl.0 141011 lb:above legutobtrIts.Ihe crtIttealeo.rortirtnerl Tod trbiltott,11j.110,.,11.11 M1.1$:,,s,,i,,,,,,,,h,,,,,.,,,,,c,i pr, - -- ''..1 fil.A.te10&tor VA weaned/ma . T Irteotto Mac rev CIO dial i;Mitt&nod Mat Cron iCRIN West not Ned a,ttn eaeot II FL)•1131,.1 I sill ESTIMATE TIM MAIMET RIESE.AS DEVISES.SI In SUIJECT PROPEATT AS OF Or:tot,r 4 th II ISO) Is In$_11 5,",, v... : i ,co.,,hai to PIP b..94 0.11 W, O)kl,,,,,,s jnd tylo.1 II,1,,,11•1,11 ... .1 new...,t“,.tot t.rtto t;no t,,11,.....e...44.,,,ricti Hoc,,tw,i y,o,N.H.: : IV,rit en SS toe ro de lie!ii, AnA`LAnn pi Ali rooted,tote 3.1tet tilvd oti II,i v-in,I.iist 111.11 I CA.')1.110.no 41nr..1,i.1 d tti.tsc t pew,IT,19:41P01.e thetest.. . . ,44101!IntSi 1 t, V, 1,,,.,1'T. REVIEW areltaiSt It _f Am 1-1Poril IIIIIIIIr .;r• .._- t 1,.r,,. . '• ';. •' \ Dens 0,la.N't.ttr.^1 #2271 TT,tsto-totet _ s ,,. „,o, . ._._.. loseterl fnaote • . iir"... .1..' • wt ...)2 .• escrlollsn II Analysis UNIFORM RESIDENTIAL APPRAISAL REPOR1 Frio Na.271-Ni5f:1,79--- 4-''''T'ate'._9920_PaThoral.la-no Census War I loots Mar IrrIttAllY us!i CsonlY Henrylplp Slate MN Zm Ende ::,.. ..1/7 Saw Owe I leglIDeccnimo014t_19__Dictc_k_k_t_rgilrle Ear,l)14 Addi LIM DaIP i ,:aicur Ser ti ,_ —/S7r eersr_ yAndhSlea :1- MompgeAmna S Si!met r - Ors 01514 P77/1ITY ••.num MNIAlt.)13%gloom Toe i.1.0.1P charpeofceace5sions lo be timd by seller S - 1,x I Tee‘rnnple ONX01,11Poi.J,1 ao..te,lort Cvm-......m. .1 R.E.Taxes S 1613 1,47._ fax Year 1959_110A Vito - Li Lesielinkt Paid by Seam S. - tende/Cbent Metrpoll tan Fl name i al Mor tame",Cori! I 1 Condnommin IntIONA1 1U,Mmots PUO SmPte r ix. [iikb. Lx1reanban LI,11;val NEIGH001010410 ANALYSiS Gm,' Aro f I i • ['7'j Om/5% 1=-I 25./5% 1„..1 Under 25% EreOloinallt SMbrMY fil LA]I- ., . ._.., GBEILRONT UP RATE r Rapid 1. ]Stale Li skn co....,to Employment L 'Lc--','-' ,•-•PROPERTY VALUES Inseams A Stable Eleclirong Carionsoca to Shograog ,7 wrs r DEMAND/SUP/1Y Shorter ji.In Boance Over Sopoly Commiame to Schools r.=... ii MARKETING TIME x Under 3 Solon 3.8 Mos Oyer 6 Mot Mammy M Pak barmen/400n I,..)Fil 1...7,I PRESENT tRID USE 0 1AM)USE CHANGE PREDOMINANT SINGLE FANCY rfOUSiNG Floors:arm Faulk, I,I Fx I 2 Sick Faraly _102 NA Uroly LO OCCUPANCY PIKE 44 AdttpiaCy 01 Uldilitl Li 0.0 L3 1_ S i000) Mal a 2.4 Farnity _ Lady Owner (] Pmperly Cesn0altAty Li I.-)I---1' Multi.larruN _ III pocess U Tenant Li___9011,• 5 Notei.bon from Detrimental CVO_ Li 1.,1 L..1 g cor..4. To. Vacant 10-SST [X1 5341 msn 25__Police&Fire Protector, (-1 rxl t__! iIndustrial 1502,14(say 5100 Pr000rnoss G,nt/.1 Sops..or Noshes r._I Li()I_ Yscani 110 - 10 Appeal to Market f..-1 Ix!44 Nat Rue a ne r1c41 Composition nt the Ser9100111000 BOB not consklerecl'Noble Apo/sisal limas COMMENTS'__l_romesila_te p.a3-chkerbkod-D..enslit_er_DDET-Ira.111.e_and_compatible single fani ly resldenc- f _and Deng... • . '1..GroseSE,,,,,S,,ordA,iym5:31 x5_11218 x 188 X__1_24 ThOnSaORY 5 1911 liE S4 Area _1a,79.8. CPtilef Lot Np_ Sue A verao ZOSSEI CLisslication S1n_Ele Family Zo^n Comkance Yrd She,' T.tStfitl1Ar._ . 103}1EST 6&EST USE.Present Use Yes Doer Ilse N A Dwane CIC • UTILITIES Thibric Other SITE SOPROVEMEN IS Ins FAO:. Nate View Residential&lom• Electricity 50 Shod .AorPbail_____ C.il 7.i tr,deeeeg _.1rOtra ____ Gas CAA/Grater Concrete Cx1 -] Dmeymy Agp.131t . . Water x Sidewalk None Li Li Apparent Easements Nona .. , , Sanitary Server ,, Sited Tights _Yee _ x I , IIMA flow Hazard Yrs' No __:x Stcrin Sower x Ansi No 1 TEMA'?hoards N ror'7----- COMMENTS(A0ovent adverse easements.encisachmtnts,spena asFessenerds.sfide ems.(del Tbtr_e_gre na apparent adverse easeranntr • ..er._,Inc_rernmantz_dlnaPciated Jii_th t_bis_p_ite.____ 1;GbliERAL DESCRIPTION 't Stades EXTERIOR CESCRPNLIN 20,15 1 Foundalmn CementIllock_'Faa°UtINDAMt mrsmENT INSULAIION lip Area So Ft 1161 Root __ ,__ , 5:/lL_Extenni Walls \tett,..yind Cara SOK, ,1, %finshed 25,t cenal _Ave.Ix Type(Det!All I Dat.neheLi_Root Surface l'at.lb TO:GIP__'''''''''''' Cedao Dryan 1 1 wan Ave !x Demon ISlyel Liplt_ppir Grillers&Orsicols Sim Purr* Yes aids Dro_da_11 ilea Exising Noosed ....r0,7......Wolow Type _Tny_grs, Osneneso _lip__noor 11prir_t _N,t, _ _ ED slam sdsn Up Sorlemont '.Undo.,Construction_Bo Screens Age(Yrs) Ion No Ile _10 _Manufactured House lie----142_21"I'gakmvidence of damptiesn no led Outs&Ewa- Yes Attemaiy_Aie_I X Emmy Elbow iimm Standard iaRmi,00S1,erneS2 n, Foyer loot Onsso ' Kitchen Oen NI11111,Am Het Am 1.161.P. ,Oaths Laundry Other Area Sn I' Loyal 1 _1_ _ri__ A ___]. Partial - I i maned arra ebege era•m caroms 6 2 Part I lint. 3_, 1 220 Eno!, 1.322 Rooms. 1 RxX00.1,1. 1 Da111 1124 :110111.1fol a,lona:iron.,X. SURFACES licraaarriapersfC7A..loyon,,_izvArta _EA... Re,i1C,111-,Nm.EOUrjrIP i,A,,,,T Tier: Yes IMPR0VilitEN1 ANALSIS 1 floors Wails 1:1 Oral.or Constrocrion Prria 1 1/Aye Fool Gas Hato/roil,. 11 Stairs r-I Cr,oAon 0!anonsennora Torniimish Hood/Ave _ Cip41110,, A od aconsol ..'rs)Thrlp St,v LI Apok Si,./1.a,uul Ba,11 Flom Ceramlc,Tye__ Atfrouiry ,491.; Xx11.11,. I.xl&Mlle [X1-1 Clset,mK1 Shaw Bath Wa.cco1 Ceram!c/Ave ee/UNG Cmon Noo4/Aye 4.maiono [_14 floe Li Pomp,1111,mty Goy) Ary {a. P.. I.11 I- 1 I )i Ix I 1-1 I—) I- I Ix;F II !_I IAI t... I' C.,,,,,,,,, y„,-, 1.ix101XIO1 f....I I1ea90 [__I Plinttmq Mequaty 6 C0011101 1.-I Ix;).J 0:).,, _ 414111rer/11,1,11.il!mar C f i Ec,,ricalAt1cptticy L C.Ntlirm Li I x l 1„ 11 0..,,,,o,, ,,, ..Ye kkr,13.vave 1,„j Not ti 1110111:111Xie llt ArletitLiCy A Con,1_ 1 XI I._.I t fioroirceisi rr tri,k • 1 /..d.xprt:y A,/, 1.,(101 510,1e11 I-I PmtpaRmIlly 101.109101000.1 I,_1 ix i ..,CM StORAGE Goose LA i Attached 1_,‘, Athmua1c loon EaRy x /44,j ,,,,,Markddoloy I_I I),I I.,)I §No Cars 2, Cool.' I, 1 Pplac00 [.. 1:0000u3le [,1 OuNvIr Friir.; III Islanalhl floputni icpciarmt Lire a c..35 Condition Alio This I 1 NW In f nea,, ,, 1 i, La j li-roond rntiyi-11 Put01011 fleon.mq P0,1001 ble il 5-55 0, Ad0110021P.1.10,.1.1.g cj;, 1K y 11 Eh t,_i'atto._Nraulted_C di 11.nr.,.._Pluntinc_1,._.cepi- r,_Eaer:trieal_.,,vry°e_e_1, .._________ Deorecurion IFiroircal.lioXisnal and orlernat StrOsloacrec,0p50s neetied,frodonwhqn,irc) This dwell inkhae Veen aei 1 aatntained and is in Enact condition. _ War General nude coatroom SW Prevalence and ardant ay S011E1/1101411 sea regarding loan Ancourris,interest 0000000$24150058000egr reCi al gel Itr_. _Inducements.and_belnw market—int erent rata_rinaacinn..ran_affact_tha_aalna_rrl.a.e..rtsra.V.....tat Appeal No. PID # 26-116-22 12 0026 Date Received 3/30/1990 Appraiser 5,,F=:, APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 9 512-9rl �"" (n� c Work: zv 93V0 Name: Ke v \A cvr�s w t , Address of Property: j ( 7.-4=7-- ul.J+-(vs LAax January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the no ce: $ 4/8 3, 00u Date property was acquired: S. ,, /In Purchase Price: $ ,;"co, ya Terms of Purchase: 39 i;ooa ifild,41,10 , heal f co-s t. Additions and alterations since purchase: 44V0 5.( 'rA/6-- Cost of additions and alteration : 1/8,ooa Is property listed for sale? f0 If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ .��" 000 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): _ 'flu elker IZGrses %N oar shet 4(`arlroc�/(iliv�' S�rc//1� _ / k�ili-h ac7 Is a/efr,`ca/P__/-4 ✓a/f�LE' a G8 /0 817 m f A _ �/(la,4 s� rt'z ., Ouis rs � 7 7 2 , 71th 17 ,yc isxs,s14d (.l)L red(oo r Awe, ;5 ✓7 r Nick 4 ', l i L i/ t Ifas e,n i%e FL.041dif ed. .Z ,e ,T tZ set ydpeoo -,I,oagaao), �,..�0✓rs i.;a,ern,e . t✓e fee/ o✓r- c,, e eazt9, of"frrr�Ait. ,rrct5 10`se 5lw,>Qkk ✓o.feGe'" A A.ANer A Signetfiof Owner / cors,ikru-. 411 odr neO k rkvQ'. Please note: This form'requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 3300 — 33co L. 1/2/88 3,PCO — 1/2/87 a7o0 — a1cO i... Last Inspection: Jj /gp Appraiser: "noh..v1/4. Sc w4 Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments ii/4o ouuna— $ yea-o0Q WE) 10°70 // $ ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: • . • • • fidt19,4vev) 5-Z7Vgif vrss tv,./ are e(."1 /44 f (6_4__ Iriex.4rr41C.gite.c?hvit - _ 44.4,�. _ 3sy oW �7 8z rl60 we/� _ yo,ao o . . 7G//6-12.-/a-/r //?`''$ wt(/as S3/S"/ov o //709 w¢/{cam 3L`9,vc v ,74 /7b-Lz 11 al (44'/ 00 0 ,,26- 4 h /Z 3/ 1,( /Do/o0a 76 _116 -to r2-32 -- _ 1l-711-we/krs y13,goo SDo.000 + ?' - 6_-f16_-zL-rt -Z6 25-116-22-22-0032 Appeal No. 3-7 Date Received 3/3 90 Appraiser John Sams APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW //�� (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: "l1L1 09Sz ! Work: 34/z ('2 S9 Name: lad) G-j tv4A //'1► Address of Property: 1p�p J N1+-Ct1/✓G January 2, 1990 valuat on as it a ears on the notice: $ 35 Date property was acquired: D�'-r D I( 3 Purchase Price: $ 2.4,S K Terms of Purchase: 'p Additions and alterations since purchase: 3Movt�C knZkc n_4112_h4 /NV14 frOtA Cost of additions and alterations: 4 7,9049 Is property listed for sale? i p If yes, at what price $ - (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $.3/67 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated- value? (Please attach supporting information): /1 50Icero arJ'lt5 pn Sa�'►GWork 0f *are Pt Signature ofr Please note: This form"requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 I1500O a35000 350000 1/2/BB IOC as 11Op a7 x'O 1/2/87 9elaop ,Aot(,pp a5 CC) Last Inspection: 1 1/$1 Appraiser: >\✓` SGK+S Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: 1...l..c 14 'I -v-b Q ..waa AR# at$3SO,oCo „ ,du, c./ Ytiai u a. t�csu�l aL` I uwe�.r T,he 14 o 0 Ad z. .b 1vz Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments /SI cKU $ yoso W0 SA12 w is for Io4 oly Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: . . < \,\ 1 r 1,4 kti --i2-f--------fr i 0 k A 5 '41' ' _ ...........1514.2/111 ST1.2 ST CONY t•M1L 0 . 0111AI1/57DAYS PTS-0 SO•00200tP.SS1SA00 1141 t1 1 rM�lm;r,� ,. n s,._ t 4 P 7 1: it , r' '''' 0lpp•y . 4 .M� v 10If7M1 CIMTE .tax MOM sot 110147 -SA '..Z.- 1A MUASDENFAAMN 2133W IAXW,ASSIHII kId q1t Sfl 51M I COUNIr 14M1 O IEIIDMl 11. ItS 103XI111XI12XIlI AC AS s I t3l0 N `Mat NM A '➢34 '°�3nM. f1T AMIEASOt111II1WT 10 FAAIS �, D AMAIIC.MMNESSIYE SOIAny MINN S BO HM WIASPIC. 2 MOON MA.AM.PONMLEDSMAAT.A SEASON MACH OSEA• LODONO ATNEAMWAT OF OISADN:IMIS OO'F COMHE.TIE Al nE tot WAIL IMRnS'i iNMO0M1111XCl►TgNAIII 'w- M0A1 Ol NUS 71N AOINI.-- -CO.CaFJM10DTAAi►JWC FD Sd11d2-22-ODu • •I C 13U AFIDX CS CPC. ..8 • : 1 y iI ' to t tIll, II I CII FtA AMC MIMS00IE- ONO 3,i+tk l M 11X73 211 11111. At FA OAS IGSO Mt%O D 12XT2 31 ISXMO ItT MUST TIFF Ct3 OD ASMN ASMN Cl 11111 10 1 12XIt IF MP ISO 1N•CD11 ASMS Apt IA 1/X11 1A 11312 A3• COT ISM ON 11113 51111 1SMIM2 $1SIA MAT IF A2/0 272 1N177-f111 '14• iT�n NOE 1N AGI.F11 SMSAAN/10S'101AEWM 11.1 1 EA MUMS IIAINEN OF COO O 4 4343.2MF 111.2SM o i • ::.r,,,e i I t a\f'4051- •N nr r,l,t',;,10 O W . 61131 •BR 1 O80..3l011 STY!ST OTNR 1.-f389.900 II11189 31 DA S PIS f062030LPf319.900 f4700,O00 OL `+ rDrl1Pr A•f L cam �—rig'�'"�`" .+ . r 5a •1AAUSk Y'J ' 11202 MT COMM 110 N► Ni /AAI11 M ,..:,,I.r 1 V• EO0N PRANK VISOR? TAITAI1 wIAS1 fNtf INCE lY - , • . '. 692 SUSI COUNTY NEMI AI PENON NELL TO 121StI7SRSlI1 ACO R211990 III WILT 1911 .AM MSON LR PARKWAY•NRAMD•MT C1HowVE•NO MIIITIC TWO STORY CLASSIC IMCR 010MAL WITH PANORAMIC MISTS OF DYMPLIC HILLS 00V COUNSE►NULL MI 011SE NASTAT. 1.SUPPLEMENT EGO/LOT 1 ILA 1 OLYMPIC ELLS ITN ADON •1311621440003 CW-CO •MP.MIO.Dw1.ON.MC.• L ArROR I MHOS CS-CO VAC SEC DSC./OI.WPL.N• a 7SIS II 311111 PL 4 ANC TERMS CON.DTN tau 13 131113 MA OAS 1010 i0000 0 SCL 31 II13 ST W000,I• TYPE CUR 00 NA ATM N ST 21614 II 1114 .SNIT W0Y 6110 1M•CON ASMN TR O21S N 111116 GM3• SAY LL M:AS.APMOS 17ITS IR MISTS S2N0 1SIAT SAY /ASTRNY Tr 1000 '•2/2 r09 7.1160 1103117 AOT(7N CONNIE CIIMILWOA STOTLER 1440411 S 2.1 TER MUSTY 1NI000 ROM SO 1203 07PN 12f•/100 APT 92f•1100 . i 1 _ 1 12X10 "S. SUN ROOM:16X10 ADJACENT TO 12X10 INFORMAL DINING AREA. BOTH ROOMS HAVE BEAUTIFUL OAK FLOURS.SUN ROOM FACES SOUTH AND LOOKS OVER THE POND.DECK IS OFF OF SUN ROOM AND DECK HAS STAIRWAY TO BACK YARD. FIREPLACE IN FAMILY ROOM HAS HEATALATOR. SHOW TO YOUR FUSSY BUYERS! ERA-M.B.HAGEN REALTY CURT RUTTIER OFF:938-7681 RES:938-3908 • 03/07/90 11:40:29 15 � knee n ou/7 <<< L-3369.900 left SOLD>>> BR 5 TBA: 4 F; HET: 1 QBT: 0 STL: 2 STD • TRM: CON ASM INFORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED 11352 MT CURVE RD TAX $8212 /89/F MAP 47 -5A MUN EDEN PRAIRIE ZIP 55344 TWA $8212 LAKE LVIEW AR 592 SUB 1 COU HENN ASB3000 ASP N NEIL LOT 110X177X110X179 ACR 000 HS FOR 1990/ F YBL 1983. DIR PRESERVE TO FRANLO TO MT CURVE RD. ** ON GOLF COURSE +* LAKE VIEW ** GYM ** OVER 5000 SO FT +* THIS LANDMARK RESIDENCE IS LOCATED IN THE HIGHEST DEMAND FAMILY NEIGHBORHOOD IN TOWN WITH AN ENDLESS SUPPLY OF CREATURE COMFORTS. BEST VALUE I'VE SEEN IN YEARS. LGL LOT 6. BLK I. OLYMPIC HILLS 6TH ADD. PID 2311622440008 WAT CONN INCL RNG.DWS.DSP.MIC.F'H • L APROX L APROX SEW CONN MPH.BUS.FLT.SEC,D/P,POR.W* LR 1 20X16 IB 2 20X15 FPL 3 AIR C TERMS CON.ASM DR 1 164(12 2B 2 13X10 HEA FA /GAS MTG $184400 INT 7.75 %: ID 1 IIX10 3B 2 13%8 EXT WOOD.B* EXF CON.ARG OD 9/83 ASM Y KT 1 17X14 4B 2 12X12 BSM W.F.L PIN $1413 2MC N 2MA N FR 2 18X17 5B L 15X11 GAR 3.A.V ASSUME WITH NO APPROVAL OF 1 I5X11 FM L 36X16 FSZ 1530 ONE OFTHE BEST ARMS EVER! BET Y MBT V FSF 5400 SDN 272 SDP 937-1658 M629124 AGN LEE CHRISTIANSEN 929-2339 BB V SA 4.05 LTV ER EDINA REALTY. INC. 5877 OFPH 827-3551 APT 827-3551 rr. List No 629124 Sup* 1 Add 11352 MT CURVE RD IS THIS PARADISE? LOCATED ON PRESTIGIOUS OLYMPIC HILLS GOLF COURSE, BREATHTAKING VIEWS OF NEIL LAKE! MT CURVE-1HE HOTTEST STREET IN TOWN! WHAT. MY OWN GYM? 1SI FLR OFFICE WITH BOOKSHELVES THAT OPENS TO SECRET HIDEAWAY' 2 FMLY RMS! MASTER WITH FPLC! 2 PERSON JACUZZI TUB WITH PRIVATE VIEWS! 3 LEVELS FINISHED WITH Wi0' OVER 5000+ SO FT! FINALLY PARADISE IS AVAILABLE TO ONE LUCKY FAMILY WHO CAN LOCATE ON THE MOST POPULAR STREET IN TOWN. THIS MAGNIFICENT HOME IS IN ONE OF THE NATION'S MOST EXCITING COMMUNITIES WITH CREATURE COMFORTS TO PLEASE ANYONE. SUCH AS MILES OF BIKING B WALKING PATHS. MAGNIFICENT PARKS. A BOUNTY OF CHILDREN OF ALL AGES. SIDEWALKS. LANDMARK RESIDENTS. MINUTES TO DOWNTOWN. AIRPORT AND ALL MAJOR SHOPPING AREAS. FRONT DOOR PICK-UP TO OUTSTANDING EDEN PRAIRIE SCHOOLS AND EDEN PRAIRIE COMMUNITY CTR WITH ACTIVITIES FOR EVERYONE. ONE OF THE BEST INVESTMENTS IN THE CITIES. ONLY AN OUT OF TOWN MOVE MAKES THIS TREASURE AVAILABLE!! * AVAILABLE FOR IMMEDIATE OCCUPANCY * • . _ ------------ List No 629124 S0p# 'e! Add 11352 MT CURVE RD FEATURES OF THIS BEAUTIFUL RESIDENCE INCLUDE: *OUTSTANDING 1ST FL OFFICE WITH VAULTED CEILING & SURROUNDED BY OAK BOOKSHELVES (DON'T FORGET THE SECRET HIDEAWAY!). • *2 STORY FOYER WITH EXQUISITE OPEN STAIRWAY. *LIVING RM WITH FIREPLACE & BEAUTIFUL OAK COVE MOULDINGS. *DINING RA WHICH HAS A SPECTACULAR VIEW. *LARGE CTR ISLAND KITCHEN WITH AN ABUNDANCE OF OAK CABINETS, LARGE FAMILY EATING AREA WITH SPECIAL VIEWS, PANTRY, PLUS A PLEASANT WORK: STATION AND DESK. *1ST FLR MUD RM & 1/2 BATH. *LARGE PORCH & DECK. Ti: ENJOY MEMORABLE MOMENTS AND LAUGHING Al YOUR NEIGHBORS' GOLFING. *2ND FLR CONSISTS OF 4 BRS, LAUNDRY ROOM PLUS A VERY ENJOYABLE FAMILY FUN AREA (17416) WITH BEAUTIFUL VIEWS ; OF NEIL LAKE. *FABULOUS MASTER SUITE WITH FPLC PLUS LARGE MASTER BATH WITH DBLE WHIRLPOOL TUB, MANY CABINETS, SHOWER & SUN DECK. *WALKOUT LEVEL FEATURES FMLY RM WITH CUSTOM WET BAR, OAK WOODWORK, LARGE 5TH BR, FULL BATH & WHIRLPOOL & SAUNA AREA & (GYM). YES YOUR VERY OWN (GYM). THIS IS THE GREATEST ROOM YOU COULD THINK OF FOR FMLY FUN, JUST IMAGINE PRACTICING YOUR TENNIS STROKES, SHOOTING HOOPS, VOLLEY BALL, GOLF, THROWING THE BASEBALL, FOOTBALL, & ALL THE THINGS KIDS LIKE TO DO IN THE MIDDLE OF WINTER. *PLUS: SECURITY SYSTEM - INTERCOM - HUMIDIFIER - C/AIR - 3 CAR GARAGE - PROFESSIONALLY LANDSCAPED LOT WITH DECORATIVE LIGHTING - SPLIT SHAKE ROOF - 3 FPLCS. *ASSUMABLE MTG VERY SPECIAL W/RATES & TERMS SELDOM FOUND! . • • YES THIS HOME HAS THAT SPECIAL FEELING SO HARD TO FIND! LEE CHRISTIANSEN 929-2339 363135 155.5 SSA-31011 stY-1 ST CONY L-3373•000 10/13/03 SO DAYS P15-0 S0.511601.1.-1341000 34317,000 —1 Iy 1301pLYavIA ON TAX SO241 MIS Aw 17 .IA NUN 1.1. 2P 11341 11YA WWII LAZE 0517 0111 COU1N101 ASOS Mr LOT 131113311M1115 OCR 0 1410N IWO/1 YR 11M DIA c 0 no unotL10M11►M411A340•10.CLMY3 043313.1A IN ••I T111001 COINRNY1101ED5M21110 TOP11Ylc1%MM•• LOCATED M A PEACEFUL SUM OYERLOOI 515 III 11111 14011 Of OYM ICMLLS OOZE COIDIM.TIRO I MONOOAS. 4 OAIMIKPAI OMENS MI11/ANAUMIOLOpTYL1.501 SUPPOO MO Lai . 1 TIT T1_ TIM PO 13 1.21.1300111 AT CpMJ• • M! • WOK . COWLS. -.....—'t:...' La 11130 II 11114 • 2 AMC IL 01 12111 25' 11115 EA I OAS G30 MT % D • 35' 111I11 11 MIST OD AMt AI 10113 N• 1111S MJ.L SD MCI 2IMN • fa T2111 SO 13511 3.Y PO 12311 DR >. 1 •0 MTY TY .3334 ,_. 2t .`11M AGNSNL SAMMONS/00LT101 UN SA3.10 51YEI M/MAI MOULTS 1314 OM91125.1100 APT MS-21M • S{{rq NOR-1 SAA-2/0/1 STY-2S1 CONY E • 04/04/19 11 DAYS PTS.00 SO-�S Otpu{e,{oo S-$�-t2o23O2 ,w as, • le e. 06100EYAVµ OA O NUN EDEN MAME 7010142 U I2 NA 17 SA DOT/12 SUS2 COUNTY M:NIIW/ASf12E ARE IS 101XI AC I ►1NDN DE CST IS . 0 I: I. 100S RANG PRYEIYRMOOR SY terrCONSINUCTIOK OPEN DYNAMIC DEMO MTN !1 CO%1120NMMY TOUCHEUCM!S0 {MgWi0b�i010 Eryrrur. O MOONY rM r2M1Api Il 1's LJ � AIAOK CW40 •AN.0A7.N0AACiAN 1DA 11 12A11 it, 1%21 • 2 M C U..., a'........1 O IOAI! >t. 12%I7 TM OAS ,f0 M7%0 . CT 11%11 21 IIAI{ • T XXII WOOD,i� AENN dA OD1 My 71 •, „ ' 2' 0S100Y iN 2NKDA ASNN OSFA EMNM .! ADiM11NU1A17M •L1CY%Y1W '•' 2 7N ETA • _ EDIIAA11 M. area I-7111/NI-IS21 SE7 T1A MR EIM{444107 MT 011.7107 M T 1. n aril" . ,(7) I Ms 30 '90 09:40 TO:9-9229102 FROM:CITY OF_EDEN PPAIPIE T-123 P.03 PID 4 26-116-22 11 0008 Date Received 3/30/1990 Appraiser John Sams APPLICATION FORM Appeal # 3 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 943-2436 Work: 927-4403 Name: DAVID P. STEWART Address of Property: 9427 OLYMPIA DRIVE January 2, 1990 valuat(on as it appears on the notice: $ 575,200 Date property was acquired: January 12,1Pmfhase Price: $ 520.000. (NET $505,000) Terms of Purchase: rash Additions and alterations since purchase: Paint and decorating Cost of additions and alterations: $2500:00 Is property listed for sale? No If yes, at what price $ N/A (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 505,000 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): $15,000 of purchase price paid to buyer (Stewart) as excess down payment. This was a corporate sale and seller felt it important to show price of $520,000. Actual selling price was $505,000. i nature of r Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data iS not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 ggacxJ 4373C:0 535500 r 'al 1/2/88 g5000 Na3-CCQ 515SOp0 1/2/87 '{co ago() Last Inspection: .j_/j/gg Appraiser: _i b v. SawlS Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Convents 7 1/5r1 f�i ll 5-sOC O v)O-Case sc.l� Lb-3/15 --57 $s s co ******,****************************************t*****************max*********a** Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: _ • 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. 1/p Date Received 4/2/1990 PID # 17-1I6-22 14 0087 Appraiser Steven Sinell APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BDARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: Name: Af)7cf c a( Work: 4?)-s.f/Y e9�er Address of Property: 44,372 1 e'o.- L'- January 2, 1990 valuation as it appe s on the notice: $ eGOYOOe.c' Date property was acquired: /9T9 Purchase Price: $ 30o Oe0 Terms of Purchase: `f 4o7. Additions and alterations since purchase: A/o c Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): Sig u 0 Owner' ` Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/B9 191000 - 191000 Vacant land 1/2/88 173800 40500 214300 Commercial 1/2/87 I73800 40500 214300 Commercial Last Inspection: wilfin Appraiser: si-ela— Sih.cli Building Permits/Appraiser Comment s7i�uuti..-..e �Li,«, ce Si 3oo.,000 43 -""' Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments / ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. 4) Date Received 413t�10 PID # 01-116-22 41 0003 Appraiser StevQ Sinpll APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: Work:.'gal-g513 Name: The Eighteen Park Business Center c/n Tnvpctmant c,aruires Group, Inc. Address of Property: WO Washington Avenue s ntli).a An orwirig, mm January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: 1 'ao,non 00 Date property was acquired: 3/11/RR Purchase Price: $ 7 j00,0n0 00 Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): T. Signature Owner �N Please note: This form requests private or confident data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Oepartment) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 67600o ioabO( D /70,)000 - 1/2/88 5071000 IOPbodo /s'70ao .Z 1/2/87 y OOP ioa6000 ISO OD Last Inspection: 2/I1/BS Appraiser: 5 Si`w-e if Building Permits/Appraser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 76/12 77 a,7c000O LAX) Pb T - .s - .€ Sale. / / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: ,;ppea i iiu. qZ. _.. Date Received /a 11c PID f 24-I16-22 21 0007 Appraiser marl 2.Pnt APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: '?'/'/ Work: /¢4/<7- 5'a( (fte'd) Name: Frtdr,c.K 0,0 .tila,era / ri/cir Address of Property: Y(05.5 6/0CAC /v(Q le tDi 'V� January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ /9C,.3')n Date property was acquired: ,-(7 ri- /<?7R Purchase Price: $ //n)t.oc Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: �//;/.<i <` / 4ddt,rd d K Cost of additions and alterations: h/� cGo —6,1 Is property listed for sale? Air If yes, at what price $ pnlifiggo, (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ /7.5" 4,-m' What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): C( >74 e-L'G!-. .etz.as //1-7 c'-[ i'� 4.7-2_ c,./1z_ �4<, P t ('4,' if.3,t z0 G7 2414 t e v.4'1/2 6r-22 W11. /7n.r,��e-t- �%t�' Z.1 4 el,tJ 1 )i r,2.c`; ,' eLz c-I /r ppfct tciLf ,t c.r . )1' CFyci1 t t /I« 0 rc.cr� e � cza, 6t/ U/7y a n, cc?L /2 2 signature of Dwner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Pro ert Class. 1/2/89 45►00 199100 1��4aoo 1/2/88 43/00 Ia'MOO tr(cf) 1/2/87 P _On; i►R9o0 rbl4og Last Inspection: Appraiser: Earl Zev Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments r /1.1 CRC $ II0000 WQ I / $ ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. 41 PID # 23-116-22 44 0006 Date Received q/a1e0 Appraiser John Sams APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 943-2504 ($u.yaa'kas em) Work: 828-262 4 Name: CRC& 5. WILKES Address of Property: //292. lhntavf CuAt4 2o147) January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 7 2p0 o Date property was acquired: 6/im/88 Purchase Price: $ A25,Coo Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: NONE Cost of additions and alteration : i✓(A Is property listed for sale? Afo If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ ,3oo oo o What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): • Sia i ee ner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 ;,5 ^ 3S'7 37-crn 1/2/8B :. `:`•\ argc+wc' all cc K 1/2/87 � ac^ �a,SCC , 1 7cc, Last Inspection: q/4-i/a Appraiser: 7)oLA, Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments !/7 , $ c�SCcr z.,r� 1_l�~ c 7. . $ *,r,t,t,t,t,t,t,tt,t****,tt,t,ht,t,t,r,t****,t,t,t,tt,t,t,tt,t,**********,t,t********t,t,ht,t,t,t****,t,******* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: GREG AND LINDA WILKES 11292 Mount Curve Road Eden Prairie, MN 55347 April 2, 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW Gary D.Peterson,Chairperson Richard Anderson Jean Harris Patricia Pidcock Douglas Tenpas During the past year, larger homes on Mount Curve Road have sold at values significantly below our equivalent assessed value. In addition to the tow prices,there are many homes for sale which have been sitting for a tong time. I believe that the build up in the number of homes for sale is due to a combination of: a)ongoing turnover due to corporate relocation;b)corporate downsizing and layoffs in Minneapolis and most importantly;c)the significant amount of overbuilding that has occurred in our area,which has resulted in a very high level of inventory and substantially depressed prices. However, regardless of what the correct explanation is,the market value of larger homes on Mount Curve Road,as evidenced by the actual selling prices on the attached exhibit, has unfortunately been running very tow relative to the prices of two years ago and the recent assessed value of our home which was adjusted upward by$85,000.00 The circumstances which created the drop in prices and the large number of unsold homes for sale have not changed and since they are caused by longer term issues,are unlikely to change in the near future. I ask for your thoughtful consideration of the information I have submitted including the attached exhibit and appreciate your help in this matter. Sincerely, • S. Wilkes Attachment GREG AND LINDA WILKES 11292 Mount Curve Road Eden Prairie, MN 55347 • Mount Curve Road Existing Home Sales(>4200 square feet) 1989 AND FEB YTD 1990 Selling Market Value p.ajg House # Price Sq.Footage Per Sq.Foot 2/20/90 10662 $378,000 5200 $72.69 1/20/90 11352 345,000 5400 63.89 7/14/89 11202 300,E 5000 60.00 6/14/89 10793 415,000 6210 66.83 Average $65.85 11292 Mount Curve Road • 3500 sq.ft. - Top 2 Floors 4,600 sq.ft • 1100 sq.ft. - Downstairs Recreation x 3065.85 Currentvage of Actual SaMarket Value Above Room al sq.ft. - Total x 90% 272.619 Proposed Assessed Value { Appeal No. PID # 01-116-22 32 0012 Date Received gla/4O Appraiser John Sams APPLICATION FORM Lprrvti 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 99/-/ ,/ /� nn /! Work: yze_ysrr Name: (� dfe'hce• $' Cho{CIr >'troeLrYy 20- Address of Property: ‘6// 'p Id co'it bh 0!-//6_ January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on th otice: $ /./ /oo 0 Date property was acquired: /94,3 Purchase Price: $ Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: Am' sMe1•--en,c' roe,rrr -r r &aV - Cost of additions and alterations: A Do o Is property listed for sale? 'n If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 9_S 6 0 0 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? • (Please`attach supporting information):o /, �/l,f /jc�ir� is .74,1y/,4 —— l a/r c311__ hfi taliN4f ai-c>-.ci rircdih the,,,rahQc. f/eet it Aso ken tul.7c ha7alAlrt9 yuall is toZZ rtet 'the• Fr�.n�doe rs-ZX e- C1//c' Qh? /o�lrf.�� -r4,-window j ra.hieS moire totZ✓ngl- die'ha dCho �,:"Ly, a4,..zL.r e r�°�leek 4'st�os 1 %.5.MO►*eAahCo A. g/d ggnaturefo Owner Scl//pv Node-reh wad ea.Zmik'hsi f-2ra-Mu Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. .(In be complet0 by rho Accoceinn flanartmpnt) Prior year values: Land Building Total Pro ert Class. 1/2/89 31b00 byio 9570© 1/2/88 301o0 1/2/87 afrgoO 5 DO Last Inspection: 24jj Appra ser: Joyv, S4,441S Building Permits/Appraiser Conments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 1 / // S ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. 4'14' Date Received 'flalg o PIO # 27-116-22 14 0023 Appraiser S•S. APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: ei6V-30i Z Work: 9yl-9730 Name: �,edcE , //41/e2LY Address of Property: /Z-90/ January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ /44,cna Date property was acquired: 1977 Purchase Price: $ lel 000 Terms of Purchase: C.15N E0w0v 7v /'2o.4r 06E Additions and alterations since purchase: ►3oaF Cost of additions and alterations: 4 D,°. Is property listed for sale? No If yes, at what price $ �► (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 1I63 Doo. �� _ What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): Szot.E No -rfAeoL,s075vrs Aft/4 (4J bon16/ [JE twor DNS, sm Ant T....r...06tcA- A]A -i YfLye. ifAcuru ittv6s ickru, LLY.ke--C.B6Y•ed isafisz of 0 r/>.ite+Arbib THE Ail-r,Lu_7,-ve Pet 54d a-tE !eio;. 11fs5 yt 5069-Au rr f rcd Re Tim ipt-Lok Tfl S A-aY of NIEW l/Byrs gf,Ti r-77; 05• 7�EcrY,f��/"✓ m E Seerd Emory ac Y oar BorLr. fae, Signature of Owner 7 /lo 2 , d,4 wan i,rr m 9s�'eF 70, A,aa..ur def-fh+YA2 cr t f rrdT= Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Buildin Total Property Class. 1/2/89 a7/-050 OO 1'FboOo S 1/2/88 a-7500 15,400 f lI dOo s 1a2t87 — `F/SO L- Last Inspection: 2. Ap� praiser: Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments —r / / / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. 47 • PID # 04-116-22 42 0058 Date Received ,,j/3/y p Appraiser npan Jarohc APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 9 3 1-6 ZSt Work: zZo-o�9y Name; TLY vy ontv SJ J� Address of Property: 100F k�v�. brNt_ January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ -7,2 o u Date property was acquired: 19%5 Purchase Price: $ 9,duo Terms of Purchase: \/R N ,.to µ !(.S°Z Additions and alterations since purchase: 12 k11- 11-1 F>4.,sv,44 ff L� J rSO-M St/s1l�ry i IJY�t�t ppaa..C'��A TY�'1�v.:r Ft;oht Inc, vaudir QIr Cost of additions and alterations: J _ Is property listed for sale? J4 If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 8 5-00 i What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supportinglI information): Z t'f 1-7 v. S�-c-r0.,1\, Yia�- t c 1StSx'ty V.c�^^� Tvr 7.x Q�.reu.r+_r IJ t7 QI3 1.44 k� Lr, ��wr, t4wu&rk f v.0,4 a 4 4ti,t T ( +1,-k_ +l,(sd I, e. 1 fs sell Lew. r fa 01-6,-A S 1--44—s Signature vav n Please note: This forth requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 /b100 b6300 8400 IZZ 1/2/88 1517oO g�{aG1D "1q goO Rz 1/2/87 5000 bi700 741700 /LZ Last Inspection: 1/10/6k Appraiser: Tow O'Rr,e w Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments /$1 c R 9000 / / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: . . • A-3 sc (ANL �l.,.rLS L-Wt �r.t{ 195s �1`t Ouq ?tt/ ace Io(. -fed 3yQaYS 7,91 AS zeSla Vklv,t 46 � 4 00 y4741t -c.v- I K E Y 199c k•z- v / to -- 3 b T l-9s) „rt, r ► urc b y v. fJe,„.,„ 1 h; S �r R ... �f ✓t(�7�'i` G V� /Y� V4./U2 roc P,--ta 71- Fe-Y) 1989 W�.r In T �-c M� r/eLY f° (I c? te,c Ic1 ,A 11 s _f �-� �..� . /Ze e . +. a-t -_ L S i-1s-` 5 S ro�,, *kk i; r t �� s_,%-c +w h.c I r W ,r,P 'r�v� Sf 1 #14 ; 4 wsay..1 _`for 4' k' 1,5_1�6._no"f" MARKET EVALUATION 6692 Kara Dr. Eden Prairie,MN Prepared For: Terry and Michelle Jorgenson Submitted By: John Justice February 22,1989 Caldwell Banker 8023 Glen Lane Eden Prairie,Minnesota 55344 944-8755 COLD W eu. BANI(eR D MARKET COMPARISON SUMMARY This is a comparison of your house with selected houses similar to yours. While no houses are exactly alike, these properties have major similarities to yours and in the event differences are apparent, they will be noted with a + or - symbol following the feature. PROPERTY YOUR COMPETITIVE COMPETITIVE COMPETITIVE FEATURES PROPERTY PROPERTY 1 PROPERTY 2 PROPERTY 3 Current status Active Active Active Address 6692 --_,' 6617 6625 6615 Kara Dr. Kara Dr. Kara Dr. Kara Dr. Style Twin Home/" Twin Home Twin Home Twin Home List price ---- $81,900 $82,800 $83,500 Sale price Date of sale Terms Days on market Lot size 65X206 45X178 45X175 Common Year built 1984 1985 1985 1985 SFML 1092 924 1092 924 TFF 1350 1149_ 1300 1352 Bedrooms —4"— 2 -lam 2 Baths 2 2 1 2 Master bath Walk Thru Dining Room Yes Yes Yes Yes Garage 2 TU 2 TU 2 TU 2 TU Fireplace Central air Yes Yes 1stFlFmRm Yes • COLDweu. BANI(eR 0 MUNICIPAL INFORMATION Municipality Eden Prairie Property ID Number 04-116-2242-0058 Legal Description 1/2 of Lot 10 Block 1 Eden Vale 17th.Addtion Lot Size .58X206X65X206 Year Built 1984 Taxes Due 1989 Homestead Full Homestead Filed For 1990 Full Yes City Estimated Value $79,800.00 Square Footage-City 1092 Sewer Connected Yes Water Connected Yes • COIDWeLL • BANKeR C7 Appeal No. 't75 PID # 05-116-22 14 0018 Date Received 4/2/1990 Appraiser Farl 7Pnt APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 93y-rS-2_7 � ��Work: 3 3 r-71-ri Name: �T�y rya,,o /y f �/jt�fr.U✓� ,( ///u,e,P&fy Address of Property: 6s-s9 T,y,4 �,edf January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: S /sp ec. Date property was acquired: 9-r 7 Purchase Price: $ /1,4 7/3— Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: ,-.taq.s c✓%.oc,, s4 7Mta.s Cost of additions and alterations: f/7o,' Is property listed for sale? /vo If yes, at what price $ A'/,4 (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ /Savo What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): S ..427TA4'0 �sr ,e „4✓.0 Ocrvencn,Jr..a77Qr-, Sign ure of wner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 40000 112000 352000 R 1/2/88 40000 112000 152000 R 1/2/87 39000 11810 _Les.glo R (partial) Last Inspection: j_zatE6 Appraiser: E4...1 Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments /_ __ �— / / $ ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: 6559 Taiga Circle Eden Prairie, Minnesota 55346 March 30, 1990 Mr. Earl E. Zent Appraiser, Assessing Department City of Eden Prairie 7600 Executive Drive Eden Prairie, Minnesota 55344 Dear Mr. Zent: We have received the market value tax report from the city of Eden Prairie which lists the market value of our home at $159,600. We question the valuation based upon the following: 1. The original cost of the property. Documentation is attached to support the reported cost. This information was also furnished to you in April of 1988. 2. The sales market analysis prepared by Edina Realty in May of 1989. Considering that in most cases the list price is greater than the sale price, this analysis would indicate that the value is also overstated. 3. There is evidence that the sales prices of homes in our immediate area have fallen during the past year. This is evident by the recent sale of parcel ,#R05-116-22 14 0014. This home was listed at $172,000 in 1989 and was taken off the market when the owner declined an employment transfer. This past month the home was relisted at approximately $165,000. 4. We also feel that the disparity between actual sales or constructed cost of homes to the market value is not equitable. Nor do the market values fall within the 90-100% range (for 1989 sales) which you indicated. The following are examples: Property 1988 1989 Mkt value Percent Parcel Sale Sale 1990 05-116-22-13-0080 $180,900 $ 141,400 78% 05-116-22-14-0008 127,000 110,600 87 05-116-22-14-0030 195,000 172,200 88 05-116-22-14-0033 163,900 144,300 88 05-116-22-13-0067 $160,000 148,900 93 05-116-22-14-0005 98,900 93,600 95 05-116-22-14-0027 178,000 167,400 94 05-116-22-14-0009 109,000 103,200 95 The market value to constructed costa are shown by two adjacent properties. Cost Mkt Value Percent 05-116-22-14-0017 183,500 160,300* 87 05-116-22-14-0018 143,915 159,600 111 *net deck 5. I also question the lot valuations within our immediate area. Based primarily on the above we respectfully request that the market value be adjusted downwards to a value of $155,000. Enclosed also find the application form for appealing the assessed value of our property. Please review the attached documentation and let us know if there is a change prior to the Eden Prairie Board of Review meeting scheduled for April 19, 1990. Thank you for your time and consideration. Since y, R and H. Murray LAM- Christine K. Murray Enc. • Eden Prairie Board of Review No. April 28, 1988 7:30 P.M. The Board of Review meets to hear appeals on market value or classification and not to hear appeals on the percentage of increase or the amount of property taxes. The market value as of January 2, 1988 will be the basis for property taxes due and payable in 19B9. The amount of tax will be based on mill rates based on the levies of the School District, Hennepin County, the City of Eden Prairie and other taxing subdivisions in October of 1988. You are responsible for presenting evidence to the Board of Review as to why the valuation placed on your property by the City Assessor does not represent market value as of January 2, 1988. The meeting will be recorded and minutes will be taken. The other appeal procedures that are available include the County Board of Equalization, State Board of Equalization and the Tax Court. **** You must return this form to our office before the Board of Review ***** . (Please Print)ri� / ��' Phone: Res:Name: /1:�/'il.�a✓o /j� ` �1.�STii✓/F� � // Bus: 335--7�� Address of Property: H SSA �, /CI 4 , a., /.L°l,�,F �� Si dyc Property Identification No.: 05-116-22-14-0018 January 2, 1988 valuation of property as appears on valuation notice:y160,00n nn Owners estimated valuation as of January 2, 1988 is: .4f///1(;ccc; What are your reasons substantiating the above stated value? Sff o ih/to : /) 4-pc,/'7,/91-;P .rT5.' ry /17. e?t,.i>- 2) .5 %.,.,/F r G4l411 y0../F G„rr.�//ern. �j /c..l,d Sf7,-0617i;i,- S>-.fiFinEA.r te-lrr seQy to /ee. nvYA1 Y.1>s � s /7>ir.T�TicT� /L.(iilTSrnS /f/l.:Tcc9�t' ir, cc—, / !u,/// • - . EZ. 6559 Taiga Circle Eden Prairie, Minnesota 55346 April 7', 1988 Mr. Earl E. Zent Appraiser, Assessing Department City of Eden Prairie 7600 Executive Drive Eden Prairie, Minnesota 55344 Dear Mr. Zent: We have received the market value tax report from the city of Eden Prairie. We question the valuation based upon the following: 1. The actual cost of the land and home construction cost is much less than the valuation. 2. The valuation of our neighbors' homes that either have: a) masonry fireplaces, a deck, and a brick front; or b) large master bath with whirlpool tub and a brick front; are valued less than our home. Our home has neither of these items. 3. No finish work has been done in the basement. We respectfully request that the market value be adjusted downwards to a value of $144,000 based on the above and on the attached schedules. Please review the attached documentation and let us know of a valuation change in sufficient time for formal appeal process, if it is so required. If you need further documentation please.call us at home (934-8527) or Ray at work {338-7851). Thankyou for your time and consideration. • Sincerely,4.).„/„."../. 71 „sfe.te-7 Raymond H. Murray I1 Christine K. Murray • Raymone H. & Christine K. Murray Land & Home Construction Cost of 6559 Taiga Circle Schedule I Land ( B.T. Land Co.) $ 38,500 (2) Home ( Martin Schutrop Construction) 97.255 (1) Additions: Lighting 930 Dirt fill and grading 2,707 Painting, staining and wallpaper 1,605 Ceramic tile addition �148 Home design costs 320 Retaining wall 2,005 Sod 445 Total cost value $143,915 (3) (1) See settlement statement attached line J 105 - N.C. Bennett Lumber $27,114 line J 109 - Escrow 2,200 line J 111 - Martin Schutrop 60,441 Original contract downpayment - Martin Schutrop 7,500 $97,255 (2) See settlement statement attached line J 112 - 1st Bank Minneapolis (swing loan on land) $37,654 Less interest included in line J 112 ( 154) Original contract downpayment - B.T. Land Co. 1,000 $38,500 ,(3) Reconciliation of total cost value to IRS form 2119 for 1987. Form is attached. Tax return form 2119 $148,500 Title insurance, abstracts, recordings and mortgage application ( 1,800) Attorney fees (primarily due to contractor failing to comply with contract) 1,950) Appliances (dishwasher and garage door opener) ( 530) Miscellaneous supplies and tools 305) Total cost value , : • • • • 9 0,.18 No 7502 o76s,E.0 r7 1,out • •DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AUG GOlAN DEVELOPMENT B TYPE Of LOAN SEflUAIENTSTATEMENT . 0,.. • . TI 28082 .•...,,.•.• - 7 hOR This form Is furnished to give you a statement of actual settlement cells.Amounts paid to and by me settlement agent are shown.Items marked"(p.o.e.)'were paid outside the Closing;they are shown here loT inlormanonal purposes end are not Included in Moralists. J NAMEOFBORFOAsh Raymond H. Murray and Christine IC. Murray AOCNES90F 11311ACWFR NAME OF SELLER Ref ins nce 40013E550F SELLER NAME OF LENDER Knutson Mortgage Corporation A0OREES OF IENCER: 7805 Telegraph Rd., Bloomington, Mn 55438 • 1 PROPERTY 6559 Taiga Circle, Eden Prairie, MN 55344 LOCATION: t SETTLEMENT AGENT: PAST SECURITY TITLE, INC. PUCE OF SETTLEMENT: 8009 34th Av. Se. P1100, Minneapolis, MN 55420 • SETTLEMENTOATE: April 23, 1987 J SUMMARY OF BORROWER'S TRANSACTION K. SUMMARY OF SELLER'S TRANSACTION .1,.. . -0' E.:... .`,�,+:-'�"•.. • .ISO.OROSI AMOUNT PIA,To 8OLLER, • ,'+t',lf�tlt°.,'., DI Contract salts price 401.Contract miss pica 02 Personal p,opuly 402.141504l1 properly UJ SanNmsnl['Thou M Dorrowu: 403. (hrmwM 1400) 2,292.12 04 t04. TIC Bennett 27,113.74 405. AOJUSTMENTI FOR ITEMS►AIO IT SEALER W ADVANCE: ADJUSIMINII FOR 111MS PAW ST SILLLR IN ADVANCE: 106.C,IynOwn Luse to 406.C4ynownlles b ISO.County tuts I/1 to 7/1 55.39 457.Coumylues To 101.Aaseuments M E.P. 78.15 406.A01lnsm040 b 109. Escrow (Work) 2,200.00 409. Ito. 410. III. Martin Schutroo 60,440.93 411. i12 Ann Hyla 17.644.09 412. 70 GROSS AMOUNT OUt FROM SORROW/PT ► I'/9.814.42 170.GROSS AMOUNT 0U1 TO Mat "AMOUNTS MD RI 0R IN IfIAOP 0i.10RR0W1R:..,,,.•.^..!._„'...7<WS:RIOUCIIONS III AMOUNT DUO TO ltllllk "'1'J':`C:it:-le}Nasy1 'ul Oep0sa orlamlll money 501.Excusdepout(Tee,nsrrucfblR) 972 PunopU 111500111 01 newt ants) 105,000.00 502.Ssllbmenlcharoes to s1011(ARM 1400) .113 Eaulmo Mantel liken luau['b 503.Enslm010111111 lahensubNGM rut 504.Payoilol last monolpe ban t05 ^' 505.PeyoI of second mafiosos loss run 506. :U7 507. :ue 506. ov S09. AOJUSTMLATS TOR RIMS UMPA10 9Y SELLER: ADJUSIMENIS TOR ITEMS UNPAIO IT SELLER 210 CJy lowntues to 510.Car/town Wit 10 ?Il.Courtly was lo ST I.COWIT lases 10 7,2 Assessments to 512.Assessments low 213 513. 714 SIt. 215 S1S. 216 516 217. SIT. Ile 516 T19 519 770.TOTAL PM01T•fOR 570.TOTAL RIOUC/IONS IORROWLR 105,ono.nn W AMOUNT OUt SELLER: +1 I 1.1., , , .,1.. , A+. ,.'1100.•CASH A7 IMLIMIRTTO9ROMltlllttru.4 Ni G.Los amount awe horn Aomori rhum f701 179.N11.42 501 GaAs amount one to seder nor 1701 .102 UM 11110unl GISd Delos Sousse(ARM 220) ( 105,000.001 602.Less Iola)ll0utll5nIm EnbIIMdut truer lane 320)I 1,1 CALM 10 IRON, ItJ gOl IDRROWIR: OP 24,834.1,2 602.CASH 10 107 10/Rout TELLER OP Tlre,o,,s Eamon is Otmoists ^ se.a,w ms, 3N ss.1 /hNl•tlaaet .. ..... �_11ES►A NB 4305 2 • • • _1 19 Sale or Exchange of Principal Residence OMB No.l545-0072 • ►See Instructions onback. lj g/87 nlnrere of Ore Irexxrq t..al nerenue Serene WI I,Attach to Form 1040 for year of sale(see Instruction 8). Mtaamrerd nels)nshowuort re 40 r 22 5eeucnce Ho Tour odd..aunty numNr Y d.✓V —�/e/JT,,Jia.• J' /i4,,g",- yv 13-4 ;.2746 not Include expenses that you deduct as moving expenses. a Dale fernier residence sold ► 474,f(4/=;7��FA6 b Enter the lace amount of any mortgage.note(for example,second trust),or other financial instrument on which you will receive periodic palurenls of principal or interest born this sate► nJ0 £___.._._. i✓ ise titer se -- -- _ ._ a II you bought or built a new residence,eider dale you occupied it:otherwise enter"None"►�Q���4/;i7 Yes No_ b Are any rooms in either residence retried out or used for business for which a deduction Is allowed? (II"Yes."see instructions.) a Were ylu55oroverort date ol sale/_- x- b Was your spouse 55 or over on date of safe? II you answered"No"to 3a and 3b,do not complete 3c Through 31 and Part II. e Om the person who answered"Yes"to 3a or 3h own and use the properly sold as his or her principal residence for a _total of al least 3 years(except for short absences)of the 5-year period before the sale? d II you answered Mies"to 3c,do you elect to take tire once in a lifetime exclusion of the gain on the sale? e Al lime of sale,was lie residence owned by. Uyouu,_—.0 your spouse, boll)of you? I Social security number ol spouse•at lime of sale,it dillerenl from number on Form 1040 ► (Eider"None"i'you were riot married at time of sale. i • 21 Computation of Galn Selling price of residence(Do not include personal properly items.) 4- 9�oov Expense of sale(Include sales commissions,advedisbrg,legal,etc) _5 510 ou Subtract hne 5 from line 4.tins is the amount realized 6 /Yo Basis of residence sold 7 • p Gain on sale(subtract line 7 horn line 6) (I zero or less,enter zero and do not complete the rest of form Enter the gain 110r1/This lisp on Schedule D,bile 3 or t0.•unless you bought another principal .70 /42. residence or checked"Yes"to 31.Then continue with tins form if you haven't replaced your residence,do you plan to do so within the replacement period? U Yes l.1 No (II"Yes"see instruction 8.) J Age 55 or Over One•Time Exclusion •mplete this part only it you checked"yes"to 3(d)to elect the once In a lifetime exclusion;otherwise,ship to Part IN. t Enter the smaller of line 8 or St 25,000(562.500,it married filing separate return) 9 Gain(subtract fine 9 horn line 8) II zero,do tint complete rest of form.Enter the gain horn this line on • Schedule D,line 10,'unless you bough)another principal residence.then continue with this Iona 10 MEI Gain To Be Postponed and Adjusted Basis of New Residence mplef_e this part i—you bought another principal residence. Fixing tip expenses(see instructions for time limits) 11_ -e_-_ Adjusted sales price(subtract line 11 iron line 6) 12__i9' /YO_ _ Cost ol new residence 13 /YSbo , Gain taxable this year(subtract line 13 plus line 9(if applicable)from litre 12),II result is zero or less, enter zeta Do not eider more Than hire 8 or kite 10(if applicable).Enter the gain from this line on Schedule D,lime 3 or 10' 14 -0 - _ � Gain to be postponed(Subtract brie 14 from line 8.However.it Part II applies,subtract line 14 from line I 0) 15 p//y Adjusted basis of new residence(subtract fine 15 from line 13) 16 lag.;3� :aullon II you completed f win 6252 for the residence in 1 a.do not enter your taxable gain horn Fmmt 2119 on Schedule D. 'Paperwork Reduction Act Notice,see back of form. ram 2119(tOe7) Appeal No. 49 Date Received 4/2/1990 PID # 05-116-22 42 0023 Appraiser Dean Jacobs APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: q34-O10 Y 1 Work: q-34 - 4-7--/U Name: I<Pvv COASon Address of Property: (o7Oq LA). 1(09)4" Ave. January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: S 13\13 oo Date property was acquired: '1193 Purchase Price: S ioS,oe+c („n,1�a ,r,Iwd) Terms of Purchase: we, were w. 4 proleck Additions and alterations since purchase: air rend,;-ionlnr, �layrnor,, in {7a5emPn4 Cost of additions and alterations: fAhlu} 31 t00,"° Is property listed for sale? tJo If yes, at what price S (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: S )oa(.0 000 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): AVevac)e 0.55e55eJ Lai D.( all hOrneS OvrOunr! us (23)- I I5 000co •p° it our G.irr12 119,goo (See a1uched p«.424... Signature of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 25100 97700 122800 R 1/2/88 24300 94500 118800 R 1/2/87 23400 90700 114100 R Last Inspection: -7/ia./E9 Appraiser: ¢¢a+n. 3utofas Building Permits/Appriser Comments: Sale History Date ource Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments /_I Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: I, Assessed i ncr ease -CDs,' 1991 s O 4 O{ lire .c.,,,, prev,0 ,s yeo-vs Ic18c1 _ 1 c190 — 3% increase 1(7190 - 19c'1t — 14% ncr ease_ Z) Co.,.pe;1..b1e asf.>es•..,.,,e...-k-5 tlMt�I'"P�v ' (off 1 1 / Goo4w9z mo,ce Ci,,n;sysed .`.: } 1,�o.1:1...) ax mil , n('or,- sk>p. (� ..c) tdew c. • V,e.,., oC Dc,.ctc Lakes t c+.✓ too 17 c v, t no„ 510pirsr..) drsve Vi e.w o L. 10oc.k. Lc.kt 1R4# -Wwa -P;r51- £Iu.0c ba.".. o to I,sib., a, d?. (,-ia . I(08*'" A.p-c. ".j co— n.rc.y<. Mare t;r.ist.ect 51..•rool. h:e)e.w- el,.nwt,L.1 txk ri..r Cx-1e✓ v... C;replace be i ckL View of Dock Lw1c.t 1 1 2.(o,700 l07 32 6u.,b...,-s4- be. 1yrsV door bakM Nt; J en,4e,,a..... 1-wept...... b.. tC 6 13s.we, {also buck bre.) isi rain • .'. . "" • •i.. '..s I i•'i'atY _ 1C 1 "=l wytl'yrw::N�X,t, s,;'4 .• (O?iZ St.iv.bwrs+ 0r• Mori Cir,,st>eA 51. 1•oolur.)e— . t r,4 ctoor b,.!-tip ..a e4 lerv✓ 1}i�hzr ol..o 1%i l tl l 2(o cw v • 3. \4 v e, have kad e3rea41 d,-C�:e. I L i "N ii3 1 St 11 it ,„ o..r Y.e;r�hborhaod. Ose hart 4,, \owe-v � sold hod +hca� haul Su„b,...sk ,t,9`'\ �Mtlr Pr.c<.S cors:dP^nbL?, ((ditZ has twee.. tFvy '-...-� o rtic„kcA (---- l 1______' {�r.e. a lasA- 3-4- years. , e-n1 w.s s e"ir 9 40,ace, ..^`°lt"' i S,\d ' Qw..W r.a. .t ;v orcgi„� ask: '_a st-v i fu411, y 5*'114.,Cj' 9 ` „5 Owrwr a4`""P}`'9 `, "' y '}"!y, fF 1 6713 lbg+ q.. . - p ev,o.s belu+t a yeo✓ sill C- ° 4115, 00 drePp;„5 �i owdQ.✓ ck op J. (o61Z `7 ^bwrs i rev,e..5 P grp wG $4+ 1.aei • ayr.Q :- Se11c„5 Pr;u pee ti"d at.-e P . sill be< s� yam' hu wc.s "^ -w. u'+i + or.0 Ae�w.:u. new ? "r-.�a.1 ,,.,....- +5• _ , sold 0, 4. n,e rlct+ Ss a+.,d has „o is Co.' Sn\c erol r o_44,5 Q adveoLts� `'�" be,.,..� h d i _ _ owr.w r Per.°ems coe C.IObe a' P -It O��y f1aS NOT �be�.- c b1. -6 e11 -� 1-'a 'Mai 5. too„.. b......... lb4e'J 4.y.c.t mew: 4 • , k tic, . .. . . . ..•.,. :-'' :,. _ .. .• • 1 ln-75-Z sw...�o,....$-E- Dr. - Pre.se..± v�..:.a .- I 4 0. 'P ..AAA-o w-� an+..) 4,.a.Ccs-S S. i.,. :ram: .>I \ 5Ir d lecws . ..- �. w . IIvB"" A Pr©P�r hi L,~� 4� b to l assessed °0 'I Irn �uJQv "`�S sid.w` Wtial,k~t eP(au `owe b„c•k o.."'� d r;yew 21 k `. h sk. .� „Aler,v.. ;� wok Soli) oa • - �ood�ork r� 7ag¢.'e .f (p Eroo) ;s r e' rr1? o' we^ l,1 1 I.:rk.0 4- -si s4.a�l 1OW ci"i`° Gomel:✓,� ,r, bo-44/, - .. _ n0 ctrs� D�.c� Lakr y y.� vice,a ° w;.•d do...^ac u Hw 4 k�d rn • waS .'er.,ovec9 b`1 -n•,y ss bl .'i , 1 04 rood d;-Cfe re-4 '''1� . sae--r tyab t. 4w , 3 w„ dw mt orf` Gob„,... .. aid rep\aca�\o .�r yP1... i Wow\d 2 :tfie•tuF•Eli,�3, a i t m F,�:a±d731 Appeal No. PID # 26-116-22 24 0066 Date Received 41 _Iyo Appraiser Dean Jacobs APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEWa.` (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: /7/' Work: Y 6 Lz Name: 'T/CQCn Senk;�S Address of Property: 1 Z210 P d,m,1 Or, e le . January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: E ((Z e o o Date property was acquired: 1183 Purchase Price: $ Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: Cost of additions and alteration 1? o� Is property listed for sale? 0 If-yes, at what price E•�� (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 4/8 j'o oa What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): AOGV.4,-s rieemit4444 "�"� igteX. , doo /� ;tinz tAiv �`� c :nrff.t. e-lrjy.244d- 1g re of wner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 0-mo0 75sc00 //moo 1/2/88 1/2/87 ao70o 1700 /0.7q Oo Last Inspection: 1/b/$1 Appraiser: Oea& SwcobS Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments r_1 j C J $ /033 Wp /_ 29 r(1._v $ R 630 wp ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. $7 PID # 25-116-22 33 0016 Date Received I-Ha 19 O Appraiser APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: `/4#-A 3i Z Work: 667-01,AName: /1A2L -E. brE Address of Property: 1,'i /o M£4rCC kANG 2 . January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 1 83 Loao Date property was acquired: 3 4 J$9 Purchase Price: $_ I9:4' co©o Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: 1/ON S- Cost of additions and alterations: — d — Is property listed for sale? II If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 17 Z What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): �f Alrt1� (3i3O r j- 2 BT A-N'$> (}ek S i b2 /( Al 1.0 v L C44i!,!i-kA-Pi-f Le*-A-et s E s u xLr T ./ S-L 44 I.be,? N rs d f►s C.rz An"Y- Sign u jre o ner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Pro ert Class. 1/2/£9 34300 l3% OO 17��100 1/2/88 3a300 l30 oc ib 1O(, 1/2/87 3 O > > I a O0 Last Inspection: L is $9 Appraiser: Sohrrrr�s Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: e S IisS A,,Tuo. /.uP..Qa.h-.l . erva ..7c1Az c fv, Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments / $ Sold -Dice. —bo+t. -144,4$ _/_/_ $ se 04 rs l bv-j a✓s u7Q,r`C. NeIc4ect ****,r,r,r,r****,nr,r,r,nr,r,r,►,***********,r,►,t,t,t,t,►,►,nr,►,t****,t,►,►,nr,►,t,nr,t,r,r,r,t****,►*********ter Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. .Ss�� Oate Received 44- eiO PION 25-1• 16-22 41 0024 Appraiser Dean Jacobs APPLICATION FORM 1990 EOEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: `/ply— S'/ - n d Work: Name: -7Terr^y / art9 tS2, n M Address of Property: -/n (n Gti I-1o,c l L January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 1M c c 0 Oate property was acquired: l q 7,3 Purchase Price: $ Tlf 230,2 Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: /},, r c t Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? A) 0 ' If yes, at what price $ 0 (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 4')3 a a c What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): )11 1 h-P �'1 e.a C e S i✓1 h C 0.+'C'.o�.. {lc�-✓Q $n/A 1� �>� /�.0 d, i e I!(o 6.,„I:,� l�„. ° '7 3( /3,._110 _ Th�r� ;S c�t'S ine s in +'hQ_ U s ene_ seS ;� �-e c.re�. 4-1L-1-ed sL `� , o« Signatufe of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To he completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 /oo oo /331Oo 14> 1/2/88 3/a00 c1bQO id8SSC0 K 1/2/87 3cce0 / 37O Last Inspection: til(c/$t; Appraiser: a& 3acbias Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 3/_h,f cKJ $ 8a395 w� / / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: qq/g 4,2 'lay oo ,, ja.3 ooa =-1 3 �-.,,v-. "e /33 ?a qq 7(c a,n+.c� p�2r S�'t-� 9 c1� + Ii L Appeal No. /)711. 2, �rJe �Oad( Date Received 4{12.(10 Appraiser ,1-0 . Su S • APPLICATION FORM PIO # 23-116-22 44 0003 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARO OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: y999-9 3 3$ Work: 31-1-8 351-5. Name: FRANC + .To /9-,vti _/)txd N Address of Property: //.2 0yi Movitir C u c'y,E 40/16 January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: 4400,O+JO. Date property was acquired: ,4ue, //B9 Purchase Price: $ ,300,000 Terms of Purchase: ('4SH Additions and alterations since purchase: LJubSCAf'/iu6/ /�ErA//vwct; wgiL GurrERS 4U�.. XTE/2/VQ 9/N iA/6 DX ir/4,J(,,ac.f? teJigiz—cc t- Cost of add(tions and alterations: 4V/6"--,t-0t7: C', er-74r//1/6• Is property listed for sale? If yes, at what price S (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: S 3 5 U c)U0 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): C// i (7 '�7Grlrl.-��GrK-rr1.�' -C�G�r @!' .-e 79Lc 1YL.�L6.4,-7Cr 9�i,LCQ,rII'�ek.),/ . W... l ,0,97a5,IQ.4..-!K4Zeko (244. cr-e ]ct Z 990..,-?4,- ^., L-t r/0r�,c3zJV. iL �CF- Scr��,yemez.G-440 44'2-6 i2.L.r �� i�v �� �./zJT/CZ-K. c :.r,G /9//9n��ta v�z�722r-Cr- a L O-rt Q tG�let116), .Lou CZ-K. a-d Gc et./.tt t—o O•}.l.0 eo. 6sEE 4,70,E0) Signature of Owner Please note: This forth requests private or confidential data 7o applicanntt which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assesso and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 115000 i0540�0 Lf?0,i00 R� 1/2/88 '79500 _ 4:0 E00 341I300 tK2 1/2/87 -7S0oO ?'#7000 39 CcXD Last Inspection: (p/2j/1$ Appraiser: ZSphh, 52.w,,.5 Bulding Permits/Appraiser Comments: G.-# -- x crg- a-2[-- ✓�D Y�� >n2 t. .inn GLa�A •ct . .a. s, Ga.Ce -4- C A A ,*C.147. 0-XLC"»_ Sale History Oate Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 9/23 $30o00o L O q.S i ii/a/gs cP $3aKq 00 W 10 Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: . . --1-1-1.--7—r • " •L ' Ir• _I ' il ii : Z-1-- I-- i.A''''''{ 1 h I ' ' } t 4. i-.7 t -1. I •• 7 t t- i 1 : 1 1 1 _I i 1 . • ! . 1 , * 1 ! 1r- , , ... , r , : . .1 I. , : k-, T t• iv.o.- -i .1-1 - , . ; .., : ---7--- .-t----: , • , i , , I ,, ,› , , . ! i i , ti i ii ', I, , i 4 • i. ,, ' f, , 4, ' -!:- t r: ', '1.-- 7- 1-•-r-: 1- i—T-7-7 • .ki,itt _.., . 1 -•1. ' i 1 . ,_ .,. _, .. 1 , • ; . . ; : ; •.,_ i , , • I ';'' ' "")s-zr"i -r- 4 -' 7 ' ' ! ', ' ! ; 14 1 1 ,C , 1 , . -i- t , 4 4 t r t- -i- t—i—i- . , : 1 .: .: i , ; •, i , i i .: • I_ „_ , , , , :. 4 4. ,. 4 . , t • 1 --4 ' ' • ' • • • : ! , 1 ! •! , ,1 : . • . ' , t: I ,..)_':,.. ';--IL" L. 1 4 ----7----1(7)/-i. '--/ --L---1-7' --,-77: , . , t :; • ' ii , ! tr.. ; . .1.z...... ; i i , . . 1 •-•* - . , 4 - ; ''• --- - 3-4---i -[ ' -4 4 t 1 • /--- 1 .v.,__Tv,4 1 .. f i 1 1 I ! Li "t tril ' I • • . 4 ;_ ;. ,J 4- . •,- , ',. ---, r-4- 4- t 4- '- i ; , • , ' . , --- 4 4 ! • ', . ! ; -! : 1 -f- j---7- 1---1-- i , '-+---/ -1—, — _ • :•. '. ! ' ll ! ' Iiiii i 1 ! i-• 4-: l!' -I ' ' -, -;- ; '• -; -7 •41--.t --- ? --t-----t---1"-'.4- ±-----i- i ! I 1 •'', i I, ; ' • •'• •': ! ', '- ' !Vil 1 I i _*r' '• ! '• 'VI ! , , • , , ', . ' i 77Z7-4 -1- --I t- .,.,t .1--.t---t---rts)-1 I ._(,,: ., ., , , :. ; ',. , , : : : ,101 , '.. , i •.,1-r•••.': ".. I i., 1,'.. ir nv I 1 , ' : : -i- i : ' , : , , 4 - '•,- -,- ', -1,- i ---..:. -1.. --;--.74-,,,,,,-f---1"---4/4--,.----t--—.1 • - ', 1 1 1 1 1 1 i i , 1 : 11, 1(111 ._ '1 _II, - ' : t t • , , . 7 ' : . I- 7 l• 1 , -1-.4.-17-1..1,1 -4,---r--' , ; ;0.!.. ; ; 1__....4:,, ,'' '; _4 _4.,k... t• ..____ _4____ii ,____I____.; . . : ',k j" ', ! 1`,S,: I; ' ! )•I IQ ;..4 ' 1 I i • • . • • Pq N.) I 1 1 ; - ; • - : ,5.4 4 4- .-.10Q-1 4—--1,1 i T_ ' g . . - , • - - -, : : : 4- .., -4- -ft. i- '. .•, ---t. - , i: , 1 ; • , • , ! : . . 1 ,_ . ,„ 4 _•4 •_, .4• -4- -,-- , : '- - ' • , . . . . . . . . . . : • • la' ! .• 4 ' ' ' ; t-- 24 ' -I- t- - : •t- 4 . ,. -°c -.(-5', i- '7,_ i I DO ' .' 7- ." --7 , 771- , 7-7- 17-77-‘ 1 -r- -1----1-7-r7 • I j ' 1 '. ' ', • i 4. ' --t- 4- -4•-----4- .1 , • , IT ' , ,, i .- 2, , ' 1 1 , ' : -•r- -1 1 111. -1 '' ',--- 1 • 1 , L_ . , _1_ 1 _i___I • 14 44r-"tt 1- 1-- , ,-- • , , i ,• Iiii, ;---4 -i, --1-- _i_ ,_ , --+-1 1 T ---t---'----:, , . —7- . . . . t t : r ; : --'.--7, 1- --i ,---1----1•••-t---/-----, 1-", :1 i • , , 1 i: , .: „ ;• 1 I , . i -. ,.. • c .., :. ,_ ,. , , ;_ .. 4,- - - -,r- f-r.--j--• ' 1---+-13,4---4 --'----r (. ' . tt i 4 t 4 -44-44**rtt ' i 94.1 . t ., A ; 4 i Ts.- 1 • It- i ,, 4., -,, , -t- -4,- •- I -, , • 1 I ' t , i , , , • , , ,, , t , , , ,.. t 1 ,. • ° . ,' - -' 4- •-t -4---------- -I- ' 1 . , ! : • • , I. I ', , . . , _ . . , „ t— i ‘ ' *- j- . 1,-- -4— 4 -4-- A •i•- 1, i•-- ':. , • i i : ••• : —!: , i i P,,, ,, ',. ; : , ' •,• , 4. • •_.!_ ,- ! • • -4 -4 --,.----,IS-'! --+ -i------•-: . , . i : "'. 7 i.-' : -', ..- ' .-t-- -!:- •t.- .:- ; .-.. ' F.,.,.;k1 in7.174..f...-b•7. . . --.—.....—.........—.............—”,, . •,-----,--,-.. ., Appeal No. ‘i PID # 24-116-22 32 0009 Date Received yJ .Iq0 Appraiser Jnhn Sams APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (/)} (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: �1ci1-I1;2 5 —� Work: (`3'7. 1,".,,i l Name: LC ait- ` rCati1 e i,(ti) 1.050 n Address of Property: (f I'�)t i !"�1-1 1'V(}I) 6r(J e• January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears od the notice: $ 2--) -4o‘' Date property was acquired: J(i Y( Purchase Price: $ rv'r. bt.<<It t,, F (t:.,it i 1 Uuu-, Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: iC ( /ti LI / �(1 11..1_ J J l�Ii /Ir '(,' '! t '•)tiVi, Iwo )11 / / i.' (1lll::.l•.in i1(— I(Iill Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? /,_1 �) If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $-j0 J6,0 0i) What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): // L5 C%f 1.41. (-/ t) I/L-�.', I Y,;( f/u.P JLi ) 1 _�t j�� 'Z}i �y ffffff�l�� �/ Vi� f' ��� .ii P. i; t. (l Siglature of Dwner V Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 h.i3pp r ca:o(' a035OO 1/2/8B l�.}�o000 t56gc0 194e4100 QR,� 1/2/87 .7."-tiC.i7 t4a CO J5<141v0 K C Or•ta! ; Last Inspection: 3/L/15/ Appraiser: t.er,.w L,se.!l Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: 1,..k.o, .4r,,:.6 ce, r,;,c ,-6. -"t .r:..l.:_f ."'1,. 'c, Jeri w+ .t r- rt1.C. 1-t,,.4c.ett.n1-c .,Y",.f i l."P.1,-(-IC L�.PS,4CC ,7-4,r 4v.c.s.e..4C L7"4-4 . 1,, :ris-.-. .y;:::6.f.. eJ 1-17. ,.C.Cr 4f'1'] ('IQD• Sale History ,. Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments / $ 1 / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Qdu April 5, 1990 Mr. John Sams City of Eden Prairie 7600 Executive Drive Eden Prairie, MN 55344 Dear John, After considering the new market value for 1990 on our property at 9170 Flyway Circle, I still feel that $217,800 is too high. Therefore, I submitted the application form to have the Board of Review (City Council) consider $205,000 as a more reasonable market value. Attached is my analysis of the homes in my neighborhood that have the same lot value since they face Neill Lake. I think comparing gross square feet on the homes is a uniform way to look at the home especially since this is what a realtor would do. In any event, you can see that by this analysis, the market value on our home appears considerably higher than the larger homes which certainly would bear a higher sales price if they were put on the market for sale. Please reconsider this request to lower the market value to $205,000. Give me a call either at work (937-2291) or at home (941-1127). Sincerely, Kathi Johnson April 9, 1990 Property: 9170 Flyway Circle Request: To lower Market Value from $217,800 to $205,000 Previous Market Values: 1986 $148,500 1987 $181,900 Family room added/basement finished 1988 $204,300 lowered to $196,900 by City Council 1989 $203,500 1990 $225,400 revised to $217,800 on 3/30/90 Comparison to houses in our block on the same side facing Neill Lake: Gross Sq. 1990 Address Feet Mkt Value $/Sq. Ft. 9130 Flyway Circle 2007 162,500 80.96 9140 Flyway Circle 2448 216,600 88.48 9150 Flyway Circle 2466 216,000 87.59 9160 Flyway Circle 3196 220,500 68.99 9180 Flyway.Circle 2646 237,600 89.79 9185 Flyway Circle 2074 162,000 78.11 My Home: 9170 Flyway Circle 2102 217,800 103.61 Changing the market value to $205,000 would equal $97.52/sq. ft. -- A number still considerably higher than the neighboring homes on the same side of the street. I t 1 Appeal No. Date Received y .)5/0 PID # 35-116-22 22 0009 Appraiser Dean Jacobs APPLICATION FORM 1990 EOEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 9�// v 9�6 �'^ Work: 4'93-J/d'b Name: ©hu�� JPN/ Address of Property: /Q,2.7 C.0/ e% P/o Z� January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ ylPfl 0D Date property was acquired: ,S'Q 7, Purchase Price: $ Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: JP ekea40,1j Rona Dei 1 Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? If If yes, at what price $ X (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ ? ?'12�IU What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above statedvalue? (Please attach supporting information): gki ATAA-. 4411e- itleArh.4..)c" flp Iry ,, hk (!� Uit2 et -`'9SX)€V qA.6.. /. /441, S gnature of caner / i Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Oepartment) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 a7-6-C75 1 OQ ggq00 1/2/B8 y�00 0 9,5300 1/2/87 23500 S SOO S.PODO Q Last Inspection: is/L/S.IS Appraiser: ptkA, Z$.i.o{u Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments /3.I - cla WO / / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. 63 Date Received i '4/a/40 PID # 24-116-22 33 0005 Appraiser John Sams APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW f (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 941-3116 Work: 141-393Z Name: t4(0414 S.f SiZ Pc.Ae !, SEGikl Address of Property: 1wto2 N1o,1ntT C.aVe Wtjj January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $411D0 o Date property was acquired:NM O981 Purchase Price: $ Terms of Purchase: cASW Additions and alterations since purchase: ca sTtz•.1c-rbh jrYN Cost of additions and alteratiops:t24g o00 Is property listed for sale? AO If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ ,525— What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? �(1Please attach supporting information): I.4p�" L -H IEss 4Acuu viElYliLbAs on €i.Ek side be-ratisf c j J in:�r-us&cy) fit 2 OulnEI-S ?fitfully U/ht (E 1t sd hOMES Or, ffils Sifrc c 'fiaLISerC deli .1 ber-CLLLSE. CJFrent altar *alkyls cud vt'1Ydtd pol y a.sc€ssinv4s .Y`' �i .. 1,0cry?I liki/"t ' cQ C6 1vvr1CA Ff Ard •teye jfg kas- 41 I kcpss&I ( �C l! . �"iv* ture of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Pro erty Class. 1/2/89 11500 ag6000 1-111000 1/2/88 00 ab8000 ,363000 1/2/87 sy00p — 51000 L. Last Inspection: I/ry_tz Appraiser: ZSOhk, 3a* Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: T.A4 on -V>dA..e ,.ato00,44/ a# 4411,000 cctk•i.) {A u Q_ bCa N- . I I Igo .uz+Q •i. Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments $1 Oa v $ 58500 tJ o Sale ,s {o r l o4 o r 1 y Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: t Appeal No. PID # 09-116-22 23 0036 Date Received q ;. p Appraiser Earl Zent �a ,# APPLICATION FORM ��� S 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 934-48�( Work: 43A-O(S n Name: JJME5 A,. KAUFAAA l Address of Property: Ong $1 , January 2, 1990 valuat on as it appears on the notice: $ 143 { ,0•3 Date property was acquired: 3—(,A Purchase Price: $ td fbo.*9 Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: pot t.t giiip )y e•17 ) $1edr ck in �ri.i t 0 Cost of additions and alteration / oo^_ Is property listed for sale? MD I yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ /3 7 5 b D 3 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated/value? (Please attach supporting information): e;,.<l (7 ,7 ,11 ',JIi6 F11%a .ri‘14. L/,C'j,r ,,-,'� `:w`'L/C1/d.i/"'. l f yf/,1 j!if G?�,.. �4Lf. : G iil/1/1>i;.) i r t'%1,1/ 1?`// . /l()i 1 + l f?,G ).,41. ;18: , isL1.`4 ilJE1 qdtii .ci/,,. 4!✓r %/ e „-,� 1J Jtt-LL.,�.Otrr )/a.!/ '..AftettZ tilt,"I a,c).-.Y.4.,,,,i.:/./f !,;,i..(..cl 1/474'L.. M Signature of Ow er • Please note: This form rlequests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 ,3'7 1(100 /3690O l: 1/2/88 oOO 973cso /35300 Gpar4r0.1 1/2/87 Q?(v•.a �3S0o H$$5.Saaqq K tfhr{rai Last Inspection: [L/ /.; Appraiser: fi 2r) e.�-(—' Building Permits/Appraiser Convents: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Convents 7Ti/fie c.J la$ �oy3 tvo 4'70 / / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. S PID # 03-116-22 11 0002 Date Received 1 0 Appraiser John tams APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW /i i/ / a(To be completed by owner - please int) Telephone Home: / /7-(O LW v Work: Name:..D0A/17 /C 4j1 w VA/9 /41) Address of Property: No Address - Vacant Land January 2, 1990 valuation as i ears on the notice: $ 3 5-DO 0 Date property was acquired: /7 Purchase Price: $ /75 6 D 0 Terms of Purchase: G0Ai ) flC-r Additions and alterations since purchase: 30 FT, 24-I9li/4t/OA/ G,toE iS i 4J FIIN/N4 gLd C/rl#i OWA/�/� Cos tt of aditions and alterati ns: �}�7yp/ Is property listed for sale? 0 If yes, at what price $¢r 1__. (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): l�E.Dei- 144,a/e- 6/,/c .J4vT ,,«ocvzo' &4,/„/cL of ,may h`6,' e' DO (u//d gpp/tok 1wI? 3D1A,tAAS f/t'rn PAe, i 7L;,(,r- . _ 5 FOKCCD Ta >3A y ca rArig prz./.r- wHir� k iti1E IC ,A5 I'5 /4,6 T., D,suG/Dren s, • 5) Pnofel:1 fLoo1) $*2-7ICWi3D' c/MP6 n i 6 ELEIrAfi oti r1iT. © alt, 5,raa - i Az),•orps GDmrfie b ?A ��jn *vaop Com fl cr4/ fZATK /ze d44ue9 Ar.pf7:a''/ gna r�• of I,rr Please note: This form requests private or confidential data .f applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. . (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 77 7oO — 77N100 1- 1/2/88 70400 -- 10400 L 1/2/87 ing0O0 -- E mac Last Inspection: £/(D/$g Appraiser: ZSDNr. Saw►S Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments ;' +a30/157-6-1p 173-i-0 4.0 / / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: rtM1 Appeal No. 64, PID # 03-116-22 22 0022 Date Received 4! ..iq O Appraiser Steven Sinell APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: Work: 7377.107 Name: /1/oArfr r✓4.,s42 4441r — Address of Property: Vacant Land - No Address January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ Date property was acquired: 0,01,0,,,E Purchase Price: $ Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: Cost of additions and alterations: ne+-C Is property listed for sale? no If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): L..•/ .v --440-'-4", o•.. -...,,L,..-6,NUZAN.a ow a 1�..O.o.,✓,a,I444.2' 4..4.4 11.. a. 7v av1-#. .. i'h , rP -.^ no p'nlX" ' '- Si gnatur of Ow er 7 Please note: This forii requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 81000 - 81000 Vacant Land 1/2/88 57500 - 57500 Vacant land 1/2/87 44 Last Inspection: 1/-/gg Sq Appraiser: Sir . Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments �_ - / %% $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. PID # 03-116-22 22 0019 Date Received N i iqO Appraiser Steve Sinell APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone HomWore: y3 7 730 7 Name: WO'ZTHat/ooD GAS Gc. Address of Property: Vacant Land - No Address D3-116-22 22 0019 January 2, 199D valuation as it appears on the notice: $ &a a Date property was acquired: //nw'iew, Purchase Price: S Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: "'owe. Cost of additions and alterations: 4 o4 e Is property listed for sale? n o If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 199D is: $ 8-0 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): L=a-f Signature f Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 800 - 800 Vacant Land 1/2/88 800 - 800 Vacant Land 1/2/87 700 - 700 Vacant Land Last Inspection: A/A1.8iS Appraiser: SFev2 Sire// Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments / / Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. 68 PID # 03-116-22 22 0021 Date Received 11I7.I90 Appraiser Steve Sinell APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: Work: y97-A34 7 Name: 4/OR 1/.w'OO 9 GAS �G Address of Property: 6380 Industrial Drive January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ r0 7,/e c Date property was acquired: vd,Croan Purchase Price: $ Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: ',zone, Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? no If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 79 Bod What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): QO.22 4 L 044, y ,44., c c� ,Q, wacw ate_ - 4- Signature of wner Please note: This form 'requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 74000 28000 102000 Industrial I/2/88 54700 76000 Industrial 1/2/87 511D1 21300 72400 Industrial Last Inspection: j/Z/ Appraiser: <4-20� Si.v I! Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. 7 . Date Received a f s 190 PIO # 23-1I6-22 43 0017 Appraiser John Sams APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW pp (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: "ty 040 (� y Work: �1 Name: Lv Aar 4.01 1 t �(1 Address of Property: I t bi�a, ry T CttA,Q� 1.6,A January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 34-7 S6D Date property was acquired: ° AQjl Purchase Price: $ 494,000 Terms of Purchase: Isr nwitT6t+6P___ Additions and alterations since purchase: tutenk7471A\ LOOP._ I/NkoafitFas 4 Cost of additions and alterations: §QCXO Is property listed for sale? 'f If yes, at what price $ (WO (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 3aAtq',(b What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): Signature of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 10.50F0 a o 3�f7500 1/2/8B '7g500 a37 00 31b4OO 1/2/87 15000 .ao144000 a44000 R Last Inspection: 1./1_/ Appraiser: -4-e ,,u .a-a,..p- Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments C.Er $ 3ag900 wA VW) / / $ ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. -7 3 Date Received yla 190 PID # 26-116-22 44 0044 Appraiser 3.S. APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: q44-‘6,B8 Work: 944-c 4qq Name: 1...M-Gcii G401.IS1-• (QC. Address of Property: JG()(DL} iu e&ATDe./ OAI t-0T 4 Bug January 2, 1990 valuation as ikk appears on the notice: $ 000 Date property was acquired: A Purchase Price: $ 007?-1 Terms of Purchase: C 4tlG�JT , kat 0Iz6A Additions and alterations since purchase: t0J,)E_ Cost of additions and alterations:/ 10 04E_ 1/ Is property listed for sale? V If yes, at what price $ L1bq(g0() (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: LIN q Qa©OO What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): u.ST QuA c S 'O LOTS ! �,L�t�STF�'� S�'` JT3 &IV 4 u- L. O B L 04“. t C&kE 4_40L-LC qnk_ k)oT V;P4 fcl 11-TIAro O9t_(tb 16 4)4 lbiAG tae-AL-b buct.oLU Signature of Own Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 APo0 _ L 1/2/88 aaoo — aaco A 1/2/87 1414 NO} Last Inspection: ► /i&L/5.0 Appraiser: Buildin Permits/Appraiser Comments: o - �L 4 X (@ }+ • an 4(t 14Q .L�+.� Aa4 it .Fes $y64 1 efit v Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments / / / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. 77 PID # 25-116-22 21 0019 Date Received 4/2/1990 Appraiser John Sams APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 612 - 944 - 2009 Work: 612 - 942 - 5335 Name: Boyd T. and Jean Jones Address of Property: 9424 Clubhouse Road January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 133.900 Date property was acquired: N/A Purchase Price: $ N/A Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: None Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? yes If yes, at what price $ 179,900 (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 129,900 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): Unequal Assessment - Land Economic obsolescence due to large size of duplex in comparison to others. No offers to date. (Agent for Owner) Sign n lure o Owner Thomas J. Schwartz Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 37000 96900 133900 RZ 1/2/88 37000 121400 15840Q RZ 1/2/37 28900 105000 133900 R7 _ Last Inspection: 11/10/87 Appraiser: John Sams Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: The 1989 value was set at $133,900 by the Eden Prairie Board of Review. The 1990 value is the same. Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 9 /9 / 77 CRV $ 245070 WD Sale if for hoth Pin's _%_% $ 25-116-22 21 0018 & 25-116-22 21 0019 ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: I Minnesota Property Consultants,Inc. P • Property Tax Reduction C �\ CONSULTANT • AGENCY AGREEMENT PROPERTY OWNER/LESSEE �Q 1 K4/A/f-// fad et / / PROPERTY ADDRESS /p y�� 3ORG. S Iy/ p/� /7e1y C`4bl 44j, TOWNSHIP S P(zriht2 / mit) 51s.5 cl/ COUNTY 71-f-hm‘ttr+ P.I.N. 3G IIL/aal-)a�-000� p P.I.N. Zs �/b" 72 - Zl — 0Q J O _ G. 25 ^//( - L7i L/ —co/ (� — 9yzy� • P.I.N. ,,.p I/We, R� ,4 J o t J , agree with "M.P.C., Inc. for the real estate assessment year QCi 9 Cf D , and for the year/s remaining in the present quadrennial period (1951 and 19 q l✓), in I.IGN'p,pjh County, Minnesota, as to the property referred to above, that prdparation of a real estate assessment appeal of the undersigned to the Local Board of Review, as well as to the State of Minnesota Property Tax Appeal Board. The undersigned authorizes "M.P.C., Inc." to obtain an appraisal or appraisals of Market Value for the property referred to above, for the year stated as the tax year in question. Unless otherwise indicated the cost of this appraisal will be paid for by "M.P.C., Inc.". The undersigned further authorizes "M.P.C., Inc.", as agent of the under- signed, to execute and cause to be filed on-behaif'of the undersigned, in the name of the undersigned, any and all document relating to an appeal of the said assessments, for the assessment year 19 (f/) and the remaining year/s of the quadrennial period referred to above, before the Local Board of Review as well as the State of Minnesota Property Tax Appeal Board where permitted. If the services of an attorney at law are required, in connection with any appeal referred to herein the undersigned will choose and engage such attorney, at the cost of the undersigned; in which event "M.P.C., Inc." will co-operate with said attorney in the furtherance of such appeal. "M.P.G., Inc." for its services are separate and distinct from any fees payable by the undersigned to any attorney at law engaged by the undersigned. Agreed: • 1 &wner/ (Strike the inappropriate designation) Date Approved: "M.P.G., Inc.' By 7333 ANN COURT • EDEN PRAIRIE, MN 55346 • (612) 942-5335 Appeal No. 78 PID k 25 116 22 21 0018 Date Received 4/2/1990 Appraiser John Sams APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 612 - 944 - 2009 Work: 612 - 942 - 5335 Name: Boyd T. and Jean Jones Address of Property: 9416 Clubhouse Road January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 165.000 Date property was acquired: N/A Purchase Price: $ N/A Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: None Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? Yes If yes, at what price $ 235,000 (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 161,000 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): Unequal Assessment - Land Economic obsolescence due tc large size of duplex in comparison to others. No offers to date. gent for owner) Signature416/(ner J. Schwartz Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1T2/89 37000 128000 165000 RZ 1/2/88 37000 134400 - 171400 R7 1/2/87 28900 150000 178900 RZ Last Inspection: 11 /10' 87 Appraiser: John Sams Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: The I989 value was set at S165.000 by the Eden Prairie Board of Review. The 1990 value is the same Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 9 /9 / 77 CRV $ 245070 WD for both PID's 25-116-22 21 0018 & / 1 $ 25-116-22 21 0019 Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: M P / Minnesota Property Consultants,Inc. • Property Tax Reduction s CONSULTANT • AGENCYQ AGREEMENT PROPERTY OWNER/LESSEE Q0 /�/'/J fail Y. /'/ PROPERTY ADDRESS /(/7 �/ 3/N)`7' /2 igc( � ' 9/ i Ct/45/7Vu �ICG TOt,'NSHIP ti 'VGiV)te / mn) COUNTY lit AK? •".P.I.N. 3(.-1),-?a/-ai-OOO , P.I.N. ZS //4- Z? 'Z/ — QQ ) 0 yY/(.. P.I.N. 25 "//( - L2,�/ L/�o—oo/ `( — 9q2 y' • I/We, �2�. -dove' , agree with "M.P.C., Inc. for the real estate assessment year 9 q U andm for the year/s retraining in • a the present quadrennial period (195' and 19 {✓), in 1,k,H a pLp its County, Minnesota, as to the property referred to above, that prdparation of a real estate assessment appeal of the undersigned to the Local Board of Review, as well as to the State of Minnesota Property Tax Appeal Board. • The undersigned authorizes "M.P.C., Inc." to obtain an appraisal or appraisals of Market Value for the property referred to 'above, for the year stated as the tax year in question. Unless otherwise indicated the cost of this appraisal will be paid for by "M.P.C., Inc.". The undersigned further authorizes "M.P.C., Inc.", as agent of the under- signed, to execute and cause to be filed on-behalf of the undersigned, in the name of the undersigned, any and all documents relating to an appeal of the said assessments, for the assessment year 19 and the remaining year/s of the quadrennial period referred to above, before the Local Board of Review as well as the State of Minnesota Property Tax Appeal Board where permitted. If the services of an attorney at law are required, in connection with any appeal referred to herein the undersigned will choose and engage such attorney, • at the cost of the undersigned; in which event "M.P.C., Inc." will co-operate with said attorney in the furtherance of such appeal. "M.P.C., Inc." for its services are separate and distinct from any fees payable by the undersigned to any attorney at law engaged by the undersigned. Agreed: i—/ -9a Ywnec/.Fge,tt/LeSa (Strike the inappropriate designation) Date Approved: "M.P.C., Inc.' By 7333 ANN COURT • EDEN PRAIRIE, MN 55346 • (612) 942-5335 Appeal No. 79 PID # 02-116-22 34 0003 Date Received 4/2/1990 Appraiser John Sams APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner please print) Telephone Home: Co/Z-8)-9—1 Name: /Qot/ el/oa/ (GiC(y/y ISMe��n Work: (��z-9y' S33S Address of Property: wPP/ 8e'Reln X06 January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 449300 Date property was acquired: ? -i , Purchase Price: $ 3 7o,000 Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? NO If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement 3 G Q� Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ / What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): (11 et uo/ sr Menem f ftN:1 40VW / q1r:[ ,4 Chill Sig atur o Own Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/69 112600 3U98UU 422400 R 1/2/B8 10240U 281/00 384100 R 1/2/B7 98300 - 260800 359100 R Last Inspection: 10'4/89 Appraiser: John Sams Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 214/B6 CRV $ 370000 WD 10.625% / / $ ****•*•********************•*******•****•***•********************************** Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Minnesota Property Consultants,Inc. CProperty Tax Reduction April 11, 1990 City of Eden Prairie Assessor's Office 7600 Executive Drive Eden Prairie, MN 55344-3677 ATTN: Mr. Steve Sinell Dear Mr. Sinell: Enclosed please find a revised "Application Form - 1990 Eden Prairie Board of Review" for the property located at 6881 Beach Road, PIN 02-116-22-34-0003. After further research and review, we have concluded an estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 of $396,000. Supporting evidence is attached. We would be happy to settle this matter prior to the Board of Review. If the indicated value is not acceptable to you, then we wish to appear before the Board of Review. Thank you for your prompt attention to this matter. Sincerely your , Thomas . Schwartz Enclosure 'i. 7333 ANN COURT • EDEN PRAIRIE, MN 55346 • (612)942-5335 2 SUMMARY OF SALIENT FACTS AND CONCLUSIONS Purpose of Appraisal: Market Value Property Rights Appraised: Fee Simple Ownership: Rolf s Carolyn Bjelland Location of Property: 6881 Beach Road Eden Prairie, MN Date of Valuation: January 2, 1990 Type of Property: Residential Building Size: 3,054 square feet Site Value: $ 160,000 Value Indications by: Market Approach $ 387,000 Income Approach $ 403,000 Market Value Conclusion: January 2, 1990 - $396,000 J1 r.w�"'�'" "M'^ """".e:;— `v�H..,. .. +Wry-•�+� START oF The images appearing between this point and the End of Retake target are true, accurate, and complete copies of records that previously were not filmed or were filmed incorrectly. • ` ._ sue..-.v,• M I •.l�;'? , •`A :r. t `.J �Ai .�t ^ a. ti' N. • �• ' Wf •;ele : _...... . 'CJ. t� L I. END OF RETAKE 'I 3 {{``I[N t • - - '0 I L O V Cr. cJ1 A W N r 7'6 0 a c* I 1" ' 0 I rt I 0 O O O O O O O O O O N N I NNNNNNNNN I 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 B I 01 I 01 7 01 7 7 QI 01 01 +7'' •p N I I I I I I I I I i N I N N N N N N N N N 2 0 N NNNNNNNNN '. 7 I IIIIIIIIII I W N W W W NW W W W N A I W WNW W N N N A M I 1 1 1 1 t 1 1 1 1 O O O O O O O O O O° Wt O N °0 °0 °0 O O O O 7 I 3 I 7 7 7 7 037 CO• i S .-N N N 0 0 01 7 t0 0. m I O W W N 7 N A CO 0 a M 1 .. O OCO COm11 Obi ' Pt 0CD m CD CD 0 0 N W f 0 N O i 0 IL N d 0 0 0 0 0 7 17 0 0 7 7 7 7 7 7 3 77 a 1 m �'• n n m d m d ID I a 0 0 1 a s a a a I+" Y. I I v v v n Y. I J1 CD t0 I 0 !0 0 00 0 tL 0 0 IW 01 OD 7 01 7 CO 7 *,1 -...1 01 fi 07 1 A N !0 1/40 A CO O N N m ' n 1 7 I )3 0 d Ul A N ill CO A 7 W 71 v A I A AN W O A OD O I I N N CO N W " IV "' " ro "'r '. CO I 0 0 ill A O t0 N V W N .-'0 O W O CO W N 7 N O CO 3 a0O w cow C11 0 m A A 7 M 3 O °O °O °O ° p0 0 0O °O ° `° tt I I t * II C • I O V A 0 V .V. A N S37" A I V . O 0 N V N O \ a 0CY. ✓ I 7 O O N '0 V 01 V 0 \ Z ' IV CO 71 0 CO N 01 0 V 71 'D 5 Equity Analysis (continued) As a result of an analysis conducted on the above residential properties, it was found that an inequity exists with the subject property. All the homes utilized are located along Beach Road and Beach Circle. The subject does have an enclosed pool area and the comparable properties do not. Therefore, we will exclude the pool and pool enclosure value, as stated on the property record card, to arrive at an equitable square foot improvement value. Once an equitable value is concluded, the stated pool value will be added. Comparables #3, #4, #6, and #7 are most similar in age, with comparable #7 most similar in relative size. Comparables #1 and #8 are of older construction with comparable #8 similar to the subject in relative size. Comparable #2, #3, #5, and #9 are of newer construction and #2 and #9 are larger than the subject. Comparable #5 and #9, the upper limits of indicated assessed square foot value, are 16 years newer than the subject. One is smaller than the subject (downward adjustment) and one is much larger (upward adjustment). All comparables utilized are similar to the subject in some respect. Based on this analysis, it is concluded a more equitable assessed improvement value for the subject would be $62.00 per square foot. To this value we add the pool and pool enclosure. We have trended up the value of the pool enclosure and pool to account for appreciation (5%/year) since the property record card was completed. Thus, the pool value is derived from: Enclosed Pool 1600 s.f. @ $35.00 = $56,000 Swimming Pool 777 s.f. @ $12.00 = 9,324 Total $65,324 This value of $65,324 has not been depreciated by the 16% factor listed on the property record card. Assuming a current level of 18% for depreciation, our final value for the pool is $53,565, or $53,600 rounded. 3,054 s.f. @ $62.00 per s.f. _ $189,300 (rounded) plus pool enclosure and pool = 53,600 $242,948 or $ 79.55 per s/f Thus, our total value for the property (land value included) is: Land (1990 Assessment) $160,000 Buildings 242.948 $402,948 Say $403,000 • or $131.96 per s/f (land included) { - ' r I ,; P CI A w rJ , 1 et I 1 . O u1 C C O O C C. O N G I N NJ !J 'N 7N 1I IW 1 S VI I P+ P+ P+ a' 0 7 T NiIM 0 I NJ Ni NJ NJ N N N 1. NJ in I NJ NJ N N NJ N N IZ W A A W A A I NJ N 4 1 I I I I O rl- I C w C G p j O I I I 7 N LII UI NJ ^• A O L) O 0 A CO 01 VI i I i O 1 Q` 7 .. 7 r .. Q, O : G al 1 !I Imp I 0) S A J A A 0 71 CD CD N 0) ID 01 ID 0' pI d O I 1 DI 1 14 In 0 I 7 0 0' Q R 7 ?I 1DI A 0 ID +D NO ID 0 A 1 0 DDi I 7; D 1 1 1 • ID t CL I A IC -4 IC IC re I O. O I v I I 1 I d m A ID A A N I 1.4 0. 14 O. O. N rr n I III, a' s I 'OSs CO CO Z CO A IID CO CO OD OD CO ,.0 cf.) ODO I m I ID t. d I NJ \\, \ \ \ S \ -II ? I N O N O — N NJ O Z I 01 7 ,.0 CO OD W Ur 1 W C S CO -ID 0' I , 0 m0 s ,.0 OD O CO O %CI ID O. s I WO I ,NO NJ PW+ NJ N NJ W IN A m - CO A OJ A N n I I I { 01 A VI I N N W N w N W '0 UI A ID A P+ t; ^J U.) O O 1 0' ,O DI ,O I A w al N m O ..•. QID WC 3 O I ,rO N C s C 4 O ID 10 . , O r• I N W O W 0 000 I 1 I i} `0 I • ti I NO I A 1 \ I f0 ‘.0 ‘.0 s ‘.0 s 03 Uil 1 U\1 -� .. IT1 1 4 CJ C CA w W UI 7117 N I f • 7 Market Analysis As a result of the market analysis conducted on the above residential properties, it is clear that an inequity exists with the subject property. With the exception of comparable #1 on Beach Rd., all of the properties are in a nearby neighborhood and are all of new construction (downward adjustment). Although many have lake views, they do not have adjacent lake access (upward adjustment) or swimming pools (upward adjustment). Taking these factors into consideration, it is concluded a more equitable assessed value would be $109 per s/f. To this value we add the pool and pool enclosure value of $53,600. 3,054 s/f x $109/s.f. = $332,886, Say $333,000 $333,000 53,600 $386,600, Say $387,000 Value Indicated by Market Approach • • 8 Reconciliation Value Indicated by Equity Approach $403,000 Value Indicated by Market Approach $387,000 The Equity Approach was used to illustrate the large inequity of the subject property's assessment. Greater weight must be given to market values. Therefore, the final value indicated for the subject property, after all analysis of variances are considered, is $396,000 - 1990 Market Value Thus, we are requesting the total assessment for 6881 Beach Road, PIN 02-116-22-34-0003, be reduced and set at $396,000 for 1990, for taxes payable in 1991. 1 Appeal No. Date Received 4/3/1990 PID / 14-116-22 31 0032 Appraiser Steve Sinell APPLICATION FORM ,.I 199D EDEN PRAIRIE BDARD OF REVIEW /6 "" `L (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: P/-/voa� / Work: ,J -i3�0- Name: C/L/ o 1,--raJ 3f Address of Property: 1ZZJ G- .#,,,I✓b/ trZe. January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ / zo a Date property was acquired; /9(f Purchase Price: $ /do /0,e o Terms of Purchase: /i/af /0,on.re46 J Additions and alterations since purchase: Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? If yes, at what price S (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 199D is: $ /b47e17D What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): �P �w.rrf`JJJJf<� /J� /a? /200.44�Oh�ry /a �ja, /1'i(�AC !" f trele /'�1,00' "ply /VO-�`�A�,s, ,/{.y,c�. 7"%y i. //� ��yv/' i fr, 44z rye Signature f; wner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is • helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 31000 /asoO 1,44000 I/2/88 2/oar /JSZOO I'13800 c-- 1/2/87 o P-3!DO c, • Last Inspection: 1 / Appraiser: f-e0Q S/k,e.ij Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments_ -_ l 0-- kJ() L7'/g';'p / / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. A) PID N 14-116-22 31 0033 Date Received 4/3/1990 Appraiser Steve Sinell_ APPLICATION FORM 199D EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW '`t "I' z (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 41/ /J o Work: S3 ,f Name: / f)C/ Address of Property: 6-2,t7 ,-r'*-i ''K L January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 3" doa Date property was acquired: "if Purchase Price: $ 2 7..op Terms of Purchase: Fi44r 10,.41n-41° 0 q-✓ Additions and alterations since purchase: 4/4 Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 2 Zo 0 0 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information):/ 14,,y, 01,.4 .7 W{�.//i /•rsi/W4d1,7s/e,(�_ /O <..//11 �.. OJu' /J -7/lG ., ,��.�.e. �..��r'of //' -y f„v_i�•. Q`^a•t / 44, �2e.L.✓.eQ Signature fcOw er Please note: This form requests private or confidential -data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 go5OO .144 300 33q 'O0 C. 1/2/88 6000 ablf SOD 33.:)SCr? 1/2/87 640Oo .0.4:41.50Q 3,3?500 C.► Last Inspection: _va/25 Appraiser: S41:047— Si'N2 a) Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments % / / 1 $ *************************t****,t,t,t,t,t,t,t,t,t****,t,t,t,t,t,t,t,t****,t,t********************** Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. Date Received 4/3/1990 PID # 14-116-22 31 0041 Appraiser Steve Sinell APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW /.4 / ` - ` sI (To be completed by owner- please print) Telephone Home: O 3' /oo/ �� Work: 2S- /30+1• Name: ,H d'//� �n • Address of Property: FZZo Cn, 0.,A 711 January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ Date property was acquired: Purchase Price: $ yrf•S000D Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: 44A Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 2.W SS"$ What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): )/f4 .d .44 o//AL - (J.,/ !/u� A Signature -r Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land BuildingTotal Property Class. 1/2/89 i3b s�rr=lcC0 . go 50700 L. 1/2/88 l t'IOC ? r 000 3y%1 CcO 1/2/87 ,;I- Last Inspection: 3/3/If( Appraiser: S l-r vk nQ(i Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments / $ -// $ ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: 11 FiP—.:8— 0 WED t 6 :9 6 t_UR T I P. D TURNER ,_0 I I1C P . 02 • MURPHY,BLANCHAR et ELLIOTT P.A. AT TORNBVn AT LAW 7900 FIRST AVENUE SOUTH BLOOMINGTON,MINNESOTA J5420 JAMES L.MURPHY (612)1181.0342 JON W.BLANCHAR FAX:(612)861.3632 PATRICK H.ELLIOTT* 'Atlo admitted in Anon, March 28, 1990 Mr. Curtis Turner Mr. Orlo Johnson 5270 West 84th Street suite 500 Bloomington, Minnesota 55437 RE: 8220 Commonwealth Drive, Eden Prairie, MN 55344 Dear Gentlemen: Subsequent to our letter of March 22, 1990, we have had an opportunity to further discuss the proposed purchase of the above property. We would make the following proposal in an attempt to consummate a purchase agreement: 1 Total ronzideration for tho property uould bo $287,553.68. We understand that this is the principal balance due and owing the Richfield Bank & Trust Company. We would propose to assume this obligation with financing provided by Richfield Bank & Trust Company on the following terms: a. The loan would be interest only for two (2) years at an annual rate of 9%. This would be paid monthly. At the end of two (2) years' this would become a fixed mortgage with a term of 7A years at 9% interest. 2. The Buyers would pay $25,000 toward any delinquent taxes, penalty and interest at the date of closing. This would include any taken due and payal.la on May 1C, 1990. 3. The Sellers would agree to finance said $25,000 at the same rate of interest paid on the underlying mortgage aecut.ed Ly R1�hfil.l Sauk & Ttual CutWJauy. 'buyer's would agree to put their existing building up for sale and apply up to 50% of the net equity toward the payment of their tax liability. If said sale of their building did not occur or 50% of the net equity realized was not sufficient to repay Sellers the $25,000 then, the Buyers would begin to repay the tax liability existing two (2) years from the date of closing and amortize said amount over three (3) years. 1'IHR.-2.0- !p W C D no . ee Ck_.R T Z +J D T V R.f1C R CO i 14C r . C • 4. The Sellers shall be responsible for any delinquencies in the current mortgage against the premises and also any and all sales commissions. 5. The Richtield Bank a Trust Company would agree to a purchase agreement with the above conditions incorporated therein. Very truly yours, �Jo a,Ar James L. Murphy Patrick H. Elliott Appeal No. 83 Date Received 4/3/1990 PID 25-116-22 22 0020 Appraiser APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: MI - 181-7 Work: 9V,1 -5�''?L Name: .�� 2,(mot_ I`.�1�� Address of Property: Iog3Z. Mo1JJ" COY(L (Lae January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ . If3 Date property was acquir IJ/g5 Purchase Price: $ 31 S Terms of Purchase: 'W — Additions and alterations since purchase: NOt..,617: Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? {J If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 3434,4f150 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): /!20"z Moourcuu.6r 6rt) icciftr tttANt O (sP) 1078z " • (mac sA E)Rtngs- 0601CALS 331°0114) S `t (DLO ) G 1z-it / O1.37 (510 gnature of Owner Please note: This form'requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of revi by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in pr paring for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is t mandatory, 4oriever, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prio ring, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Pro ert Class. 1/2/89 I I�0O a973Or &4 i 3OO 1/2/88 79500 ago40O 34,7g900 1/2/87 co ,74000 34140OO Last Inspection: p Appraiser: Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: • Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments CRv $31' 315 wo erlo ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: 4 Appeal No. $lo Date Received 4/3/1990 PID # 04-116-22 24 0003 Appraiser Barbara Cnnl APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW �1 (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home:93 u r 3I 3 4 Work; Name: -1(Q - L S��-I h S T�- Address of Property:(th35 ICUTrr7-- LAN January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ -743 Lf0 0 Date property was acquired: Vq 57 Purchase Price: $ 1 3.�Sv O Terms of Purchase: o3RIG►NA-4. CXON1_R-(�U1�DC3(� Additions and alterations since purchase: NOt- Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? No If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ CoS,0OO What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): ?c201PtCZNj ov r�-Fwt= `'1 t-\514cCz s o t_D DAP <\NT s Ag-KWr Slow Ft?. ol-p Y}oMGS LAtcr__st-IORC 1 S t NtPPW11-- alp S+}DuLP DEL .TAD F O- Ne\lx, Nct c NvTiC�(IT IS VOW A Sw(w ) gnature of"Owner Please note: This form 'requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completedby_the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 37000 Niyo0 9 oo R 1/2/88 3c1,C0 415'DO 70100 1/2/87 a9YCC 5gc400 (S/3op Last Inspection: -1/4/$2 Appraiser: 6.4,10 (ooK Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: • Appeal No. 1 7 Date Received 4/3/1990 PID N 02-116-22 32 0004 Appraiser John Sams APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 247/-5 9 F z / Work: 3�,3-6: 73 Name: RrcNAA-8 C`. 1. A7-sEsrr,zY Address of Property: lv G S'/ ,'c:.¢cN .4p January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: S.330/ 5410 Date property was acq iced: Ail, ,/f77 Purchase Price: $ /BSOoo Terms of Purchase: UEN77AAL4f.- 1 r? 46 - Additions and alterations since purchase: 5c, .e c/ Anted,. mn/04—eK Cost of additions and alterations: Rr/S a00 Is property listed for sale? A/e If yes, at what price S (attach copy of listing agreeme t Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 2 94;, What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): .5-4 /fat i idle.% a n 4,pra;svr /o ad of oar set l-lc Lthtlac, 4, was eleareo,f.cd /3'7% J,ecrcuse i/oces no?Aoue a - nrsled base,ne4 rreer` t95-6/Arca ' /$'99 da lua4-e++ Increased dy ce.H a.ueraye of 6`'7,151 fieryear, Cl5%n7 Ma-/ a r'e-e-14 accr hemeg fat so..e/1,4 4s slaidrzk- e, T`ie wreiser Tncrea5ad' uuoJaoOrs. by ny's bto_eut 2 et sa k e•C tKpe-ns l rre. ne.th)ho sties `fke rI-e_It asfheoc datuc -tern s l.au(d Le dascda-n our hove t7 di tit; kbvr s I / c.fna�d G CJrt-a..� ` Signature of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Buildin Total Property Class. 1/2/89 I06700 ?i 03OO 1/2/88 47000 J5-9oO aswgoo IZ 1/2/87 g3100 /SeloO(> ii44760 Last Inspection: _/2I/ 3 Appraiser: w Sawc. Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 1/17 C .) $ is 5000 W O ***********,t****r***** **,r,t,t,t,t,t************* ****rtr*****,t,t,********,t,rt******* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. gt PID 4 23-116-22 11 0058 Date Received 4/3/1990 Appraiser fart >p„r APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: -yy .boy? Name: j, Ci./'�tc/ k , 2t},� Address of Property: wf ; January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 77, not, Date property was acquired: au; 'i-1f6 Purchase Price: $ is,o uo•06 Terms of Purchase: (4. t t, Additions and alterations since purchase:/ i -3 ;sk. IrsT.:rs *Close r{l'p•oer.,4 Y•r', C7el 1�:'.:. r�,ow���r•�� an. R ^^.-1c�r. Clew 5(Q;K,p-iv MLW � w�hClou� Cost of additions and alterations: Q Is property listed for sale? If yes, at what price S (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ $5 DOD What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): ; rn��:T -.ter •n � _.-'(c.:?'K',-1L.1 /) /ie1 i'?a;-1^ Ct C,:.(Ce 1/10 Ft ve place mrc rr C C wc.Ter —(Ow.. _oe/I) 14,4,7rY1 "/Yif.n j76Dl Signature•'of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be_completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Pro ert Class. 1/2/89 31000 bT1ao0 1/2/88 aaeoo 1/2/87 osoo aact Last Inspection: io/Li Appraiser: Ear 1 Z-a-$.ti' Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments / / // $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. qI Date Received 4/4/1990 PID # 17-116-22 12 0058 Appraiser APPLICATION FORM 1..vv„ti 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: (642)432-9022 Work: (QA2) 858-6788*4128 Name: 13thari 1)Qszi Address of Property: (5607 Teuay Pisne Datve I Edam 13282:e1 e- January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 77,200 Date property was acquired: Sept. 186 Purchase Price: $ 65,0oo Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: WoodQst deck Was patntod. Expea,sWe- watt gaped, h'dofessiomty '(7fls1aUQd, Moss. lmmioved ;wan bose2mint &mid erwiatuaeIFiood. Cost of additions and alterations: (rmago.ttve two thousand dotknss) Is property listed for sale? No If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 7 ,g00 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): (4) Farm the data.of p.CischasQ. -Una paoiaerty Shows 5.410 appaecta+tadLeach yQ.aw• St is L-Entgaied •zm ctaket Natue. r��� (4 The. Orb is in de+o7ikatian9 ccra,dl+ian (rind hea,ce. 0()'+res T¢els that 9Q le sat ar aak2t lino¢ isles does amot app% 10 th s FeDpen• 0 (3) Tho Qrsocsrr6 mf4tco. (nag bins np67etr,m abosnt A„ paapell es, (This Was HOD PvDp¢'Dty). Th4.s pit pe,sty c, s cral ce(sta ic2t� a Sealt-- Crski eno ova brnag(et :et. Zhe_ o(,xsloa bettnve. 'that this (i)aS Inch a borc50:or) as ttha Q sSQ ssvd obtisa. t(n ian}GS Ci§,L6.41•; Q•ZeQ1►- Signature of Owner 31300 Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 15600 .573 cZD '?900 27. 1/2/88 IS4,o0 5'700 1/2/87 /9101Qn 55000 Last Inspection: 0I/ Appraiser: Carl Ze&i. — Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 4 (.1 c tJ $`soco w0 8. cra t-140 Sale a/_/$3 t2VeV $ -710oo w 0 3 St c4t1 h'7a10 w0 Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. 9S Date Received y 14.;q PID # 11-116-22 11 0020 Appraiser .lnhn SAMS APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 941-4078 Work: 339-5300 Name: Donald J. Sorensen Address of Property: 7121 Willow Creek Road, Eden Prairie, MN 55344-3225 January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 226,700.00 Date property was acquired: 1967 Purchase Price: $ 7,750.00-raw land Terms of Purchase: Cash Additions and alterations since purchase: Original construction of house, 1967/1968, $35,945.43, including personal property; finished basement, 1981, less than $4,000.00; replaced rotted deck, added gazebo, add two skylights in family room, installed lower Cost of additions and alterations: See above and attachment. /patio, 1988 Is property listed for sale? No If yes, at what price $ N/A (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 166,900.00 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): See attachment. Signature o er Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 59,100 148,100 207,200 1/2/88 53,800 134,700 188,500 1/2/87 51,700 129,300 181,000 Last Inspection: n/i/7; Appraiser: 7)0h0\ S, Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments / / S Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: April 2, 1990 Dear Board of Review Members: I have had serious reservations and objections to the assessed valuation of my home for a number of years. My concerns have been heightened during the past two years. The 1988 assessed valuation, which I believed was too high, was $188,500.00 (land = $53,800; building = $134,700). In 1989, the valuation was increased to $207,200.00 (land = $59,100, building = $148,100) and this year's appraised valuation is $226,700.00 (land = $85,000; building = $141,700). This amounts to a 20.27% increase in the last two years. Last year when I received the Real Property Assessment Valua- tion Notice for my home I contacted the Assessing Office. I was informed that that valuation had been based on a neighborhood adjustment process, which I was unable to comprehend as it did not encompass the usual appraisal techniques with which I was familiar (i.e., cost of replacement minus depreciation, comparable sales, and income approaches). I was told that there would be a full inspection of my home later that year so I decided to delay making a formal objection until that process was completed. Mr. John Sams thoroughly inspected my home last September. Last week I had the opportunity to review the assessment records and discuss this matter with him. Following my meeting with Mr. Sams I have had the opportunity to talk with various contractors regarding a number of the components which comprised the appraised valuation. Based upon all of the above and upon my knowledge and experi- ence, I respectfully take issue with the following facts and fac- tors in the assessing department's valuation: 1. Land value. This component is egregiously over valued. I understand that the assessing department's conclusion was based in part on land sales which had occurred in the Bryant Point area. I wish to point out that these are not true comparables. First, the Bryant Point subdivision is serviced with municipal water and sewer, while my lot is not. A number of years ago there was a feasibility study done in regard to installing sewer and water in my neighborhood. Because of the terrain involved and the lot sizes, my recollection is that the per lot cost was approximately $22,000.00. I believe that the per lot cost of installing sewer and water at this time would be at least 50% higher. I believe that anyone would acknowledge that a lot which is serviced by municipal sewer and water would sell for appreciably more than one that had a private well and septic system. Second, the value of Board of Review -2- April 2, 1990 raw land is greater than the land value of a parcel which already has a structure on it as the existence of the structure reduces the options to which the land can be put. My opinion as to land value is also based upon relatively recent land sales that are fairly good comparables. In 1981, my wife and Joel and Kathleen Harding purchased the land which is now Willow Creek 3rd Addition. This subdivision is immediately adjacent to the subdivision my home is located in. After over six years of attempting to sell Lots 1 and 2, Block 1, Willow Creek 3rd Addition, those lots were sold in August of 1987 for $40,000.00 and $50,000.00 respectively. (The Certificates of Real Estate Value show slightly higher amounts as the purchasers paid a pro-rata portion of the 1987 real estate taxes on those lots.) Each of those lots is about one acre in size, is heavily wooded and each has an undivided one-fifth inter- est in two outlots which comprise about 400 feet of lake shore, including a permanent dock and a sand beach. While each of those lots has some advantages and disadvantages (which I will detail if you so desire) in comparison with the lot my home is on, it is my opinion that Lot 2 is at least as valuable, if not more valuable, than my lot. Accordingly, I do not believe that the assessed value of my land component of my home should exceed $50,000.00. (The assessor has set my land value at $85,000.00.) 2. I generally agree with a number of the general character- istics set forth on the City Assessor-Real Estate Data sheet. The ones I would disagree with are: (a) View. The assessor has categorized this as "1 positive", while I would classify it as "2 equal", with some negative aspects. The view from the front of my home includes Super Valu's building and parking lot, the radio towers, and the very dense Bryant Lake office complex. The views from the rear of my home include the Country Side Auto Parts and Lee Data's building and immense parking lot. The tree covered hills which were my views when I bought my lot are, for the most part, regrettably,a thing of the past. Because of the terrain and location of my lot, its views are generally less desirable than those of my neighbors. (b) Quality/Class. Mr. Sams has stated, and I to some extent agree, that this rating is based upon a number of factors, many of which are subjective. Mr. Sams' opin- ion is that my home should be classified as A-4, while I believe a B-6 is a more appropriate classification. When I built my home, I attempted to build as much square footage as I could afford and the result was that the construction was relatively Spartan. With a few ex- ceptions (the fireplaces, the kitchen cabinetry, the Board of Review -3- April 3, 1990 cathedral beam family room), the construction factors were identical with those used in the average rambler house built in various tract developments at that time. The factors which differentiate my home from a tract development rambler are items which this assessment process uses as separate add-on, increased value items. It appears to me to be unjust to both use those factors to increase the quality classification as well as to use them as add-ons to value. The significance of this quality classification lies in the square foot cost basis that is used for each classification. At a 2,300 square foot size, an A-4 classification uses a $47.76 per square foot multiplier, a B-5 classification uses a $45.56 multiplier, and a B-6 classification uses a $42.44 multi- plier, as the base point for the appraisal process. It is evident that this classification can have a large effect on the value that is ultimately derived. At 2,300 square feet, an A-4 classification starts with a $109,848.00 basis, a B-5 classification starts with a $104,788.00 basis, and a B-6 classification starts with a $97,612.00 basis. Accordingly, the assessor's begin- ning valuation is $12,236.00 higher than I believe it should be. Another factor to be considered in regard to the reasonableness of this classification, as it relates to the cost of construction, is there are but six rooms plus a bathroom on both the first floor and basement of my home. This relative sparsity of rooms means that there are fewer interior walls, less sheet metal work for the heating system, fewer interior doors, etc., all of which translates into a lesser construction cost than would have been occasioned by a home of this size having a larger number of rooms. (c) I am sure that each of you knows that the wood frame construction techniques of the 1960's used 2 x 4's rather than the 2 x 6's with exterior sheathing that is now used. The current construction techniques are far more energy efficient and a buyer will take the energy effi- ciency into account (i.e., the costs of heating and cooling) when a sales price is arrived at. (d) In an effort to make my home energy efficient, I had urea formaldehyde foam installed in all the exterior walls of my home a number of years ago before the pos- sible carcinogenic properties of that insulating material was known. The existence of urea formaldehyde foam must be disclosed to a buyer and will have a negative impact on my home's sale value and salability. Apparently, the assessor was not aware of this factor. In order to Board of Review -4- April 2, 1990 correct this situation it will be necessary to remove the wood siding of my home, remove the urea formaldehyde foam, install new insulation and re-affix the siding. I have not had an estimate of what the expense would be in such an endeavor, but it is safe to say it would be substantial. (e) I am continually amazed that the City Assessor's office considers the area between the service door of my garage and the front door to my home (that is 30 feet in length and six feet wide except where the bow window area of my living room extends into this walkway) which is covered by the eave of my roof to be a "porch". I am even more amazed that the alleged added value of this "porch" is stated to be in the depreciated amount of $1,310.00. The roof line of my garage was simply ex- tended to the area of my front door. Until two years ago, there were no supports for this extended eave area. However, because of some sagging in the roof, I had three 4 x 4 supports installed at a cost of $165.00. This area is basically a sidewalk. (f) Based on the computer generated program, the vari- ous added value items in the assessor's appraisal results in an alleged additional value of $69,560.00. I dispute the values set for many of these add-ons. (1) The asses- sor states that the added value of my 2-car garage is $9,090.00. One and a portion of a second wall of my garage are actually the walls of my house, the cost of which has already been taken into account in the base value of my home. Sussel informed me that the present cost of a four walled 24 x 26 garage would be from $6,000.00 to $7,000.00. (2) The assessor has added $2,200.00 for the fact that my house has a rear walkout. No excavating was needed to be done to provide for this walkout feature due to the terrain that existed on my lot. Apparently, it is the assessor's opinion that a wood frame wall plus windows is $2,200 more expensive to construct than a concrete block wall and windows. (3) The assessor has added $2,980.00 for my two patios, one of which is a 20 x 30 foot concrete slab in the front of my home and the other is a paving stone area under my deck in the back of my home. Neither of these patios is affixed to my home and, therefore, i believe they are more properly considered to be a part of the land value of my home. The assessor has predicated the valuation of these patios at $2.00 per square foot. I dispute this valuation basis for two reasons. According to a contrac- tor I talked with the life expectancy of a concrete patio Board of Review -5- April 2, 1990 is 30 years. Twenty-two years has already elapsed since this front patio was installed. By adding this item to the house value (where only a 22% depreciation factor was applied) the value of the front patio has been grossly over stated. This rear patio is comprised of paving stones over a sand base and was constructed 2-1/2 years ago. There is no concrete or mortar used in its con- struction and, accordingly, it is subject to heaving which will necessitate periodic re-laying of the stones. (4) Apparently, one bath is included in the base cost analysis of my home, so that an add-on of $6,000.00 is made for the other two baths that are in my home. One of the techniques that was used to hold down the cost of the construction of my home was to place all the plumbing piping in two areas. The basement bath's and the laundry room's pipes are located in one wall and the main floor's main bath and the bath in the master bedroom are located directly above and share the same stack of plumbing pipes. The plumbing for the bar in the basement (which has never been hooked up) is located directly beneath the kitchen sink. While one of the upstairs baths is rated good and the other average, each added bath is appraised to have an add-on value of $3,000.00. The fixtures in these baths are standard ones. There are no jacuzzis, wall mounted toilets or similar upscale features. (In point of fact, the toilets in the bath in the master bedroom and the basement bath are experiencing opera- tional problems and, despite repairs made to them, they no doubt will have to be replaced in the near future.) Because of the construction techniques used and the age and condition of the fixtures, a $6,000.00 add-on for two bathrooms is very unreasonable. (5) The assessing office has added $2,324.00 for the fact that my home is air conditioned, based upon $1.00 per square foot of my home. As my home has forced air heat, the furnace duct work provides the distribution system for the cooled air. Jerry Kleve of Kleve Heating and Air Conditioning has informed me that the maximum life expectancy of air conditioning components is 15 years and my system is now over 20 years old. Further, he has stated that my pres- ent system is very energy inefficient in comparison with the systems that are presently used. He estimated that it would cost $1,200.00 to replace my condenser. Again, it is evident that the value of this add-on has been significantly over stated and the depreciation factor used does not result in an accurate appraisal. (6) The assessing department has placed a add-on value of $3,591.00 for the screened gazebo I had constructed on Board of Review -6- April 3, 1990 the rear deck and classifies it as a porch. The assess- ing department basis was $21.00 per square foot. This gazebo/porch was constructed for me by Edward G. Howe 2-1/2 years ago. His original bid price was $1,900.00, but my wife and I decided to have interior wood added so that the total cost was $2,400.00. (7) The assessing office originally stated that the add-on value of the two fireplaces in my home was $8,400.00. When Mr. Sams and I discussed the fact that these two fireplaces are lo- cated on the same footings and the appraisal data book he used showed that the cost of constructing two fire- places was not double the cost of one fireplace, he stated he would reduce this item to $6,800.00. (The appraisal data book showed it should be $6,500.00 but because of the computer program used it could only be adjusted to $6,800.00.) In addition, this add-on ap- proach does not take into account the fact that the fireplace in the basement does not have an adequate air draw capability which means it cannot be used without the basement filling up with smoke. Essentially, the utility of the basement fireplace is as a brick area divider. (8) The assessing department places the value of the deck on the rear of my house at $11,508.00, based upon a $6.00 per square foot cost. The deck that had been on my home had rotted. Edward G. Howe removed the old deck and installed the existing one 2-1/2 years ago, at a cost of $7,686.00 including the portion under the gazebo/porch. (9) The assessing department states the value of my finished basement to be $23,467.00 which was arrived at by using a $12.00 per square foot multiplier. The base- ment (other than all the plumbing, some wiring, the basement bath, and the laundry room) was not finished at the time my home was originally constructed. The finish- ing of the basement occurred in about 1981. I purchased all of the materials myself, my brother who is a licensed master electrician put in the added wiring, and my wife, some friends and myself put up the added insulation and drywall, and the bar consists of kitchen cabinets pur- chased from Knox Lumber Co. As the main bearing wall was necessarily already in place, all that was added were three 15 foot walls to create the three rooms plus the furnace room toward the front of the house, three clos- ets, six hollow-core stained and pre-hung door units, insulation and vapor barriers on the three concrete block walls, and drywall over the newly framed areas. No new windows were added as the wall to the rear was already windowed, doored, and finished as part of the original walkout construction. Even including the carpeting that Board of Review -7- April 3, 1990 was installed on the floor, my total cost for the fin- ishing of the basement was less than $4,000.00. If one were to factor in the value of the labor, a reasonable value of the finished condition of the basement is less than $10,000.00. 3. I also disagree with the depreciation factors that were used by the assessing department. The only depreciation factor considered was an item Mr. Sams described as a combination item that he informed me contained both physical and functional compo- nents. The life expectancy of a wood frame structure is generally stated to be 50 years. Although there is usually some value left in a structure at the end of its normal life expectancy and a straight-line depreciation factor would not realistically reflect the structure's market value, the 22% depreciation factor that the assessing department used does not accurately reflect the deprecia- tion that exists in my 22 year old home. As has been noted earlier herein, a number of components of my home (that have been included in the construction cost and add-ons) have a shorter life expec- tancy than the structure of my house itself. A buyer would take these items into account. As time has elapsed, construction tech- niques have changed for energy efficiency and aesthetic reasons and the design of homes has been altered to account for changed desires and expectations of home buyers. Examples of the physical deterio- ration of my home are such things as: numerous cracks in the batten siding; partial blockage of the water pipes because of the minerals in the well water; a 20 plus year old furnace and air conditioning which are not energy efficient; the flooring in the family room dips as it spans from its end support areas; plumbing fixtures that not only have outlived their life expectancies, but are also in colors that are no longer fashionable; the front concrete patio is depressed below the walkway from my garage to my front door because of settling; the garage floor and apron are starting to pock and flake; the drywall walls and ceilings have nail "poppings" and "ripplings"; etc. Although I am still proud of my home, a realis- tic assessment of it must acknowledge that its best days are a thing of the past. I submit that while 44% of the life expectancy of my home has expired, physical and functional depreciation alone should amount to not less than 30%. Taking all of the above factors into account, I believe that the fair market value of my home using the assessing department's approaches should be derived in the following manner: Board of Review -8- April 3, 1990 A. Land value (including landscaping improvements) S 60.000.00 B. House 1. Base construction cost - as B-5 $105,800.00 2. Add-ons (a) Garage $ 7,000.00 (b) Walkout 2,200.00 (c) Patios 2,400.00 (d) Additional baths 3,000.00 (e) Air conditioning 1,600.00 (f) Porch (gazebo) 2,400.00 (g) Fireplaces 6,500.00 (or less) (h) Deck 7,700.00 (i) Finished basement To tal H useCost $149,800.00 3. Minus physical and functional depreciation (22%) - 33.000.00 $116,800.00 4. Minus urea formaldehyde foam correction - 10.000.00 (?) Building Value 5106.800.00 C. Total Market Value $166,800.00 ! I fully realize that the above figure is $59,900.00 less than the Assessing Department's figure, but it also is more than 380% of what it cost me to acquire this land and construct this house. Thank you for your time in reviewing this matter. Yours very truly, Donald J. Sorensen 7121 Willow Creek Road Eden Prairie, Minnesota 5344-3225 DJS/k Encl. Appeal No. 9 b Date Received L4/4 i c1O PID # 25-116-22 22 0028 Appraiser ,lnhn Sams APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone HomWore: q(-q 345 Name: \All 1e0., Address of Property: 40q(i( MOtta+ Q u.-oe C4 January 2, 199D valuation as it appears on the notice: $ Date property was acquired: g-8E Purchase Price: $ ZGO, bov Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: 1J o N e• Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? t)o If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ �- 7O.000 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): S tzA4 4 - 2 . = t tcfS5 - 3c& 0o0° 1079 3 kero - ql5 ooa , I ZO2 /k+ Cru - 3ov,000 w 9 397 01`.Dt- 311,006 1 r5+sas e l 5 I -e rOX r Sa-.-e S t i-e 1,3 S T`* Q ' l Signature of Owner Please note: This fort requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 !I500o I-' ioo aE"1100 R 1/2/88 &SOoo /-7ddOO a39,00 1/2/87 k4aCp ib 15oo g -1co rr- Last Inspection: II/a/g`6 Appraiser: A�. Sa.M.5 Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments CAV Ea60Cb0 Wo IC•375°7a / / Board of Review Action: 1 Referred to Assessor for review: 2; Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: • Appeal No. /L— PID # 02-116-22 21 0029 Date Received 4/5/1990 Appraiser John Sams ^ APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: (-7:L`1 i`l U re Name: `-J Z�1 7 9 Y2h1�1 S -f (�R--11.-WL : �,�` 1� 3 1 \ Address of Property: (4-7; ZV LWk Sic W U Q NO ��L January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ ( (-7 C V\) Date property was acquired: - -- '-3 Purchase Price: $ Terms of Purchase: vv-cm-y f,a c,-5. i c1.-A S►'S Additions and alterations since purchase: t-J t* E_ Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? 11 6._ If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 4 7~ T L7O° What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): b i= 1a"t)YkS- i0x-'5 ''GS'1 b S C 7 b2 (Gt-4 S17-v- '7k-y - iv-i - t-3S4">6 ) Id15 l NL1..-1.4> S saw+,€ f Er4owAn- `0 1Df j CA 1,ZtiVc- - �sts> o ,TV1 tiev e& - '0 S C-A V t \ '► L il,' ,4,1 c l', A- c -7 5,v0��. Signature of iwn Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/B9 g0000 2n4nn 1lnann P (partial) 1/2/88 85000 - 85000 L 1/2/87 6000 - 6000 L Last Inspection: I /3/Lid Appraiser: '",'5owvi_ sa.,,.,,5 Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments �2/_88 CRV $ RRnnn wn _ Cash Sate is for lot only / / $ ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: 1 A 11S UI RARIMINI UI HUUSINI.LOU URBAN DINIIUPMIRI SWI M(MI SIAI(M(NI •. MINNESOTA PIN 8 02 116 22 21 0029 TITLE 4 I API o,to. 6 In1 nuM6ln 1 1061.YLMMR .YORHACI YSWwU 1/.S!Ro 11 f 1.4 1 1 1 I... 1 13'toN1 Leis 1 1 I s Cl MIA Al 603408 - E Nan 1A.40.9 1,..,, A.L,.,6....re.AA.,r.n Hm.as <nn,A..w,e.ea..e..rs..m... N o.m...o..,..me H eel..esa•.�...m..n..N.mn..w.n SIIDHI --.__.-0-0--- I LINE O 0 .•YI wo 6006I Sf 01 NMAOWIN 1 MYL ANo AOOAI SS of SLll1A 1 YIYI ENp AppNi Sf pl IINpl. lithos 1 I,. G.1171.1 i11 lt1INf 1 }WE 141M111!OTA, Katherine E. cantrili NATIOETAI AS90CII1TION ' Jylasai hales, Inc. 6th Street 6 Marquette Avenue 2540 iiomset Blvd. 12800 White'atcr Drive, 4120 I Pinnealx,lis, Minnesota 55479 Minneap pis t•4I 55416 Minnetonka, mi. 55343 e 1e.ri.ii ioLnfd. R SI11IIY1.1 AQNI f•11NIIEf171'A T1.11,E 1 SIr11IMUl pill Hennepin Canty Closet- Darcy A. Johnson CLOSING DATE: 6320 C11asevoul Drive :.O.of SIIREmeii 5/31/89 Wen Prairie 3601 West Minnesota Drive,11150 PAYOUT DATE: Minnesota 55344 Bloomington, Minnesota 55435 5/31/89 .SUMMARY DR WORRDW(RS IRANSACEION R.SUMMARY 01 SELLERS INANEACL1011 100.GROSS AMOUNT OUE PROM BORROWER,t? 400.GROSS AMOUNT DU'.'.TO SELLER: e� n1D1 C.Nn1WtiIR1M"a.a:.''4:.SISC..,,..I.,• .$�,550;762 00d 4oE Mwuas. .._ :; 49, 50h16260a III pn.ona pommy 402 PA,.Nn.1 propon! lli37 6..1.—L RMNt b iarrlli_It1II.109I,,'�,'r R't'1'',,27 331707 •... . . ..... :._r..:�. `~,Y r''P:t•�'thC isiii 104 404« lips. .. . .',.1E7 '!2 .14.7+a11i!`' ,O5'DAI •r• ..n.;rlr•!..>I V1. a0n•..!'! A9..Imrs 1st orris pill by N.O.r in thole Up.Syet.IA,(WISE 01 by lebr N NINNIES '.Illy.'OM/I.NI1 HM. 7• •Ao..DRn...h.i75','..Y.•N..•.-'."P" .,y.,1,1.I9 7 9 .,•,FAIN III Count,malt 401 County H... ,Soy Amu0I100 •.,;1-?'Piece'.+1,ite.. -,.r.. ... .. ION. pNMA.'7RPO'A'�?,(4:,il„0:,,.,,-,'t r .rt,r,..•I.r..p j,.� 109 e091sN.� 1011, .1 .-:r....I. ..., .,. 74 '.,. „•'�,.1. '.I16 il".SAAV;i.14va7KT:.f'..I.:E107',•L' ,u;•c1,..'vy..'•'.YMt R7 III All III.. .,..'... '..,,16 6o,c7; .}-,1 -."617. ry :nl _ . 170 GROSS AMOUR!HUE I20 GROSS AMOUNT DUE f ROM BORROWER 553.115.03 _ TO SETTER SS()769 nn 100 AMOUNTS PAID lI OR IN MALT 01 BORROWER SOO REDUCTIONS IN AMOUNT OUE TO SELLER 201:DNp.NNM..Ina'II M,40*! L 'TW.4y'IL.'., .F106:1000:00 1let:1•;TNl'yipdi116.1011W;h1;11 `•' rlY61:C!;"•?''" .106;'0005011 707 P..acips,mown of new Smell 150 000.00 SO2 S.INem.m chines to 1411.1 I 11001 70) E+NNI1M0DIILO. N f1M. .,, ^"�Y •Z1 1 • ILMWI • `.` l .. 201 1 SO4 Perot!RI I nt molq.pt All 20S.. 'rn'.'• •n,{.,pr1#rl L7• 1 Z1CCT ca gc'R • ..." 706 Lot Credit 8�80000..000 S96 Lot Credit a 0.00 2A0:4`Y/ OUe SON Adnisments I4.oams•np II seller . . � A/ M I..IRm.enp I S1 , 70-0 anM..-""r%Y -r T�11,, Y.rgey' .^7• 0 $ R RI 41101MII 5 1 In County r..., III Counl,.n. Henn. 1717.A.Mv mte . .1...'. ?^. :;;:11'7q'1lSSS',T.,'7,.... 2 ;;-„a'_ .}}?�M.MNMy .1:..., T . II) S17 .2i a- ......w...._...a:141'^EiatnuY1AL i 4.1t.''„'TT•4'1W1,' ielailiMilig,7V.1 i`„E`R"JI.+,QIlf 715 '.,,,,;•,tI 1717.?/..,'i: lirMCtRit:I R4q[a?'KF, 'OIL:. .let on Ecaw: -- . • 11700.i 11; 517 771.;.77 7.-.!12:1L�5'r`'tv!'n-,+.E'.. .. 1 w i... r! ster''v` r c. .F?ct°?It'rPRthiJ'!el.iP•k'P:.10..p.maiwarxtIg I III III 4..T°IAA M10 15JW L .fig; t" 4%,,C Y Roulgl o ,•lay '.`}.fj S 'C-:•. NONROWIN•tu.Ya k:,14,.a `i• P�!:7!clr�%Rig j'1441000.00 I ,tin S.A.N'"PP- - a: .' '' ?'r:T+'4g6 ' .Ll'�.t':. sl,100 CASH Al 5(111EMENI FROM/10 BORROWER 600.CASH Al SE1100MENI 10100DM SELLER 7NNM 00I/GIN MnwnihY i,wbar.NIilNw 170174 4•.'.M,iVIM,':553;115:651 bl'r.DI....rir:wry.yol ...:4"1ta( "q��:'T�$O�ti627LL�y 3117 In,.mmmil p.,n b!/lor bonowm II...7701 i 344_D10 Inn) 601 less,em,mNII In5moum NNe m1v Pm.5701 I L01 CASH IW PR,MI IL'I.BORROWER 209115 a 6D1 CASH Ir,)10) 1❑01110ML SELLER 796An1 co ., nIR t S...,...1 S,n�.n,.n1.. . .np.n..l b...1 n mpM n.,1..,..r1 seam b1 .p. . Yr..,.I m...,col<'that 1 b..•,.6m..e•tee 61 n.•HUD 1 s nam.,sunmenr1" ..a 1L,4.L4 \ (Ep-`).. m�''.L"(-,f ROH16IgtRS SELLERS 111r1 ISO..N URA Appeal No. /0 I PIO # 23-116-22 13 0018 Date Received 4/5/1990 Appraiser John Sams APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW �� (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: Q-i11 �-6 5 4 7 Work: g2..1-8510 Name: LwJN1 Gu1.b6n) Address of Property: Sg72 •KrJOBLE CALL'T. 664 WA Pe 1114 55347 January 2, 1990 valuation as it a ears on the notice: $ 2 cif).Date property was acquired: jz/J4 Bto Purchase Price: $ Terms of Purchase: ToWhlth, s • be 1ft IN LAI' Pic P-C F IC . Additions and alterations since purchase: Fugot- et 1,11J 1n,hsFiEb 1.6 , 5(6NIF c4 6564Y0 -t1F�.b 93AcK, Corracrerg WE/tit f44014-r Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? 141) If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? , (Please attach supporting information): Sign ur o Owner Please note: This form requests private or confid ial data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 5?SDO 16??OO 2"-1-700 K. 1/2/88 5?000 /bO'OO (=CO 1/2/B7 4AG00 1'tgcoo I44OOO Cparl''aI) Last Inspection: ,ajiO/gj Appraiser: Zohi.. Sa,Mr+ Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Conments TrLa/'ib CRv ayayW u)n 7-5 / / $ err***err**********err*****err*** *****err****err************************err**err**** Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: J Appeal No. )C) . Date Received 4/5/1990 PID H 1D-116-22 24 0012 Appraiser Lorna Lisell APPLICATION FORM • 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home:&/5).47,-T939 Work: Name: UL .SC,yFF Address of Property: 72c` B January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: Date property was acquired: Purchase Price: $ Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): /tY C'e'rf 6-47/0 _.s e/J/rf/ec47s5/f/ ,9T7ox_i //L},o iUG'27- ee-)i Tff 777/4- /'1,a7.27 '7.-- K•9L/1/E Sf_6 igna f ne l�— Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Pro ert Class. 1/2/89 LT00O ,co?00 es ff c,ves4eAcA 1/2/88 - .)v,D /00 AaD es r-✓h ;. L,,� 1/2/87 8'vyo0 Last Inspection: 0/j/5 Appraiser: jci.m. L,sctl Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments _/—/ $ / / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: April 2. 1990 1990 Eden Prairie Board of Review City of Eden Prairie 7600 Executive Drive Eden Prairie. MN 55344-3677 To Whom it may concern. I am submitting an application for re-classification of property type from NON-HOMESTEAD back to HOMESTEAD on my home of twenty-five years which is located at 7288 Prairie View Drive. The property I.D. is 10-116-22-24-0012. I recently received information regarding the rules for homestead determination and an application form that is to be submitted to the Board of Review. It is not my intent to be present at the April 19th meeting as this would entail un-warranted time and travel away from our current but temporary California living experience. There is no question in our minds as to where we claim our domicile. our permanent legal residence. it is at the above stated address. We intend to vote, maintain Minnesota auto plates and driver's licenses. and to pay our taxes using Eden Prairie as our base of living. As with any persons who travel our mailing address changed and as a consequence the homestead declaration was not forwarded. The rules that were given to me by the appraiser's office identify two dates, January 2nd and June 1st. It would appear that their primary purpose is to determine 'original' homestead entitlement. I would Imagine that a secondary use for the January date has been assumed in that it appears to be the only date that is used to de-classify homestead entitlemant: if not in fact at least in practice. January 2nd is important only to the extent that a home is not occupied on that particular date. I wonder how many homes are 'occupied' on the 2nd but not on the 3rd; and what happens to their classifications? The second issue, being away from home for a reasonable length of time, is equally as arbitrary as a date for occupancy and even states it as so in the rules. One year is given as a more or less arbitrary guide to the assessor": certainly provides for a wide interpretation and an assurance of inconsistent application. How is this rule applied in Eden Prairie? The last point is the one that is most difficult for me to address and the one that may make your decision easier. at least it would appear to be easier on the surface. We have rented our home to a young couple with three children and 7 } that would seem to be a fitting end to the discussion. Your decision could be easily made because the rules state: "An owner cannot maintain the property as a homestead if it is rented." My question is this, is renting defined as profit for use? We have rented our home for $550.00 per month which we calculated would cover our taxes, insurance and a reasonable fund for maintenance: this did not include any profit. The reason we did not plan for any profit was because we believed that to have our home occupied was a fair trade for the anxiety we might have leaving the home vacant. I truly believe that the city would have been able to conclude that our home was 'occupied' if we had left it vacant while we were away. What we are asking is that you conclude that our home Is 'occupied' by us when it is rented under the described situation. Thank you your consideration, Paul chee Appeal No. /03 Date Received 4/6/1990 PID # 36-116-22 43 0003 Appraiser Rxxlcxlmic Lorna Lisell APPLICATION FORM 1990 EOEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 9t111 1238 Work: Name: Iyl pn r pe,wi pn 93K-3113 Address of Property: _ n 1 K ii„„i Pev l n January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 311,300.C::0 Oate property was acquired: p, 105n Purchase Price: $ tnhPrii- ,- Terms of Purchase: T'erhans 1 can locate the 1950 listinrr of the property when inherited, if helpful Additions and alterations since purchase: rein i:oure was built on ur000rty Cost of additions and alterations: 1,T0ue Is property listed for sale? No If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreemer Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ e^2r0,rnn_no What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): rronrt, rot have 79ter 7• e.,er (an c'on,t went it) about l,al ' -y property hfls been put in a flood plain, my river front will Zip t"' - fr., op•' n eolonm<n}, tl,rq nninrr r +,T property. I ur: mst nd my low land hs,s been t' en nut of A^ricul.ture, +r;ti-n+•t • o r *`o in-'nrmPr4 rf thnt ortinr, 7,y lour; hr,n„ tillc+r+ tl e p.a :.n ; t.:o years, anc' sh^11 he this year. iry property was r,ina'R in value lonL ve r, because of the Fell n11, �,el.onment. From which T receive no benefit. If my property was to berained for tit reason war.nii; the properties to the west. T .: told by a Property o rn r on ore-sono it Sigma u e Please note: This form requests private or'confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: • Land • Buil�din9 Total Property Class. - 1/2/89 /7 5300 13(0000 311300 - IOmc.e Q.,,..0, • 1/2/88 !! IOO 1aa-y�O a,piaO -l04c�¢. Qn..nQ. 1/2/87 /I (000 11 71300 3 'f00 -!0 tL..a. Off• • Last Inspection: ►0/j/ Appraiser: Q,ck . ersb.+rqq • Buildi Permits/Appraiser Comb�nts: 19 ld !G ct° -44 Sale History Oate Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments �- /_ $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. �C`f Date Received 4/6/1990 PID # 05-116-22 12 0040 Appraiser Earl Zent APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone m y 9;5 l 2� Work: Name: JAMES Aval LQa 1 0t5or3 Address of Property: Will /t V LAn1C E.� January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ Z 31,trt Date property was acquired: 1- $$ Purchase Price: S 2 LU,oao Terms of Purchase: Mo0.t6M.� Additions and alterations since purchase: &LhvE Cost of additions and alterations: Nay t Is property listed for sale? No If yes, at what price $ — (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: S Z-20,cen3 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): 58e leis►- 3-23-4c) &t Signature of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 3g000 c10 . 1/2/88 400c0 — ‘t00.'OO t- 1/2/87 r•op — ). oO t-- Last Inspection: (1/25/8 Appraiser: )ra✓I le t-t' Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 771 /SF, McObow aa000O tic Per ocher / / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: March 23, 1990 Mr. Earl Zent City Assessors Office 7600 Executive Drive Eden Prairie, MN 55344-3677 Re: Property I.D.# 05-116-22-12-0040 Dear Mr. Zent: Our 1990 market value increased 5%. There are several reasons which we feel this is not justified. In reviewing homes sold on Ashby Lane, 16458 Ashby sold on 11-89 for $183,500 which was purchased in 1-88 for $175,000. This reflects about a 2% annual increase. I feel this entire $8,500 is due to an el:tensive deck addition, Afi orating, and landscape investments. They have also planted m' , large trees. I " feel our new unpleasant view of the TimerCreek townhomes has decreased our market value (see photo) . Our sewer connection broke, and our plumbers tell us this is due to a very poor organic soil under our front lawn. The front yard fill settled and broke the sewer pipe. Due to this soil, this may be a recurring problem which, also, has decreased our value. The completion of the house directly across the street - 16582 Ashby, with it's relatively low market value will make it very hard to get our market value for our house. We are losing four very large trees which would have a replacement cost of over $10,000. We are not going to replace these at this time. With these facts we feel that our property value has decreased at least $10,000 last year. We would like to see our market value decreased $10,000. We could live with the 1989 market value, but we cannot accept an increase in our property market value. • Please feel free to call me at w rk at 935-2121 or home 934-4484. (We will be out of town April 6-13) Sin re , James & Lori Olson 16581 Ashby Lane, Eden Prairie, MN 55346 Appeal No. in S Date Received 4/6/1990 PID # 13-116-22 14 DM 0017 Appraiser Steve SineTl APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARO OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Wore: 926-6800 Name: Lexington Cabriole Ltd. Address of Property: 9531 West 78th Street January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 939,000 Oate property was acquired: 10/3/85 Purchase Price: $ 425,000 Terms of Purchase: Contract for Deed @ 110/0 Additions and alterations since purchase: None Cost of additions and alterations: None Is property listed for sale? No If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 300.000 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): The real estate value since acquisition has not performed up to its expectations. This coupled with the fact that • our density is in question with the C-i y of Eden Priarie raises the issue of value. , r � • a ure of wne Please note: This form requests private or onfidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/69 1/2/88 -- h'!l�1/2/87 /I . Last Inspection: I / /�O Appraiser: S-Feulz- S.i.14..11 Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History • Oate Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments **************r**************************************************************** Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. /06 PID # 07-116 22 32 0037 Date Received 4/6/1990 Appraiser Earl [frt h, APPLICATIDN FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 9j y_56/£r Work: Name: 41,2,,,,,r1,e/ � yvfcoy✓ Address of Property: /j/// �,P,5 f,e C A}A/ e- January 2, 199D valuation as it appears on the notice: $ I. 71 00 o Date property was acquired:pt 4-/qgT' Purchase Price: $ /O3�o o Terms of Purchase: ( ,,,, ;,;,,,/ f Additions and alterations since purchase: Cost of additions and alterations: 'F Is property listed for sale? NO If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Tr..e(Jew u. Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ //S'0 0 o o ,1A.4t, w What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated va ue? P (Please attach supporting information): 4..y.. 0 -w tZ1 ..L ct-, a! /40.114044,. LZ i natur of Owner Please note: This formirequests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: land Building Total Pro ert Class. 1/2/89 411100 ��/00 1/2/88 a490 1/Sg Q 1/2/87 D2 7 Op 11� Last Inspection: ±/rD/3OAppraiser: Sarb CooK Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments /ti Trir $ IOg000 WO 11•. V7r, /-/ $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. (0 7 Date Received 4/6/1990 PID # 25-116-22 33 0076 APPLICATION FORM Appraiser John Sams 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home YV-88 2.1 Name: noAr# .4A' MoREi✓ Work: 935-33 83 Address of Property: ///m 3 ../14C.kSei✓ b*i Y`E January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 23.0 So 0.00 Date property was acquired: t/u/mpg Purchase Price: $ 2aq,73y,00 Terms of Purchase: NEw More-*be —uacy &qv&I /2,ern.E.n, Additions and alterations since purchase: —Ac .4 DOLT/ONS Cost of additions and alterations: NON E Is property listed for sale? No If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ .2./S o o o.o o What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): ��,ux•Ioc Cr'N.t�,.c.� Si nature of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 5-r ' I-s,rco aoo500 1/2/88 5?- /5Yc d iC OCO rr 1/2/87 ?ow Last Inspection: ,J/jj/$fi Appraiser: Building Permits/Appra ser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments W D-(..a2t. Saes ..✓:��t ..�r'E C+rh' Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: . . in 11 tr: kiderot:ro to Arm.rtr.!1,:q;hat'Ill tor r4iprar.t,d l_rineleer tetlow:r19 A real t rp:irter lIjatiurj corop:Ired the l hry prtre ot trier tidcflC 111 the te,:e Prattle 'itft:-.1n111er teatereo and merYeletillity of tine home et 111.03 Jacker.,r‘Drive. Ani„tetmettiet indAleturt 19::9 1990 thee ftljr names salt tor errouhte eetween$1'10':1110 1r:it $2111 000. tr.onlkr tIte1 the corernonlii,riceeptell methee the i veirt r to item thr"." earrh r cam merited that r1ot1 h,h$ , I ft .71,11 ,TO tOr.."' e '- -Iee tr.!. Th, , !IV-41 I , reft; oh 1.h.,.re-irk I1I 7 b, hfflhV r. 1'00 11 :ear sht;t: t1aaIcal ll: vat:J.,:et tril$tarir, $10.LIT.1 The aperf.21 -",' 7.20,7 al tt,.'cr 1Vii 7 1 i'!0 An ttie'mar Pet et 1.1.!--1,1391.1 are to.!it?! Tfv.• CIO mot--:-ptiee 9 WT 1-tie er.eralaeci v-2I ter: ttn:. hrite, $214009. ?tit- the cerrril 2rior$1 vt1ee rep: fro, prIcf, frra T tv. Ny. ; sty,:rome rear:t:(.;1,2t• 1.411r 105 Lime pet-ctrat!tot-$22-1 7134 arid 2:001:to I ws!i*D., 4'T:. The rit!rrrri1 reer1 et oil, horni, ,ro tuf,1 rf,t10 t,T, A•-•*':_ /OP 1 . --- Ci ii 3t`3s$s p p i25t 1. a R:i' p 1!Q ,s II 2$ f+ i, amsmta Sal . ik :• s 1 111 1 get._ .,l:1$ 1 e � ' Is` aaat f - s. ,s i f iPglib licINVo • A lip - :. ` is! n :: r in of;sol@tr �Si yay 1 '::- i U .. .'; lft a ' ij �.e t 4 -I 7.. 77 V'1. • i V•Y�I 1 i ' . F a ' k ` w C ;s 3 o� ; e I•�� \ 't a k xi y,..i< "t T! B j - � '' if }, . Q FL r]^ PPY L �' 3 ; t 2 N aF3 ezla . aaa ziaa _ i -: 88 gut: st.tvg,tak • k 8 Vie in1 1 Oi a . z Ro m 6 tt • Bw 2 wrc It / E. Ii ¢a wm., . / u1, g; M A i'r -ii.' j 88e; t:# ; V ( . w 1i ivgM VG iii35:g €a - 2 gr gM " .. tE 2 i e g-e qt. i ,s1 .‘r= is.9 sli z8 rer' �Ef: a .i! 1� �qx ZOC I i y it - .:':2 ‘ 23 ss g t it fl I #. 0 `. !1 ! IiII' '4 " 2 ip aw$ m: P i it. 11.Y is Vi 6- `• '. 11411 :Ii .;:ags aP $5;' »e 1 10. ifilli i $ ill! r" r ;' It 1 a�saa & ` a ;_o~' 4 2110011 li ) __ 7 !iiirirtiii i i5lis 1,?! ' ' gi pri x . , s1.1.1 X24 7 Ili li c ' i: ' '1; ' a .. s- 1 t ee, 3ness ao3 s'us "~ A ' w$ II'IIOIIILF 4 la 6P.u F n: �I la Tr fj �3 i a� Ti 3 1 2 i r 2C Yia ' --.— .49".`",7,7 2 i i 2 I S 11 ,-,-, ' Pil f v HIM . lia. . • ll i y r c F y $ aEa !l p iK F 11 j_ 3 t • I al t Appeal No. /0% Date Received 4/6/1gg0 PID # 24-116-22 24 0104 Appraiser Fart 7ant APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: ' V'—//SS 3 �1 Work: ift/-,2GCo j/ Name: DOCAylAS , Ate/ ti LE-4y Address of Property: 8'g/U !/�/47/U 6%%3 Px. January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ Date property was acquired: I e_-',$- Purchase Price: $ Terms of Purchase: ,7�}� y37 Additions and alterations since purchase: S�OJ:F4V74- ,4/0iValgsw43 02Og6 Cost of/additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? yaS If yes, at what price $ ,3 7?Dio (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ goo oo a, o u What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated/value? (Please attach supporting information): /J /�/� 4—^.�< l:/7G t 2 tom. �1i�7�N-e' !` r1!/�7/spa J �� g�( «!! 77 ado _• ,sz Z.e--7 , 7 -9 a yio �S dU� r s M�'/.r�, Signatur of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 65000 259000 324000 R 1/2/88 50600 210200 260800 R 1/2/87 48500 201800 250400 R Last Inspection: g/i3/g'1 Appraiser: e-n.-I Ze+ f Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments /85 CRv $ 243395 WD / / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. lol PID # 26-116-22 22 0051 Date Received 4/6/1990 Appraiser Farl 7ent/Lorna Lisell APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 941-0908 Work: 941-0908 Name: Shirly Mover Knutson and husband Robert Address of Property: 9372 Creekwood Drive. Eden Prairie NR 55344 January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ Date property was acquired: 1980-85 Purchase Price: $ approx $Q0,n00 Terms of Purchase: We bought raw land and self-contracted the house Additions and alterations since purchase: not applicable - we had house built Cost of additions and alterations: Not applicable Is property listed for sale? NQ If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ $95.000 to Slnn.n00 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? , (Please attach supporting information): That is more than we paid for it, and there is still a lot of work and many thousands of dollars to complete the house. ;7„ Signature wher irly M. Knutson Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Buildin Total Property Class. 1/2/89 33o0 a 0 ia73c0 1/2/88 ga4-o0 7 i.o.00 1/2/87 33000 )i7g00 K Last Inspection: */b/eL Appraiser: t�i&o,_ Lisel( Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Oate Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments / /— $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: y,, Appeal No. )(b PID # 27-116-22 11 0023 Date Received 4/9/1990 Appraiser X***PHElNN41ER APPLICATION FORM Barb Cook 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: gy/ -6 9J' Work: ,'pt 9-/' uq/ EYr.26x Name: LiARy L.. RADTKE Address of Property: 9564 Yorkshire Lane January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ (Y0,4100 Date property was acquired: --10LY191f Purchase Price: $ S6)900 Terms of Purchase: a.2)00o Dow,.J) 30y„, - rrt �T6AGc AT in.7_9,or Raav,q Additions and alterations since purchase: $edroo.., ,,. 6os••M�nf p4r� �«y Co.npl.c1-< a8'rc 11,1 ALTTRCNED C.RAa, Cost of additions and aterations: /¢/000 Is property listed for sale? WO If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 7../g00 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): 7YEST,rIC OF ilAnvElDFir //,9 '7:42'6 410F17 j.ry�,s�ryyeD,�w� �S t-"--6 A FOv,2 &a...4////G//w4y A t44/6- F4vD1OwE-14ftF CeosE 70 1Yf y yi4 O i c�I NQ r�0 e.5 it ff C il4 S t0 i Tr4 A I f 4,0/Sf. E't- 7KOu6N T�4S rnk e: iS�07, 4,FciC/r7/''� Pl'� cJ c,e.�M .yiiP�si?l CO OdEP TNis �e N � Knit/4-o Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 d Od0 '+3'70O 68100 1/2/88 2 ?OD 625400 1/2/87 ao-1o0 43500 &9cc �< Last Inspection: r// /gS Appraiser: tay( "Le n.-f Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments a/_/Z�t �T $ S,S7S t,JO / / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: 4 Appeal Nu. III PID # 24-116-22 21 0006 Date Received 4/9/1990 Appraiser reri Zant APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 14/ g - /Y/5- n f j� Work: (/i it Y - K 3`.1S Name: r,I� J ` e170, [�1 ) , (��J0 Address of Property: %5(a5 P-)Inrk, WlaO(e • January 2, 1990 valuatiion as it a pears on th notice: $ I R 8 $o V Date property was acquired: 1 Purcha a Price: $ P-IS i"kOO Terms of Purchase: VA. N Additions and alterations since purchase: GJ. ( ex P k Lel . rc (92s Cost of a cit' n and altera i s: IK),CY r) Is property li ed for sale? (U f) f yes, at what price $ _ (attach copy of listing agreement) Dwners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ I''y� What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above staff eli va ue? (Please attach supporting information): • 4., Q _ 6`, t I CA�� �(1ri,�C,> UCH # 7,� 5 1�i) 1)-0\_cc-kf_)t P 0(Q- 1)P-- t # ' :>i- I 'e-- 't.(1.;. Signature .f Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. . (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Pro ert Class. 1/2/89 4.3000 14:, iW 1/2/88 '1IIc00 17`I-70O 1/2/87 Opp a /k1S(0O Last Inspection: $ /% /19 Appraiser: E;ar 1 Ze .1 Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments I I d5 3c0 v.JO / / S Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. /I Date Received 4/9/1990 'ID #•23-116-22 44 0007 Appraiser John Sams APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 944-5788 Work: Name: Donald R Diana lee Locker Address of Property: 11322 Mt. Curve Road January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ $404,700. Date property was acquired: 1gR4 Purchase Price: $ $ 150-00- Terms of Purchase: cash Additions and alterations since purchase: Made upstairs family room from existing qvm. Windows were added. Cost of additions and alterations: 15 000.00 Is property listed for sale? yas If yes, at what price $ 395.000.00 (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 375.000.00 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): Please enclosed letter 'Signature of Owner „5-" Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Pro ert Class. 1/2/89 1;5cc a fe9Ccc' +4oJ70c 1/2/B8 ka .0 i o 5-i viC• 3,7100 1/2/87 S 13t: :•I:kfCL� .�9yvCL Last Inspection: °i/;3/11,S Appraiser: 70ti,1 t a,,4.S Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 2 S/ff a $??SCrr, tJ0 / /_ $ ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: John Sams City Offices 7600 Executive Drive Eden Prairie, MN 55344-3677 April 4, 1990 Dear Mr. Sams, As per our phone conversation, I have filled out the form you mailed to me. I have also enclosed a copy of our listing agreement and copies of homes in our block which have recently sold. The property at 11352 (next door to us) is the identical house to ours, built by the same builder, with the same interior and size, with the exception that we converted the gym. As you can see their home sold very recently for $345,000.00 We feel that we will not be able to sell our home for much more than $375,000. Therefore, it seems unfair to tax our home for more than the market will accept. Please review these facts and call me if you have any questions. Thank-you. Sincerely yours, u Diana Lee Lucker (Mrs. Donald J.) 11322 Mt. Curve Road Eden Prairie, MN 55347 100711 011.0110•310/1 ITY•1 IT CONY 1.ON/.100 LOT 10N1O1 MP&1 MaNN7 Mr awn No 01/IOIM 1170A1/IT41 10.11110Ud7MAN 4114400_ 101YN10/TI MMAOTOM NYNNN/00O L •00110/600111 K NMI WON'MIATMCWNO a 10110M010 fi 1 .• �`� IT OAIIMONO/YlSO011T 101N11N YCNi1M1AWAILL W^'.:'�{'1 W 4: L •rp,t'"'Z/Y'+ST_�>,'� •7/1gr701HW17N 11NMI710M 111,6wA7. / 11, 1{i ? /�1...} {• •LNW01N wITMf11NAC1aNM17iN OM COO YOYLNNW. !• 7� y y f�^ • •OYYN CV MICR 10a NIMACIAMMW. .f K4,f •1,:.I .,or; 'j •NWC CN IN1111DNTN1aWONM A1wHAIN Of(WA 1 .. .i,f., COMM LAMP PAVAN IMTWAIIMM111 MOM YOWL ' IM11 1 .PLO A ILIAIMAMNIA7 W STATOR AMNIA I�1 •111 I41 MN M a 1/1 MIN ff rr ..1'.. •-,{• •LANYOG111 NM T011Y01 WM0001MONTI MO A 1 1 R MAIM AT IMO Nol W0111.00/N0. *MOM MNS1T/Of♦M1. 011 NOON KOLA MIr .r ••Ayy� 1NN1M1fAMP SON MEN*70 11711N WIM MMT/K YOW1 l LAM 11107 N0CNYIM IM N717 full MMM I7 M NNMS MM MA NMI PN1N TWAN711 W1LWW 7NN wl0111MWIIL,MAIWI O CAMITL1NWL*T1N 1AM Mill 7NI COP NM 011000 AV Id INS 1MNONE WI ICNAT Y1.YMf CANM7L 111DW111IMN4 L01 11011//111 0111t 0CN 000 N$IN IMO/Y YN IIN •NAL1Wi UMNATIMIINLI AM MM Wi10NWITW60M OMfMM1Y11O fAAND f01AT pMMM WOOOWONI.IAI MITI IL MN MTN 1110000E AROMA MLA ••NOON COIMTf••LAM 100••NM••N41000IOR•• ►N1M.III TOSS!MP OWN MINI OM 01U1111 NOM Iw/UMNWMIWMNLOCAVM II 111 MOMS?IMAM 1W C310711M10/f011NLY IWL MI 1MWfNAC11CIi0 'MalMMONYONNi01M1MiNMIMNIiRIVKrN 10WIi7NW11110NL 0.10TIN NOMA1160WIL.MU, DNAIIM CONFORM MT YYN noN1NN 000I TMOWOO 70 IANSNLIMIONL.IALLrN1111Oi101 MI L4 LOT AIM I.OLT { TON N TM MME/0/YNinL 1 TCOW YIOOWLOII N •KOI:11016101TUA•1O.IJ001 0N ON 0 AT•C/AN•1 CM OMAM•110011NNALLr UNOKAPIP VON WORMY! _.... • LM1IIIO•MAMNMI0N•71KCL LA 11 N 1 T MC 1 AIINML/IWO YMr NICMLWNTI1 INNN1N00N MINN N IN17 71 IMIe /A /OMI 14H11101 Wf 7.1I >♦ •ni TOO NON/11AS MT VIOALM1116WM1D TO WI 0 11110 p. 1W STOMP V COIIAM 001IB AM Y 1.116010141601 M41M1 CT MIN M•17117 WPA 11111 7YCN MAN • HI I011 N 1411 7A.Y NON MMA0IM 1 II100 • Of MIMNMAW IMAI AM UT UT 001716101 111101 M7 LL/1I LWu TOM NUTTY.INC. Mn NM 121401 OII N7•x01 U. 111M1N1N Of 1 MO mat NY COM/06 4 TWO IMAM!/ LOCATIO N/0111OM1N/MNC 1W OM COMIC MLA7NTMYO NM 0/10.IMP NT DAWN'M11117 SMUT T TOWN IMAM OWN OIN7117 MI N11N MIN 10NWEMI 7M1 I10$I017NRIMIAWAW 1 NIL1 NOM MITIA W11N1K0 11111fON AAOM71 TM two moon Y10M!NMI!/MM10 WON WIM OWN MM♦MIN MWNL1 01006111 AY/LMIU TO CM UMW WAY MO CAN LYNII ON lit N0I1MAW I11N7 11.10WL TN/MAGYINMT N0W NMN100MNII0a1 NNW 101100CWMIMTp WON C1117411 COM011110 MAN ANINI.RCN MAIW N 1MMO A WALTONI M10.600INNT PMTS.A IOINTY Of ON001NOI NM INS.1100116 LAMWNINMNYIL MNOTI1 1000WlTOWa.MINT 1N0MMMANIINOMN6NNMY1N7 GOON IINJII 7O 00114,10110104 Mile SOMAS AM 1DIN f1001 CONMMN1 C11 NM K1W1111 IN 1MM10N. 001 N 111 UST 1Y1111 NTI 171*071E MTV M WT N 10*11110M MANS TIN MOM AYM0AN11 •00,11.41I1 FOR 116604T1 OCCUPANCY• ORMATION DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTI r. 19 592-EDEN PRAIRIE-SINGLE FAMILY � L_'�69� 0 BA SS 5T/MICE S439.900 046521 6BB2/210 BA S-2 Sr CA S449.000 DEEMED RELIABLE DUI NB7 GUARANTEED N DEEMED FORMATION DMED RELIABLE RUT NOT GUAR* FED `` r � f . 1 Y • ��1N(1yN����/{ .J, •45YPi, .4'�A o,::S9:i J' EAA 5E322 /11f 0.14042 Ai 1016E Mt CURVE RO YM110166 f1IF MAR al 4A Er RIME TVA59322 LAG CREEK MG f0IN PRAMR 2M61147. EV4110114 LAGS CEUMIIM AS150 ASP1 AA6N Sue 501E MTN A956 ASPU GOA,COU1f . .E17 A1AA 0t10A 1991/1 11 IRIS LOT 116R14N141146 ACR 23 030OR 1990/1 YR III! N0N•EwARD MILS AO 10 NEAL EON DR GA ANDERBON U61RWY TO MEMO TO MOAT CURVE ROAD IN 100E Vnix ETAS PERFECT'LINO OF 50011 I4AUI0U1 OE/AUG'SULT ROBERT WINCE NOME LOCATED ON OLYMPIC , A PRALNCAI 0UNCTIOlALSM HOME 02I0015 EMI GOLF COURSE.MI6 NOW TOASTSO MANY 204!EATERIES OW WIN OEN ST ARM AY TO TM Si C010'LOON ANTE TEE CMOTSMANSNP Of TM PRIMERS IVANR O THE AREA. NG OU4VIY AND 01111 lUZURY SEE SUPPUMENI MOD BELOW MMACEM4NT C012.SUM WANT 60irER SEE SURGE :Uff NEST AEX ADDITION lU t0711 ILK 1 3/1MPIC NM ITN ADON AT CONN LINO Aff.RNG.OWIASP.MI0.• 2021111.22.214061 NE MAT CO MCI REFANCOWS.0119.1•10.1 .a^4 I2 NE WCO III.TAO.SEC.D/P,E0R.W7M I A1N101 IA0N01 SEWON C MIX WIXORT 11N RAC C EE1M50NA.VA.CON.CM 11 IA 11A II E HITS;R3 AMC MMSWN.CPI '0011WA. 1CAS WA SO INI00 1 OR 111137121611E HEA rA 1 GAS M10SO III9 N ' AA"0011000 Err SEC 0011N ADA1 0 12R11 32 2 11R11 DR W00011 DO CAN '00• ASMN• '7A0I TEEM DIN SO 121 2MA AT 13113 IS I.12111 69MWA1 NN '- 2MCN DM II '1R11 I-;003.A.2 EA I1A1A N 11251E GAR 3.A RCEILENT NEW;MANGE° 1R14 XS11001 ON 1M12 AMB 31121 1522109 /MAIANE. 1,110E 943 277 SCR 91T9INJ9N119 POT 9 MB/Y TSF 6200 N 272 SOP 917.1150 00302S5 VII1.0OD Be 5A226 1T ER AGM Oft ADAMS 473•6171%.s_- SIT 512.16 MEN BOSS Wm N01116 A>10264119 EDINA REALTY.WC. 6113 OMN 9E6-3111 RM A/11131' TL , �. l�°' .. to "t 1. Y 6�+ 1 131.e41 ADD 10T11 NAITO.I DR •''; I5T NO631291 (SLIM ADO 106112 MOUNT CUW ROAD 1DDF100A Tim 1 I51EN00 TMR/1ITOMN LUAUNOUI MASTER 6fp100M IUR: MIN;R4 AND NALL. ENS MASTER SUEI NO IWRITNMG INCLUDING EMPLACE.A WNF AMPLY ROOM WIGORGE 0US VEWS EIMDUOM WMMP00l.SEPARATE NOWEA.2 IRAS.MRITMYAMIY.MU01 OW SYSTEM OVERLOOKS LAME 11R1ES WMIW CLOSET.,ODOR OLOSIT/AILSEAV10U4Y MPRSNEO. 'CI FIRER/ACE WTN MATNAT0A w1i0600R Rq'SSOOIOOM3 wE 111111 2 K06 11FDAOCO2S ON MOVE SOX OF MKSIIN SUITE TATE AN • 00 A00M.OMR 11001.1021 END FA4 RM A010IM0401ATN WIIN A 001A1f IMP O0AI EDP TE0NAGEN. KSTOVE.A GIN7I1MEN'i ORE A M ROOM t11NIMY1002.1- 211C144 WEEK CURT0M1AR CA5Mf1A1 CENTER END 2200A SRN LAUNDRY A0062SSTAWEN11.3 WRY COM0EMEN7.• 1A0M0ANCE OF CUSTOM CAIONTYR1 TDO DE IMF 213014 - i ENT EATING APEA 6 A 0r5A.W042 AREA KOCNEN M l0A010 W7011 CASMETRY,CEMERIM5NDW1C00Ai00- ' N EA TING ME 11NAE wN AS OUT TO rAU7f0 6U1.2.MWCRDWAV'E 00MLE DWN.IRASNCOMPAC/N.21004M1RY1 AT IACNE0 Elt,1 MCA 0v0R10 400 1ST GOON TAM Am WI1N WET AAP AND 14'AI t-A.104S0N 0NCN A WIIMRE AMA 51 MORLNIGAY 500 IRiM0 AS ALSO A GUEST 600000M&UTE . {({({( 0 ;AMR,.IN0O ROM IS OE At I T I MATED COMPUTE W191311 SATN AND WRM ACLOSET. .. 7 110 mkt S IS C0f:0EVENT1V r01ME0 rent LOWER LEVII RAS I.10'CEILINGS NA000 INGST4CVT 6E3UTOUUSE AM - !1}lrS' 'S MINT ROOM COMPLETE WI WIT BAN.;ARC,SEPARATE GAME ROOM. N1UI TAME AREA All WALKING OUT 70 TM SOU COURSE *4051/^V SUIT 4 will fLEGO.,Poi0 IA1N AMA 3 MORE MDI10OM6!Ol BIOS GUST50R OVUM KIP ON LOWER I. 1P.10JACU1111 SFAAAail SN0W1R NUM31'S10'STOMIE WORKS900 ROOM f0A Alt YOU PROJECTS. 1 III W'J S,ii W L AREA W.M3;N',,4Ni vE W. IEAU01Ul OM WWCl1N 0RM./TAM I MIS S CDW MOULDINGS 041522 DUE 4 30 3/011 BA&2 5T•COM S449.900 MF0RMA71091 DEEMED RE1031E BUT NOT GUARANTEED i a • ' I 1OTO NOT AVAILABLE e.' 10/.; is I i ,..2,- ,XAr10N0R TN IUIM OM CM IM11724 /N'F NUN QI 4 i Ram MUNMA60A 2M BRIO TVA SEST. 0A4E N 70RE1f0 IN TORS All WINDOW ' EA112 SUIT CM CARAT ADIS310 AS11 .. .�• An 11 ER iro4111 am TIN t _t' • 41Y! 10-1 IYS.MI 11,111 !�;IIIY.YI �. III4l.MOWS MII p610.111),YII.I0 Iy111,Y1 • • • 4' - C 1 moor lR�yIIYY�YWM K1 yW✓ =I/Pr W M.1 Wn nor' Nat arrmearkor ea/marY I.YW W�� Mt1 Ly • • • 11.0 .1 sac V. Mks AM* o r1 .W0..0 4I 0 MI Yn Y111w nt0111. • • •u__uWr • ✓ • • • 01..010100110 00000000000.0.01018000101.001. • 00.0000, .0.000000.00.0.00, 010.00011100010.1.100110•4610310 MU • her ma whir 1110• '0000000010101.100111 • Edina ANNE DEFINITIONS This Coda month de popery trued t-.� --- .. .�rL-_�!/i/ ..ravens Y1�yt,.,//_.�'—_._,! _--EDINA PEALTy.Jag. The mal Male boles). LISTING I preys to admire nog b eel i e property b to once !S l90 .I ma ma on to g teat ri'", .To corers;fa1�(�.—.A.�L. 'acd ends a NISI pm. n asl,vge,for epee b Sv k oniony and Inner e-`u may Place it S E Set"sign and a kick Ism nen MawRAILS can the omen I understand you am amends.al the appal PAX*Listing Service(POOLS)and pa we give Ybmsdnb RM m eirgoe mSry IMasapry added d*wan riannalmeecase n to cab tide pl N sywuer the pocey� may faddy RMLS and members althe sea Cods 'IneO title Rice and bons d the sale.I Pad lar by the oy.. t tlu Ihil Coosa DOES NOT nee you wlmo*y b red or monism my Property i Er a m;gege .I N rots e I want M a moms b PM erg reengage MIDI peg my eaten carman. a pprtmn d the lees b Mm morgeps ben.t undMeand that t • MY DUTIES I M moors*M r pu in Whig the properly I M pn spy M pu rand r kgurles 1 moliro abdA Ina moony I qM b pod an s d pm(b any inspector and plus l maned gteeasp patrol I softie prowls homeowners araemenapsmemel reSI N I ere Rota the Lyme enydfed Snow d cam. omen &cam,goose dery xd messes poverty SAW,es Irrlidmge ems* br deeds nceewyb Vander b the Wan mEl.OW INNPernerl We Munro pricy lo MOMS fanoS rtleeubg{Ibosee er Ian enmyI Maptrdaeq gh and mNI W It r Mo n the popsy. NCmCE:THE CDMMUSSION RATE FOR THE SALE.LEASE,RENTAL OR MANAGEMENT OF REAL PROPERTY SHALL BE DETERMINED BETWEEN EACH INDIVIDUAL REAL ESTATE BROKER AND RS CLIENT lCUR CASVAISSIOI4 1Mpm(palYpu aprrenlwn / %d to Meng place I I era apseb sr the pap My Cods this acorn end.E eddao a bete tie mead ergs tau peon a gee sex m Mang and Nil b toy the rawly r theories and Isms ego ed in tp wind.Cat mAs to er,I IA PP pat pal Be ptA oaneadh prestos your c t on sheer too,I.ads an ge a timber ter the properly p b oat I lanky emu ore ;of W pax nrriest WIN 6 arm md es,mow bol b Nay balms art'mosexting the buret wVeeb pry our connexion it Sal upon behepptsg dany db Hoeg ewes: (y Ts timing.al to nip la.My marl n dole to wit Nay OM n MP I the pdm and tees 1W¢LWmni w oNES I ehn rt dap.dra h card d fie arms I M or soma b tr to popery b weans why • (II Gains tiemstl mob inquiry ti ns atoll the popery and I old nal lr you dbdd to lamely,R T1I Oueg tee maul row n tlMwiw....gal Owes In to properly a was py-ORy Whom la popery q la and whoa tee Y on•Mien Y . yet pm me etn TS tan rr We era d tie mrbe* tag IX peY pl sae apnNµ El al Whig p M n e gm n IItop lfal property wadsydr eemsdan ance.I uea a M d MS tel toq/ar mlmrlm p II sign sedge mid Slag mesa elver the opinion of be Canna,irdr which i am rNgsed p py a commie.ie.b crepes Wooed maleeur ban[ la wax the petrel al yaw mmldmmn I hereby Mir bre the posed Ian the sag d a/ b n Inane equal n to mmnisem M you undo lee Oa II either anwoo I beg n scam b addortwt Ii rAperwA nre%E gpetyn .Mutts ndarh.mdepmYeanrw}dpweet • else a.esed n saes r ads aId wanness ncbag Y moats albmets'fees and coot mils CLOSING SERVICES Ieasps aba Bib you ell be impanel*TThe are diming a the sal al my poorly and MI mean to dosing esnwe thogh Tor Sego"Ira abrg6 deep swim 1.d bait Mt al fay NOTICE:THE REAL ESTATE BROKER,REAL ESTATE SALESPERSON,OR REAL ESTATE CLOSING AGENT HAS NOT AND, UNDER APPLICABLE STATE LAW,MAY NOT EXPRESS OPINIONS REGARDING THE LEGAL EFFECT OF THE CLOSING DOCUMENTS OR OF THE CLOSING ITSELF. • • NOTICES MC NONOISC tlbWUTON M des date I ire no steed Mope Rom any pvwmmerd e Mk I roans I unionist1+/nano hire are,agadrp alas the peprly ns t Wand OS too raA • Pledge. • d sale ry and I acme te pion*b�cam ado Peetl notee a Neiman.so nlo'Rgn.st lIed Salm Moe YAM Ngrd b pubic aesisanne.htdrmR weigher Oxica1ro or trey PIN I uaued Mow thy ban prance nag Wade odes oceans Gum EDINA REALTY INC --.--- r'i;s-%('.j i';C'47/C--- • ese Ammo Dp avrd: .--�= .L——._.-.Amp Idaes. ` T�`'/n///T.�,�„t A! Pawns 9'/V SSi • Deese 4 - •Social Sooty e: i ' 3. • Social Security P Redwal Me pI mrpdeipy • Em PPc pest aw weds ore mtxsm w.ba Mm_NO_7/�-- • WHITE.EDWA REDO S COPY:CANARY.OWNERS COPY 7 • Doe aged: _P ) .A {.) . Appeal No. /f`1 • PID 25-116-22 22 0023 Date Received H—ic-1,fq,: APPLICATION FORM Appraiser John Sams 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARO OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: e//.2 3 9 Work: 9yy•1yyy Name: JAuw rATC Address of Property: icy, Art. Caxve 440 January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ .773 a'00 Date property was acquired: 4c Purchase Price: $ ;ooQ Terms of Purchase: Ci41 rut.y 2 .44 4 Additions/� ► and alterations since purchase: Ncr 771. —cgs., a,p,e1�re�l" „el tern r� n(Q t L� e+v Cost of additions and alteration : 77.1 Is property listed for sale? ,�.) If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 330 3 yo 000 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): /1 ai si 373 eoo x • _ �✓6 000. �,, zoo.mr+( ✓.rayscM r `P—`4 Signature of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Buildin Total Pro ert Class. 1/2/89 /;'5 a p.'? 373000 1/2/88 zrsoC; aSsSbp 33511cC 1/2/87 75occ- 1 pcL 0 Last Inspection: Lpr/ri Appraiser: zsch,, Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments l 3/ter.. r $::r 5! - o)C, / /_ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: PRJAERTY TAX APPEAL FOR 10842 MOUNT CURVE ROAD OWNER: Lawrence and Jacqueline Kitts PROPERTY ID: 25-116-22-22-0023 VALE FOR 1989 TAXES: $338,100 VAak FOR 1990 TAXES: 1373,000 Total Square footage for three levels including three season porch 4,408. First floor square footage about 2,300 to 2,400. THE MARKET 1. There has been no appreciation in the Olympic Hills area for three years. 2. There are 14 hoses 'FOR SALE' on Mount Curve Road alone. 3. There are - 23 ADDITIDNAL HOES'FOR SALE' IN WELTER WAY AREA. 4. Most of the homes 'For Sale' have been on the market for over 18 months. 5. There are 24 lots 'FOR SALE° between Mt. Curve and Welter Way area. 6. Most recent sales have been considerably below market listing. 7. When I called listing agents for the homes most encouraged me to make an offer even well below listed price and felt the owners would give it strong consideration. HIRE SALES 1. Most sales near market value are really purchases by a company for a transfering employee. 2. Other market sales have involved favorable terms or transactions that make it appear to be a market sale. 3. homes sold on a truly arms length basis have been sold below assessed market value. For example the home directly across the street from mine is assessed at 1562,000. It finally sold after extensive redecorating and being on the market for over 2 years for$420,000. 4. Another home two doors down has been on the market for over one year. 5. A third home four houses from mine sold for_ after being on the market for 2 years. e POINT BEING—HOMES ARE NOT GETTING TIE ASSESSED f RNET VPLIE WHEN SOLD. VALUATION FDR 10842-Property ID 25-116-22-22-0023 I 1 I1. Should have appealed 1989 increase but did not notice til 1990 tax form arrived. 1 12. Nc changes have been made to the house to increase value. 1 13. Based on the original market asssessment of 1338,100... 1 1 the fact that no increase has occurred in our selling market... 1 that most sales are artificially inflated or show drastic reductions 1 1 THE VALUEAiION FOR MY PROPERTY SIYTULO BE REDUCED TO ITS ORIGINAL BASIS OF 1338,100. 1 Gaye I 30-Mar-90 PROFEP y TAX APPEAL FOR 10842 MOUNT CURVE ROAD O46ER: Lawrence and Jacqueline Kitts PROPERTY ID: 25-116-22-22-0023 PROPERTY INFORMATION OR CDIPARABLES IN TIE AREA taluations seen fairly consistent but are ssaply to high for lost properties. In reality lost all property owners in the area should appeal their valuation. I On Market I I Square Approx. Tire 1 'Property ID/Owner Address Value Footage For Sale In Months I I 10602 $411,808 X 1 1 4 I 10632 $555,000 -4 I 10662 $396,900 X 30 1 4- I 10692 8366,608 X 30-36 I 4 4 I 10722 $368,300 X 36 I I 18759 SOLD' 24 I 1078E 1389,000 X 12 - :ii 10793 $562,080 (Sao^?� SAID-$420 24 I I 10812 $317,800 I 10827 $388,18 I 'TP 10842 8373 000 ot 4_ ZS/l(-ZL-i2 23 + y , BUILT FOR f34O,000 and earkrt has gone down not IV'---+ l h 'ft— 2d4MWits 18861 $350,800 0 I IRS- 10902 $353,:'. + I 1O929 1253,• '' X 16 I + ---- + I 10932 1414,100 I I 10961 $345,100 1-329,000 30 I 4-- -+ 1 11022 1444,000 X OFF NOW 15 I + --- IJR- 11062 1411,000 I +-- --+ IMS- 11112 $461,800 3 TIES VARIOUS--- I ID'.- 11142 1335,800 SOLD-$3207 3 I ;JD- 11405 1385,'.'s I - --4 I 11473 1357,000 I 13D- 11491 8286,500 1 Page 2 30-Mar-90 • rROFERTY TAX APPEAL FOR 10842 MOUNT CURVE ROAD OWNER: Lawrence and Jacqueline Kitts PROPERTY ID: 25-116-22-22-0023 IJM- 11559 $382,800 SPECIAL DEAL 18 • I +--- -- —----- —+ • IDO- 11622 1393,000 X 24 I +--- — - ----— — —---+ 17H- 11682 I369,080 X 12+ I • • Page 3 30-Mar-90 Date Received 4-i0-nleiiC PID d 23-116-22 44 0012 Appraiser d.g. APPLICATION FORM • • 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: R y 4•yrJ i Work: ')s 1 -7 zu./ Name: •JO//N r r TFlett/ C'9'ry Address of Property: //47Z /'/QIi1�" eove Pc/ January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 4-4y Qoo Date property was acqu,ired:_5( joi, Purchase Price: $ 374'(,4y Terms of Purchase: ,J/n"t.;/ - 1,n.rrr1 11.1 r/y4/ry Qge �i Additions and alterations since purchase: , -010 Cost of additions and alterations: 7 Is property listed for sale? k,b If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) a Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ , 00), " What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Pleasseo attach supporting information): Signature of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 Ii C o75t4 C 0 (C 1/2/88 "MS c' �KI(DGC Z S o 1/2/87 75ccC Oo k Last Inspection: !c/i/51 Appraiser: 3u,t15 Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments /21, CLV 7.7—*-P WI) G•875°7c // ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: :7:::.: _,„7.:. :,;. ,.."..,.:: :... S rif _ Qssessi.2 yo ., 7:= Y� 70 . /n✓ .. ,) :: /, .23 -//6 - .).-)- y4/-or,o2 _ ._: - '-___. 44b, *° .., ._,a'__ -- //CS5- ----___.25.. //6 --_„.1 1 -•)1 - ',9 _ _ 2.600.-.__ 79, 7c /.5 ..//35.).-. _ A 3 •/ll - )- - 4/-/- Glee.? .6.91004 .. .354 oat, y 3Z-� . //y/2, - .12- /l6 - -)1 - z/-/-00/0 ,. . 9z Oo _ �/o,Sao. i5 _ _ /c723 - ,25-//6 - .2 D - - ) -003/Z 6?-!a - --),o 39z_...._ .. ./06,(c1 - - -- .25-//6 - .).?-.21 -cc54, CZ ou =9i,pp 30a.1/8.._ ' 95-,/o . _ _ -16 -//t• a 2 7//--oe 6P _ 3&( 1 :. a859rra, 39-57,r ::9577 .26- //c - a a- //- et) 7o 450 .;__. r28'/,ya i, 17 ,_. - 7 3 _-_ _ 36G ,-?3- //d- . a. - 43-.0 3 6 3 2'18 _ <. 3/.).,_94 _ . /.7.__ :.9, 7 . ..._.._. — ._ )3 //4�.a 1_ /9-oas/ --. 5934 3/� Sft ._ .:____. .9s.,s' .26 - /i‘_ .)._-//•-Doy 3o8] .. 9_ a o 3.5 57_::_ 9�� - //G -�. - //-c�o15- 4I00 3.Y,ov?? '; q_.:.____...93/3 a, - //6 a a. - 4/3•oo ys_ 14S : .j_7on 7 J sa-_�49L/a_7_ � - a . _ //-ooag _ 0. 57si:v - k� • • sF • i - • Z17) ` ?Ck5 2-4W-00/2- . /-qq0 /141qXti V4Zae--- :Tat) /eat 2-27 s-oo Jr) z ' qs9 a 366, 900 , " /Vo 3(4 Qa) _•_ • 3000 64.) rick- 6 .061D C90 Gn_ • Girz5" • // •• • • Appeal No. (((o PIO # 17-116-22 12 0073 Date Received 4/11/I990 Appraiser tar! Lent APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW(To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 1tt(-OO$3 Work: 42Co Name:Gy11411X ( -\C L CL t� Address of Property: ((D�y1C, T scey Pirik Dr' January 2, 1990 valuation as it spears bn the notice: $ --1 Date property was acquired: -)-a15 Purchase Price: $ ( 2), C? Terms of Purchase: — Additions and alterations since purchase: Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? no If yes, at what price $ --- (attach copy of listing agreement)Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 6.5.000 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): L JCliN¢iui 5 Arcs“tc- k.k I U'4 4 Au,-:? u>,l`l'N S A £ cos - t �ce,0-4. (� ( -too hax2 cliff .lho '::-.k ea- ,.,tct .Cor -1-1.9 uituni+s.,1h ria e1-i I7s5 7'1 etali 15k&e Cee5 Qi. l o cnA-cn,T. pu,d -Co, rr.2 hems/ ti,is tT F. w., t tlk Awl,.11 1,4, '-c T,�-- ‘L. Eden Prairie # . (A !„�,l.�u� </���f w u� 11 1ptoo,,.e.wowaftiil. � =' Signature of Owner 16 yC,OV55A0o:CD 1 C.r.ed Tr.11ii116.000.WD q„y.,�µatmv+o _,;( lFdrm requests private or confidential data of applicant which sietw.n.roppa•� •0004'WD -' for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden ttRz►u.oatto2Aoo�- y�yh,.. .....rsjttoo..... !flew to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections iwoPe..w+c""134, 1ND4f ,�iil;ion of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get wilpasswweAwtitn7iitw.iw.a �B8.� :M,upnt of the property prior to the hearing, such data is (To be completed by the Assessing Oepartment) • Prior year values: ' Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 1b300� te.7, 00 70.<00 KZ 1/2/88 15504) 59300 -74400 g2. 1/2/87 moo() 57000 7a000 Z. Last Inspection: 9/21(89 Appraiser: Earl Zent 8uilding Permits/Appraiser C mnents: i41A.. ,4yAm&oa- 124,KA. .4. Ad Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments T/ate{ 0 .v $ 63Yo0 NHi) Sa(e-- _ /L/5 (- ) $ o WO talo g 81 ctJ 0000 WO Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. 11'7 PID # 05-116-22 13 0023 Date Received 4/I1/199O • , • Appraiser John Sams APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: (73 y-//9 7 Work: 937- 7P1 Name: ,f )n1/s + suskA) 3-I14E/0,4 tJn1 Address of Property: /66? 7 .d.)o,l7f/ N1-)fK ACC i January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ f ",,5z)C Date property was acquired: 7/g4. Purchase Price: $. s GPi,'Ef i Terms of Purchase: A;Fu (e, 5ri�uc7 oN (s ,r, 6E / Additions and alterations since purchase: FA.JiS,t D >u;e,< CFO& Cost of additions and alterations: t',cno Is property listed for sale? If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ /55itn0 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): 7 Y'ffe"s e<ile-- S gnature of Owner/p Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this•data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/88 33b012 /S 700 75 700 1/2/88 �CxX� 1/2/87 30G00 !!'/OC I'1 00 K (AA' .A;) Last Inspection: 3 /L/$2 Appraiser: John Sams Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History _Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 7 / $ / / $ 8oard of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: - 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Board of Review Assesing Dept. City of Eden Prairie 7600 Executive Drive Eden Prairie, MN. 55344 To the Board Members: We wish to appeal to you to reconsider the 1990 appraised value of our home. We have enclosed several documents that we feel will substantiate our appeal. page, 1. Copies of original closing statement. 2. 3. Plot map of neighborhood with assessed values shown. Circled items have been sold at that price within the last two years. (ours is lot 8, block 2) 4. Pictures of homes sold in our development. 5. 6. Listings of homes sold in Eden Prairie. 7. „ „ • 8. „ „ II Of the 84 properties sold in Eden Prairie in the past three weeks, only 13 of these exceeded our 1990 appraisal. We feel the housing values our decreasing rather than increasing. Any realtor you talk to will tell you it is a buyer's market for existing homes. We purchased one of the lowest priced lots in block 2 of the sub-division, yet our lot cost is now appraised as the third highest. Our 1990 appraisal is also higher than comparable homes in block 1, yet the lot costs in block 1 were $10,000-$15,000 higher. On the city assessor's worksheet, he stated that our house has 4 bathrooms, it does not. It also overstated the price of the fireplace at $3400. It is a free-standing fireplace with a brick front and was included in the price of the house. We did not pay extra for it. In closing we do not wish to be unfair, but we do desire to be treated fairly. Rasp tfully Sub fitted, Dennis E. Scheppmann Susan J. Scheppmann 16637 N. Manor Road Form AGeoo.d OMB Na 2502.0285 IDA 12.31.161 • U.S.DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND URBAN OEVELOPMENT • MINNESOTA SETTLEMENT STATEMENT I" TITLE 1 B TYPE OF LOAN _. I 0 F. 2 0 Err. 3 Ji3 CONY URN 6 FILE NUMBER 7 LOAN HUMMER B.MORTGAGE INSURANCE CASE NO. •0 VA 5 0 CONY INS C-3208 c. NOTE.II.I..m.•turn....to g'•e you.statement of Niue.e.Mment con.Amounts out to end by the Nnlenom went.re hewn R.me mu k.d m o e F w.e out outs.tun cioury.MN ere.Nwn nee to rnformeool.I purposes srrd AN not.11oU1 ed.1100 IWO. O NAME ANO ADORE SS OF BORROWER-. E NAME AND ADDRESS OF SELLER. F. NAME AND ADDRESS OF LENDER: ' Dennis E. Scheppmann Deutsch Construction Co. Coldvell Banker Residentia, Susan J. Scheppmann Mortgage Services Inc. . • o. PROPERTY LOCATION. M SETTLEMENT AGENT I. SETTLEMENT DATE: 16637 North Manor Road Title 1ns.Co.of Minnesota Eden Prairie, MN 55344 PLACE OF SETTLEMENT: July 14,1986 112 West 3rd Ave., Shakopee. MN 55379 ' J.SUMMARY OF BORROWERS TRANSACTION K.SUMMARY OF SELL ERE TRANSACTION 100.GROSS AMOUNT DUE FROM BORROWER: 400.GROSS AMOUNT DUE TO SELLER: .0t COn1NC1.,N.MI. SOT.ConIIMI Wnwne _ 102 Personal P.O.,.y 402.Pw1e111 omeerts -t03.5nnwnent cher.e.to 0nr,oww INn.1•D01 ,__3.4f16.71 •03 lop. Deutsch Construction n 44.000 00 •0'I- MS. ae 1_��..,.ww�,�--�..wr.rnn 2Sn00 40 •OS. /IE26Ih.IRKt1YoAgUelad IN Win in*Over. Aalu.tmenn for items Peed by Wier.R.dmoce • 106.City/town teen to 406.CRYhewn teen IC 107.Courts I.n t. 2o.4 1/7 S7 .^ •01.Counts Nees Io 106.Assessments IC 406.RunvnenN to 109. .09. Ill •11 112_ 412 • 120. GROSS AMOUNT DUE 420. GROSS AMOUNT DUE FROM BORROWER 171 761 71 TO SELLER 200.AMOUNTS PAID BY OR IN BEHALF OF BORROWER: 500.REDUCTIONS IN AMOUNT OUE TO SELLER: 701 Droont or eem..money 501 Esces.denon In tnllrueriontl 207 Ponrn..l.moull Cl new 1o.nl11 100,000.00 502.Settlement eltsr...tolener Mine 14001 703 EsutinoIo.n1.1.men whiny to 503.ExitNne Menlo'Nkrn sublets to 204 504 P.yoll of Iist mar."lyll ' 205. 505.PaYolf RI second metsege Nen . 206. 506. 201. 50/. 2OG. SEM 209 509. \ AdW.tmene to items unoerd by WIN Adjustments to item Nos.byte., 210.Cots/town Nees 510.City/town ton 10 711 County Nee. to 511 County yeses io 212.Assessment. to 512.AMwet.nn t0 • 717. 517. �_ 7t•. 514. 215 515. 716 516 217. 517. 216 516. 719 519 220. TOTAL PAID BY/FOR 520. TOTAL REDUCTION AMOUNT . BORROWER 100,000.00 DUE SELLER 300.CASH AT SETTLEMENT FROM/TO BORROWER 600.CASH AT SETTLEMENT TO/FROM SELLER JDI.:rms.mnunr due Iron ton"own Lime 1201 i n 21J_71T 601 Grout Ammon.MN to Miler Ilene 4201 307.Len amounts P+rd ho/tot Sorrow.,urn.7201 (I nr�nnn na 602.Ins m.o..in amount der se*Btm 5201 C ) 303.CASH ❑t FROMII❑ TOI BORROWER 23,243.71 603.CASH(0 TO1(0 FROM)SELLER ,- I...cueuo,reywrnn m.NU -1 Sntien.nt Summon..N go tit.bey o1 my knowledge end belie.a n e nut erS mew.t..ul.m.nt o1.N NON. y mod.. m ono..,„.enenr. nt w 0y me m me o.m.nwl.l MAW c.ndy gnat I Mw teve.0.Noy Al RN Settlement 51Mmenl Q$Q$Q$.'.'.' `CL \l/41[4.4. , :.c o .1)6} ,\ `11 10PTo __MA,' �� M�..Jl���.�- ---`` waaoWIRS SELLERS iNses- -...ww.-- nM 260 sty• .VIM • 'I- t0B1 1451 '. i -2' .A . L.SETTLEMENT CHARGES 750.TOTAL SALES/BROKER'S COMMISSION bawd on price 9 IP %. MID FROM PAID PROM I i Dloi•ion of Csmmiwlon)fine 700)as follows: UDRROWERS SELLERS 701.5 so FUNDS AT FUNDS AT 707.S to SETTLEMENT SETTLEMENT :4 1W Comminton pod el S.III.,nenl 704 500.ITEMS PAYABLE IN CONNECTION WITH LOAN . em.loan a.an.non e» _l+c to Caldwell e9Ak� 1 000.00 • 907 Loon nrmal arm l.j$ 2 to Coldwellat Banker 1,250.00 . em.Amrnfal Fee 775�g Io C.01dve11 Banker 5225 POC EN.Omni Rehm, 36.00 1O Caldwell Banker 36 POC • 905.Lender.Inuaepon F.. 55.00 SM.Ma19.P...mance*0010.hon En to ,'a 807.Aoumorron Fee aN•4449199T544 Taw Service fee 50.01 F e09 Mrto snt fee 35.00 1 RI^Annllcatinn fee 150.00 j e°pndtrwrl tf no fee 50.00 900.ITEMS REQUIRED BY LENDER TO BE PAID IN ADVANCE • 901 Inm,.,.Iran ul , ssS I Idw • 495.20 • 907.MOngap Insolence viwnn,m let months to . 903.Hormeln emumo nn Imu. ce Pr , t .to • 904 rem.to 005. . 1000.RESERVES DEPOSITED WITH LENDER 1001 Nay,d"'loran[. 3 ....was R s 1.. per month .I . 1007.Malin,nwr.nc. months SS p.,month '(; ywe• 1003 C lv hroh.,It Ia.n .non,ns R 5 pet month �'� l:Zj 1004 Ceun„'oroom1rla.n m n..S on month -SO -`- 1005 Amru.l m,n,.n.nn months 0 e ow month • 1.11;-... r.�J...ae.Y•f 1006. memos lS no.month t' �_yyL....1,1 1007 _-. .month,0 3 en.month I„ll V.Y/ 1009 Snot On mallet , -n. . 1100.TITLE CHARGES 1101.Snnem.nt or clown,Ire Io ) 7`0.00 21t1e_Ina. CO..of Minnesof 1101.Amnact o•pll.m.Ir^ 71t1e Ine. CO. of Mlnneeota ` 50.00 1103.rP...amn.hon ro 1104'Tlp*mwrance bt0d I to 1105.0000011.111101.00.1.00 1 1106.Nmaly Ian I 1107.P.no.ner f Imes I to �} lincludn above Item.numbers; . pe 1108.Tole Inn/ne. Imfit1.r._I, o. of L a 315.00 ^".) lincludet above ::::: 110Ln7Amas o T1tIn Inn-On. of Minnesota 20.00 nn 1200.GOVERNMENT RECORDING AND TRANSFER CHARGES Ni f701.Rreordm0 7w, 0»A f 23.00 1707 G :Mat9+n S I T SO :Rel..3 36.50 . ,rlca.nW I..nl.mm-17eeds .Mpnnns 1103 State I..n1Pmn Deed S :MOtlno.S 140.00 150.00 170s /_ 7os. • 1300.ADDITIONAL SETTLEMENT CHARGES 1301 5urvee to 1307.Pm mpwnen ,o 1303 1304 1305 1400.TOTAL SETTLEMENT CHARGES linty,on lino 103•Section J end 502,Section K) 3.986.71 HUD-I 15.1111 The HUD•1 S.Illemenl Statement which I here prepared Tea true.ndaccurato account of this trensection.These causedor will cause the funds to be disbursed in eccordence with this statement. A{ Snnrnom Ana Om WARNING:II is a crime no knowingly make list slatomtma tithe United Simeon this aansoun similar form.Peneibeetrpon....lien Can inetted.a Ono end lmprlsonmenl. For detest sms Tale IS U.S.Code Section 1001 and Section 1010. ere.. j4 • 0 1=:51, �e 141 r•fln/•I ,1 1/`I IT -- _-Jv1 35 :C �, I Y1111V\/1� 50 WM/lone of Ohs i9ewhwal •,I�1.- -- C L3 Tl- t•_ +•w of See.5,sufi,R 22.7 1„ ). Na.�9 456..571U.. 1� _ , / EXCEPTION o North I 656.�0 EXCEPTION __- 3800 -- 226.00 . aoco ,.00 so.00 ze,:q: 25o°1 ,I a _-- " _- �u e' to a 'e aan t r r I N I,A u��ry`� Nogg p, ` is.., I O, ,W ,o .4 I 1 ga,C OI'- O 1 u: 'u O I / 8 it 0 p_3.,2, 1 0 :nt al I 1 it O 0021 i z NI u'v_ mi I io W ,^,ae� B��Los'Ir'N . 4: Ia N G Ir l y,,l " T ri c? '� W. 2�ri _ . \ a�pE.L5- 1, 5q•5C31 E ---_ I �_1114�11 / 0396 L. _\' 86[L,- • I i=n� t.7., a- 'p t-, 9 772-0'.$5-71 Y,v3'Fa%se�\N 3•2o'45•'E ‘".0 I ��" \^ W �, m vi tn N \\ / Inl \ r 1"rC, a^ / OZ'26"f �" y .; of 13s ml �� �1 o°.y�� n iril �y� tam ci ,moo GI I Nf I� to ✓pe N I 1 11- a` / 4 8a1% x N • Orib ai, ? V _ M •V T s, til 9 3 ivm ro —:zsc z ro � o eV � ;, , `oiO� �-� tm to 9VI :1 8.m o I 210. 25 .2s.:2• ' e! O 0 V , _eV O •.." "E NJs// u l 00 ai•n 06" :L,' ul O > Z _ QVO`� 9 �'� `.� Iv /02.7e 20700 u I ° \ \► y H I i \ 't�� Cni m t-,i 11.'8 ' I 1 1 I �I o O W a Int t -4 «. H� i y m J tti •I to OD `'".I, to - rn <I \e 1 - rx+ H 1LJL!J a. ¶LL i/. 'OII c �L__ a o o re IT OO SSAO 5,0 #66038 #BR•4 #BA-1/1/0 STY-4LV/ ASUM L-S149,900 10/31/89 6 DAYS PTS-0 SO.6345 OLP-5149,900 S-$143,600 • A ' �`�" ". F' cV '•,t rfk R1 e'w t wp.9e 6453 168TH AVE W TAX S2325 /89/F MAP 40 -1A MUN EDEN PRAIRIE ZIP 66347 TWA SSAME AKE AR 592 SUB 1 COU HENN ASBS 0 ASP U NEAR DUCK LOT 84X205 ACR.4 HS FOR 1990/F YBL 1986 DIR DUCK LAKE TRAIL TD 168TH AVE WEST SPACIOUS 4-LEVEL CUSTOM HOME ON LARGE LOT...EXCELLENT LOC IN AREA OF HIGHER PRICED HOMES. IMMACULATE CONDITION PLUS TONS OF EXTRAS. QUICK POSSESSION... ASSUME VA 8.6 % NO QUALIFYINGIII LGL LOT 3 BLOCK 2 PURGATORY RIDGE P10 051 162 2130018 WAT CONN INCL REF,RNG,DWS.DSP.F/H APROX L APROX SEW CONN MPH.D/P IA 2 15X16 18 2 14X10 FPL Y AIR C TERMS THA,VA,CON,ASM,C/D,• 0R 1 11X10 28 2 12X12 HEA FA /GAS MTG S108000 INT 8.6 % ID 1 INCI 3B 2 11 X10 EXT HBMAS EXF VA 0D 86 ASM Y KT 1 I4X11 48 3 21X14 BSM W.P.L PIN S850 2MC N 2MA N FR 4 29X15 WK4 16X10 GAR 2.D.Y C/D POSSIBLE FSZ 1335 WILL BE SOLD HT RI M8T Y FSF 2300 SON 272 SOP 937.1650 1633584 AGN SUE BLACKSTONE 881-8503 BB Y SA 3.15 LTY ER Y E S.INC..REALTORS 6349 OFPI4 888-7001 APT 888.3714 NOV SII OMR.4 VIA III/0 S.SPE/CONV L.S 119.900 09/22 b 1E1 DAYS 11.SO7S 59.5377 LA.90000 INTO P7S•00 S•S117.500,7 TYPE-RIFE CLR OLP4124.000 ,01 wi•ft ► om' 4501 w 14874 AVI TAT 31180 111 MEP 40 .11 vox MEN PRAMM 7/55741 148 W AS SO LAU 9S1 517 SUR 7 COUNTY HENN AR 0 PENO N .•51081110 ACO HS FOR tots F 741911074 31 CO R0 4 10 NCI TARE TRAIL NORTH ON 148114 HILL 11R1 f 0N1 OWNER NOME ON GORGEOUS LO7 SURROUM0101Y UPPER 1RAC111 HOMES PI VERY FRRNOLY MEIGMIORH000 MDME 117051TSEIf WILL FOR EN7ERTAMING.TWO WALROU7 AREAS.1 FROM iW fmRM 4401 FROM THE FIMSHFOIAUNORY 11145EE SUPPLEMENT IGN 101 J.,1111_MAJESI IC OARS A0017101E 170S_114.L7 770014 CW CW.CD :NCL RNG.OWS.OSP.FAN 11R0. l 4PR04 CS COCO MPM,WSH.ORY.QIC 1TM 17814 18l 20173 PPLY ARC ITRMS FHACON,C7SCRf '•�V 11813 IR 1A 1E117 We FA OAS AITGSO 7N1\0 38 M 14810 FAT W000.5. 7YPF-COI 000 ASM11 •'M 17112 Al M10110 115E71 WO P4.S0 711 CON ASMM ,1 Il 7411R GAR 2. CO OWNER MIGHT CONSIDER 7R"7 1345 151100 CARRYING C'O W 1E73.000 ON 1.1'TA 77574_1A4 117344 50771 P88037.1150 4531114 4.GUI(EROE WE 2101 5 3 15 1 ER 1,11•A 81A1 TY WC SITS 0fP.94A 7107 APT 9A17107 i ••SC 13415A ISUP11 A00 4S01 W WITH AVE ••1 4FEl/0711791S THE GARAGE • ,4 II 171MSMF0 WAIN MI FLOOR.FANELLI°WALLS. 1314 0f/UN T WS FOR STORAGE 1 TOOLS IMANDY MANS .41 w1 PLUS 1f HAS SCREENS THAT ATTACH TO THE GARAGE 7Y11Y INA 1 MARES FORA HIM.GET AWAY FOR THE HOT 7 w1 R MGM7S TNIS R US101Y PRESENT OWNERS AS A .'.w All SUMMER AN0 A5 A GARAGE ALL WINTER WHAT A •4wh1UNI71Y FOR THE NEW OWNER ••`AM 4 VAS IN DROOL.IN LOWIR 1EVEI AS MASTER THERE IS AA f STY W AY 10 MARI A DOOR THAT LEADS TO THE 37 A BATH •1 WT11 RE 1 W P R1 E HI 15 IT DR 1ATM110081. • .413 I SHARI0 TAMR♦AM W ROUGH-W PT WASING W WALL 10 1111NR00M • 12Y ws Thursday/March 22/1990/Star Tributes Hennepin County real estate Mfonmetlen for the weekly listing of real 724 Edon halls Rd./425.000.WO. 5717 Duncan Av./5144.000.WO. acute that has Mon sold Is taken from 7247 Eden Prairie Rd./550.000.CD. 6566 Prance Av.S./5150.756.WD. certificates of value Mtlte Wsotepin County 7247 Eden Prlk%Rd./$21.000.WO. 416 Ronson Av.S./1100.000.WO. Government Center.CD denotes contract for 9957 Edgebroek Pl✓s50.000.CD. 60611MMachon Bluff/1295.000.WO. deed;LWD denotes limited warranty deal; 14431 Palma,/07-411$07.WO. 14920 Ironwood Cou,t/1160,500.WD. OCD denotes quit claim deed;PD denotes 9963 Hempehke Lane/$85.000.WD. 4501 Orford Av.4106,700.PRO. probate deed;ED denotes executor deed; 7936 Island Rd./5137,500.We. 4606 Sunnyside Rd./1415.000.We. PAD de ntes personal repreaentative deed; 10100 Juniper Lene/140.000.WD. 1710 Vernon Av.8./173.500.WD. -� WOdenols womanly deed;SWD denotes 10101 Juniper Lane451,000.We. special warranty deed. 10106 Juniper pea/$40,000.We.10116 Jw Wt llpe e/536,500.WO. Hopkins opkins 16444 S.Manor Rd✓5146.500.W O. 19143 Maple Leaf Dr./5105.000.We. 5457tft Av.11./193.500.WO. Corcoran 10461 imety Morning Lone4359.762.WO. tots Jim An.S.,17/139.900.We. 1151 Neill Lake Rd./375.500.wD. 109 Ridgewood Dr./566,900.W51. 19200Weckomore Rd./1195,000.WO. 6926 Rosemary Rd./5125.000.WO. 119 Smetana Rd./129500.CD. 19949 Larkin Rd./43,000.WO. N32"Weal Lem'$123000.WO. 942 Westbrooke Way*5/535.000.WO. 9610 Squire Late/518165.9.WO. Mt144 Stewart Dr.4155A00.CD. Dee haven 15910 Summit Drds76.a0o.CD. Lake P 11995 Sunnykrsek M./555.100.Woe Long 6061 Timber Lake Dr-462.000.WD. 19905 Aeuro Adr5100.000.W0. 574 N.Brown Rd.fa/514000.CO. 6596 Timberlake 545000.WO.WD. 5160 Hooper Lake Rd/s45,000.CD. T696 Vera Cawt/54&000.WD. 262 Charter 4/S71,000.CD. 16764 Weston aay Rdr1220.000.WD. Eden Prairie Medina Edina 6441 Abbott Cewl4345.150.WO. 460 Ridgeview ckcie4150,000.WD. 9451 Abbott Cowt/164.000.WO. 4213 W.42nd 51.4124.000.ED. 10220 Antlers Rldge/$65.000.WO. 6732 Apache Rd./5530,000.We. 69e1 Autumn Terrace4118.000.WD. 4370 Brookside Court a321/s149.900.WD. Minnetonka 11307 Dlueste m Lae/5580.000.WO. 5625 S.creek vary Rd./$170,000.WD. 15117 Boulder Pointe Rd.464,800,We. 1005 Dewey RN Rd./$250,000.WO. 3523 Arbor Lane/5127.500.WO. 11972 CMetmokn Laee/590.000.WD. 9751 Dorset Lane/593,976.WO. 10311 S.Carr Lake Rd/535,601.WO. 465 Darnel Rd./5129.900.WD. I i II Star Tribune/Thursday/March 29/1990 W5 :Real estate , Reunions e Information for the weekly hating of Henne- 14924 Glen Oak St'5190.500 WD. Robbinsdale Cooper/ pin County real estate that has bean sold Is 4035 Highland Rd.%5127.000.WD. High schools Class of 1970.summer 1990.(800) taken from c.1,hcatee of value at the Hen- 5541 Lakeland Rd..5111,300 WD 0010. nepm County Govemment Center.The 3071 Lakeshore Brad✓596,000.CD. Alexander Ramsey/ St.Louis Park/ amount puohshed is the amount listed on 4604 Lynwoed Terrace/S117.500.WI) C1a55 of 1970.July 14.938.1571. 24-26,920-402 Class of 1970.Aug. me certificate as the purchase price,but 17113 Minnetonka Blvd.45400.000.WD. Anoka/ Cla ClaSt Paul Central/ because mortgage assumptions or sales on 14101 Mount Tenecez$134,500.wD. Class o1 1964.Aug.18(80D)397-0010;contract ter deed Shen involve only a down 5575 Nantucket Rd.Z899.800.wD. 1970.fall 1990,476-2230. Class of 1940.June 15,1990,698-' payment,the amounts given here may not 11112 S.Oak Knoll Terrace/5100.000.CD. 1950.July 21,423-4461:1955,Aup reflect me total once of the sale.CO de- 3667 Oekton Ridgei5281 938.WO. Buffalo/ 888-5850. notes contract for deed;LWO denotes lime- 2290 Sherwood Court'5146,000.WO. Class of 1945,July 21,498-8538. St.Paul Johnson/ eo warranty deed:OCD denotes quit claim 15453 Susses Dr./591,750 W0. Chaska/ Class o1 1970.1990,731-3250. Seed.PO denotes probate deed;ED denotes 15554 Susie.Dr./583.995 WD. Class 011980,Aug.18,920.2601. St.Paul Mechanic Arta/ executor deed:PAD denotes personal repro- iseoo White Pine Dr.�E220.000.WD. Farmington/ Class 011940.Sept.14-15,227.58� *emotive deed:WD denotes warranty deed; 4220 Wilson St./599.500.WD. Class of 1965.Aug.4 460-6100 sW 0 denotes special warranty deed. 4136 windndge Circle/2123.000.CD. , .Cradle / 1955,summer 1990,488-0865. 5107 W000gate Court/5169.000.wD. Class e�1980.Aug.11,(800)391-0010. St.Paul Wilson/ No kips/ Class o11943,August.484-5725. P St.Thomas Academy/ Chanhassen Minnetrista Class of 1950,July 21.935 7248.1970, Classes 011940,1945,1950,1955, Aug.18.19.935-2121. 1960,1965,1970,1975,1980 and' 19011 E.Lake Dr.17,750.000.WO. 1590 N.County Rd.110;2130000.WO. Howard Lake-Waverly a0 May 4-5,454-0090. 7814 114th An.N,i573,900.WD. All classes.June 23,543-2749. litillwsteN 6325Mark CAv./224000 0. Mound Minneapolis Central/ 205 Mark ClrcteN524,000.WO.O. Class o1 1970.July 21,430.1 d86. 206 MetCacte/52a,000.WO. Class Of 1940,Sept.21-23,93d-d548; White Bear Lake/ 521804•0ew PlaceZSI s0.000.WO. 5579 Auditors Rd./5120.000.CO. 1960,June 29,544-6660;1970,June Class of 1945,June 15-17,429.706 r'.',90ebswelae.IS179.900.WO. 3026 Highland Blvd./5206,000 WO. 23.625-4520. 53200abaerPlacai5166.800 WD. 3031 Highland 81vd./572.500.CD Minneapolis Edison/ 9404Padside Circle/5110000.WD. 3017 Longfellow Lane/565.000 WO. Class of Jan.1938.April 28 789-9405; Other/ 2700 Tyrone Lanai558,500.WO. Jan.and June classes of 1940.June 8, Dee haven 2724 Tyrone Lane/568.100.WO. 781.8846;1950,June 9,435-6147. Minneapolis International Deep haven Patrick Henry/ Training in Communicatior 19920 Cottagowood Av.'5130.000.WD. Orono Class o1 1970,June 30,535-5054. All torrmer members,April 7.533-8 16452 Heamcote Or.'5175.000.WO. Minneapolis Roosevelt/ Oak Terrace Nursing Home • 3656 Therese 5t476.501.WO. 155 Bederwood Dr.'2 7,000.wo. Class of Jan.end June 1930,May 5, Glen Lake TB Sanatorium/ 3271 Casco Circle/569.000 WO. 872-8574 or 835.5619:Jan.1941,Sept. All former employees and patients, -- 4eeoCreekwood Trai;'S107.000.WO. 29-31,721-4327;1970,Aug.11.443- 19.934.4100.ext.204. • Eden Prairie 2565 Dunwoody Av./2575.000 WO. 2855:1975.Aug.18.832.5140.1985, University of Minnesota 4470 North Shore Dr.'585.000.WD. July 28.459-8222. College of Agriculture/ 11304 Btuestem Lane'5330.000.WO. 1447 Park Dt.5176.500.WO. Minneapolis South/ Classes 0f 1940 and 1965,May 20, 1e587 Chennault way/5154.850.WD. Class o1 1930.June 30,929-3896:1936, 7473. Bets Cottonwood Lane/2180.390 WO.9798Crestwood T5n001 PI 1' ouch Sept.26,721-7978:January class of University of Minnesota 808 6 Curtis Una i5103,500 eda WI)WD... WD. Plymouth 1940.Sept.14,854-6892;1950,July 28, Institute of Technology/ 9519 Hartfon1174.351.WD 17200 end Av.N./$112.903.w 729.5678. o. Class of 1940.July 26.28,624-103L 19092 Joseph Cunei5108.500.WD. 18505 5th Av.N./5177.000 WO. Minneapolis Washburn/ School,military and professional 19164 Joseph Curve.'5112.500.WO. 17125 11th Av.N./575.550 WO. January and June classes of 1940,June group reunions that will occur in th 10386 Juniper Lane/579.300.CO. 16030 24th Av.N.'$d6.000.WI) 22.24,929-9404,1950,June 22-24,835- Twin Citiea will be listed in this col 16943 Knatie Lane/5169,500 WO. 10615 301h An.N./550.000 WI) 1760. from March through October.Item! acts Lakeland Av.N.464,900.WI). 18435 N.30th P1./5157,000.WO. Mound/ must be submitted in writing 10 de 9905 Linden Dr.-2112.000 WD 10540 43rd An,N.'S56500 WD Class o!t980.Aug. -5.588-0W5. 7525 Mumneli Rd,i52 121.800.CD. 11635 45th Av,N.'5169 000 WO. 9 before publication.Please mail or< 6426 Morgan Lane/563,000 WI). 1550547th Av.N.'599.900 W0 Richfield/ liver to: 7148 Mulrfeld Lane'$112.100 WD. 16605 49th An.N.'2105.100 WO. Class o1 1965.July 28.861.4934. Community Reunions 16780 North Manor Rd./2241.000.WO. 11620 52nd Av.N.1106.000.WI) Robbinsdale/ Star Tribune 9535 Olympia Or.%S59 900.WO. 1079953rd Au.N.i£156.000 WO. Class of 1945.Aug.24,938.7812:1970. 425 Portland Av.S. 9535 Olympic Dr.'2330.000.WD 11025 53rd Av.N.460.000.WO. Aug.18.424-3610. Minneapolis,Minn.55488 7375 Ontano Blvd.,2165.000 WO. 2735 N.Cheshire Lane'51000000 W0. 6263 Sequoia Cire'S15r.000.WO. 500 Cottonwood Lane'5269.900 W0. Robbinsdale Armstrong/ cl 10614 Sherman Dr./5100.500 WD. 3000 County Rd.101•5125.000.OCO. Class o1 1980.Aug.11.553.7842. 12000 Sunnybrook Rd./530.296.WD. 15600 County Rd.9'S575.317.WO. 15477 Tnsvam Way'943.000 WD 4405 N.Harbor Lane,2207,000.WD. - 14325 Weslndge Dr.'5112.000 WO 655 Holly Lane/5228,000.WO. • 9559 Woodridge Circle'S120.500.WD 1885 Ithaca Lane'515.000.WO $ P i ./.'1 6040N.Jonquil Lane'S12o.00D WO. DENTURE RELINE 9S '' ->:,✓ 3510 N.Kumar Lane'921t.000.CD. WHILE YOU WAITures whilesleep. "CELEBRATE WINTER" Edina 4710 Kmpawaw Lone 5156 t 89 WO Dent you LIVE ON TONKA 35 Nathan Lane,#120i453.000 Wo. $400/MO&UP 472-4939 4275 w.slat St,01101B1.900 ED. 35 Nathan Lane.,011B'S55.183.WO. A location neer you. . te_a _au,.ns , 311 Arthur St i S218 765.WO. 1415 N.Dskvtew Lane'Si 10.900.WD 4519 Browndale Av./2325.000 WO. 4160 N.Orchid Lane'2137.000.WD. 929-0378 '.,, , 4922 Bruce Av.i$355.000 WD. 4513 Orchid Lane,5100.243 WO. 7500 Cahill Rd..a 3270-148.000 WD. 4620 N.Orleans Lane'1129.800.WO. 53640 Colnce Way.atAr9000 00W WD. 5625 PlymoutOulnwob Lanea1 3 6.640.300 WO.WD. �� f■ SHOE REPAIR Cooper An.'5170.000.ECr. 6316 Portland Av.5.,570 000 WO. 4640 France Av1700000.0. WD. 5625 GN1land Uee270.0 000.W0. 6566 France Av.S..0609'£125000 WO. 5625 Ouinwood Line'S138,500.W0 212 Hsmson Av.'564 500 WD. 4850 N.Renchwew Lane/2106.500 WO 418 Hannon Av.5.r53.820 OCD. 2335 Rosewood Lane N.5146.000.WD. 4936 France Avenue S.•Peteraons,Edina Mall 7 250 Lewis Ridge Pkwy,a 209'5139.500. 4310 Rosewood Lene'S66 400.WO, ,70 4310 Rosewood Lane!567.800.WO. e f•��O A 6085 Lincoln Dr„eI15i586.500 WD. 4980 Rosewood Lane'5234.500.WO. •Quality Shoe Repair 6105 Lincoln Dr.,e328'591,500.WD. 4995 Rosewood Lene1199.500.WD. •Complete line of shoe&leather 4062 Sunnyside Rd./$100.000 WD. 5790 Rosewood Lanai$d9.900 WO. care products while 15 Washington Av.S.:51,725.000.CO. 18458 Terrecevlew Lane'579.900.WO. 7220 York An.5.,0109/S74,000.WD 4300 N.Trenton Lane,0215450.250 WO. •Keys duplicated you 4300 Trenton Lane,e320.139.152.WI). •Scissor&knife sharpening wait! 1310 Urbandale Lana'5137.000.WO. •Established 1946, �►o a,` Excelsior 3640 Vinewoed Lane'5217.000 WO. V Wedgewood Lane WO. 922-4356 pa 274 George St.i£57 900 WD 2400 N.xenium Lene�Sa.t00.000 WO Star Tribune/Thursday/April 5/1990 W5 7Y Real estate 4101 Thomas Av./11105.000.WD. 5241 Westmill Rd./S110,000.WO. • Information for the weekly listing of Hemp Minnetrista pin County real estate that has been sold is Edina . taken front certilicates of value at the Hen• 7220 Hwy.7/5138.500.WD. nepin County Government Center.The 5816 Bernard PL,6135,000.WD. amount published is the amount listed on 5532 Brookvlew Av./590,300.CD. the aerdlkste as the purchase price,but 7510Cahill Rd./671.500..WD. d Moun because mortgage assumptions of sates on 5909Concord Av./$95.000.WO. 8�8 contract for dead often Involve only a down 3501 Fuller St.493,500.WD. payment,the amounts given here may not 6105 Halifax An.S./5122.000.ED. 0014 Bayport Rd./$82.000.WD. reflect the total price of the sale,CD de- 7129 Heethenon Trail/6122.000.CO. 6000 Beechwood/5120,000.CD. notes contract for deed:LWD denotes limit. 7112 Lanham Lane/5300.000.W0. 2055 Grandview 8./$60.000.WO. ed warranty deed;OCD denotes quit claim 5224 Richwood Dr./5155,000.WO. 3030 lalandvIew Or✓5132,900.WD. deed;PD denotes probate deed:ED denote. 5605 Shannon Dr.i5243,000.W0. 4240 North Shore Or./568,500.WO. executor deed:PRD denotes personal repro- 5917 View Lane,6192,500.W0. 5410 Three Points alvd./340.900.WD. sentafive deed:WI)denotes warranty deed: 6612 Warren Av./5124,900.W0. SWD denotes special warranty deed. 5304 WMdser/5115.000.ED. 6833 Wooddate Ay.S./6279900.WD. Orono 20 Woodland Rd-/3450,000.WD. 21606th An.N./6273,000.CD. • Corcoran 3051 farvlew La«/S1A50.000.CD. Excelsior 3525Ivy Pt/6140.000.WD. 8920 County Rd.19/55.500.WO. 150 let SL/591.000.CO. Plymouth Deephaven Greenfield 1151025th Av./1.4112,900.WO. 20560 Carson Rd./$111,500.WD. 15625 26th Av.N.,MA/674.996.WD. 7345 Clay St.590,500.WD. 15630 26th An.N.,MD/593,000.WI). 15821 27th Av.N..483,750.W D. Eden Prairie 1472531st Ay.N,/569,000.WO. Hopkins 1232013945 4433rd An.N./345.000.WO. 5850 Alpine TniV 31 W.WO.CO. 14515 44th Av.N./6157.500.WO. 18521 Avon Court/6100,000.CO. 3096M Av.N.459.900.WO. 1486345th Av.N./$135,000.WO. 18521 Avon Court/3100.000.WD. 222 7th Av.N./683.900.W0. 1100551st An.N.16152,000.WD. 7229 Aron Lane 577.250.WO. 3018th Av,N,/380,000,W0. 9895 Buckingham Dr.:6136.000.W0. 28W SIM Ay.N./349.9W.WO. 6250Ces«wood Dr./St35.W0.WD. - 2380ArcherLane/5204,500.WO- 14244 Chestnut Dr./$88.500.WD. Medina 1980 Juneau Lana/$75,2W.WD. 15600 N.Eden Or✓5107.000.wD. 2986 LawntlaN Lane/S54.OW.WO. 7473 Eileen St./5150.700.WO. 3120 Cedar Av./$125.000.W0. 2985 Lawodale Lane/630.0W. 17867 Evener Way/5109.359.W D. 2985Lawndale Lens/5340,898.W0. 6472 fellbrook Rd.:St 99.950.W0. 2725 Magnolla/575900.WO. 9529 Hartford Circle,579.900.WD. 3980 Orchid Lane/687,200.W0. 16361 Hilltop Rd./S95.000.WD. Minnetonka 2530 N.Queensland Lars/5175.000.WD. 19207 Lotus View Dr.:5117.000.wD. , 3200 N.Queensland Lane/5123500.WO. 18644 Maple Leaf Or./5125.000.WD. 4201 Chriaty Lene/$148,500.WD. 44i4 Urbandale Court/S96.000.CD. 9715 Mix Creek Dr./696900.wD. 5831 Covington Terrace/575.000.WD. 2430 Yuma Lane/$255,000.WO. 11352 Mount Curve Rd./6345.000.WD. 18305Creeks Bend Dr.:569,580.WO. 450 2lnnfe We/538,000.WD. 8678 Pine Bluff Court/6115,000.WD. 1441 Durham Rd./S125A00.WD. 9717 Purgatory Rd,/5174,000.W0. 16604 Edgewood Av./5106.000.WO. • 10446 Sherman Dr./$94,000.WD. 10441 OreenbnerRd.,M309/643.502.WO. Shorewood 9380 Spring Rd./5163.000.WO. 12605 W.Holloway Rd./$260,000.W0. 7005 Springhill Circle/593,000.WD. 3528 Dakton Dr./6140.000.CO. 28325 Oak Leal Tre114190,526.W0. 18369 Tristram Way/555.000.WO. 154173015um Lane4105.000.WD. .WO. 814001d Chaska Rd.477,000.WO. 7362 Walnut Court/$140.000.WO. 8695 Weswind Circle/6115.000.WO. 17002 The Strand/690.000.W0. 6305 Whispering Oeka Dc/389.90S CO. Appeal No. Ia 0 Date Received 4/12/1990 PID # 10-116-22 14 0111 Appraiser Farl lent APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 941-ii d-h, Name: Q q�,, p ,.�n,vr+� 9� %1(��A4t d, W� k � , �Ae,t2_ Address of Property: 'J.v.01 (1; e.c,v-- 1• S h-etc.hcL JS'34 6 January 2, 1990 valuation a it appeaps on the notice: $ /g/ So 0 Date property was acquired: 1gf,4 Purchase Price: $ /7i.i Otl O Terms of Purchase: ,' / p 1i Additions and alterations since purchase: - -c>-it_¢_ Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? -n_o If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ / 'I V, o e o What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? , (Please attach supporting information): /� 9 �/l'...e .'O cam.# c P I�`.h 1 , 2/-a-&c.e� ,x ' m aches -Le.--i7 n -Ar4.d -1,.i,o%e-rc..c_e_t� //il u.t?-L.%�9, r�-a-,4 .ri,?..= �a�� .e ah1.. s/ (- �,c�,ye.a,� /9 S7 9 tit, 0-.1-4 o.t._.e of y 0-0e., //g, ae-.o Signa 4.of 06fnet/141-' Please note: This for4n requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 445DD0 154,500 ig1SoO 1/2/88 36H00 I Ste,00 /7aoop 1/2/87 35000 133cLO /4:4000 i. Last Inspection: '? IL/1S Appraiser: ira.l Ze bet" Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments i cu/AR r $17.100() C,wo.G./ / / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Addition Appeals received after April 13th, to be added to your Board of Review packet for April 19, 1990 • I 1 L' f(uy,sn1I time tll p� Ir T 1De WI, LLI Prope,ery basement.na AnetYeb YNiFORM RESIDENTIAL APPRAISAL REPORT rite No.6r,1 isr_•., Pmcerlr Veto 7:56 Unfair sit boulevard Census Dad 260.U1 LENDER.USCSET%%OARY USE err Eden Pras 3e Ca1ny Hennepin._. Sbk PIN LO Cale 55344 Sak Roe S + Lega Uesc010n Lot a Kock Prairie Knoll 2nd Addition Date Owle Ocenoant J e or °r F ant f,0Uf man M p Nekrorr. .l;-qtl Mortgage Amount $ Care Price 5 FJ/A Dare or San N/A FRC/PERTY RIGHTS APPRAISED Mortgage type Loan ennfoeTiounces9ons lo be RA!trySen S N/A X_,!foe Ample Uscount Rants and Other Concessions RE S q D , y I Ei 1 ir N ha 199O SA M, N/A [_ i Leavhord Prof by Seder $ 1 Lente.0 Jam Tr 1.1 m I..auf man [ ICmeun/tom 1HUDYVAI al 77..56 (Tatar 1n PIvsl.. Ed(:n Pr ale le'. MN I--i U.M r"T PUO S rti T LUCAIIUN L Dba11 IX f Suourbm, 1-fool NEIGHBORHOOD ANALYSIS Gene arp far Rem I BUY(UP 1 X i Ove 75', [ 125 75% r 4 1 U bcr 25'.i Emyloereebl Stabrhty a]O❑❑ p GROWTH OPERT RATE 1 I Naga X I sled,lane 1 1 A Convene rce to Employment l - `}PROPERTY VALUES I X,like "q `15!aae 1 Ifyecm.g Lwwen enc.Io Stopping X .Lrm,j, L .'P DEMAND.SUPPLY 1 Sno lag. 1 X j h Balance I 10 r SooDo Convenencn 10 Schools rX�L_ ) y}MAPKF IP:$11011 X I Snow 3 M t-l 3 6 Mors I 1 Ovet 6 Mu, Mo0aAcy le Pablo bansPoilalmn LJ O CI CI .PRESENT LAND USE cAleG USE CNANGC PREDOMNANt SNIFF FAMILY TIMING Amend,Fat*!ee Xl ��r�'�t Bops Family 9l• N tkey FX]OLCEIPANCY S�eAI (Oil Adeouaey a Ut*Iks (� l IJ ] t o Family Likely Li owner Ill-Xi sit property Cornpat taut„ [,%] .:'Mu!Inbmrhy In PIu'-e50 Tenant Ll 125 I, New Protection oom Detnmentll Cab. [], �_ r Carnercar to Vacant(0 5?sl [X 1 1.90 INA� P0oe A Fire Ptotectwn LrT_-1' IMatral _. Vacant(ova 541f tooreomal General Aopeaarce of eropertrs XX R R Vacant 10 170 - 2 Appeal to MarkelI ,..4 X 1 Note Race or Me racial conpos,ton 01 ate nephOMOOod are ret considered reliable appraaal factors COMMENTS The sub,Lect property is located 1 bloc': north of Valley View Rd. & 1/2 mile east of Eden Prairie Rd. or led. q in the cityofEden Prairie. The immediate area consists of qua'ity_bui Lt eplit_l eve! &�etory style homes similar to the subject property. This area appears well maintained. • Dmensens Irregular - 'see attached) Topography ;lopes to rear • mow'- Site Area 9i756sq.ft_capprox.) Cane Lot No Sme Avu. for area RompCWssiteauon Residential loans Come:ance Conforming Shape lyre ul ail HIGHEST A BEST USE Resem Use loess dent i al DIM Use Damage dyppears admavate ' t UTttiIES Public Oiler SITE IMPROVEMENTS Type Public %mate Vow of wetland area Elethel), IT] _ ____ Street M phalt Latbscadog deal Gas rt-'l CublGupet Concrete �_' DNeway Placktoo Water N. --'—_ --Snewalk Cpnn�rQte Li *Tana'Easement' in,I_G al Sammy Sewer (X 1 Street Lome Yes [� L FEMA Flood Hazard Yes' No ___d.2 ...._._.._..._._.. I__ FEMA'Map/Zone Swim Sewn. �l(] Aury None n COMMENTS(Apparent adverse easements.arroactmenrs.specral assossmems.We auras,etc I Ther e_wen a_cio_yndvgr sg-t,QDS1,SS1 on5 or encroachments noted. Typical utility easements. GENERAL DESCRIPTION EXTERIOR DESORPTION FOUNDATION BASEMENT INSULATION Units 1 Foubatan Concr.blk Slap None ___ Area Sp.N 12E'0 Root Stores Exterior Whits Wood Gawl$pace None %Ft itreO 25Y. Caleg E n Type(Der/AftI Det_ Root Sunace Asph_Shng Basement Yes Ceitnp Drvwajl Walla _... O.K.(Slytej 2-story Cullers AOwmpts Ad eq.Ovhg Sump Rrmp Yes_ Nhls Drywall Floor „E.uunp Yes Window Type Easement Dampness No. evid.Flom None Blase Proposed No Storm Sash Yes Setnemenl No. evi d:Ouube Emry Yes Adeooacy Under Constructor No Screens Yes mlestaton No. evid. Elegy Moro hems Age(Yrs) Manularroe0 foorr No Ellttllve Axe IYrn)1- RCU,'S iweer _ !nvnig Denny Kil0hba Den-_family Rot HOC Re Bedrooms •Bach Laundry Other Aea Sp Ft. Basement _ _ .1. R.1._Area _ 12E10 Lrvel! area t r_ 11 _12� .Levei7 - __-' o 2 1 1 396 FmM.ned area store Grade contains 7 Room, 7 Bemoonks!. 2 Bamisi 1.676 Souse fed or Gross bong Area • SURFACES Malcnal.,LoodAwn HEATING KITCHEN EQUIP. ATTIC IMPROVEMENT ANALYSIS iaod Ara fan Rwr Fwrs Carpet/Good Type FWA Rdrgeralm [M I None ❑r.7 Quality d Construction Wilts Ur ywa l l/Good Fuel Gas Pargel0ven XI Stairs LI Condition of Improvements tL�.1;j Tnm7Fmsh Ga¢/Good Corbuwn Good Dspasal 71 000 Slair 1 Room SveslLayat Bath 1100r V 1/Good 7dogoacyGood Dishwasher [5]Scuttle [j Closers and Storage X���...111 Bain Wainscot Cerems c/Good COOLING Far/Rood �]Floor Li Energy Mooney Doran :toal-core/Gtl. Cenval Yes Compactor rj Heated El FMmbrrr AOepuacy ACohoaion X Otte Wa nerlDye LX f Fnrsnetl � Elenrrcar•Apepwry 8 Cpnddion X Condlron Good Mcowave [X] L-i Kitchen Cadrets•Ahgwcy V Cool.F,M cty.. l a I Aoed c1Good ten an ill — El Comdat:41y to Neighborhood 0 tI CAR STORAGE &Page K qll rso 1 X I Ailed.: rX f House Entry LX]Appeal V Markeablay No Cars 2 Carport I] Detached LI,inadequate [L 1 Nabob Ent o L1 Estimated Remould;Economo Lae 63-64 Yrs. �,C0n0mon Good Noce 1 Bmlt-tn ( 1 Electric Door(-1 Basement Entry! 1 Estimated Remamirq Physrll Lite N/A Vs • Anomonalteawres 5l:yl[9ht o. ceiling fall., setback thermostat, transient heat in basement, small X 10' wood deck„ basement family room is partially fib shed • ready for millwork & carpeting. _ Deprecator(Priysrral runt oral and Werner lna0Fgwpe,leper needed nlasemRtron,etc 1 There were no functional or physical inadequacies noted. No required rEiasrs noted, 150 Amp electric • service. GPM.i master[momda ant preva-Mt and moan in Subrecrnrana area regarding loan discoU116.:Meteor 0Wdowns and concessions No unusual finanrang or excessive buytlowns, discounts or concessions in subject marketing set., to. ......,..1 rn,e6 .S�J • UNIFORM RESIDENTIAL APPRAISAL REPORT site tie. %OWN.,Seel.Pn I Ppm,or Aptarsnp,to nhowe Ma•ket Vex as genet rn me CeramAn.I Statement 0 lrm,1 Condom, 81•Let-±1,8101(NOM GROSS LIMP AMA At/SAL WEI I ESTOAATED REPREWCIION COST.NEW-Of IMPROVEMENTS Dwervg 1,676 So Ft ea S 50.00-$ 87,802_ 2 x 17.5 x .. 27.00 Psennt 34500 ft.$ 8.00 - 271fP9 11 x .75.5 y: = 2130.50 E.N.6 App I s. B. C/A • 1.7 y: 211 x . 7 6.oo r 1 r ep 1 AC Ft -- . 2,000 2 B x -.25.5 x r. 204.VO soeco Eneov Otisiert hems - 11.5 x .75.5 0 .,- 408.25 Ppenes P.m<etc Lump sum - 1000 :774641) - 1.5 1. Its ,: := 24.00 bareMba.pb.i 440 SO El.S 12.00- 5,280 • 18 et 2.2 , 96.Vet ION Eshmated Cosi tie. -$ 98,840 • - Total I.f.(3I-ira 1 I vino Area = 1,675.75 hiss/al t funtOonat• Erewnat Lee Depecrato.2965 .10 ICJ -S 2,965 • ("teemed Vow et topipornerns -$ 95,875 . So imp-as ts-(orivewa).landsoaPtng.etc/ -$ .5•09,1 P. ESTIMATED Set VALUE -$ 79,000 II?teaseled snow o+N maseAND value i INDICATED VALUE IT CDST APTITIALN -S 137,875 11101621, trielimmoo 0,Pedro ES,and t route Wel Constructron Warranty i_1Yes W No Does oto;totty annloirn IA annticattle MOO/VA properly standards, ED Yes LI No harm et Warranty Progtam N/A (INo.Potato Vearranty COVerage EetreS N/A .wean.5 r.•moreg anoe+R.aaaa....kV,ream an*,i at.aroarnew to sang.ene toe caracerra mesa in.FM+.en....ine de...+CR...a.. S...Wart,mesamsraanan to I..a....ltrh.CAN ren.ant.acen tSe sonwo and<mower,prone•rws it a WM+.dem el nle c......0.......... •..Zsarni:Ze'al:Zn'In'a'sa7a:t,R.I.7arai'usl.'I'a .-.71rX.:.;LZt."..'f 7,'+..Zc'aLr:trI/:g.....-.ITEM SUBJECT COMPARABLE NU 1 COMPARABLE NU 2 COMPARABLE NO.3 Al,,,, 7.356 7384 Ontario .., 16391 Manor Road 7221 Mui rf ield „Int ar i o Ell vpoul ever d c,2.3--' T;.4.-L.8.4 . Plesmito to Smoot 711,LITUREEEIE I block 1 smile 1 mile *"="11/. . Saes Pme S N/A 7- 'iri Ts 155 000 , • 13 -139 000 S 134 900 ...: PRAT/Gros by Ate. S N/A 0$ 87.8.7.0 LS_ 91.45 0 I . Elli,j d$ 82.460 Data Sae. _p_)specPr /Agent MES/Agent MLS/Agent NAM ADJUSTMENTS DESCRIPTION DE SLAPTION i•1-11a..... DESCRIPTION I t fl 8 re*. DESCRIPTION I•I•IS Pam.Sates or prorroorpo I l OE!ill I ill1111:°nv. 3onv. Cony. ,Concesmons 1 11111;) 18.1V.111.111 .Dale DI Sateffirne 3/16/90 5/1E1/89 3/22/99 4/3/89 ..,Location 3ood 3ood iood 3ood 'SieNrew Good hood Good Inferi or +2,000 Omen me A.R., 2 s t or y 2 story 2 story .?. story ;...Suatty or Co:1,80bn,iood superior ;-10,003ood 3ood Aee 1987 1998 1985 +I,000 1987 .ENsa6o, 3ood 3ood Rood Good . _ . -Aloe Grace o,. •A.,,,,,Si., 115,11 •WM,Sails la. .11a;..bans ....a .OPP.Las Room Coon! 7 5 2 7 7 2.25 -1,000 7 3. I +1,000 L6 .3 .1.7.7.: +2,000 1.005515no Ami 1,676 Sg.Et., 1:765 Sd-Ft -2,2C/0 1,520 Sp Ft .4,000 1,676 So Ft .basement&Frni<heO 'Pa .Jnf i n i shed ;1,000 =R,2EIR,88--- ,''r i,BR : -1,000 Acorns Beew Grade 7u11 'Li 1 1 ..,-1.111 -5,000 run ,t ,- 1 . tunchonat —.UPI, LOod Hood 7ood Good 'heahnO(Copong --WA/Central-WA/Central =WA/Central =WA/Central. _.—..Ga.D6Camet 7 Celf- a tt. .'' car at t. 2 car att —_..._, ,Z, car att. : -2,000 t•cvehes.Paho. Screen pm-. -2,000 FINN.mc Jock 2 decks .2,000,Deck Deck ...,, 'I. **PIT Energy ........- , Etttpient nett, ',Standard 'Standard , Standard _Standard .. . Feeplene15) -) I • T 1 .,Omer le g Imchen "-It-it. Equip. At. Equip.: bit. Equip. Kit. Equip. 'ourp.remonermol / . +6, '?'!_.')SO!''. ', 117117E77 i I• rl _!S -14,200 f--. .!-:$ -2,000-rr-i. --- _.$ ..1,0 00 inereated Vat. kijii!i. 1!11171111 11 lfillrilr [HUI! triplE1 eh p•I prpi,Iir,( EE et Sutnect ''1!!1, 8i198 0 vt Pi!I II'!litrIllirrItitrtS.140,800 1 1;1.M!: .il!RiiiS 137,000 1111 1111 Will$ 135,900 ,4 Continent<on Sates Comparron Poet adjustment, the three sal es strongly support the cone fusion of value. These camper abl es are believed to be the best currently available. •MOWED VALUE II SALES COMPARISON APPRDACII . S 137,500 INDICATED VALUE II INCOME APPAOACH III Apeutle)Estrenated Market Rent I N/A /Mo a GrOSS Rent Multober N/A •S N/A 51 Bros TDP'f+a,is mace[IC]as is FT}.1.0 to the reeds,aiteratens.knspenons or condmons treed berow L j compeoon per plans and smorgbations. Comments and Cenortrons ol Avatar.' The fees paid by the buyer and/or seller to obtain or assume f i none mg foe- this property do not affect the value of the appraised property. Enailie66,161+41 While the Cost Approach strongly supports the final conclusion, the ".... Market Data Approach i s given most weight.,as i t best indicates the actions of . buyers and sellers i ri the marketplace. • . toss 0550,54!is based unnn ISO darer no<ere:eaten contingent and Mining metro.,and Markel Value denten that are slated on -a (__.;BMA HUD Atv VA ingruchons '.. Li Poore Mac formal.(Rev 7i86)(Er.re Mae Form 10048 Bev 7/13Elleed with client 19 [ ]attached I!WEI ESTIMATE DIE MARKET VALUE.AS DOMED.DI THE SUIJECT PPOPEATT AS Or March 16 II 90 1.Ai j 137,500 I(*)relay that to tne Enrol soy oust Prowiedoe and belief the tads and Iola Used*rem We Isue and coma Mal I hvel personalty mended the SOME ProPettV. boss vile and ow.and nave made art eNlmwm.•.oe Of all cempatade sales sited a MIS stoat end snail(WO nave no unds: ntetest,pew or prospect.stem Russell 5.0111 545-4404 Wane/m n,,,aIII,......1".,-7 ej.:,..7.I? _Review RDINal501 A-00,K ''':,4•-•.'-'421C7 • !D'66,0 El De Nor ' Rue-eel 1-.C. Sme t SRPA inspect Proem), . • ...V--.49 DEFINITION OF MARKET VALUE The most probable price which a property should bring in a competitive and open • market under all condemns reguisne to a fair sale.the buyer and seller,each acting prudently.knowledgeably end assuming the price is nstt attested by undue stimulus.Implicit in this definition is the consummation of a sale as of a specified date and the passing of title from seller to buyer under conditions whereby;(I)buyer and seller are typically motivated;(2)bah panes are well informed or well advised.and each acting in what he considers his own best interest;Ill a reasonable time is allowed it exposure in the open market;mil pavmnent is made in memo of cash in U.S.dollars or in terns of financial =MO arrangements comparable thereto,and 151 the price represents the normal csmssderausm for she property add unaffected by special Or crcauve Inancmg or sales concessions•gunned by anyone asatctased with the sale. •Adjustments to the comparable must be made for special or creative financing or sates concessions.No adjustments are necessary for those costs which are normally paid by sellers as a result of uaditton or law in a market area;these costs are readily identifiable rinse the seller pays Mesa costa in vinually all sales transactions.Spatial or creative financing adjustments can he made to the comparable potgerty by comparisons m financing terms oflered by a third pony institutional lender that • is not already involved in the property or transatoon.Any adjustment should not he calculated on a mechanical dollar for • • dollar cost of die financing or concession but the dollar amount unt of any adjustnmeni should approximate she market's reaction to the financing or concessions hased on the appraiser's judgment. • CERTIFICATION AND STATEMENT OF LIMITING CONDITIONS • CERI'IFlCATION:The Appraiser certifies and agrees that I.The Appraiser has no present or contemplate]future interest in the property appraised;and neither the employment to make the appraisal,nor the compensation for it,is contingent upon the appraised value of the pmpeny. 2.Tlx:Appraiser has no personal imeress in or bias with respect to the subject nutter of the appraisal report or the partici- picots to the sale.The"Estimate of Market Value"in the appraisal report is rot based in whole or in pan upon the race.color, or national origin of the prospective owners or occupants of the property appraised,or upon the race,color or national origin of the present owners or occupants of the properties in the vicinity of the property appraised. • 3.The Appraiser has personally inspected the property,bah inside and out,and has made an exterior inspection of all comparable sales listed in the report.To the best of the Appraisers knowledge and bdief.all statements and infomation in this report are true and carat,and the Appraiser has no knowingly withhold any significant information. 4.All contingent and limiting conditions are contained herein(imposed by the terms of the assignment or by she under- signed affecting the analyses.opinions,and conclusions contained in the report). 5.This appraisal report has been made in conformity with and is subject of the requirements of the Code of Pmlessiaul Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduce of the appraisal organizations with which the Appraiser is affiliated. 6.All conclusions and opinions concerning the real estate that are sot fonh In the appraisal repo were prepared by the Appraiser whose signature appears on the appraisal report.unless indicated as"Review Appraiser."No change of any item in the appraisal report shall be made by anyone alter than rho Appraiser,and the Appraiser shall have no responsibility for any such unauthorized change. CONTINGENT AND LIMITING CONDITIONS:The certifivrinn of the Appraiser appearing in the appraisal report is subject • to the lallowing conditions and to such other specific and limiting conditions as are set funh by the Appraiser in the report. • 1.The Appraiser assumes no responsibility for matters of a legal nature;electing the properly appraised or the title there- to.or does the Appraiser render any opinion as t the tole,which is assumed to be good and marketable.The property is appraised as though under responsible ownership. 2.Any stitch in the repon may slow appra mate dimensions and is included to assist the reader in visualizing the prop • - eoy.The Appraiser has made no survey of the properly. 3.The Appraiser is not required to give tesrinrny or appear in court because of having made the appraisal with reference at the property in question.unless arrangements have heen previously made therefor. 4.Any distribution of the valuation in the retain between lard and impnwemetus applies only under the existing program • of utilization.The separate valuations for land and building oust nut be used in conjunction with any other appraisal and arc invalid If so used. s tut 5.The Appraiser assumes Mai there arc no hidden or unapparent conditions of the property,subsoil.or structures,which would render it nitre or Ins valuable.The Appraiser assures no responsibility for such conditions,or for engineering which • might be required to discover such factors. • • 6.Information.estimates,and opinions furnished to the Appraiser.and contained in the report.were obtained front sources • considered reliable and believed to be true and correct.However.no responsibility for accuracy of such items furnished the Appraiser can be assumed by the Appraiser. 7.Disclosure of the contents of the appraisal report is governed by the Bylaws and Regulations of the professional appraisal orgaoizatinns with which the Appraiser is affiliated. g.Neither all,nor any part of the content of the report,or copy thereof(including conclusions as in the property value, the identity of the Appraiser,professional designations.reference to arty professional appraisal organizations.or the firm with which the Appraiser is connected),shall be used for any purposes by anyone but the client specified in the report,the borrower • if appraisal les paid by same,the mortgagee or its successors and assigns mongage insurers,consultants.professional appraisal organizations,any state or federally approved financial institution.any department,agency.or instrumentality of the United Stares or any stare or the District of Columbia.without the previous written consem d the Appraier:or shall it be mmcynd Iy anyone in the public through advertising.public relations.news.sales.or other media.without the worsen consent and approval of the Appraiser. 9.On all appraisals.subject to satisfactory congdeiion.repairs.or alterations-the appraisal report and value conclusion art contingent upon completion of the enprovenrents to a workmanlike manner. • 3/l-9e Date Appraised.). `7 n•.ex'�,fy,.— t .....r.......-.. .. ....... ♦...•,.�•.....f n-....i n-,.,..ri.......t m"^`abaVt taw.Il4rxt • w �,MJs d # r''' � z \\4i rvt3� al�' �_ . I 'W'"°'' 1 e• lea?1 4..�c s 'wl i 3�1 IV r'v ”,s . �. ai m. 7 - ji •:G, ram• . «N j' = 4i°gi. f, . l te a. ; 0 "" u+fl iz. ( ; s `¢ oet , ` I� a .�w..t1'wi `$°(°`',,y4a�'Qy,,.6yiw", "�.. .'1l' ... / •4 Y o... r A' f ?4 144 eR �o.Y .. ? �•. a ° sE � ' ! fig °.y / � � g ,yr9y, .!� '4.niiii%,. �'~w :n `� � C3 P�� (.7" �GUN ��rqq�j 4tS, i '. AL V � i �J F� a '{`s u- 1 17/ .cam / .,..,› .... ,,... .....,. 1 _ .., 1 4 1.- _ a yy4 - ., nib i .. . s. i //- V \` ...4,- ,, ! ' . ) 1 11 .;I I° ,,,,' ] a', ,,,- ..f n G J ...cam ,, 00 cur. �--r"s ,.•`°°°~ Wp'� 1 a. 0 `.vi4rs+,•�'v tt Zr(, \'vim Amer w. ,4. -IF i . i?....74.:',1 - VI,i 5. r ❑ L:‹,..,,,,,:-.,1;--\,-r.--/:\--/t,,n-.)y.4. wo_ - /p i' , _.\ V (4.0\ R l EDlFe fir/ ".fiN P l \7 / • `/ t\"2l` fix •L q�IYQF I W""""`•.a•a V 4. I twirl owns Y �_ 4 . _�I ':� %wit I. \ A QM•r�` a �4i t L ` yr `P.016 „a \� -4.� n tC 11 •Wes.. �./ e C (17) i 9uTlaE C� �4 2 6 (,5) (16) n r' (26) , 7• (14) (13) R 0 D & Ou,Eat 9 +Est x w., (25) w " =_ KS, a ion F.t (I) =_' 3 :.. J t v',•' •.�^o 1 152.99 4, TI'J. # '3'1./1 1 p ab .(y 1 ' .. (.al y.. C. .. 1 f.+S OJ ( J �' (2J) 2) y(ie).•` 'A..„, ..:0(49.), ,_;,::„)„ ,r e I ,: 003^ 8 : (31) $916 = ...P4•r '12 153) • a .6- a (m .8. p4' a o®Q�(28) a 8 t!' II 8 1.. :. ism' •• (32?' toil ' P IJ Oa '.1'' 'A.h y el�,i • 'Ut In (44) yt7e.ilia Yq ..p�(5 49 ,(27)C:\g. (,e) ,at q(51)� 4,y . `'4 . • Z..4 . "ve,,,ia4;.•4`� g,. `07 .1 8 1, 5RD9 ~, •o �., 2 i,.". ;';� py�f'2)°� �4. (i0) '[� .4'' • Mc0.12(1a 55 ((53) o I, :la( , 7~1 �'�. ,'- . , ` 9 $ ;t •Iq.. (,6) 7 m..25 k4.25 P : (54) QR. 1e T. <J.o)3.y... .� 41 2 $(9) S:.:,.a .. .,..? 57.91 552 ' 4EIi5� t '(s; 4 : .. 1°47 • ' 552.a ADOR'_ ( 1) , , •, .1. , 05 '12 �) ?I .. 8 (I) (2) R . -, 6....j, .,,3a. ,Iq-a '30.2.t 99e '(i e •2 V' - w:Fs(55)"' Js � 9t5 . .,y3L $ a• (,ia �.` d 56 2 —• i,y, 13t Y>‘ r� 5B?g (5) (Iq 9'I-�r �` * e R F (515) u$ ( 7) $, •__ (3) `$of. a1. 241I 1.)g (1 7 .7 ' PN!a9.5'9 9. •• ,25,7 19.0)17.Ia.- 5)5 a}` 7e 2��7.. _ _-..�•.r=S NA—_5_ 3,t 5 i5•Ex l_107 94 R; It — '.9 _ ie%) F`—a,sie; I..;Dft'•1a- �r'-�, 97.39 (>o�b 94.13 (52I)• I '9 I I I. RN C iV .tom Cth6 r" MOT -}O !'Y.McT Sc,Mte. 1: { 1 /D 3q 3'i Deck 3' S. /Z, Bedroom Living Dining ^6' 111111 Bedroom /8 /3,f Bedroom _ MI Closet Bath Bath ! IRS' /3' I•S. II.f•.D'' '12 /2 Kitchen /0 L:• y' 7o Garage 7. 22.' C''.0 o. 3 kFrb+ .rJ Via' 7® PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS OF GREGORY P. SMITH Gregory P. Smith has been actively engaged in the residential real estate filed since 1973. During that time, he has been active in appraising and financing of residential one to four unit residences and individual condominiums and townhouses. ___4111 Mr. Smith has been accepted as a candidate for the R.M. designation in the American Institute of Real Estate Appraisers. He is an affiliate member of the Greater Minneapolis and St. Paul Area Board of Realtors. Mr. Smith is a graduate with honors of 'cum laude' from Mankato State University with a Bachelor of Science in Business Administration. He has successfully completed the American Institute of Real Estate appraisers and Society of Real Estate Appraisers courses, 'The Appraiser's Guide to the URAR 6/87', 'Standards of Professional Practice 1/88", "Real Estate Appraisal Principles 7/88' and "Residential Valuation 7/88", plus several courses and seminars offered by Mankato State University and the Minnesota Banking Association. From February 1973 to March of 1981, Mr. Smith was associates with the David C. Bell Investment Company as a residential mortgage loan consultant. From march 1981 to February 1986, he was associated with Rothschild Financial Corporation as a Vice President and Branch Manager of a residential mortgage office. Mr. Smith has vast experience dealing with builders, realtors, developers, FNMA, Minneapolis Community Development Agency, Minnesota Housing Finance Agency and several private lenders and investors. Some of the major corporations he has done appraisals for are Preferred Mortgage Corporation; Marquette Bank Minneapolis; Executron Mortgage Network, Inc.; Countrywide Funding Corporation; CU Mortgage Services; Teacher Federal Credit Union; David C. Bell Investment Company; Twin City Mortgage Company; Windfield Homes and Miles Homes. He joined Russell Smith Associates, Inc. in June 1986 and is manager of the residential appraisal department. r � Via♦ ME® PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS OF RUSSELL C. SMITH Russell C. Smith has been actively and continuously engaged in the real estate profession since 1950. During this time he has appraised all types of property ranging from vacant land to residential, apartment, commercial and industrial property including income properties and special purpose properties. Mr. Smith is a graduate of the University of Minnesota with a B.A. degree in architecture. He has completed real estate appraisal courses offered by the University of Minnesota, the Society of Real Estate Appraisers and the American Institute of Real Estate Appraisers. He has instructed the section °Appraisal of Special purpose and Industrial Buildings' in the University of Minnesota Extension Division. For the first five years in the appraisal field, he was employed by the Appraisal Service Company, appraising industrial and commercial properties. For the next two and one-half years, he was employed by Investors Diversified Services, Inc. (Mortgage Division) appraising commercial and industrial properties and managing commercial properties; including shopping centers. While employed by these firms, Mr. Smith completed appraisals in Milwaukee, Wisconsin; Louisville, Kentucky; Dallas, Texas: Chicago, Illinois and many of the larger cities throughout the United States. From the fall of 1957 to January I972, Mr. Smith was associated with the A.D. Strong Company as a fee appraiser. He was a Senior Vice President and Manager of the Appraisal Department. Mr. Smith appraised all types of real estate ranging from single family residential to special purpose properties while at that company. Between January, 1972 and December I974, Mr. Smith was a partner in the firm of Boblett and Smith, Real Estate Appraisers and Counselors, specializing in appraisal and counseling related to the real estate field on a fee basis, in a manner similar to the work performed at the A.D. Strong Company On January I, 1975, Mr. Smith formed Russell Smith Associates and since that date has continued with this firm in the field of real estate as an appraiser, counselor and broker. He is currently Chairman of the Board in that firm. Mr. Smith has qualified as an expert witness in courts of law. He has oftentimes been appointed to serve as commissioner in condemnation proceedings by judges of the District Bench. • =1 "1111- PROFESSIONAL OUALIFICATIONS OF RUSSELL C. SMITH Cont. Mr. Smith is licensed as a real estate appraiser and also as a real estate broker in the State of Minnesota. He is a REALTOR Active member of the Greater Minneapolis Board of REALTORS and the National Association of REALTORS. Mr. Smith has been awarded the designation "S.R.P.A." in the Society of Real Estate Appraisers. He is a member of the international Right-of-Way Association Fri State Chapter#20. Since becoming a fee appraiser, Mr. Smith has appraised property for such public agencies as the University of Minnesota, Minnesota Department of Highways, Hennepin County, City of Minneapolis, and most of the Minneapolis suburban communities. He has appraised for may major local and national corporations such as General Mills, Honeywell, Ashland Oil Company, Dayton's, Equitable Life Assurance Society and Investors Diversified Services. He has annually completed appraisals for numerous banks an! mortgage companies and other public and private companies plus private individuals. .a PHOTOGRAPH ADDENDUM 90053a ... f r 1, FRONT OF SUBJECT PROPERTY - r ./..—_____•___. 111.3" 'IL 1 ,..."... -......4--,,... '''' r x 6.4'•-e...4,I,j A''"7,,,,,..14`••••'•*.. 'leer,*....4'..-"''''" • .....A.,.,r, .......-.• =II _______ REAR EROF SUBJECT PROPERTY ,.z.i..... I . ' V% li •P'os. i, lis ""-- ,L,..st=s. ' d ,- :..._41.4.1 .4,--, _,......... • 1_,.,..,......„,, ,.,,,,,.....,,,,....1.., ,..........,,,,„,„„.,,.....,---,...„ .- -„ _... ..--,,,...... ..,-, i STREET SCENE 0, ' - / V • -. ' • 1 i 1 Avg., _-----,,••--,--------.........e' _'''"-- wom......7„, - ...— Korio.*'"- •••••. W -, .e. .. Z. .. V . , - -' 7 ADDITIONAL PHOTOGRAPHS ON REVERSE SIDE • ,, • ,,• PHOTOGRAPH ADDENDUM Bmto..ntlmnl Jim anti Kim Kaufman F10pm11AO* I 7356 Ontario Anulvvare ul1 Feta/airic._ cuvntr Hennepin sate Minnesota zlpc6a. 55344 Len0e=,lim anti KimJ(autran 1 t t f /., • i;tT a 3 1..'�' 12`�? e •f•'1 AI E r '. ' jF rkI t ,.1 1f 1 WOODED BACK VIEW f .{ 1- ti.i .St `. .,. _ ..w r _ .� . Cl ADDITIONAL PHOTOGRAPHS ON REVERSE SIDE FW ACE ON 't*M Epma and...me Inc 215 Vmney aw Now am n.CI 0630 Al R11t11 Am,*1110011134546 Iam• 113100 PHOTOGRAPH ADDENDUM . )2t1fr 777,4 (Iota,io 8,1ev3r,1 ,y Ed, Tral r ie ee neesota ze cod., 55344 dP1 hiLltr. ranee COMPARABLE SALE#1 7384 ONTARIO BOULEVARD , 4 nevion • COMPARABLE SALE#2 tiist 16391 MANOR ROAD ,s1" •; , • • vni••,te ..0s.iy4fte,%, oi e•-• • ./1 — • • . . COMPARABLE SALE#3 7441 MJIRFIELD _ • -*T*44 ",fk,OAf.#'• p tofu- W I t _11 mg.'I l 111111.1101.icot , f, L • '1 ADDITIONAL PHOTOGRAPHS ON REVERSE SIDE Appeal No. tam Date Received 4/13/1990 PID # 01-116-22 44 0012 APPLICATION FORM Appraiser Steve Sinell 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 715 - 425 - 5571 Work: 612 - 942 - 5335 Name: Robert L. Bouvin Address of Property: 9835 - 9901 W. 69th St., Eden Prairie, MN 55344 January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 1,868,000 Date property was acquired: 7/22/88 Purchase Price: $ 2,100,000 Terms of Purchase: Warranty Deed - 1st Mortgage 5 2nd Mortgage Additions and alterations since purchase: None Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? No If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 1,660,000 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): Supporting Evidence Attached Sig a ure o wner omas J. Schwartz (Agent for Owner) Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 4n2ooO 3yg000 !S31ooO 1/2/88 ITh-//goo 1/2/87 2o0C ,7.9OD 74•Nl o —r Last Inspection: y/ /5525 Appraiser: S •a_. �,�cE. Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: S j 14 -1-5s' Co r b foc 000 Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments / / S /_/ S Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: M P" Minnesota Property Consultants,Inc. CProperty Tax Reduction April 13, 1990 City of Eden Prairie Assessor's Office 7600 Executive Drive Eden Prairie, MN 55344-3677 ATTN: Mr. Steve Sinell Dear Mr. Sinell: Per your request, I have enclosed the income and expense information for the property located at 9835-9901 W. 69th St., PIN 01-116-22-44-0012. This information has been incorporated into the report previously sent to you on March 6, 1990. Also enclosed you will find a completed "Application Form - 1990 Eden Prairie Board of Review" for this property, we are requesting a reduction in 1990 assessed value from $1,868,000 to $1,660,000. The rent rolls you requested are not available as Mr. Bouvin does not maintain any, due to the limited number of tenants. Thank you for your prompt attention to this matter. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely, • Thomas J. Schwartz Enclosures 7333 ANN COURT • EDEN PRAIRIE, MN 55346 • (612)942-5335 11 p 1 Minnesota Property Consultants,Inc. • Property Tax Reduction C CONSULTANT • AGENCY AGREEMENT PROPERTY OWNER/LCCCC➢ j?c r� BOUV in PROPERTY ADDRESS 6W A 6.4, St I 1 h I' TOWNSHIP t. COUNTY RQ vhS2-U P.I.N. O'-}5- ?? - ?3 — U U'I 7 al C P.I.N. '-5 -a-9 — a-3.3—vo7/ /C P.I.N. t7SU /N7 agree with "M.P.C., Inc. • for the real estate assessment year 19 90 , and for the years remaining in the present quadrennial period (199O and 19 9( ), in unSet( County, Minnesota, as to the property referred o above, that preparation of a real estate assessment appeal of the undersigned to the Local Board of Review, as well as to the State of Minnesota Property Tax Appeal Board. The undersigned authorizes "M.P.C., Inc." to obtain an appraisal or appraisals of Market Value for the property referred to above, for the year stated as the tax year in question. Unless otherwise indicated the cost of this appraisal will be paid for by "M.P.C., Inc.". The undersigned further authorizes "M.P.C., Inc.", as agent of the under- signed, to execute and cause to be filed on behalf of the undersigned, in the name of the undersigned, any and all documents relating to an appeal of the said assessments, for the assessment year 19 90 and the remaining year/s of the quadrennial period referred to above, before the Local Board of Review as well as the State of Minnesota Property Tax Appeal Board where permitted. If the services of an attorney at law are required, in connection with any appeal referred to herein the undersigned will choose and engage such attorney, at the cost of the undersigned; in which event "M.P.C., Inc." will co-operate with said attorney in the furtherance of such appeal. "M.P.C., Inc." for its services are separate and distinct from any fees payable by the undersigned to any attorney at law engaged by the undersigned. Agreed • Owner Agent/Lessee�Str e the nappropriate des'gnation) D/e Approved: "M.P.C., In By 7333 ANN COURT • EDEN PRAIRIE, MN 55346 • (6I2) 942-5335 2 SUMMARY OF SALIENT FACTS AND CONCLUSIONS Purpose of Appraisal: Market Value Property Rights Appraised: Fee Simple Ownership: Bouvin Enterprises Inc. Date of Valuation: January 2, 1990 Type of Property: Commercial/Industrial Land Area: 5.35 Acres (233,046 square feet) Building Size: 58,641 sq. ft. (GBA) Present Use: Office/Warehouse/Manufacturing Highest and Best Use: Present Site Value: $ 519,000 Value Indications by: (1989) Income Approach $ 1,640,000 (1988) Income Approach $ 1,500,000 Potential Income Approach $ 1,661,000 Market Approach $ 1,600,000 Market Value Conclusion: January 2, 1990 $ 1,660,000 3 Identification of Property The subject property is a 6-year old office warehouse building situated on a 5.35 acre site on the east side of W. 69th St. in Eden Prairie, MN. The property common address is 9835-9901 W. 69th St. Legal Description All of this certain parcel of land is situated in the City of Eden Prairie, County of Hennepin, State of Minnesota, and is described as follows: 01-116-22-44-0012 Lot 1, Block 1, shady Oak Industrial Park a; ,t ;t lid" '%, ,•:< �; , : : 5•A "' , . a " ,a `*s` ° sue- fir` 11-. _,-- y+"an,..;}k , '. t •.' r r r—'— •ram.. 1ft:ZiV.;:u ' A .t . 1 1 x v r y 1 1 }ie _ . -- --- it,'. th : le; C I NE :;•!",;...!.._:2 JAS ':11 i " .....:1; -- --"'--...re•••••••*--""14.1jr 1.....,:o!.°He rf L.. f.:.1 a o a o ea .- •, e I 1. .lip MI i As ! it 4r t Ik 1.--r • 1 ''' e I .• ...- .;.. 1 • ' N, .___J I t I •••0/ ., • a% -e kele . °," '! ; a e 6 ° 1. . ....i s" tiku .'- ...4 .•'.1.-'.... f ' - -i ,,1 4 ' - ..$11.:': Un. • % .1: ../Ti- ,"'•al / *•1 S. ,41 SVZ) •---. • E 1 Tr -.. . • rk, • ',ki,-, --,,,,t. ,\,, Ifi. i,I I , I -.,1 d€:i. ,ri.• , :''.-..1. B..- i ' i; • .• , .... . -__ ,:_:..._, ""---ve,. ...!sk — — :—. 1 _ _ •----. --- --4:7, e `1 tij'-7-'...--Lral.....,jr..... .-‘',74..---'_ ' .--,r. ..,.s: ._. .._ •- fr N... ® . * I ® I 41,4, -. *0,,., -vp. -..... 4444167 ' 4 '' slp :f f .‘ gill• ..4:-.4-.7if /1 1 i,•'' _ 77 Y 9111'7 33.5 ild :14 nit - - : t . • I• . l• ' .• !.1.• I Pt)1'11,!TY :•;7,1,i'N Ni01‘MAT t/N• :.• MN PID: nttTi rdn : iat u: ;•-• I Ci t t y and r;,,,..•.1 It•y I : squa:r, mat , t ()I y masonry (Fabct...r.) war III Ir In t7F, a:.t. :, vory ,o,i • :. 1 t:‘'t r•t. , 1•;11'1•It:1 : ' W. I on PI.I : ' . • .. •.•• I, . •• 4-m11m:454 . • - • . • 7 Eden Prairie Off ire Warehc)uu. Buildings r'mmr,arah'.e :ales PROPERTY SALES INFORMATION: an-st pry rtu;ur;., ;: o`.f i.^e warehou:,e building ADDRESS: 10175 - 1020`_, Crosstown Circle, Eden Prairie, MN PID: 01 116-22-13-0023 SITE: Level 2.15 acre site, drained and sound; blacktop surfaced parking lot and landscaped yard. Average identity and good accessibility. IMPROVEMENTS: 32,012 square foot masonry-(Fabcon) constructed office warehouse building, built in 1979 and in good condition. SOLD: 11/1'2/87 BUYER: Hamilton Associates, Steven Hoyt PRICE: $ 817,500 PSF $ 25.54 r r1 f a" $• 1 ♦ : ? • -...���• ..ear„ r �.;�,�r"'�—. ..� ' L 7%; rr ,ems* .r w =is F. en Prairie_Office Warehouse Luildings Comparahle Siec PROPERTY SALES INFORMATION: Two-story sub,.;r.!-an office waihouse building ADDRESS: 9805 Hamilton Road, Eden Prairie, MN PID: 01-116-22-41-0016 SITE: Level 3.12 acre site, drained and sound; blacktop surfaced parking lot in good condition. Average Identity and average accessibility. IMPROVEMENTS: 42,546 square foot, two-story office warehouse of masonry construction, built in 1973 and in very good conditIon. SOLD: 3/87 PRICE: $ 883,286 PSF $ 20.76 • • •, - • r. • , • , ! 241 •• • • - :td. 1'r t : : (d. t• 17d1t, PROPENTY SALE:7, INFORMATION: HI. ADDRESS: '0,0)1, 11d:hilt , Lien aitte MN PID: t, : 41 and ttd:Iti; AveTage Identity dnd dve: Ade I HI'RoVEMENTS 41fO 1-na:-:nnry iaitr--on) non:t:t I on, huilt: r. 12r7 4 1t(t1.1): .1 I/I I,t87 PUY : on "::::H,t• t on St eve:: II,Dyt. P II 7,7ii z , . .• 'it..? . , • 4 . 1 --:L$PACf • • PP}PEHTY SALES I NFORMAT I : f:':'!y t:!! '!C:e I. 3700 1St i4',00 1 FY '"VCI r l M . PI D: It; J.17 .!.? 43 0010 SITE: , ,^^ c ,i 3rt'.ing C:t . P.v,-2r age dhi-it Lt y and (insd iN.P1.()V1:MENTS: 1.73,950 squat,2 tout, two-rt cry masonry (Fancon) f cP warf,ho,:s«, , t in 1975 and ii uoud snort:t ')/20/ LITTut.-d I PRICE: 1 4,-(14,000 PSF r: 24.80 . 4.0 . • • ' • , . • — . . . , - . —, .- • • ' ,• 1 ;.• ••• • • • • • - • . . • . 11 Edo,:i I': al ale W t? :Le ?, mparihle S. PROPERTY SALES INFORMATION: rlsw t fco ware'.—1fe 'funding ADDRESS: C 170 - 1000 W. 70th St. , Eden Pia.lie, MN I'll): 01-116-1'2-4:c-001.2 SITE: Level 7.4 a,-: e ,:te, drained and sound; hlacktop ea is Average -identity and average ce.ce, uinility. IMPROVEMENTS: f',1 ,028 square toot maLir.fy-(f.'itican) constroct,d office warehouse building, built in 7083 and in very good condition. SOLD: 1j:7/87 BUYER: Ardnsy Electronics, Ronald Regan PRICE: C 1,C.47,842 PCF S 07.00 . - ' • , , • -"izkS. '4;4 F: --31cA's,rAjf : - 4)4. - • 12 Eden Prairie Office Warehouse Comparable Sales ;',IP- 7 PROPERTY SALES INFORMATION: Two-story su.`-Purnsu office warehouse burlding ADDRESS: 67`_,0-E7u0 Shady Oak Road, Eden Prairie, MN PID: 01 116-22-43-0008 SITE: Level/sloping 4.36 acre site, drained and sound; blacktop surfaced parking lot. Above average identity and accessibility. IMPROVEMENTS: 72,900 square foot masonry constructed office warehouse building, built in 1979 and in excellent condition. 49% office space. SOLD: 12/8/88 PRICE: c 2,100,000 PSF 0 28.81 S i _� d -,�+,}'r_' "�@g' yrl ter= ('-, J > ;ate...'.• . Ytr a is i4 7:7": '— SA1.i iN}'t+!(k.A'71t>il: .... - .. :. .. .. Is t): iM3.t<uVF:Mt;NT:'.: OLI)- .. J � . w. .L.' 14 Sales Analysis Unit Sale Sales Sales _ Location Price S/FFA Price 1 10200-10224 Crosstown Circle $ 1,250,000 73,985 $ 16.89 Eden Prairie, MN 2 10175-10205 Crosstown Circle $ 817,500 32,012 $ 25.54 Eden Prairie, MN 3 9805 Hamilton Rd. $ 883,286 42,546 $ 20.76 Eden Prairie, MN 4 9905 Hamilton Rd. $ 1,000,000 42,150 $ 23.73 Eden Prairie, MN 5 3700 Williston Rd. $ 4,314,000 173,950 $ 24.80 14900 Minnetonka Ind. Blvd. Minnetonka, MN 6 10300-10360 W. 70th St. $ 1,647,842 61,028 $ 27.00 Eden Prairie, MN 7 6750-6760 Shady Oak Road $ 2,100,000 72,900 $ 28.81 Eden Prairie, MN 8 6410 Old Shakopee Rd. $ 1,400,000 67,186 $ 20.84 Bloomington, MN 15 Sales Analysis (continued) Sale properties 1, 2, 3, 4, 6 and 7 are within 1/2 to 3/4 mile of the subject property in the same or adjoining industrial parks. Sale properties #5 and #8 are located in neighboring communities and were included to show regional consistency and verify sales price range. All sales properties were comparable in style, construction, and amount of office space to the subject, except for sale property #7, which had a significantly higher amount of office space (49%) than the subject. The higher quality of sale property #7 and greater office space account for a significant downward adjustment to the subject, and thus the $28.81/square foot sales price of sale #7 reflects the upper range of value for this type of building. Sale property #6 is the same age as the subject and sale properties #2 and #7 are only three years older than the subject. All other sale properties are older than the subject and upward adjustments were made to account for the age discrepancies. Sale property #8 is 23 years old and its sale price of $20.84 reflects its age and amount of depreciation. Sale properties #1 and #3 reflect the lower range of values for this type of building, due to their age and condition. Sale properties #2, 5 and 6 reflect the upper range of value for this class of building, and sale property #7 reflects an even higher value, due to its superior construction, grade, quality and layout. Based on the above analysis, and after consideration of all quality factors and analysis of variance, we have concluded a unit value for the subject of $27.00 per square foot of building area (land included) or: $ 1,583,300, Say $ 1,600,000 Indicated Value via Market Approach The Market Approach, which is based on the principle of substitution is a method which involves the extraction and analysis of sales data pertaining to properties of similar utility. Eight sales of a degree of comparability have been analyzed. They have produced appropriate units of comparison. Analysis of variances, when compared to the subject property, have been adjusted. After careful consideration of the facts and data which influence the value of the subject property as defined in this report, it is our opinion that the market value of the subject property as of January 2, 1990 was: One Million Six Hundred Thousand Dollars $ 1,600,000 • 16 9835 - 9901 W. 69th Street Income E. Expense Analysis Year Ending December 31, 1988 Based on Actual Income E. Expense Income Rental Income (6 Months) S 121,567 Total Income S 121,567 Expenses Accounting E. Legal $ 8,760 Administration Expenses 3,363 Miscellaneous Expenses 6,444 Total Expenses (15%) 18.567 Net Income Before Depreciation E. Debt Service (6 mos.) S 103.000 Annualized Net Income S 206,000 Capitalization Rate 9.00% Overall Rate 4.80% Eff. Tax Rate Capitalization Rate 13.80% Net Income/Cap. Rate = 5206,000/0.138 = $1,492,754 Say S 1,500,000 17 9835 - 9901 W. 69th Street Income & Expense Analysis Year Ending December 31, 1989 Based on Actual Income & Expense Rental $ 252,600 nc Rental Income 11 597 Less Vacancy $ 241,003 Total Income Expenses 0 50 Accounting Fees $ 2,398 Attorney Fees 351 Office Supplies & Expense 3,038 Insurance 8 Management Fees 3,6,03000 Repairs & Miscellaneous 870 Travel 15.774 Total Expenses • Net Income Before Depreciation & Debt Service $ 225,229 Capitalization Rate 9.00% Overall Rate 9.00% Eff. Tax Rate Capitalization Rate 13.80% Net Income/Cap. Rate = $225,229/0.138 = $1,632,094 Say $ 1,640,000 Value Indicated by Income Approach 18 • 9835 - 9901 W. 69th Street Income & Expense Analysis Protected Maximum Income Potential Income Rental Income $7.00/sf (top rate) x 8619 sf office leasable area $ 60,333 $4.00/sf (top rate) x 50022 sf warehouse area 200,088 Total Potential Income $ 260,421 Expenses 12% (1988 Actual Percentage) (31,250) Net Income Before Depreciation & Debt Service $ 229,171 Capitalization Rate Overall Rate 9.00% Eff. Tax Rate 4.80% Capitalization Rate 13.80% Net Income/Cap. Rate = $299,171/0.138 = $1,660,659 Say $ 1,661,000 1 19 Reconciliation Two standard approaches to value have been used in this appraisal. The values indicated by these methods are as follows: Income Approach (Highest) $ 1,661,000 Market Approach $ 1,600,000 The values indicated by these approaches are within statistical expectations of each other. The lower market approach value is indicative of the depressed market for commercial/industrial space in the area. Indeed, one-half block away (6900 Shady Oak Road) sits a 60,000 square foot building (the old CTS Fabritek building) which has been vacant for over a year. Other vacant buildings are within one half mile of the subject (e.g. 7725 Washington Ave. So.. Edina) and many multi-tenant buildings in the area have vacancy • rates over twenty percent consistently. However, the Income Approach is the most reliable indicator of value and carries the most significance since an investor, the typical buyer of this type of property, would be interested in the income stream generated. The final price and therefore the market value will be determined by the income received from the building. Thus, the best determinant of market value is the Income Approach to Value. Therefore, more weight is given to the Income Approach Values in this case. Taking the above factors into account, and after careful consideration of the facts and data which influence the value of the subject property as defined in this report, and subject to the limiting conditions of this report, it is our opinion that the market value of the subject property as of January 2, 1990, was: One.Million Six Hundred Sixty Thousand Dollars $1,660,000 Appeal No. 113� PID # 12-116-22 41 0007 Date Received 4/13/1990 Appraiser Steve Sine11 • APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: Work: 1800843-0139 Name: KYLE FELDMAN, AGENT Address of Property: 9600-9700 76th STREET WEST. January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 8,122,000 Date property was acquired: UNKNOWN Purchase Price: $ UNKNOWN Terms of Purchase: UNKNOWN Additions and alterations since purchase: UNKNOWN Cost of additions and alterations: N/A Is property listed for sale? NO If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 6,011,210 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): SEE ATTACHMENTS OF OPERATING STATEMENTS. DECEMBER 31, 1987 MARKET VALUE APPRAISAL PREPARED BY COLDWELL BANKER. COPY AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST. Signyture of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 it !`i C C' 'co 3000 i. tCO - 1/2/88 ciooC 7op3GCC. sC/aapop IT 1/2/87 n 19oo° eq.-(70CV 773toxC �C Last Inspection: ,L/ 442 Appraiser: Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: 5oid io-Rw 4cr t 8,7001 ocO Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: STATEMENT OF OPERATIONS PROPERTY NAME: TECHNOLOGY PARK I S II MAP REFERENCE #: 12-1.16--22--41--0007 • COUNTY AND STATE: HENNIPEN COUNTY, MINNESOTA INCOME 1989 1988 Gross Potential: 877,014 86.8% 873,030 87.9% Vacancy Loss: 277,576 31.7% 223,571 25.67 Adjusted Gross: 599,438 59.3% 649,459 65.4% Other Income: 410,632 40.77 343,506 34.6% Effective Income: 1,010,070 100.0% 992,965 100.0% EXPENSES Administration: 3, 105 0.3% 1.356 0.1% Management: 23,492 2.3% 28,856 2.9% Security: 2,335 0.2% 1,402 0.17.. Legal S Accounting: 11,068 1.17 8,802 0.9% Utilities: 23,398 2.3. 14,136 1.47.. Water S Sewer: 8, 144 0.87 12,711 1.37. Insurance: 14.503 1.4% 11,888 1.2% Ma i nt S Repairs: 42.536 4.27. 32,958 3.3% Refuse Removal: 72 0.0% 53 0.07 Advertising: 7,272 0.77. 2,224 0.27. Miscellaneous: 115 0.0. 3,502 0.4% Total Expenses: 136.040 13.5% 117,888 11.9% NET OPERATING INCOME: 874,030 86.5% 875,077 88.1% • CAP RATE: 14.54 14.54 INDICATED PROPERTY VALUE: 6,011.210 6,016,411 . ..__ _-_...... . ARNIM! . ••.,7. .,,. . ,... , . ..,. .17". '.i.. 1.:`"`_. . ::..11:-.. . . ,,,.. ,.. ,..1.. ,to 11,1... IC MI, o1) Mi. (1.1 111/11. V 1;•. ;CA . 1 ' ' --! 1.1C.C, 1.CM... • .11.1.,••• Mg:..”-,• • 1/Cail. a. VIC... :••• ,--4 al . ••1-.../31 •,19.C10 :::1•0 .:2 C...7., ' 20,0 - •21.1st., ••••, . ••• CI, ,:".f.. , o ea 6.m •:„ ....! ..',1:,1 .git •,..•••• •,.; non ; 1 I 0•••. r 0 , •-•-.1 ... •••el ••••••I os, I.., r • I f •0 0 vs 0 ! •••• nu • ... ,.... i..0 ..." •, it to.: vo i ta ID ,.16 to 1.1 :1, ,,,,, a: v. ,1•o1,1 ,t (11 ..o.o ;:i ,g .; ; ,. • O•••••C'•''o, 1.1 ool,o,•OA,. O: 0, , to o: •• •• C. • ;2.00 , /1../... 0 0•••• •••••.‘1/ moJa• 0 of. , 0{../.. 4,11 0 11:11 MC 11,: ' VIC MC •-nao, 1-101,1 '.....t/ 1.,11 ' 1.41:0./ 1.l.104, 0 NI •1,111 WTI- • T n •=...i 0 .. ...! 4.. al ••• , o I... MO 11 T. ••• .: 1., r1111 • ,11., 'Z' •,... rt oho .....: oov :t . -,t• ..•• no an nr• • 4/V, f/11 • • no tv m , .4 co oo o• n o o • ....o a o o n .,-.. oto on. o, o o o. o a ' a o a,e• o• z. too n • -iv • - , • I , It :. i • 4 f r a , • I i ni -• tn m ! , • I C• Ca . 0 r M :3 4 1 al 11 1 i I 0 I .. i . ' • I I i I i I • I . . I I Z. •.: r 011 )11, I 21 2 2. 21 II 1 I 01 0 12 01 0 I 01 I P 0 0 ! g 31 I I N r I I. I I I • 1 z t ; I i . i 71 i . • 0. i o ... . I 2! \ • . V 1. e•0 i 01 0 O• i C. 01 0 O 0- 0 1 0!0 I ol . • / • a 1 e , I e o•o II I I • I . ! I 1 I • 1 1 1 • I , , • . I i I I , I I I 1 1 1 I I I r I I I I I I I I ; I I , 1 i I . • I 1 I I , / I , I • 1 , • I I I , I I I 1 1 ; I I • . I I 1 I I I I . I I r 0 I I e e I ... ...1 . I 1 0 Cl i g i - . i . : * I e , o 4 • • 1 e -4 0 0 0 , 0 •••• 0 o m ! 0 : • 41 0 • A • i • . . • i • a . • . • • . •• i . . • , . • 2.45.2/ . , ' . . , PM2.4 I 1,1=2112 I . ' • . . I . ! I , I , I ; ; . I j i I ; N 0 '.•'"" - I . I I . . 1 • 4222 ! ; , •1.1NPI • 1 ! r..3.-` : I I I ; • . co- . . . • i nt a • N \ I 1 I 1 I I. • . I ' . I . I i I I i I I I 1 I i i I L I 1 1 • I_1 i __ .•, : :::•,2 2 2 I,,r;„..;.2 2 c.:2:•.r:::::2 12•I::::::::....11 2---;4-- - 4,. c t i ..t....dra -":"' ^Z-i2.> TI"�::: "'Y't:i: 31-C:: 1:f C'" ZYC:: i"i 1 1 t[In t 23N: I A,A2I n Alnrl •^' 9N2 to ANr 'G'JS IIi I ',I na'-. n7' • n .on Is -, Me' •n m.n `"' .:l z- w0....c•inw.Wll-, • t0011 u.n..., .., .nnwn . NRIO -• n/n•a( . '�. .. Inn ..y0 •tiO1a • ..OC 0 • 4C i• -i 0W> J'-W :z -`InI• Wu-1 n:sl .II v1 l 1 nI ot ii m r, I..in-'':. ^'In rn J:1: .1.nar .-•$n.1.,.... ,.1.0000•00 - I a10i2 • 'r0:1 nln:d •a1> In I a in ? ,n -.I,•,-I•'t•I'n - 0•nn ' L•>,tn -1•nU nn-• .7.' -u 0 :i .II•a .Z . b I> 00 r ' 1 bi 4,tt. 100 ,9I 00. •oft, 0 t.),I.:0 I- • n'C nu, A•• a:. • . Iv!o 0', ...I o :•'n •-•I n: i.i .•II:n Or.: o as.Daa•.aa -•• 1 -p I -:y 00 >I i. - . r 00 1,00,0 y •I r v "•aa'Paaaa' n 1n I . I n •• zz.�¢aa i .� ;e I a . f>.'rt•C4l0nn 'I • •• 1 Id I I • I •tr..•4.rra<. 1 In :n 'n •o I} 'n 1 i T: 1 ' ? ? >I � :a11]IAA0l111 I I T O r? i•0 ! D� 1' e 1^.InfnII ISfnrnm+ I 0 ...,...• o 0 0• A 01 I •a• ! ..:I a 1 I to,tz n o a2 oe '--,t o of ,> 1 te.• e II ''I •a { I I I i ,, .a _I ' I 1 .. , IJNn.l.l1 14• f� I Is a I I + a . I • ' I iZ(p' a . C Z I 01 O I 0 0 a, !1 PV[Ol.r W i aWao00e1 1 0 01 1 0 I o e I1 2, r a061000001 0 oI I O , 01 e : 0I 0 0 O i n• 7, h•IOW./0a.00' 0 O: 0 of O . of 0 j 0 O 1 1 All M y I i I I I 1I 1 �. y ,+ I r• j I ( 0 I I I O . I I 1 o , , 0 ao Io 1 al o0 1 ole i aie I S. .p •p .a I • 1 I o o i o 01 e i of e I c1 e I n'. o • I O o1 l 0 , of O 0' O I 1 t • I I ' l l 1 I 1 •• { • i i I j I 1 N I b N I 1 • I N o a N a0 I.. y a 0 o ao a .I. a a - a s I[f O .1 0 -1 VI a W 4- • t C-10 - . >tn.,a n1n2-I 11IOPI1a 0 4N0 • . nlVfa _.,0 . N*3-• CO•- In o N O 0 • ,._ i t r nim r1 4An1 'boo a mwaL � • 1 I Soo O I•. -.IN NbI.. - C tri PGoizr < l •4^ - r r c I I _ ,nir 1 t I _ av +gym , 44, o.. •puma „ c. t.t r tr . Ol irf.r9 .V .n � . 1 .. in no i i isace z a 4. n V - nnnn-. D f- Z. r 2ZL2 A I KK tKK X. I.4 K a11A9A . n )9).^+? ). 2 C Plmm-nm m:• r V I O V 1' II K a 1, ZI v I I ! .111 W.I 1, I ID-. N' ) A 440OW 1$ tJr bf F ) ' I 2.1 O ru Pmr011 !. . . ZI .. M-I W JT-W I POOI.IW I n r t'0 NPO>I1 1 .IOOWW { m M .4 I ) ! r I O o 21.4.1 1Ii I - I- y Z i _ I I «1 N.1 _ I I 0 4. Cs I 1 I INi1 1 0140NoN11t 1.9 i I O I -IO•d00 mpw. m I 1 I f I 1 • • • I I 1 I 0 1 r I I I 1 I ') 1 i m1110.1 ! . . . I0 own.w;-n • v i • N •. I I I I• —.,,. I—i.. T TN in:..4 A4'm fn..1 W /11.+'lu % ,V.'co I',t1 i i' .r + y NnIWA 0,:...... 0.. .0.. �..f.:... WCW.. -. NC 0.. Il-I f A { O O O rp62 1!C P. { { eee9 ee111 000 OOW o10 I m -F'x im W 11 W ��� I o > 4.N• 0 COA { e 'fA m W m ofO m I I Z m a 0 0 0 o ro 0 o ♦ :I Iao I ^ m 0N1_ r •eM 1 • r 3 •Om 3 J einW2 1 I 1 A 014,. { 011 m oi1 m G11 In O'1 m a 010 DNS OP O L1 no C. O OWM t] r T . Coin o On no. no.. - ; A l D no. - n -1n i n inc , JW3z { W3w W3N IA OM :440MON OW. i e1.13N I el in ) 9 A u,D~9 J~« l0~.. .0•ti�+ iLL.~... NW~.. { 1 q 2 '`. W NO r ON IZ OM Z o10 IZ om 2 W "II' 2 w m n1 I ' nn nn • nn nn nn o • 0Z o e 0 f u{ • o el O O O A o e o r e o e a o 0 o• o Z o n.. r.. . ZI A I r N -I m i 1 -. n o e o O 0 C e e m 0 ~ I of o 0 0 0 o of e e o' o e W O K o .4 e o e e ? ? Z .. e 0 e e m A• o 0 e c e c e { 1 2. 2 Io oil 0 0e e e e ✓ « oW o 0' 0 0 0 o : n II 1 .. ro I i { 1 ; . j m I la Li id (0 e e ie o F N 0 16 r I. e: e 0 .,1 a ,P W 0. I 0 e e is o i i 1 *0.0 0 00-1 OIAI010 e 1e1 =..t m0 oom a e i z a I I„. : . : : : : : : : , . ..„ ,. ._: „ 1 : : : ; ; YY. 7. ... Y . . . . . . . - , t� 044 O0u`0440.0a01ti wn.00 -4 Un.DO r 1nm.00 '1-1 r A 000000eoO•Q•0 O 10JA - ..M0a - ..'O00 Ilw 00000000000�eo t o 4111111111111 +I .....000000 D x 1 02 00 II C 1 r 092r3-/..Y003. Fp'a- NIVNI Wra^.9 �;m 10 2 r I f. N ^ I 0 3 OI O �� O 0; = m 01 'f A a mcrLc A T N o M m O^LNW0. NI + 2 N V4Ba3 0 am0.0 ' 3 I I 000l--I1,10a Of O 01..N -I O,IPr r WUIt000, 0 003 M03 .3. 1N1 A 0.0000101/110 010f0110W ; OA ;(OA I 00 ++ PI O OOOOD00000000 M.O- .11.I0w ln1919191111191 Olin Olin •.WT3 • • TTTT T D a n ...Y-I-I-/ti-Iyl-I I\-10 _.,\-10 0\./w 2 01w 2 00 n j -0 3 I• I 00'no N WINny I../ 0.1On2O w~i 3 I o 00 .1' 09 O 10I 0 O O 0 ««« I«<CIC< O 00 -d 00 0 111. CC 2 0 0 nnnnnnnnnnnnn u-1 -1 -1 -. w' 2222222222222 to N 0 r A A I 1- nn nnnn000000 -I (0 -I tl4.K-t«<144 A �m i 0 m -1 IT .OAAAAL3AAA3AA 2 o e -1 n 0 0 o 2 0 o 0 sssssssasos>s a 2 z -I.....-1-{Y-1{titi r 01 2 -I mmmmm10/1lmmmmmm 0 2 0 00 2 0 o m o - O O o 00 0 o 0 0 r t0 0 1 i , < .0.-NNW m i a WO.ONNO I r C a 0 00000a a C a 00000.WW0.0a 0 O 0 0 0 0 ' ; )R N • 00000-O0000. O 0 O 0I O O 102 .. I 00000+ 0 0 0, 0 0 1I m P -1 ` a I 0 2 I o 0 0 00 0 0 12 i. 4 •0 O o; 0 0 10 w 1 f o t o of o o J I n I I I r In 0 oW IA N 0 0 W o V N 30 r 0C-10 0011-I Nm -1 m7mm 0 1.0. >O> 3010 MOM VI O 0 \ • J : ir1 — • 1 . : . . : : t : . : t . - . . . _ _ _ : :=`:-a ._-.__ _ _— • zr X. I Al cul a Z, 44 I'y D 1 n Y<'Yn it I d A . •VnO m o 13442 ' A onl V > I o i.py r v .0 Aria . AOMZ I m 0 •I .0404 0... i n m • • I I s! a CM I 2. A n • y ; OI r mr A r s i 2 ▪ n r r 0 I r • i 'N. A m -I m i < 00 f 0 A ' x z m o O r 0 0 < t i▪ v 0 o PN140 C A ' A J(U0 • A 7C A 1 N < 0 WOSO I 0 ^ A I I s o mows /Il • < r o A+s@ G o +I J ! a 1 o_ 1 s 0 0 4 �( 1 i i .o044 )R N 0000 0. J 0NIAl1J , �I • • 14 0 O 0 t i VC+0 101 O4+< ..Am 0 10> Z Y0o In 1 I � 1 • 1 1 _ ___.... j .. 0 c., .... (.: 6 0 e e 4 :: 0 0 0. 0 .-•:, . . . . . : , , . , ,. ... . : : . : : : : :: :„, „ „ . . . • _ . . _ • Vt 1Q • .. FKC - • nc �a *xraibxz`1 t+�'„"ttr ay w 4�4 �1 . , l� t Appeal No. 13,4 PID #12-116-22 12 0004 Date Received 4/13/199g Appraiser Steve Smell APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: Work: 1800843-0139 Name: KYLE FELDMAN, AGENT Address of Property: 7100 - 7148 SHADY OAK ROAD January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 4,985,400 Date property was acquired: UNKNOWN Purchase Price: $UNKNOWN Terms of Purchase: UNKNOWN Additions and alterations since purchase: UNKNOWN Cost of additions and alterations: N7A Is property listed for sale? NO If. yes, at what price (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ $4,284,966 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): SEE ATTACIDOTS OF OPERATING STATEMENTS. DECEMBER 31, 1987 MARKET VALUE APPRAISAL PREPARED BY COLDWELL BANKER. COPY AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST Si' ture"of Owner ' Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 -79 OCC' ::19),loo U 1/2/8B C 419 t4p0pa Y-'i s'To0 1/2/87 '7 Ry Dc O 3gsy 006 41', o00 c- Last Inspection: _/_/ S Appraiser: 1.4.t_ Building Permits/Appraiser Convents: 30C),00a Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments / Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: . . STATEMENT OF OPERATIONS PROPERTY NAME: SHADYVIEW II MAP REFERENCE #: 12-116-22-12-0004 COUNTY AND STATE: HENNIPEN COUNTY, MINNESOTA INCOME 1989 1988 I Gross Potential: 524,141 72.9% 526, 100 93.7%Vacancy Loss: 108,517 20.7% 179.319 34.1% ----------- Adjusted Gross: 415.624 57.13% 346,781 61.8% Other Income: 307,575 42.2% 214,630 38.2% Effective Income: 719, 199 100.07. 561,411 100.0% EXPENSES -------- Administration: 2.436 0.3% 1,055 0.2% Management: 17,406 2.4% 17,145 3.1% Security: 53 0.0% 0 0.0% Legal & Accounting: 9,302 1.3% 12,713 2.37. Utilities: 12,858 1.8% 12, 136 2.2% Water 8 Sewer: 7.098 0.4% 6.711 1.2% Insurance: 11,136 1.5% 7,701 1.4% Maint & Repairs: 732.106 4.57. 20,189 3.6% Refuse Removal: . 0.07. 299 0.1% Advertising: 6,572 0.9% 1,658 0.3% M]scellaneous: 1, 198 0.2% 222 0.0% Total Expenses: 96,165 13.4% 79,829 14.2% ----------- ----------- NET OPERATING INCOME: 627,034 86.6% 401,582 85.87. --------==, ---------- CAP RATE: 14.51 14.54 INDICATED PROPERTY VALUE: 4,284,966 3.312,118 C © 0 C. C G c' 0 0 r.D /? _' a O 0: ! • . I • tit e n -0 n' -I e n -I 0 n) -I 0 ML -I \ r \ \ \ \202 SrC2 Irc2 IrC2 I11111''''CZ I 0 m 01 Aln2 CO A.nZ of AIn2 N 7II12 VI 00Z I I I O 00 11 1 0 0,1 O I1 1 I 0 01I I I 0 n'1 I I > 4 -4T m3 m T mb 0 m ml+ n m m n 0 'II m0 > n 2 4 r V 000a.Ov 1 1.•. -4 00 -� (n o0 .4 nr -4 ..<oo �'Iao ., 4 0 III> `l0" aA MW-40 2 w I m 0 I r J'16 r'.o n.te mf• m0 I I 0 a (nI l IT a10 0 1,1 n b M 10 > in n p (4: > 0 . r PIW +I inre.. 0 • I 2 in re ^ a (111 0 .. n A CIn PT a, NIn1< P 4A .0 OMNI (0 00W.. > I 1 -• 0.1) 10 -C 1 00O a 0 1+0 o a.l o> a Oleo r --•1 �C I IOr aA (-0'•01 O 00> I Ce )04 mem A .a n N 2 n T in I lni I NO NO IAT • VI> N 7 /nW02 t.12 o —rot W00 410(n n m -0.1.• �•11I •t'10 0.10 0.0 a A 0 0-.-4n Or'S-IC 10••am •N-40 0-\-IO I r -I 0 I1•0 > Wb 2 Nb V N.c Wm n , a 4 3 10 an r N MO 0 N VI+' A N on. w 10 NO .• 4 3 .I n • .I n nVl • •10A • . I n> .. m m in OA 11 Ne a 00C 0 0 O_Z o en 0m 0 tri Oj ON 0 O n -00 +0 0 rA I O a C O n A 1 r PIse it 6In 111 inIn PI i { e II 0 eo = m o o� a Om o o1p x i -I OS n -0 00 o1n 0 en 0 O In Oe00 O 00 0 00 VI C O e 0 A O N . to m L r s a O OI O 0 0 0 O OrI O O[ E 2 O OI 0 O 0 0 0 01 0 0 n a O 01 0 o o O O O{ o Ot m -I • 0 1 . a • N b I Z . :I 0 O In r0 O e 0 0. O ON O 00 O OO O OO 2 \ P O O O e 1 0 O q O 0 0 el O O O'I O Y .00 o O 0 O, 0i a of 0 e{ n I { I i I • I { 10 10 W V --4 I N a .°I -I P N N a M e 14 14 1.1 Ol o �.1 0 1 O 1 0 L o L N s 0 In N 0 0 0 0 0 a e r n0-40 Sw..a 0142, 14A1n111 "2 i =„i I -.ow ASP 1. 0 \ , 1 . Zo I • I I. I h I. I - n . M n .1 N1 n M A z .. n �:1 , 1' 2102 2r C2 (0 2rC2 21C2 (0 Ircz :1 2 A C' 3,o 2 n T U.2 01 2.21 2.2 N Ur1.2 11 I O m 6.1 1 CI op I I I. 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 >1 D 2 2 II 1.10 00,A• "Al Ill•.O J. o4 ey '('C'ni .; In,0."Al 11.14 12' M 11.(m�o 1 c r r- 1,1 n r s1 Iv,'n3 I'\* ♦-Vol mo ru•.rI• 11 o 2 I. m 1 y s e 0 a14 1 �4 0 aN 11 0 2 in l9 z WI I T. C. a - a : .- N I. 1-In IO 00 p tr., .o IIID0 n01,14 III O 0:0 01 (. 4 a *In ' r 1 1 5o i 00 D I W- o I-11 I a I ♦ f0-." r I?I104 IOW' D40. oC a ,0 nlmy DIeD �_^ 2r l9D 21:2 01`n 2^a 1 ZI 01 I m O I WON law or I -•W0' W0•. I -1,10« in in In V e'en --nm I • e.T> m o'Iz -02 I > a n .04. 0 I 012 0 I e10~ I m 0O•Nn -.10tris. • r -I 2 IV -.LA0 --! I0 Fl IvO.W 2 0o N WO j I -I j e n. dl nL. 1 m VI! 0 4 oII 0 In +I O 1 0 0 m 1/10 2 0 a 02 O a oL o; o W' o i I 1 I IA I ..t I -'I«. I -. I Oe a 0 O Z I r r m I IIII I m 0 m nI n 2 2 j I m e; o 01 00 0 0 1 I e o eo I > C y o • . 0 m O m x 00 01 0 00 I m e' 0 eO o 0 00 y C ejI y m r a « > I I 0 0 ( oI o 0 0 0 e oI D N 0 0 0) 0 O 0 O O 01 0 > o: o I 0 0 0 0 0+L IT i I I. LI I 1 i m y = •1 W I N 0 ! I o 0 o o o,; ea 0; 0 00 2 S. j I o 0 0 0 Cr o I e t o oI OPN i eI I � •N • . r IO O « V N m y 0 a N in o •d O IN a p 0 0 1 ..• a r VI o VI 0 j 0 W re W I o ♦ a a + r I j I I 7040 7/043I j I I I 01112 11121114 o 2+_ >VI> 2••4 OW m 0 0 y1n + w I I 2 ( fn ;.` c, !.. 4'. tee, :7 0 .) i 0 00 ' • i i L... I_ 1 j CC'CCCCCCCC'I< • 0 01 -I 0 n' -I 0 nl y 01 II 2 m ..222222Z22 I D ; -. zr'c2 '. zrcz \ zrcz 1 1n I 0 1 D 1 I 1 I I I I I I n I Ill mmz yl 0102 10 AI02 II I' 2 y I I 0 0111 0 0111 Ll 41,111 ID 1; IX A�-00/00000 I y A O_OD -1 NZJin A I0D O. lI A 1, T Wo-A.J.JJ-JJ., .. Jln ..IOW= '2 oC .. I. ' r -.�� I+-s loos 1 y(n IG I r 0 LJWIV--O Wrm —sa, 'no 1 �j 9 Z r t ..10.0..1 A M I I� a 1 O D OM O I I m n s MID a1 9 W em I a� C 1I Z it r II, C a w m i r.W..' Ull4 m 4mmm c Om..3 co a1T.m . D 1 1 a I AO.N ate VIlIn W1-.M In OIar r am.; oat ..o= c.c.:, , IIIOO-JOcooN 'COD mo3 .OM I m 2 A to ID'nlnoln0.0 � 2 2 ; m o 0000000000 -W03 I 0000 ;02 I n m mmllli ll'nllllhlll •0'O .0m3 AID > M 0 yyyyyyy.Miy V.\-C N\.19 W\.0 r -4 O I rn fu too n. > -, 0 > ..0 3 rV M m N .o. 2 N• 0" In ' y 3 IIn W� A N ! m VI.l. " O n 0 0 M 1 I ««««<e O W; O 0 .r ON 0 O O 2 N n I 1 DD,>>>>» I - I - - n0Annnfnnn, a >E,I = nnnr0it0 ont2Ynn n• A 1 ! 1 <.[<K<A4A4..l m m I m z to 2AF21022A II IInI ti > 0 DD,DDD>DDD 0 oO a 00 I D 0 2 0 0 mmmmmrgmmmrn O O O 00 O 07 I or y y 0 0 coO ! m op M Ke o .<. I C I W- 0 00 1 Z I 01111*0 Py011 � I> N r i I W 0001 -.I I.. 12 > O OI I N 000000000 e O O 0 0 Zn >00000000 O O O O O m I a • s . j N '�j 2 .4 iO , O • j o o' O ev .i O ea 3 N 0 0 0 Oro a o0 40 N 0 OI 0 0 .I 0 O ; n i I I • • I I I • ' I N 01 0 y ;C. NO IO'0 �O I 1: O i0 O YI O r I I 1 vc-#o I sos OIR0ti I mwmm . to0> Wom I I I I V I ZAI I 1. C co oC C F:: Gs :; L e ,J �...n.; 1 r I r▪ 1.1100 n DID y y 2 cc n A n Y A NI eope O < D • m e �1p���aaaff •c neor� 2 y n r .A. N 1{ O D • i 1 D.'l13 lT • 0 n2C1 y • I II I om3ei ISio • y Mnn� N T • NC I) D ) •) A n or r ii 2 i 2C ~▪ In 1p Z• O e > I o r I I r I A 1 1 I , m co in m y 1 O . D O xi • i m t M 44 19 s • 2 O. aI. III +4PN 0 C LA .. >, • N o JI, ommo • 0,, m1Y01 osino p ) • ' I o. -own) 111 y• al' -Join- '.3 o a o om L. !() o I = I I I + o 0 �, n N I- M1 0+ J m aON OIN +O J+Jao W y I I i I .i 0 .i Z I I ) 0412P12.1 111]0111A 1 ilns • • II I aoUj p e w I i 2 • I I I 1 f 1 i I:,oi 11 II PIZ LI III lilt...r, 4.1 prit in ',I ria..i. ;.; Ti ••, ... m,.. ,i ' "COO • ••202 • -11001,1 -V00 o.....V2 v< .. VW 0-.3 O*0 0...41 .....a 0+ ,fni e.c..r -to; ..,..„ ....,r 1 : dp X •-/I04, -....0; ,....,... ! ,Asi 0 I . .•et1 yn , I • i 1 M. W ; .0.4... 13 1 l.11.0 el i q‘.41 r3 WO :.... 1. -•%,":! .i. -• ... ..,I .:.; .., - . ...,..,6 ,. .i, ",, ...; ...;.1 :.. ,T,Tzl; 4. ...., ,t-r-. ; -,-1.; 1 Co Z ; 11 $4 111 ..t NX . ow ; 'no 1.0,1 03: 01.s,:.,;:..- I ..4...,..c !:•1.4,4/X h.,...C.; 1../. ..01• • , 3 xr 4.,-14.: 1 Iso..4 ......., —n,.: r• . . . 1.00 3 1 i..0 2 -.14, -3 • 1,0 1.4.0 .1 3. .... A 10 4.10 4- II, -40 Cr 4.$ 11,... .4 ....00 In :44 ..in, . -.. . 4 ,”/ . 0.11 .n 0 .r i ti 4. , ,,, ra4 ., „... 'Sr, i • .00, u, ... 04, 4 • , •0, I. 0:11 0 0 0 XI -, O O. 4 0 0.- Z .0 II • -..] -.I.: -.1 I ...14 ,..,, .... i 1.'2 0 1.1 • :lb . :•• I ;i 1 4: r . ,..1. 21 1 • ' ill ...1 1 1,0 r ID , ,4 III O ' I. ...4 . ni 14 ! M I pi I P1 , : Of, fnIn . • $ •-,' $ 0 : 1-• ; fl 0 .4 ..,00 ..., ,-..1 00 I 0 00 4, 00 0 00 1 .. 0 C 0 2 i -Pt , i•M , IK ... .0 ., O. I-, .7., 0-0 1 ,..., 00 ' ,1 .'?D' Pj! ' PI,' 01 00 1 .,1 00 &I.: .0 W 00 • W < X. I r• , W ,., 1.4 IA W I P1 11 : .1 , I I V V f , C 0 I a' X)EP : to , CO ! la I r 3 30a 3 i 113. 4-4 r ; r r c. - I . 0, J$4 0 0 0 0 0 0 ; Cl a 0 0 30' 01 e I 01 0 a 0 ! 01 a , 0 0 V 2 fit 3 a 0 / 00 00 i Gi 0 I 00 111 .1 1 i .1.° 1 1 ... 1 1 •i I • .... . a... .. .4 I 1 a , I : 1 f V a i ;01 . . 401 ! I 1/1 0 a . . I 2 ! .,• .. .t au, ot 00 4,, 00 a oo ' 2, - 0.0°' 6 ;:,' H. .. a 6 ' ..., 0 0, 0 0,0 Oi 0 01 0 01 0 0 0 0, I •I $ $ I 1 I , 1 I $ I : I • . I $ j 1 i I I I I I I I i I $ I , i I L ; 1 L . i i. .. 1 W 0 l4 0 ut an . a, 0 d4 0 4 1.4 V Of t 0 I . ; ..,, o .• Cv 0 0 ..4 V i I 1 I • :, 1/0.421 31.0...3 01112V P1X101111 I• I• 1 0 I I i • nrOni . 1 ; , 2:..r. va,... _ I : 1 1 .C(3.0 I . IT'. , a ., II , N N. a I i se i I • I . . r i . , 1 i , 1 .1 __ ... . __,t„......,`f.,!..•.:t ...:....•:'t 4 I 7 4'1 4';!.;.:.1::::,,, ;•'.:•:':. ,.....-..s•-,.,„..,,„--_--- — -:. •. L L • OCL - L l LL - 111 • CL - L CP _ jC.;a0 I ;;;CO3'• -2.; ;14:01: ;;;t00 1;1'4.git0i :2.1, I ii.,.:'.,..,, 0+1111111111 .: - . ''', " " .f.,1' '?.,Z1 ."•?," 7,1 1 21- .• ....r .r, , , .._ , .01 . ,. 11,P.1 1 • 0; ‘• .......c.' 1 , 1 , -0 • 1, . 4.4, • : .. . J. :. ". 111• 4: I- . 6: • .4 1: 2: 1••.: .I,, 4.., ... ,,,. ... .... ,- -', ;-; . . . ., : .. .,t :: ' .,G•,, . ., :: - .1143 r" • ![..:.--: :, •: z 1- 4.11 111 4.1 'f: La/44 - ..J•J r..... •-.46r...I.,. • ...•,, •J7.1. ..."112 • a 0Z A, A ,s I.,..., 4,11.•-•-1 : Or..-...1 ......67 I.,40 0..0 ... , A'.1•6 ,t1 40 •I. -61, ; .. .1, .I A. ,/,1 .;.: , .2,1 , 10.1.11:o i ••• -s; ; •• ;;/. k.; //,'//. /4/ ./.• .-• ;kn ....1 , 0 •n -4. at , 2 se A a 0. ....14 , a/ A, 0:4 ,a A. 04 i cc a AI a, . . ! i 2, t . r , HI . In , in 1"• . In I n ! ri is i , I :, t ', -• ; " . ..,. , ! .. .. 4.. .,,, . 1 ,..,...;, i.. A , . ::., .;,' , i ',2! , . i , , . .,.„ , COO ! cc, .. .. . . I ...... .. 1 , 4/± , I 1 to , ,-. !I: . I 1 ,. ' I ,., I :., I C 0 I I in I I In I i P r . P-' 1 i 21 i 1 i 0 .1 , . 01 1. fi I..* "'1 . 1 , 0; 1. AI on 1 I 1 o 0 o at ; e 0 t 6 0'1 0 01 0 0 , 0 ,0 , P1 A . . I I , , , I 14 i . • i - i ,.. 1 I to ,t 0 • I I I I I I 0/ 0 I W 1 I ..o oa i o ; o O. oo ; . I' • O 6r . 6 6i ,• •..I , • 1 . . .0 i 0 01 ' 0 .... ! , 0 : III, 0 ,0 01 I'. 0 0, .0 01 0 a o , ! I I i I . • I I I I 1 • 1 . . • I I i • I I I ; ; •. ; I i I , 1 i - I I 1 i i I I I I i 1• : I . I I 1 I : 1 , I I I I I I • 1 1 I I I . ; . I I 1 1 1 1 I I i • a a • -.1 VI AV 44 ..I e a VI 0 a -.1 W a ... : o ' . 1 VI 0. to a a VI 0 3. a a N W 0 A o A 4. r s S• • • • • • me-40 •. . gams. • inamm . . . o ••-••- • udroci . , . • . nrum , I NA-. . , , • . . 'AC"0 ;.. • a , .I , I . • , I i I I . , I i 1 I i I . I i .I I I . 1 . • I • t ..,--•-,--• • •• -----•••••-- •• • --,...• •...-.•••'.:-••--,-,••,4.4:''':!.:..".,:..";-.4'7, .-4 7- . . . \. LI- ta I I e ' 4. t. t 4.. - . • • e ,-...ir.. .. `tY--.Ln?000001..' . JI�00 -fit In?6:! Al NyG' -II V.foD •, JUNE II Iu/b1.--_.-. UD Irn.11.••-•o -.Me Nr I -1•1 I t I OB :•:i N Oa I ) • tlj ! - '• • ' ree, 4 2.N t•1\OI ! N.1 1 T. N{ IJ'P 1 .2N I�J.an ,..... 1.'.. l,wl;l ,407, of 1, . . .n1.11n11.r1 Inn unlll n .,4 K -. 11 Il Ali 1:. •:��1'llit `�•t�t.g C'••nl. L11:1 . 14.1 c1'3.2 z, .1.1y I.0 IJ J j I ,r ^ill .11- .�i In -C 'TI .J 1' �O 0 �,i 1,. .l ...:.:•,_t.: 1n 0I 0 0 In 0 0, w 0 IA4,4•Tr cl,r.1111.1 I I ,0 i 0 Dby>...:"r`i 1 .1 In Co r �f1 11 1 n 1 m /- t O1 1 lY 22i2i3e212322 I 1 1 m y a • >..>n--.':.1.> :)i Om - ..0 ,.1.•m - 01 0 1• - o ' Inmmmmc nlmmin ,.i.. 2.1 ..v d .n 00 • of o • m • et • 11 a I I y I I •-I y I I I 1: 0 t. I . y A6 uo lotn oin r f ! (D' 1 t C! W0010 OOLO 0 0 Oi 0 01 0•• 041 0 I 21 el • I W.400 .DOOIYJ 0 O 0I 0 nj 0 0I 0 ! I 12111 D �{IIOO�IW JOInN 0 0 0 0 OI O 1 0 0 I m. y M. 1 I 0 m • N I 3. ? i a re i o I OI 00 of O2 01 0oIOf 01 =1, ! � oa a o! of m1 0 Ia • • • ! • I f i j • 1I lii 1 i ! I I I ! ! I W I N .. - 0/ O. Y .0 O CO A .) 0 0 P m N O T O O N ; 1 W ; W r ' . I ; I VCyo• Dail- . Y1mam • • mpmm • ' •.NO I nom I Wm-.I I m O • 04 N . 1 ! • I j I i 1 . j - I I ' I � • • ___I I :r.. 1 • -4 .+W+Mlfl 1N I 1 100 ' I • 1 I -4 COCC I r I3 1 I 2•02 i I If, I o 1:,,-7,m, I v > -i .i -, : -IR" ' - j Q r 2 G- 1 I In. 1 ter I a.,o r:. . r In 9 CO i 2 i I n, C 1/1 • .. • 0 ..1n♦ • . S. 0 I • -, 1-0 i•N1 fl,i • nwnm my• I { N 0.0•n• {f 0 • A • I N, o , ..1 ml p1naA*ond N 0 ,00W01 0 MOM... N .44.00j ll IH 1 • • • • r 0N,•,0 1,12.4 m 7omm .... C .. • •.II I 19Nm • 00-4 i CS-' 10 m 1 CmN %I 0 ur11.+rdb ess•so Imo+MWR•tom Iru.oasis'IIt•1 'r!"• �M"s• WNi[+�P3 IM[ ' NIIV15 r N30100 6e6 pop7.7 eta spy1 pees Jno pexy)e pun tpueq Jno i.e owe"ley peuDJalepun Au warnJd lep►send"Atsar rsa 7tlaalpr�rNu., • J0Wled IewU00 op pue'uollPJodioo sexes e '.our'sep'nb3'S'0 Jpopwle7 11 Wee se 'dlgsreuued lmJeue6 semi e lesunoo elels3 Ivey uosge8 8 wopUUe7 :A9 0IH0 dO W31SAS 1N3W311113H S33A01d$13 100HOS •eleldwoo sl'uen16 sl NOIIVZIIJOHYIV dO J LJJ7 s5U3 UOJUM Jo► esodlnd eq3 spun Jo "pl7 'sau/peIS B (lelmOon Aelse3 AO pene!OGJ Si uopeuluues Io eopou uepuM spun JBpeawW loeN0 pug eatJo► u!ulewOJ Heys pue uonezuoglne►o Jepe!slgl Jo uo!noexe eta uodn eouewwoo pegs pesuw5 ulewU•prl's6ulllRJS 8 geleoo5 Vetere►o uonepoglne pup'sJeMod'sni6p mu MUG peuBlsiepun eta AO pe!lopuoo Jo peumo sewedoid uo s3U6u peuonuetvaxnR wogs EPAM'loe►u!ABUJ0l3e Jo/pue'lueBe se Joe of pgzuoglne s!'•pl7's6unls3S 8'geleooW%else3 'uonolPsunl Jueledwoo Jo sunoo ero►eq Jeedde os'pepoglne eregM Due seloue1e Jo spieoq enpailslulwpe eJo►eq Jeedde os'sum se:eyeo0J os'sexes pus semen Auadad leedde of'slugwssesse pug slesle,dde ele8psenul os'swnse'elp of pezuoglne s!'ps7'03u!IIRJS q geleOoW'Asp* •Auedoid!Buoyed pue leer uo sexes Lamm py 6ulweouoo sn luesatdeJ os peuoglne • s! golgm 'P17 's6UIIISIS 8 gele30W 'Aelse3►o umd mil eonpau1U! II5M repel slEL NOIIVZIHOH1t1V dO 1:13i131 II melA APegS esnoUeJeM squid ueP3 :311 weouo3'VJ 11 woUM 01 5Jegl0 pue savoury rel wensleA pV :01 Iasueo)alsis3 MN ues99N't HJOPWVI a :.at.J START oF RETAKE The images appearing between this point and the End of Retake target are true, accurate, and complete copies of records that previously were not filmed or were filmed incorrectly. 4 r—s • LLehndorlT&Babson Real Estate Counsel TO: Ad Valorem Tax Authorities and Others To Whom It May Concern RE: Eden Prairie Warehouse Shady View II i.ETTER OF AUTHORIZATION This letter will introduce the Firm of Easley, McCaleb & Stallings, Ltd., which is , authoried to represent us concerning Ad Valorem Taxes on real and personal property. Earley,McCaleb&Stallings,Ltd.is authorized to file returns,to Investigate appraisals and assessments,to appeal property values and taxes,to receive tax bilis,to appear before administrative boards or agencies and where authoried,to appear before courts of competent jurisdiction. Easley,McCaleb, &Stallings,Ltd., is authorized to act as agent,and/or attorney in fact,with those aforementioned rights on properties owned or controlled by the undersigned entity. The rights,powers,and authoriation of Easley,McCaleb&Stallings,Ltd.herein granted shall commence upon the execution of this letter of authorization and shall rema;.n in force and effect thereafter until written notice of termination is recieved by Easley, McCaleb & Stallings, Ltd., or until the purpose for which this LETTER OF AUTHORIZATION is given,is complete. SCHOOL EMPLOYEES RETIREMENT SYSTEM OF OHIO By: Lehndorf&Babson Real Estate Counsel, a Texas general partnership, as agent By: Lehndort U.S.Equities,Inc., a Texas corporation,and its General Partner %t4 By: , d.�/ /-/� 1.-C`-`--- Vice PresidentRANDALL i.RCST Vico President The undersigned has hereunto set our hands and affixed our seals this the /4Zlay 0 999. ciNct,,.i STARK • Y..as r 1no Q 7301 C.Aor iPrn,m so.0•sit S10•eWu,Smwol i0 In1{f0•fIOS•TLx:IOW•TMmper ISM WHO END OF RETAKE BAND OF INVESTMENT RATE OF CAPITALIZATION - INDUSTRIAL THIRD Sl1ARTER 1989 Loan to Value Ratio: 74.60% Conventional Loan Rate: 9.79 7.j03 Equity Ratio: 25.40% Safe Money: 7.72 1.961 Total Cap Rate: 9.264 Effective Tax Rate: 5.275 Total Cap Rate Including Taxes: 14.54 Sources: Conv. Loan Rate -•- AIREA Research Department First business week of Oct 1989 Loan to Value Ratio- AIREA Reasearch Department First business week of Oct 1989 Safe Money - Three Month Treasury Bills Moody's Bond Survey September 1989 Appeal No. J S Date Received 4/13/1990 PID # 12-116-22 42 D013 APPLICATION FORM Appraiser StPVP SinPil 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: Work: 1800-843-0139 Name: KYLE FELDMAN, AGENT Address of Property: 10000 76th STREET WEST January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 2955800 Date property was acquired: UNKNOWN Purchase Price: $ UNKNOWN Terms of Purchase: UNKNOWN Additions and alterations since purchase: UNKNOWN Cost of additions and alterations: N/A Is property listed for sale? NO If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 2,596,362 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): SEE ATTACHMENTS OF OPERATING STATEMENTS. DECEMBER 31, 1987 MARKET VALUE APPRAISAL PREPARED BY COLDWELL BANKER. COPY AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST. Sigure df Owner J re't Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 3bcccc a575%(c ,973311GY) 1/2/88 3%,�ooc ciSS8OQ C- 1/2/87 36CCCO 31/3soOQ 2Vs WCQ L Last Inspection: a/ Appraiser: Su 4Ce- Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sold /D-` 6 4-0( w 3,'1oo,000 Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments / / $ ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: STATEMENT OF OPERATIONS PROPERTY NAME: TECHNOLOGY PAfy: iI1 MAP REFERENCE #: 12-1 16-22--42-00 13 COUNTY AND STATE: HENNIPEN COUNTY, MINNESOTA INCOME 1989 1988 Gross Potential: 381,317 87.6% 370,161 92.3% Vacancy Loss: 98,637 25.9% 105,263 28.47. Adjusted Gross: 282,680 64.9% 264,898 66.1% Other Income: 152,850 35.1. 135,989 33.9% Effective Income: 435,530 100.07.. 400,887 100.0% EXPENSES Administration: 1,414 0.3% 640 0.2% Management: 12,763 2.9% 10,537 2.6% Security: 0 0.0% 534 0.1% Legal g. Accounting: 6,229 1.4% 6,232 1.67. Utilities: 6,538 1.5% 5,994 1.5% Water S Sewer: 1,904 0.4% 7,276 0.87. Insurance: 7,400 1.77.. 5.082 1.3% Ma nt . Repairs: 14,472 3.3% 13,844 3.51. Refuse Removal: 72 0.0% 169 0.0% Advertising: 6.542 1.5% 797 0.27.. Miscellaneous: 685 0.2% 309 0.1 Total Expenses: 58,019 13.3% 47,414 11.8% NEI OPERATING INCOME: 377.511 86.7% 353,473 88.2% CAP RATE: 14.54 14.54 INDICATED PROPERTY VALUE: 2,596,362 2,431,0.39 4 611 r '1 1 0 1 n 1 p r 4. m m. r m mL 1 m A ~ ba e n IA ply y N'o0 -I N4'ew .~. r a m Soo* c 1 coI K o o y n loaw+ 2 e oDx ..�ex m r c 1 N -00 IV m m .o = r Sc>n ^'n • • �? - o m 3D'A3 I P •aI O . wI V N o �r nm t •i I m ret�o: I m�i a 1.41 o o{1a= 11 w torso +lpJ CO Coay • oomz con co x ti nt0 n.1 me o . *' m o 1.00.. 00 •.400 WGz n to 0 r mr 4. eN~-~I em-I I D -. 0 C w Ne. .V W OM y K = r m " n m O O 0V 0 . 0 CC 0 o 03 0 o�. o i m n • fD nn 0 I N D D1 C r n I • z2 m 1 nn Ca \ 3 • a m -1 m •00 m11 • 00 0 0 .. 0 0 0 2'a mm e m O ~ z e n o o 0 0 0 [o 0 0 0 .. z 7 to s Id N -. C O y 10000 $ 0111. a x D _ 00; D 04 O O O OI f 0001 00i a 01 0 O n ... D • o •UI awl, oollllll o o O t11 ..I -. . C WooW e 4 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 « - O cm c e 0 .00 • O A W wal • 0, 0040 0 AAWab; 0 N. 000A 1d' owow, m ti . • I i r N P . y P W p I f t VC•10 0 120 I momm 1 • 3.iws t Z K ( r:0eem 7 0 \ . 2 0 0 Ii .Jr—.... •IP o C ! ..16 ao j !i� • To ;nN' o1 Rn �I • •a N I 0 i .w l i- • w Im• , r - I.s... m ufl 1. ' .2 Ir, f IX I. wr.'. :. ..I00 rt•c:J «..1 .f1.1 I rli 1, D )+b i < I rN f' + 1 1- ? 2 •IIKI r i 1. 1A ;+ .•� m (n i� ^1 RI • 'J I~'im GI 0 I :.I In • ^ I7 : b • ci .oj w ii G+ r • I �.. I •.I . kJ:: o .7.f o , ra. :- n -1 ` I• I -�N m 1 ! (• i 1 • V 9 i D R D • i044•41 o I o 0 I o 0 0j o �I u 0 I ! mb o I o o o o a a o o Zt . D I I .1-10 o o o e o e e1 e I • III, -. -4 t 0. I I I a i I ( 1. t o I I j I e • f = ^ 1 i ! e1 oo o e o ;! o el oo I . I I • er 0 • 0 0 of a of o n- o i 0 ' o, o o I of o o, e I I + i I i I • l I • , • i • _ , W N 0 o • N -1 a N 0 ,J N H o N o e .0 W 0 0. D e o o N 0 W N .I • DM..D 01,13-1 malmm I 0 4414O n 1001 ..CC t0)••• • N O. I I I I I I r I ; , . ; I I I I :a +. : c. = -.. . . ._ . . , . .`,. .L _ ` ` L L ` ` ` ` : ` L L v 4.r.1. ' in I .m ;. .. III . • I., D D r b i D • y r a r j • I , . 1 i. s i r. , n r , O 11 I it r :0 . II I 21 T1 .. .N 14 —Wli I CI A • ' N •{4r0mi M 1 b S D • r ` ' I ,:at O VN1+1.1 r 21 r 1N .•. 4.omrnry I Cl. r > O UIOPI; I IN r f 1 1 N O a6U10�1 i I. . I I o1 3, o I I NI V I :I o i 1 I I , �i UYONai CO I 1 • 1 N. PfJ I O PuWPWV'1-.1 1-I 1 i I I • I i I I 1 . I 1 j y I - • •• • . 7C-io aNr,,, 1 om3N 1 I r1AmA • 'O • ...coo • SNn I N'- GNr . I m co N u I r 1 I I I I I I I ! i I I I I I I- I . t � , Appeal No. la co PID # 24-116-22 43 0029 Date Received 4/13/1990 Appraiser _Farl lent APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 414k-0d io Work: w5Q-S4a3:. Name: ' Tc.ep 1or . Address of Property: 92-SS -1-11- c 6 Q r" January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ Date property was acquired: Pu chase Price: $ 14 S r-r) �Terms of Purchase: C -JUr � . Additions and alterations since purchase: 3)ee YJ . Cost of additions and alterations: .41 7-00. Is property listed for sale? If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): ign ure o A ier Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Build�in Total Property Class. 1/2/89 S0000 i -7C) I77oO0 k_ 1/2/88 i1S000 151700 fZ 1/2/87 35c0p 1094,00 1,4,1bO0- ,Q Last Inspection: a/j/lp Appraiser: 5A,-I Leyt- Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments _% / / / $ ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: No. l CVQO DateaReceived Li)1-1 l Appraiser APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 9 4l-y4o3 Work: c1U 1,-I '� Name: l dc;4_ Address of Property: Qrc+(L f 41 Ljr wolf La-tc. OR.-/Ljcr January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 4 3izc p._ Date property was acquired: 1,903 Purchase Price: $ =f,frx: {.roc Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): Signature of wner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 �•,c gG/C�J l` 1/2/B8 1/2/B7 3ay� > — 3a3yoU v� Last Inspection: / / Appraiser: Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments _%_/ ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. 3 O �� �t,�� (�n� ev3=-- Date Received L. Appraiser APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: c-fl-,N c 3 Work: 41L(1-L( y:3 N ame: 1.k.)0.l((h o i. 4-(c k• et l Ci-N1 Address of Property: UJ'-F(V ) ?Ou+(t- D 7- ant (St_�-� C`_tJc January 2, 1990 valuation as it dppears on the notice: Itc 9 y UO Date property was acquired: l` Q,p Purchase Price: Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): d L s c L (1 cu'- LI/ ()APR*1f �,j.// /( I' f�� Signature of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Buiidinq Total Property Class. 1/2/89 15-f007 -- ,5yc00 VL- 1/2/88 ✓L- 1/2/87 bhco — Frhe,42J y� Last Inspection: / / Appraiser: Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments / $ _ / $ ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: - Appeal No. !3l 1/6- g Date Received _y/i-Jyc.) Appraiser APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: qyl-y 4 O 3 Work: Name: ta,,, II CULL .trtct U-u -.Fran( De-.;e_L- f tu-4't Address of Property: SLu Uu.tlol t3 ��z)wlr l-c�(E. (k,,A e.(- January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ L,2, 0r,0 Date property was acquired: Purchase Price: $ 30,e,(7,c• ik Terms of Purchase: }u Additions and alterations since purchase: Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): i2e CB c` C� Nf5 Ihef�ic�. /i nli .� //( Signature of t wner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/B9 1/2/88 4-70r c' — - Lr- 7000 8- 1/2/87 rd70O — 1-1- 700 ✓L- Last Inspection: /_/_ Appraiser: Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments / / // Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: /l_//6 az L/C/ CD fl Appeal No. 13�. / Date Received - c ;c� Appraiser e✓c ,red/ APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: `HI 4 4 0 3 Work: 9,1 I- 4.2 e,3 Name: LCxi.11cu t(.��+c cl � e5tcid 1 M—r Address of Property: I,c.4 3. 31t_1 <<7lu tt1� g4 January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 1 7 Oa) Date property was acquired: 1"1 5..; Purchase Price: $ Terms of Purchase: !-,nc{evuclt Additions and alterations since purchase: Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): /1//e//z 42 Signa't reof Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 ;'o00 — 110000 ✓L. 1/2/88 /55/00 — / S,OO ��- 1/2/87 1,/i o0O , +)00O ✓L— Last Inspection: /_/_ Appraiser: Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments —7- / $ - // $ ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: rl a/ �j/ Appeal 133 Date Received y j)70 Appraiser 4c,sr APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: �1 Work: c-44I-43L3 Name: t�jallr ( E 4.AU-5 car l 'reeIL k �4 t hcir ``eASKJf Address of Property: Loi- -311-t_S4s Cbc-mf c-i £-(-t> January 2, 199D valuation as it appears on the notice: $ WO,o c o Date property was acquired: lti i(,o Purchase Price: $ 3 ice, Ae _ Terms of Purchase: Iv oFe Additions and alterations since purchase: Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): !/A n //({.17777 Signature of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/B9 1/2/B8 1/2/B7 — — — — Last Inspection: / / Appraiser: Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments — / $ _// $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. -l/( �, � ai �3� Date Received -r Appraiser APPLICATION FORM 1990 EOEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: cfq(-y 4 C3 Work: qyu-Li?,es Name: Wa.11v�ex. C-(f. t:— rrratis Address of Property: Lr (0, t�Ir:Ck f —P)lu -ctk h January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ (y5,cxo Date property was acquired: t 9-lt„ Purchase Price: $ 34c,c Ae_ Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): 0,5t \3 d1s �,ccb ca f CIS rn.cihr' �(A /l(( //r( 'Y , 7 Signature of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 — ,1/2/88 1/2/87 — — — -- Last Inspection: / / Appraiser: Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments % / $ _ %/ $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. 1310 PID # 16-116-22 31.0O39-.. , Date Received 4/17/1990 Appraiser Earl Zent APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: '' 3�- ,?/ a Work: Name: ) < 1; 3 Il :, , ) �� Address of Property: /c1 `/ 75- Pic January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: io Y c'C?c Date property was acquired: II- e I Purchase Price: $ Terms of Purchase: w Additions and alterations since purchase: Ilo11 E Cost of additions and alterations: it, r} Is property listed for sale? nu If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ )3`7, S-o What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): •'cl,, F h�� .c /1,•, ,{ Signat re of Owner l Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 LioccC ;c/CCo i "C% k 1/2/88 /.;ci 50C.; /5-1700 1/2/B7 0 SIC tJK3CO ;5'170O ({ Last Inspection: = ,-/c,, Appraiser: n,4 Ze„±— Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments ri/ / C k.0 $ r, '' iUY J0,0°Tp Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. i 3 PID # 23-116-22 43 0016 Date Received '4 Appraiser John Sams APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner /- please print) Telephone Home: y -0903 Name: / ,M R 5 O(. e L�n Work: �3/ g�rvy Address of Property: lIG.sz me /4/7 0 UiY1 Kd January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: 3 2 1 d0 O Date property was acquired: �,� - Purch se Price: $ ,2 7O,p o Terms of Purchase: /0)a40 Additions and alterations since purchase: MO J10t Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? /L/a If yes, at what. price S (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 2 7/dae, sa What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information):f 1 1( 2 2 M T, C UIW E /�.f /,-e. ,r h.# 1 3 4. .. �,� fri2 . 9 - ,4 _ ►. ?x-e-s4.-41 fr> Sig ture of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of a licant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 ^,. 7 75o5.0 -=•oar? ti 1/2/8B -?qjO-) ors p./S100 1/2/87 ) �lg4-lQ_ =l�✓? k Last Inspection: / / Appraiser: Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments _/ / $ / / Board of Review Action: I) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. /39. Date Received 4/18/1990 PID # 35-116-22 11 0072 Appraiser Zent APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: W-G Z lC� / Work: -' qe- Name: "77 F,.'r y b.� ( r c C1n,t,4 R!i',N A' ( /r,,V+rl Address of Property: I I r'`'I I I �'u7Gi ( ,ANL January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 17 3,c-(,(O Date property was acquired: c.'.. -'; Purchase Price: $ IC -;',cct• OF- Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: L / �� <,%7tr ft/ Cost of additions and alterations; cc• Is property listed for sale? Al/ If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): 7crw,2 f �Aic I.• E%`,) /Ire hn. /✓rT- i �r"mil' � -� /ci !/- id((, 11`Z- J/'i)!-e a--As 1/e.Tl7-7 C�rz__ I y _ ,i Lc'" 'tuiz,C' ['Or;C lei Fl- C.✓I /h- •, 7,/t" 77,✓! 77 - 7L1: devS[ LvYYS (7›.157ec:• "V i97S r^,K.rt, ita,; ilemn-5 / Signatuyei owner Please note: This form requests private or`confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 48200 124800 173000 R 1/2/88 44300 1I45O0 158800 R 1/2/87 41800 108100 149900 R Last Inspection: / / Appraiser: Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 10 /17/89 CRV $ 163000 WO 9.5% 8 / /78 CRV $ 109000 WD Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. 1'10 Date Received 4/18/1990 PIO # 26-116-22 42 0009 Appraiser John Sams APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: I,,(-0- f /1`) Work: <; 7,it Name: (-"G ry , ( ,e ,c, Address of Property: r I\I( (_c,i r _n C I.c 1 January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ /✓r <rr. Date property was acquired: r'rx,' Purchase Price: $ rro Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: :i/r ( ri`iF“ rl '(a Cost of additions and alterations: fl�> rrci— Is property listed for sale? 71.(' If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ / What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information):/ t r /')/I Y r fry) / �/‘--,11 /-l�E'‘,'4cf `f tr A��i 1 12.; (.'•7 (i z 4 Lt/ It! Z11_ ( �/L�L E ),461,)/ 74. [-7/ 6 /.r //Id.irf 7 11-6-7114) Signature of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 36000 104900 140900 R 1/2/88 25600 I00800 126400 R 1/2/87 24200 95100 119300 R Last Inspection: 12 /20/ 88 Appraiser: John Sams Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 4 /9 /87 CRV $ 144,000 WO 9.5% 4 / /82 CRV $ 125,500 WO Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: LcJ /TTEX/ }}PP�gL, Appeal No. 1 y Date Received 4/18/1990 04r116-22 31 0007 Appraiser ' E. APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 4 37—/55g Name: .13 /0 V&SEN 83&—g6E.. Work: it Address of Property(/ 53/8-20) 74-4*.f ?E /€/22./164( C/RCCE January 2, 1990 valuation g iS Naplear on the notice: /33400 ,,,,-.", , Date property was acquired 8) IKE7* Purchase Price:' 000]3k.a..T..cZv. Terms of Purchase: (/mCfi4(o6 C ��O � 9 Additions and alterations since purchase: NOvUE Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed fon sale? tip If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement (a Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ Cf��) Vaa4/440,) What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information):� io %P- • gnature of+Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 2b600 104800 I 4b0 DB 1/2/88 24000 98000 122000 DB 1/2/87 24000 9B000 122000 DB Last Inspection: a_/J / 89 Appraiser: Fart 7ant Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments TO /83 CRV 12� 3000 WD 9/_/18 CRV $ 96250 wn ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: _ 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: z4G-90 OF $bp D 01E-cc) BEcAuSE nY JOB ReQUm6-5 ME 70 7e9t)E ouT of TOtOiJ 1 _.[. 4M e /'S(:E TO 447-7E.VO YDve_ G3OA-e O M16/i vc, MY 19-PPE4(... /5 BAssA D?/) T//E- "No A1Aeee7 4)4C-elE 4SSESSP/� T O 40 /0E71/T/C4C.. AtDAseTY 70 T4 T14)0 Doug' ,kbt)6.4c00)S 7/fAr 2 /Of T.e w�i y��e F�-�5 Peon .c ocA7 .4T /s3Q/-93 7 rAWE YEAR As ,'/Y 7W O P.eDP6;e74/!.5 0 978) sM/o AMS T/}E u4/16- S'4 FobT4GE (/D DES,/6x) Tff91/64607 THE ifeoPE,erY aT /5391 93 7.ei ��0�#S S (/UE 4N0 EnKff 5/� Olt T/E � / antY ��,.c- NaerET �� OW 4)ED 4iVO T#(15 ERA 5/G� s As-5 A-PPOSEl) 70 / Ni T d4WC FOe 7/f6 COHot 7 Be-Dega 56- 7rv0 AMOrP Foie /S39/-93 T,e/tua7 ciecCE Aer j r pAlaEs Zpp � �Rc/f 5/aE Ae°/3D///o o u �c) ,tfPL YD To667f�i�, MY 77V0 j.eOPE,eTYES Ake- rA,ert-M0 47- /33/Y00 - /3//SOO, T /5 /'/Y , -EEuxXo//M/D 4-7- 01 Z e 7-116t. E574T6— A GEC T5 1 4,4e SPb *) TO/ T/1-4-T My AeoP6,e7Y Weil..o 13E Mc 0/F1'/cu67" TD sEG( ,EC4u5E 7? Avvesroe. "'wee-Er ff its Da", c.E2b tag- TD 74 >4-4465. -Z DD •1)0T Pam_ ?*A-T 2 coot-D SEAL MY coif&[.&TE Oou8z-E- Raz. fO_E OP_ 6t) t) 716 54.4(E £ET4/C. 1e/CEE 45 T/fE z 7Whi) /fotIES #T /-3 9/-93 T.2/<C_/u.W( C//e C CE, /T /S ,'D,e To e679-5t () Tf44T -17 Av+"/ Asir/(4, ,cod 4 eEOu cT/o4) /,v AI N4xr T v-eie S To TEE /litroemOz 514-T e'D OA) NY 41PU6¢7-04) OF /301000 t //S OOO E5/ECTMECY T/f4 rdu FAe SiDERiEnov • Glee/776V APPEAL, Appeal IN� Date Received ved 4/18/19 O PID N 09-116-22 31 0006 Appraiser &.7. APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: q 3 7-/5 Name: ��1 .V%SEN Work: it Address of Property�� X 3( Zv3'�/ —' -o) ie/w- i.' Ciecc January 2, 199D valuation 't app•ar on the notice: $Oa) Date property was acquired; ; d 7? Purchase Price:Ire0•1111#754 aloft 2 //Yoo4D) Terms of Purchase: � Q Z(MD,e746. ) Additions and alterations since purchase: NdWE Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? it/O If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement 6 (a Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $5(0 �/a OOP) What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): .2* � cf 9 nature of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 25600 102700 128300 DB 1/2/88 24000 96000 120000 DB 1/2/87 24000 96000 120000 DB Last Inspection: 8/15/J9 Appraiser: Earl Zent Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments --7— / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: p� 130o PEaM) BEcAu5E f!Y JOB ,QcQu/ 65 /M6- TD 73&9 ) OQ7 op rota()/ ,z A-M a ua/3GE 7-0 A-T7 A13 Ye5t/ _ R3O•4,eD Ne6/Aveo, MY dt-PPE4L /S 8A1S�1> O.tl 1 /990 N4 R'T (,)4C/-/E 4S$4 SS TO ,A) /o ut/c e... /eol -y 70 7f/E' T&&e, Dou4r.E- ,8ait)6AcO'OS 74474 .Z /4PPby4e/. 4 , 7, /5 Reos 3 .LDc�4TEo /s39/-93 7,./LL/4W c%ecGE, -,Z T W 4S �1Y 7& R.eOP € ' :5 (Me ,wo /MS Th`E 8R�/E �� AS 7e'�.ed/Ca/F�T 5,V/E' S4 ,r-ooT4Gc ibUO DES/L� %HE A-T /639/93 e/ u � SS ieRT Y ,C/.UE ,4/VO EAc'/f 5/DBE 5i 7ffE OC Ma[�x�T � UeUED *VP 671C41 5/AE 'S 4 � cos/PCE-rE q'S f}PPDS "D 7D / MR'e'CES p�ae /539/-93 �� G�� ,4,P£' Tir/E� ?CUD �yq,P.,CET e.911! 1 Gcd ZOo Foe E/'cff 5/DC Ael/3D1/40 a (.4.u{E.t) .400ED feoPEp rYFs AoheE ,v,9.ertrED 47- /3✓/y0O t /3//3OO. 7rf.¢T 0i Z OTffEt. ,QFi4L EST.4TL` /T /S ,yy �E�t-/�tXo ADD �O,pcP6,eTY Wt�u.�,0 A&Et)TS 1 SPb *.) TO/ T444-T /'iY /3E No.eE 0/1=F/CULT TD •SELL BECAa56 THE /•t10e570P. ,40,4erer /MS OW/ND( 7D &A" TD 74-k c ,v&' 5. -Z Do .UDT p _ T/ 4-T .Z coact:. 5E7.L. MY caf DDQ8 Fat_ "ME De_ E'VFV 746" &WE ,eE741C- ip.e/cE 45 Tiff Z TWU/N ,COMES 447- /53 9/-93 7-,e/4L/Iby eAect.E, /T /S Fae T/Ws +e-460J 7q -T -L 44i RS/14X. 1COZ 4 ,eEoa cTAW iA) MY A/4xrET vniES 7o T4F 4NOa47s 57'4 TE'Z) O•) NY .9PPVG -7-04) OF /30/00o t /z8/000 €e,EsiteT/ ?; 7-#4 YOU ' roue_ co,US/De 47 </ Appeal No. I443 Written Appeal Date Received PID # 26-116-22 12 0024 Appraiser APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: J 3.7- I Q Y 3 \ Work: y;; 1—Z?-OO Name: w ufr‘ . L (a.>0iUEYL- Address of Property: 9 �{ C( 2 ���1+-� ( C�2- r2( (3 4_ E P January 2, 1990 valuation as i ap ears on the notice: $ 281 . cab Date property was acquired: 3 2 '/ c. Purchase Price: $ :L So, o0 0 Terms of Purchase: CO&-wz r,o.Jt9 t. Additions and alterations since purchase: `(JO A.l C Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? ,00 If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 2 5 0, b6 O What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): Ct11.Gaups Ivsd ,Q 32 17-2SO. Uvo Sigri`ature of wner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 68000 213000 281000 R 1/2/88 60000 18900 78900 R (partial) 1/2/87 2700 2700 L Last Inspection: 1 /20/89 Appraiser: John Sams Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments / / $ // $ ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. ILI PID # 04-116-22 43 0093 Date Received 1 Appraiser • },.5 .Ce APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 93 1 .1r9( 9 ^� Work: Age /940 Name: �oHN f-1. £ U& .LwscD Address of Property: 6 8 73 \..../oo D 1.,4.N b 172 January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ iz q zoo Date property was acquired: Nov '8 Z Purchase Price: $ 2 o 000 Terms of Purchase: C..4-a w 4 c/A (p4 10083) Additions and alterations since purchase: CONsrfLucT-.D s'u6.&.e— F,4- -a's( 3- 1 EoYeoo M No u.se' Cost of additions and alterations: 478 000 Is property listed for sale? SElLl i. Jf--yes, at what price $ ii 9. 000 (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ /p g 000 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): j 1'20 PERT'Y ta/A-S /..i STF_D FC E. SAtE Fi2o'. REf3, /'8 q '7o Jc..N �ce 9 w,**4 E ws. lesr,u G. P2 E w.4s I c //9,000. /Jo o r-FeeS W c of N.ME .s,- Tr-ems- P2.tcE. -i Low EZEo P Qtcr co l/o,000 ,w p jYLfeP 7o saw_ i- VSELF. Kb 6FFEQs WFo1c mw.4>K. Co PI EL o p 'ac rruw- DOC.cwM6NTS __ AO 49 7 o CoC ?- F wv pi E.P.e s ►R,R-r'E oou12 S' nature of Owner Please note: This form requests private o confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 35100 94100 12V6-0 R 1/2/88 34000 91100 I25100 R 1/2/87 29200 93300 122500 R Last Inspection: 9/a1/87 Appraiser: Lorna Lisell Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments _/ / $ / / $ ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: 04-116-22-43-0104 Appeal No. MS Date Received q/lq/1gg0 i' �� • APPLICATION FORM Appraiser Lorna se n 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 9. U - I Name:-i)A1e 4- PAE y (q P2e� Z Work: �/ � .4�io Address of Property: /4/PY /,/[Cry January 2, 1990 valuation as it ap ears on the notice: $ do 9 , 900 Date property was acquired: a/8 Purchase Price: $ ig„l, coo Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: c'o,ei4'rriY - c...)&pfy,r,✓- ux„do,,) e,(1L 4.UM Cost of additions and alteratio s: ? Is property listed for sale? ho If yes, at what price $ — (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ o?oo.000 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): 0 A)0 Aitl/k, 4loce. Lax,Yr/ec/ /it4.sle•xi )0/, 'IA e X 4/4' rho) .>,1awEn1 (a clut. peesa>, 00 71,_) 1, , @, &- i,) 14 bo,wink w /IS 1'671/M9 Signattureof ier Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/B9 46500 163400 209900 R 1/2/88 45000 158100 203100 R 1/2/87 386 0 141200 179800 R Last Inspection: 9 / _B7 Appraiser: Lorna Lisell Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 17- /.$9 CRV $ 182700 WO 2/ /82 CV $ 174900 WD Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: • Date Received 4/19/1990 • • Appraiser Earl en , PID # 06-116-22 32 0039 APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by/owner - please print) Telephone Home: 4/2-9`hI^76,/0 Name: /t'( qv/G. L. 1107.50e1 Work: Address r j01/2-gy2-�335 Address of Property: 6775 �61'S /??"1 4-we. k/eJ January 2, 1990 valuation as i appears on the notice: $ /63, 90U Date property was acquired: A//A Purchase Price: $ Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: /UOnR. Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? AM If yes, t �what price $ ,9 , (attach copy of listing agreement) Wal 1;10,4 aw /3. o I —,J Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ /di 7 OGO What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above statld value? (Please attach supporting information): MQ eke 4 /SR/el ,4nuCyi r .h,,. e. ATPrr,X % �jj(/ tax_ /Vo c,c:a.S .4. IS J.OG ignatu a of Own ,q„a,,f `'Ou/W,d Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year vales: Land Building Total Proper_ty Class. 1/2/89 23200 140200 161400 rig 1/2/88 1 22500 135600 158100 DB 1/2/87 %, 21600 130200 151800 DB Last Inspection: 10/28/86 Appraiser: Rick Petersburg Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments T/ /79 CRV $ 135000 CD 11/_/12 ray $ 120000 wn Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: 1 SUMMARY OF SALIENT FACTS AND CONCLUSIONS Purpose of Appraisal: Market Value Property Rights Appraised: Fee Simple Ownership: Mark L. Thompson Location of Property: 6775/6785 192nd Ave. West Eden Prairie, MN Date of Valuation: January 2, 1990 Type of Property: Residential Land Area: 26,259 square feet Building Size: 2,128 square feet 1,064 sq. feet each side Value Indications: Market Approach S 124,000 Income Approach S 124,000 `i1 • r :� ' .,. its r.' 4r • O 1 in /Mx- 4 • • • • O u I Ci 0 0 0 C T C `J -J v v T T • I IS I I I I I I I r N I T is co T T T T T 10 I rt I I I I I I t N N NJ N N N N Z N I NJ N N N N N I I I t t 1 l NW I W A W CO .- W N I IIIIIII o C 0 0 C 0 0 C I 0 O C C C C W A 0 0 A I I I I11'N•• I N C W W 00 CO 10 3 It N T C T O C •U 1 C I A T A A C. C. R r N I R I 0 7 I Ot A CON I \ \ O ' O OI N 1 0 COtO C 0 v r \ \ \ \ \ \ ID I CO 00 00 00 00 CO T • 0 'V V CO T 0 u0 V • I n1 to a' 0 1 I N * N 1 b} N .-• I '0 C N T N 0 V N 'V T O T 1 1 7 CO N •.0 I T A N NJ «•0 0. O 0 0 I C7 O O {�(111 p O O 000 N 0 i O rr I 0 0 0 i1 O O 11 •D I I 1 1 L • I. I. I * o i 0' \ 1 0 t11 W 0 T 0 cn ,1 • Ul C (1� N 10 CO 7r1 I 0 N - W - W '11 1 1 1 * '* bt M * *1 C O T T T i11 iN 'V 01 •0 W 'i T > , ,0 • • Cl I i.0 ;0 U1 f11 111 • t0 N N rC CIl I i 4 Market Analysis The subject property is a twelve-year old, non-homestead double bungalow situated on a 0.60 acre lot in an area comprised of 80% single-family homes, 1% two-family homes, 1% apartments, and 1% commercial land use. The frame exterior is in poor condition and there is an amount of obsolescence in the interior of the home (original fixtures and decorating). No additions or improvements have been made to the property since it was built. Due to time constraints, only a limited amount of market data was assembled. After considering analysis' of variances and other market factors and conditions, it was concluded that a market value of $58.00 per square foot of gross building area was appropriate. Thus, the 1990 Market Value as shown by market analysis is $124,000 (rounded). 1j If rl 1 5 Income Analysis • Rental Income 1987 $ 16,200 1988 $ 16,200 1989 $ 16,200 Gross Rent Multiplier = 7.65 (Market Rate) Value Indication by Income Approach $ 16,200 x 7.65 = $ 123,930 Say $ 124,000 Since this property is an investment property, the typical buyer of this type of property would be interested in the income stream generated and set their price accordingly. This approach is often considered to be of the most significance for that reason. The final price and therefore the market value will be determined by the income received from the building. • • { `r M P 1 Minnesota Property Consultants,Inc. Property Tax Reduction C • • �� CONSULTANT * AGENCY AGREEMENT PROPERTY CWNER/Ir SES— I qia / PROPERTY ADDRESS b 77J/�7S-5" /,�No TOWNSHIP25:/2 //2Ol 13u ri COUNTY re n P.I.N. //i ZZ 32- �U P.I.N. 36 -liW-- Zz - ZL.-0oo3 P.I.N. ,,,,.��/G I/Me, /V'"4- -'/LD Sd-'— , agree with"M.P.C., Inc." for the real estate assessment year 19 9d , and for a year's remaining in the present quadrennial period (199). and 19?3 ), in l.�nrP i,; County, Minnesota, as to the property referred to above, that preparation of a real estate/assessment appeal of the undersigned to the Local Board of Review, as well as to the State of Minnesota Property Tax Appeal Board. The undersigned authorizes"M.P.C., Inc."to obtain an appraisal or appraisals of Market Value for the property referred to above, for the year stated as the tax year in question. Unless otherwise indicated the cost of this appraisal will be paid for by"M.P.C., Inc.". The undersigned further authorizes "M.P.C., Inc." as agent of the undersigned, to execute and cause to be filed on behalf of the undersigned, in the name of the undersigned,any and all documents relating to an appeal of the said assessments, for the assessment year 19foJ and the remaining years/5 of the quadrennial period referred to above, before the Local Board of Review as well as the State of Minnesota Property Tax Appeal Board where permitted. If the services of an attorney at law are required, in connection with any appeal referred to herein the undersigned will choose and engage such attorney, at the cost of the undersigned;in which event"M.P.C.,.tnc." will co-operate with said attorney in the furtherance of such appeal. "M.P.C., Inc." for its services are separate and distinct from any fees payable by the undersigned to any attorney at law engaged by the undersigned. Agreed: /y/d OwnerjigeMee—(Strike the inappropriate designation) Date Approved: "M.P.C., Inc." By 7333 ANN COURT • EDEN PRAIRIE, MN 55346 • (612)942-5335 Appeal No. PID # 36-116-22 22 0003 Date Received 4/19/1990 Appraiser Earl Lent APPLICATION FORM 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 6i/2-9V/.16/0 AA Work:4/2 -9y2 -5335 Name: ,"lark L. Thamp! 0'1 Address of Property: //a?O/ �Urr leQ' v(om/ yt January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the` iotice: $ c/S 7 5'oO Date property was acquired: 110 Purchase Price: $ ,435'1000 Terms of Purchase: Nfvr{jcc,y# II Additions and alterations since✓ purchase: f72c1.- Set Cost of additions and alterations: '406 Is property listed for sale? V?5 If yes, at what price $ 3 97 CIXJ (attach copy of listing agreement Dwners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ 023e,000 What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information):in /S4lC/ n 4,40.(l -) g,44104 .6104 Signature Owner A-airier 3 Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 72700 184800 257500 R 1/2/88 66700 169600 236300 R 1/2/87 63000 160000 223000 R Last Inspection: 4 / /86 Appraiser: John Sams Building Permits/Appraiser Conments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments 9 /_/$Q CRV 230 WD / /— Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: 1 SUMMARY OF SALIENT FACTS AND CONCLUSIONS Purpose of Ap:?raisal: Market Value Property Rights Appraised: Fee Simple Ownership: Mark L. Thompson Location of Property: 11201 Burr Ridge Lane Eden Prairie, MN Date of Valuation: January 2, 1990 Type of Property: Residential Land Area: 0.5 Acre Building Size: 3,500 square feet Market Value Conclusion: $238,000 , . , . . .• . . . . . .. . • • - r•.....'..,•- ,.- : '•' .7....'•:•.:.-.'•'!',5 •"` ' •.', , , , „....,...... .. • . ,. `. , . . . ' ''. i-,,,:iis,,,,,•••tr•-•,,,6,'• tt...••••,..v •:,;',.. t-r;i*---t.,1•• ,,a•rl: f•-• ,.•. -r s;,•,..7:.,'?..4APL•5:,- t•',.___ ' .:--,-,-;:',,,.--,-:;:.;',•••1.44'1,. 4itr34‘.W.- r),,,r''..:.;,,-., .::i.-,,i,,,...;-!.:4_,. .--.. AA-7- r ...-.. .,- , . ' . . .., .--. --,%.,,4 • ' ,-15..t. „;'-',.-'1.;.t, ..-' ' .- .• 'II , Nc e'N'',..'l' • '''..;'::.k. '4' •.,,,.. . - , . , • 4-44-;:o -• '" ..rr•. - ... ./-7,--, 1 i , , i Vx•ttp.,-..A.., , ,.... :.,,,,.,, .,...;„..i,„4:•;::.,, ..i..-.-,... -.'-' I.' I• 1,',C, 4.!,,----11 ' - , '• "•,,,le's-- • :. ,i-.' .--,• :. ,1. .- •-•410..i.y.,,,44-' - ..., , • 't •/-_.• -- r -, t-'I; •,...*/-..T.-1 :v I . • -, • . , 0 --,1t-•-•'N,.. itrt ,/• , - •; • .; - - . ..- - • • - ,.04:,..t-,.,,1-!, , ---':''•. '--- .... - • • . ... .:„,, . f'-,itr••'T., -,g1",•=,:;.,eiP,''..,...!.t,, ;,,,ve,,ii.c._. .:-.„5,7-,-...•..--;'.'5,7'...,.11,, .4:;. .;,,,,,,.• ' ,' ,;,,1.011,-,t :!fiAVIAr, 7-,'.': '.--,:', :,,,,,..1,41,„Vt4,t;...4 '., VA.4.-:;,' ..fr.,''• _ ... ii... .. ...-- . ...,4,, ,:,,,..,.-- j./To',,,; .,), ,, ,- --• ..a•...... V- .,,,-- k•.; % ., •ri...-'. r..L./.....--......--,tt4".7-t-,,, '‘,., -‘ ,--•,.-, ,.... • -, . 'et % •r .• . -. -,--rri>,=-:--..--t-' ""--77:',"' ' =4,.4 "i f.:r-r.- :.;'-');;*• •=4v,..,1,7., V iO4.AP:,,t,,-10 1 t.<Z4,.,-V1 %.'...?,,,," --,,,,, ',., ;.- .,.t•;.,-1-;..P. ,-. .,,a..‘1 ,-,:,p,,--. ,,,,,-, ,..•.,, ,.,,,,,i .,....„ :.... . . ,, ., . ..,,, .. ,,,,,.„.z..., $,,,.. qo -- ----. ,i..... ,,, . , ,>,/,.. .,, ,,- ... ., , ,i1,,,. ;.; ,,,,..„.„, _....-..,:,..,,.,..7,-,,,,,.--04,, ,,,L.:,,,. -,, 't''-•t.,,,l'i:''' 1.--1 "i••••-• .-- '-.....;•-....., '- - •-.(:,,Tv -':- "•-3.:',,..!.,,13..i.,-,..,,sr-,'.. wo0w_---- ...7,- . ....,,:.1.,„,,,, 4 4 11'1•••"../.A."••;', 1''',4 4 -r--= .. .•-Z-, ;E..,k-4, '„i:;..--3. \--,, ,..... 4 ',.• 1!„,<,, :„..?..: V. (,/,- ,'',.\'• •:.-...:-.',. .:, 7:..;, •,-i..- - . - - .. I. ..1 • :-..:- •', ii • jlt 1, ,...- ..:M.1'•,..! : .,t •\. ..,.., ,•,,. , -.,.. i ---._ ...,,,...,,, f..,•••., • . . ., , 4 . \ .... ,- .. , , ,,. .. 'fa!,.'.. '..-,. •._,p !:, ' •._•,.. • r• .".;.• m ) - 1. ,' ' ,7a, . ''''SP.( ''S1 . : "`• 4 1 : . or,.-,...-4.k., .r.vgt ., • 7,,,,' .,ii 1 ,,yt.,4,,,t,‘,..- a . • • ' ...., • CC • IC A W N .- 90 W 17 I 1'0 m .-Ct* ! NW W W T I T UI UI UI 1111 T or‘ ON ON0 1 1 1 N NNNN 2 N N N N N N I A - • .I- N A N I I 1 1 1 1 . 0000 O I O O O O O N W NJ •`J W I A 10 U1 N 3 O O N N I W N N O o A A d T - t T C' — N ID 2) cr COCO9 I 0 J CO O. 0 C C a ' f ID I 1 31 ID I ID 011 I 0 r$ VI .- A . 1 A 1 0 70 IA 1/1a a a 10 1 10 O 0 10 10 m D 1 1 m • I n ✓ r < < r 0i I 01 m ID Cu .• . 3 3. 3 N m I 0 m O . I C I 1 1 \ \ NI 0 \ \ 110 xJ u) NJ N IA 01 .. \ 1 .- co N D r$ a co \ \ \ \ .-m O I o C C o m ID s.0 s.0 s.0 W .• 1 r Do 1 3 (.4 1 v W .0 N N \ P 1 0 CO a% N A �'\TI . 1 ,. I 1 NJ 1 N •- '01J1 U J NJ 0 1D 01 1 01 N I 10 .- A W 0 I 00 0 O O m N O 1 O O O O 1 1 b1 1 bl @ 1 U N b w O 1 \ C 11)Cn I �n , 0 \ ^J I 0 N PJd TI . 4 Market Analysis The subject property is an eleven-year old, two-story contemporary residential single-family home, situated on a one-half acre site, situated within 1/4 mile of the BFI Flying Cloud Landfill, which has had an effect on market values in the subject's neighborhood. Generally, market values have declined due to the presence of and the possible expansion of the contaminated, leaking landfill. The comparable sales properties are all in the same neighborhood as the subject's house. Comparable #1 is the best indicator of value as it is across the street from the subject and sold last October. it is of newer construction (downward adjustment) so the $68 per square foot market value may even by a little high for the subject property. Comparables #2 and #4 are of newer construction (downward adjustment) and their higher market values reflect their superior design and architecture. Comparable #3 is smaller than the subject (upward adjustment), but is reflective of the market sales in that area. Taking the above factors into consideration, it is concluded that a more equitable market value would be $68 per square foot, or: $68/sf x 3500 = $238,000 Value Indicated by Market Approach p i• Minnesota Property Consultants,Inc. PProperty Tax Reduction C '1 CONSULTANT * AGENCY AGREEMENT PROPERTY G NER/IEf,SES— 'U,�.' Z. / Trio 50 i✓ PROPERTY ADDRESS 6 77J7‘7.� TOWNSHIP ,, /l20) Sur.- t tect- nLL cool? &/tom P.I.N. //‘ —ZZ 32---00 P.I.N. 36 —// ..- 2.4 - ZL —0003 P.I.N. ,,�G 1/Ae,//1 'Z-T`zp Aso--- , agree with"M.P.C., Inc." for the real estate assessment year 19 9O , and for a year/s remaining in the present quadrennial period (199/ /7,4— and 19 7; ), in NP nnP i:, County, Minnesota, as to the property referred to above,that preparation of a real estate/assessment appeal of the undersigned to the Local Board of Review, as well as to the State of Minnesota Property Tax Appeal Board. The undersigned authorizes"H.P.C., Inc."to obtain an appraisal or appraisals of Market Value for the property referred to above, for the year stated as the tax year in question. Unless otherwise indicated the cast of this appraisal will be paid for by "M.P.C., Inc.". The undersigned further authorizes "H.P.C., Inc." as agent of the undersigned, to execute and cause to be filed on behalf of the undersigned, in the name of the undersigned, any and all documents relating to an appeal of the said assessments, for the assessment year 19 ylJ and the remaining years/s of the quadrennial period referred to above, before the Local Board of Review as well as the State of Minnesota Property Tax Appeal Board where permitted. If the services of an attorney at law are required, in connection with any appeal referred to herein the undersigned will choose and engage such attorney, at the cost of the undersigned; in which event"M.P.C.,.tnc." will co-operate with said attorney in the furtherance of such appeal. "M.P.C., Inc." for its services are separate and distinct from any fees payable by the undersigned to any attorney at law engaged by the undersigned. Agreed: Owner e Strike the inappropriate designation) Date Approved: "M.P.C., Inc." By 7333 ANN COURT • EDEN PRAIRIE, MN 55346 • (612) 942-5335 Appeal No. 14 g Date Received y I lq Igo Appraiser Sang APPLICATION FORM PID # 11-116-22 11 0012 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home:Work: /ll�!/./,��190 N ame: ,/Avert,✓ Address of Property: ,//`/(//J elf. ,' &9/2 January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ 40'..5,t .e2d Date property was acquired:..yah,,,,, Purchase Price: $ Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: Ai/e1,/,/ l lf�� Cost of ad itions an a terations: Is property listed for sale?Afl If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ r; /3S,t /<ri3,9, /...., What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): Signature of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being'collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 77000 9600D 173000 R 1/2/88 70000 87300 157300 R 1/2/67 67200 83800 1510D0 R Last Inspection: 9/22/89 Appraiser: John Sams Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments � / / / $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. ISO Date Received y►iq lqp Appraiser unro Cc'K PID # 22-116-22 24 0119 APPLICATION FORM 1990 EOEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW l"v/0 (To be completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: 739/-77,51 J Work: ('etc; -gloGoe Name: `JO<7AV\e/1K/,U5 ` ,i trt/4,J _SE..0 Address of Property: $7g16o f/esAer..' O'GC E' January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears on the notice: $ Q f3,boc Date property was acquired: Purchase Price: $ Terms of Purchase: . Additions and alterations since purchase: Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): Signature of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 8000 ---- 8000 R 1/2/88 N/A N/A 1/2/87 N/A N/A - Last Inspection: L/__/_10 Appraiser: Barb Cook Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: _ Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments --7 / $ / 8 $ ******************************************************************************* Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: Appeal No. 14 9 !�}1 �•' .!� Date Received ti 11R1c-rL Vv,/i Appraiser 1r4�... t APPLICATION FORM PID # 23-116-22 43 0039 1990 EDEN PRAIRIE BOARD OF REVIEW (To be //completed by owner - please print) Telephone Home: .6/9c-GL/ Q Name: L/iw2eivt 21 C�)cleia Work: 31 9-OSF53 Address of Property: Q (-,/ ()/Y 17ip, , l/2 January 2, 1990 valuation as it appears orf the notice: $ 3 S ,10 v Date property was acquired: /JoU. k S Purchase Price: $ Qv, t)o 0 Terms of Purchase: Additions and alterations since purchase: AJO Cost of additions and alterations: Is property listed for sale? &1 V If yes, at what price $ (attach copy of listing agreement) Owners estimated market value as of January 2, 1990 is: $ &9.5 0121) What are your reasons or documentation supporting the above stated value? (Please attach supporting information): /.G Q /990 • Signature of Owner Please note: This form requests private or confidential data of applicant which is being collected for purposes of review by the City Assessor and the Eden Prairie Board of Review to assist in preparing for any appeals/objections herein. The submission of this data is not mandatory, however, in order to get an accurate assessment of the property prior to the hearing, such data is helpful. (To be completed by the Assessing Department) Prior year values: Land Building Total Property Class. 1/2/89 115000 210400 325400 R 1/2/88 73600 205200 278800 R 1/2/87 695590 193600 263100 R Last Inspection: 9/13/88 Appraiser: John Sams Building Permits/Appraiser Comments: Sale History Date Source Sale Price Terms of Sale Comments / $ _// $ Board of Review Action: 1) Referred to Assessor for review: 2) Assessor's value adjusted to: 3) Assessor's value sustained: